Laviano to start

RU'70

Junior
Dec 12, 2008
910
244
0
I will respect the decision of coach Flood. However, I still disagree with it. The first TD pass to Caroo was the result of Leonte's athleticism. The ball was underthrown. Caroo had to come back for it. If a pass like that is thrown in any other game this year, the DB intercepts it.
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,185
90,330
113
I'm starting to think you're related to Flood in some way....hmmm

I am starting to think you have issues and a vivid imagination.

So what if Laviano goes out there and lights it up and we win big. Are we still going to have a cry fest every week? And not you, but I can't stand this "higher ceiling" nonsense. WTF does that mean anyway? I know it is a saying, but it sounds silly.

We are not going to agree. I don't see why people are all balled up about this. I don't care who the QB is either way. I trust the coaches to do their job.
 

RUMcMahon

Senior
Dec 19, 2001
4,926
532
0
Will support CL but thought Rettig looked better with more upside. Rettig's pocket presence was nice to see , CL reminded me of Nova with happy feet. Just my opinion.
 

RUTBAY

Senior
Dec 14, 2006
2,616
472
0
Geez... Can we have a civil discussion about this without impugning the character of the team's starting QB? I'm personally invested in the TEAM not any one player.

Some people on this site don't want the right answer they just want to be right. When they don't get their way things really turn ugly.
 

KJRU

All-Conference
Jul 25, 2001
3,098
1,149
113
Not sure if you watched the game. But Laviano had nothing to do with any of those TDs. Let's see how he does against a fresh defense, in the pocket, and with pressure on him like Rettig.
I agree, two were behind Caroo and the other was a screen that Caroo got to the endzone. By the way, his other completion was a screen...it's kind of hard not to be 4/4.
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,185
90,330
113
Geez... Can we have a civil discussion about this without impugning the character of the team's starting QB? I'm personally invested in the TEAM not any one player.

Some people on this site don't want the right answer they just want to be right. When they don't get their things really turn ugly.
This.
I guess we have a bunch of choirboys and boy scouts here who never got into any kind of trouble. The comments and hyperbole are laughable, with trumped up things that someone did not do or why they did certain things. Are most of the people posting these things adults?
 

Caliknight

Hall of Famer
Sep 21, 2001
198,732
151,568
113
The smart play is to give the guy with more upside (pretty clear based on what was seen and others have said) more opportunities early in the season, assuming he earns them, to see how he develops. Rettig has.

The kid has a big arm. That throw he made when he got hit off of his back foot is not something I have not seen an RU QB do in a long time. Not sure why you wouldn't cultivate it. Let's remember, that was his first real action in two years.

He earned more chances.
 

KJRU

All-Conference
Jul 25, 2001
3,098
1,149
113
The smart play is to give the guy with more upside (pretty clear based on what was seen and others have said) more opportunities early in the season, assuming he earns them, to see how he develops. Rettig has.

The kid has a big arm. That throw he made when he got hit off of his back foot is not something I have not seen an RU QB do in a long time. Not sure why you wouldn't cultivate it. Let's remember, that was his first real action in two years.

He earned more chances.
I agree
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,185
90,330
113
The smart play is to give the guy with more upside (pretty clear based on what was seen and others have said) more opportunities early in the season, assuming he earns them, to see how he develops. Rettig has.

The kid has a big arm. That throw he made when he got hit off of his back foot is not something I have not seen an RU QB do in a long time. Not sure why you wouldn't cultivate it. Let's remember, that was his first real action in two years.

He earned more chances.

That is a a fair opinion, and opinions obviously differ on the subject. But there are other aspects to the job that are important too that perhaps the coaches felt put Laviano ahead of Rettig.
 

RUTBAY

Senior
Dec 14, 2006
2,616
472
0
The smart play is to give the guy with more upside (pretty clear based on what was seen and others have said) more opportunities early in the season, assuming he earns them, to see how he develops. Rettig has.

The kid has a big arm. That throw he made when he got hit off of his back foot is not something I have not seen an RU QB do in a long time. Not sure why you wouldn't cultivate it. Let's remember, that was his first real action in two years.

He earned more chances.
I agree with this opinion but it may be that all of the controversy from the last two weeks changed the equation to more of a safe bet. Given the competition was so close the staff wanted the best chance to beat WSU and PSU. We will never really know what went into the decision and anyone who says any differently (on either side) is likely doing it with an agenda.
 

theRU

All-American
Dec 17, 2008
11,135
5,798
0
I'm just curious... I was passively watching second half and it seemed like lavishly had great command and was throwing well , but after the fact I saw he actually only made 4 throws. He did not get much work... Shocked by this and that he will be the starter.
 

Raritan83

All-Conference
Sep 6, 2011
1,688
1,468
0
For those stating that Laviano shouldn't start cause he got in trouble, should that also apply to Carroo and the others. You can't mete out punishment based on who you want to see play.

But the others weren't involved in a neck and neck race. Basically if it is a tie the suspension should play a factor. Leonte was not tied with Carlton. If Chris really was ahead of Hayden fine but if not how give it to one who broke rules?
 

Raritan83

All-Conference
Sep 6, 2011
1,688
1,468
0
I'm just curious... I was passively watching second half and it seemed like lavishly had great command and was throwing well , but after the fact I saw he actually only made 4 throws. He did not get much work... Shocked by this and that he will be the starter.

And two completions were screens and the other a great play by the WR
 

KJRU

All-Conference
Jul 25, 2001
3,098
1,149
113
For those stating that Laviano shouldn't start cause he got in trouble, should that also apply to Carroo and the others. You can't mete out punishment based on who you want to see play.
That's exactly what I said earlier in this thread, in fact I said Caroo should've been punished more so, because he is a captain and he should've been stopping this rather than participating in it. By the way, it's ok to disagree on this subject, no need for animosity.
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,185
90,330
113
Other than their actual play?
Well, some have said that Laviano ran the offense more uptempo than Rettig. Maybe Laviano knows the playbook better. Maybe Carroo and Laviano have better chemistry--and that can cut both ways because a big complaint about Nova was he locked onto Caroo. Look, I don't care who plays, and I will support the decision of the coaching staff. What I will NOT do is cast stones at our players or nitpick their performance.

I think the most important thing Rutgers can do this week is slow the tempo down on offense and control time of possession to keep WSU's offense off the field. So, perhaps the uptempo aspect of Laviano does not factor in. Too many variables for us behind keyboards to know about.
 

T2Kplus10

Heisman
Feb 24, 2010
28,180
17,566
0
The smart play is to give the guy with more upside (pretty clear based on what was seen and others have said) more opportunities early in the season, assuming he earns them, to see how he develops. Rettig has.

The kid has a big arm. That throw he made when he got hit off of his back foot is not something I have not seen an RU QB do in a long time. Not sure why you wouldn't cultivate it. Let's remember, that was his first real action in two years.

He earned more chances.
Also agreed.

This seems like a narrow-minded decision by Flood. Something he decided at the end of last season and is too stubborn to change now, even though Rettig is better.
 

mildone_rivals

Heisman
Dec 19, 2011
55,607
51,274
0
While I understand the attachment people have to their opinions, and I'm just as guilty of that as the next guy, I'm also kind of curious how many people posting in this thread have coached D1 football.

I'm also curious about how many of those posters have observed all