Laviano to start

ScarletNYC

All-Conference
Jul 31, 2008
10,497
1,538
113
* Asked whether he is considering playing both QBs, Flood reiterated Laviano is his starter and he doesn't want anyone looking over their shoulder at that position.///////:

Just saw above. Appearance of fairness again voided. Shame. At the very least seeing what we have you play two and give them chances.

Nothing more to say on this, other than thought the favorite days were done w nova completinh his days. Guess its how flood operates.
This is proof that Laviano was his pick from the start. Shameful.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KnightsofChrome

G- RUnit

All-American
Sep 13, 2004
14,418
8,038
113
9 for 11 without Carroo and connects with six different receivers. Nice rushing yards, pocket presence, no happy feet and not locked in one reciever. Other QB is suspended for violating team rules... Like Kent State, PSU, Va Tech, etc., something is amiss and reeks of unfairness.
 
  • Like
Reactions: theRU

JPhoboken

Senior
Mar 15, 2005
11,963
585
0
I am OK with this as long as qb's are pulled if they are performing poorly. I was rooting for the best to win but wanted Lov because he committed to RU out of high school and is more of a local product. I thought the offense clicked with Lov and I don't remember any mistakes by him, and he showed wheels last year. Rettig looked real good but did need the TO's and I thought he held the ball long and the luxury of time we be decreased with better teams. I would definitely give the 2nd teamer, (even if it changes) one series per game to keep him fresh and keep up morale.

The Townsend reference above is classless.

The 64 million dollar question. Flood says now he has to consider that, but past history is strong, We'll see.

I don't have an issue with the coaches picking a QB, but Rettig looked real good, and if it was clearcut, Laviano would have been announced a long time ago. To me this is a tied to the hip with Laviano move, IMO.

I do have an issue with a guy getting suspended for the first half and then getting an advantage with throwing to an All American WR.

Maybe its just me, and I don't believe Laviano should be punished forever, but how do you reward a guy who just broke team rules. You think Rettig wouldn't want to go out for a beer too? He sacrificed, doesn't get suspended, performed well, didn't have Caroo, and still doesn't get to be the starter.

Again, I think its all moot, because in my heart of hearts, I see Rettig as the starter, and at minimum, he will play some meaningful minutes this year.
 
  • Like
Reactions: theRU

rufeelinit

All-Conference
May 16, 2010
12,647
4,351
0
If he was going to play two it should be a series by series rotation for as long as it takes for one to prove themselves to be better than the other. Even though they lost to Portland State, WSU is a significant step up from Norfolk and will not necessarily allow for a first half second half evaluation because the game is likely to still be in the balance. I think Rettig is getting a raw deal if KF is not committing to giving him some quality time on Saturday. I also think if he thought Rettig was equal he would be justified in telling Laviano that he lost he job for now based on his suspension. Evidently he feels otherwise. Who knows what the deciding factor really was but KF will need to live with it.
 

RUTGERSCHEWY

Redshirt
Sep 23, 2007
42
31
0
9 for 11 without Carroo and connects with six different receivers. Nice rushing yards, pocket presence, no happy feet and not locked in one reciever. Other QB is suspended for violating team rules... Like Kent State, PSU, Va Tech, etc., something is amiss and reeks of unfairness.

I agree and we should have extended the competition another week. What I saw of Laviano last year, still scares me, even if he has had a year to improve.
 

JPhoboken

Senior
Mar 15, 2005
11,963
585
0
I think Rettig becomes the starter by the end of the season. I just don't think Laviano can move the chains as well as Rettig. Unfortunately, it's gonna take a bad loss for the switch to happen.

Hope this doesn't happen, but can't say I wasn't thinking the same thing.
 

Caliknight

Hall of Famer
Sep 21, 2001
198,732
151,568
113
I want to add to the group that feels Rettig is beyond a doubt the better QB. Thankfully, it looks like Laviano is better than Nova was at the same stage in their careers. It does look like Flood is favoring Laviano just like he did Nova even though Rettig looked better.
I feel bad for Rettig. He mentioned over the summer how hard it was coming to a new team and learning a system etc. It has to be hard getting accepted when there's already a QB there that's been part of the team. It looks like it's going to take a slam dunk better performance from Rettig to make Flood change his mind. Doubt Rettig transfers again. He's too good for FCS and he can't sit out another year.

Joe Flacco showed how to do this. Hope Rettig isn't forced into that position.
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,185
90,330
113
Can't wait for the game threads with every little mistake being highlighted and picked apart 10 different ways, with the armchair coaches second guessing the decision. Let's get behind the QB and move forward.
 

Caliknight

Hall of Famer
Sep 21, 2001
198,732
151,568
113
Can't wait for the game threads with every little mistake being highlighted and picked apart 10 different ways, with the armchair coaches second guessing the decision. Let's get behind the QB and move forward.

Too late for that. The staff should have never let Rettig show what he capable of if that as the goal.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jersey Boys

JPhoboken

Senior
Mar 15, 2005
11,963
585
0
Based on flood's history with qbs it will take multiple Kent state like losses before we see Rettig again.

I fear this too, but after thinking about it.

1. I think Flood has grown and learned his lesson on the 6 INT games. You can take out a guy having a bad day.

2. We now have a viable alternative which we probably didn't have before.
 

G- RUnit

All-American
Sep 13, 2004
14,418
8,038
113
"We now have a viable alternative which we probably didn't have before."

Huh? Dodd was certainly a viable alternative. He won a bowl game and won one of the better comebacks in RU history against USF.
 

rutgers4life11

All-Conference
Jan 22, 2014
2,951
2,450
66
I fear this too, but after thinking about it.

1. I think Flood has grown and learned his lesson on the 6 INT games. You can take out a guy having a bad day.

2. We now have a viable alternative which we probably didn't have before.


Unfortunately , I don't think Flood ever learned his lesson. In 2014, Nova played like absolute garbage against Penn State, Ohio State, Nebraska, Wisconsin and Michigan State. Yet, it never even crossed Flood's mind to bench him and give someone else a few reps.

And this isn't a new thing either....

In 2013, Nova played AWFUL against Louisville, Houston, Cincinnati before Dodd saw any time. Dodd of course went on to become the MVP of a professional league.

In 2012, Nova was abysmal against Vtech, Pitt, Cincy, and Kent State. No benching whatsoever.
 

KJRU

All-Conference
Jul 25, 2001
3,098
1,149
113
Flood said that he has never had to make a decision like this before, obviously not. He has never been a HC or coordinator. He's never had to make this decision out side of Nova who had no real competition. He
acts like he is expert on this, lol
 

bitnez

All-American
Jan 18, 2006
6,791
7,834
113
While I understand the attachment people have to their opinions, and I'm just as guilty of that as the next guy, I'm also kind of curious how many people posting in this thread have coached D1 football.

I'm also curious about how many of those posters have observed all the practices, sat in the QB meeting room reviewing film w/them, known not only the outcome of plays, but the actual plays called, seen how the QBs interact w/the team in the locker room, have in-depth knowledge of the QB's personalities, etc.

Because, based on the aggressively stated opinions in some of the posts in this thread, it sure seems like we must have a whole bunch of current or former D1 coaches with even greater access than Flood, Fridge and the rest of the staff to all the information necessary to make a truly informed decision about who should get the nod at starting QB.

So all you posters with more D1 experience and who've had more access to the QBs than Flood and crew, please raise your hands. Don't be shy.

That way, you see, we know which of our posters we should actually pay attention to when they critique the coaching staff's decisions and which of our posters are just your typical blowhard sports fans. Not that there's anything wrong with that.

While I appreciate the general premise of your post I always find "this" argument misses the mark. If only D1 coaches could comment or offer an opinion then there would be no fans and certainly no message board. Also, there are plenty of D1 coaches who make horrific decisions. Simply because someone is D1 coach doesn't mean that a fan cannot offer an opinion. That's what fans do.
 

JPhoboken

Senior
Mar 15, 2005
11,963
585
0
"We now have a viable alternative which we probably didn't have before."

Huh? Dodd was certainly a viable alternative. He won a bowl game and won one of the better comebacks in RU history against USF.

I was speaking in general terms throughout Nova's career. But I get your point, and there was no way Nova should have stayed in the Kent State game.
 

GoodOl'Rutgers

Heisman
Sep 11, 2006
123,974
19,586
0
Given that both QBs looked good and one of them broke the rules... I think the wise thing would have been to give Rettig the start and let Laviano have the 2nd quarter then decide at halftime if the order is to be reversed.

Keep splitting time, by quarter, until you are sure one is much better than the other.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rutgers4life11

GoodOl'Rutgers

Heisman
Sep 11, 2006
123,974
19,586
0
While I appreciate the general premise of your post I always find "this" argument misses the mark. If only D1 coaches could comment or offer an opinion then there would be no fans and certainly no message board. Also, there are plenty of D1 coaches who make horrific decisions. Simply because someone is D1 coach doesn't mean that a fan cannot offer an opinion. That's what fans do.

Just last year Flood called a horrible fake punt.. or allowed the possibility for it to happen. And days ago he decides it is not wise to try a 2 minute drill up by 8 to Norfolk State. Horrible decision.
 

DHajekRC84

Heisman
Aug 9, 2001
30,708
19,816
0
per joe schad of ESPN


I like the guy who made two outstanding decisions to run the ball. For for a 1st down and the other for a TD. When was the last time RU had a running QB threat for the other team to really worry about.

OK...I really hope to see both play.
 

RUbacker

Heisman
Dec 5, 2014
16,232
23,249
108
And Rettig will get time too, he should since he earned it IMO.

I really think the locker room leans towards Laviano.

As a fan, I 100% root for every player that's on the field for Rutgers.

I'd like to see each QB get somewhat equal snaps and lead us to victory.
Aren't you the guy that killed nova for 4 years ? This board does not handle QB controversies well. The BS between the fans will begin.
 

CranfordKnight

All-Conference
Jun 23, 2006
4,140
4,116
113
As someone said here the concern we all have it it's going to take a bad loss - or worse a few as in the past-before there's a change .

Not necessarily.

Here's a possible scenario: Laviano takes most of the snaps vs. our next 3 opponents. Rettig hopefully gets some mop up duty vs. WSU and Kansas in convincing wins. I don't see Penn St. blowing us out, so either way unless Laviano has a bunch of TOs, he plays that whole game. MSU is where things could get interesting. I don't expect us to win, so if we are losing badly at some point, Flood can make the switch and give Rettig some meaningful time vs. a quality D and then re-evaluate the situation. That would give Rettig a game vs. Indiana to prepare for OSU if Flood decides to move forward with him.
 

ArminRU

Heisman
Aug 5, 2008
11,350
12,978
0
Here is what Ryan Dunleavy said (he watches practice everyday):

Chris Laviano is the #RFootball starting QB, which tells me there is nothing Hayden Rettig could've done all camp or in Game 1 to win job.

Ouch. Between this and Flood's comments, it's pretty clear Laviano would have to break a leg in order to have lost the job. Playing favorites with players is how you get yourself fired.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ScarletNYC

IL Lusciato

Heisman
Oct 31, 2011
10,680
13,292
0
We got 2 kids who played lights out. Laviano has been balling since spring.

Yet when the kid gets the job people are acting like he's a sub-par scrub who is destined to suck. It's complete f'n lunacy and nonsense.

We get it, you think Rettig is better. We get it. Laviano has still played very very very well. So stop acting like its such a bad choice just bc u had a fantasy of Tom Brady part 2...

Stop attributing this to flood playing favorites. Fridge, McDaniels etc all had a say.

Point blank - Laviano has played better than Rettig. Period. In your twisted fantasy worlds he hasn't. But in the real world - he has.
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,185
90,330
113
I like the guy who made two outstanding decisions to run the ball. For for a 1st down and the other for a TD. When was the last time RU had a running QB threat for the other team to really worry about.

OK...I really hope to see both play.

Does anyone remember Laviano ran the ball 46 yards on one play against Nebraska? I am not sure, but Nebraska is a little tougher competition than Norfolk State.
 

DHajekRC84

Heisman
Aug 9, 2001
30,708
19,816
0
ru-baby said: ↑
* Asked whether he is considering playing both QBs, Flood reiterated Laviano is his starter and he doesn't want anyone looking over their shoulder at that position.///////:

when did he say this? he just said post game Saturday that he was never in this situation before and (appeared to suggest) was completely open to doing something a bit different..at least come off this hard stance. Did he really flip back to that stance last 24 hours and what could he have seen in the film to caused such a flip-flop

At a minimum, I'd want Laviano to look over his shoulder which might help his off field decision making.

Regardless. Good Luck to us. We have options. I think Flood will be much more likely to pull the trigger this year and not lose games to rigid stance on matters....(hope so)
 

DHajekRC84

Heisman
Aug 9, 2001
30,708
19,816
0
Does anyone remember Laviano ran the ball 46 yards on one play against Nebraska? I am not sure, but Nebraska is a little tougher competition than Norfolk State.
nope..didn't remember that. Hey.. at the end of the day not my call and as a Rutgers fan I can only hope for the best regardless of who plays. Tough spot and I support them both. I hope whomever is back there gets the OK to run and put pressure on the D.
 
  • Like
Reactions: IL Lusciato

IL Lusciato

Heisman
Oct 31, 2011
10,680
13,292
0
It shouldn't matter since RU will run the ball 30+ times and attempt to control the clock. If the game turns into a shoot out, I think Rettig should get the majority of the snaps.
LoL why? Laviano has thrown for more TDs in every scrimmage, and game for the past 6 months.
 

LotusAggressor_rivals

All-American
Oct 11, 2003
16,986
8,958
113
No matter who the starter is, there are people who will insist that the QB sitting on the bench would have led RU to the playoff if he were given a chance to play. There are people who will further insist that the more talented QB is being left to rot on the bench because of some conspiracy by the coaches. Whenever there is a QB competition, the most popular player on the team is the guy who winds up being the backup. Such is the nature of QB competitions.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mildone_rivals

IL Lusciato

Heisman
Oct 31, 2011
10,680
13,292
0
I just don't comprehend the "unfair" angle. Laviano has outplayed Rettig since spring. Even if it is by a hair.

What would be unfair is handing the start to Rettig just c he was rates higher in h.s. and is an LSu transfer despite Laviano playi g better. That would have been unfair.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RUfromSoCal?

G- RUnit

All-American
Sep 13, 2004
14,418
8,038
113
No matter who the starter is, there are people who will insist that the QB sitting on the bench would have led RU to the playoff if he were given a chance to play. There are people who will further insist that the more talented QB is being left to rot on the bench because of some conspiracy by the coaches. Whenever there is a QB competition, the most popular player on the team is the guy who winds up being the backup. Such is the nature of QB competitions.


Or then again perhaps a healthy skepticism when "backup" QB, who does not violate team rules, goes 9 for 11 to six different recievers without the benefit of the best reciever in the conference, has a nifty TD run, and an admittedly stronger arm.
 

mildone_rivals

Heisman
Dec 19, 2011
55,607
51,274
0
While I appreciate the general premise of your post I always find "this" argument misses the mark. If only D1 coaches could comment or offer an opinion then there would be no fans and certainly no message board. Also, there are plenty of D1 coaches who make horrific decisions. Simply because someone is D1 coach doesn't mean that a fan cannot offer an opinion. That's what fans do.
Nowhere in my post did I say anything about fans not being fans. I even pointed out that I like spouting my relatively inexperienced, unprofessional, uninformed opinions as much as the next guy. The only difference (with some here) is that I realize my opinions are inexperienced, unprofessional and uninformed.

But the way that some people state their opinions can be interpreted as people, with little or no professional experience, and very limited information, arrogantly insisting that they know better than the coaching staff. Which is completely ridiculous. I'm not saying they shouldn't do it. I'm not saying that I don't or won't do it. I'm just pointing out that it's ridiculous.

Even if Flood's choice turns out to be the wrong choice, which can happen because it's not an easy call to make and he's human, and maybe he's not a football genius, or he needs more experience, or whatever; that doesn't make the wanna-be arm-chair coaches here right. It just makes them lucky.

I particularly like the conspiracy theorists who want to insist that Flood would do something for reasons other than whatever is in the best interests of the program. That's not just stating an opinion, that's being paranoid, delusional and idiotic in equal parts.
 

realhoops2

Senior
Jul 8, 2015
973
904
93
I am OK with this as long as qb's are pulled if they are performing poorly. I was rooting for the best to win but wanted Lov because he committed to RU out of high school and is more of a local product. I thought the offense clicked with Lov and I don't remember any mistakes by him, and he showed wheels last year. Rettig looked real good but did need the TO's and I thought he held the ball long and the luxury of time we be decreased with better teams. I would definitely give the 2nd teamer, (even if it changes) one series per game to keep him fresh and keep up morale.

The Townsend reference above is classless.
Although Rettig played well it appeared he did not have full command of the offense in the sense that there were a couple delay of game penalties and a couple timeouts called from the sideline to avoid delay penalties. I noticed that he spent much more time looking at his cheat sheet on his wrist than Laviano. When Laviano was in the game McDaniels felt he had enough command to go uptempo. IMO if the decision was based soley on talent Rettig would have gotten the job but due to Laviano's better command he was chosen, Hope he plays well but if not go to Rettig.
 

NBKnight

Heisman
Jul 8, 2008
24,757
15,666
61
I should have clarified "that was the plan all along" time frame. I think the decision was made after the final scrimmage as both quaterbacks were pretty equal. Flood felt more comfortable with Laviano's grasp of the playbook and this decision is more risk adverse. I believe the suspension delayed this decision. You don't want to name him the starter than declare he's suspended, it put's things in a bad light. I don't believe there was anything Rettig could do in that first half to change their minds. Unless Laviano totally imploded in the second half.

I agree that Chris would have been the starter if not for the suspension, not that you can take too much from the NSU, but if Chris played poorly, Rettig could have gotten the start this week.
 

NBKnight

Heisman
Jul 8, 2008
24,757
15,666
61
Unfortunately , I don't think Flood ever learned his lesson. In 2014, Nova played like absolute garbage against Penn State, Ohio State, Nebraska, Wisconsin and Michigan State. Yet, it never even crossed Flood's mind to bench him and give someone else a few reps.

And this isn't a new thing either....

In 2013, Nova played AWFUL against Louisville, Houston, Cincinnati before Dodd saw any time. Dodd of course went on to become the MVP of a professional league.

In 2012, Nova was abysmal against Vtech, Pitt, Cincy, and Kent State. No benching whatsoever.

You are hanging your anlaysis on Dodd's MVP performance in Italy? What about his performance against ND in the bowl game? Three picks and three missed TD passes.
 

RUonBrain

All-American
Apr 29, 2002
8,110
7,563
113
What if (just an IF) they asked Carroo (and maybe other receivers) for input, and he said I like them both, but maybe Chris a bit more

Does that matter?

I really don't know what anyone on this board is basing their opinion on. 12 passes vs Norfolk state? 4 passes (3 for TDs)?

Opinions of the mods?

If the staff as a whole REALLY really wanted Rettig, and Flood went with Laviano, okay, that is one thing.
But we have no evidence that is what happened.

This is all just message board fodder.
No way for us fans at this point to say which is better at this point for our team. Time will tell.
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Injury Report: Latest ahead of the Penn State game
  2. 02 The Knight Report Rutgers Football vs. Penn State Preview + Players Era 8 Basketball Recap - TKR Pod
  3. 03 The Knight Report Join The Knight Report TODAY and get it for 50% off!
  4. 04 The Knight Report WAR ROOM: Latest Recruit Scoop and Team News on Rutgers Athletics
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Women's Basketball HC Gary Redus II's Maryland Eastern Shore Press Conference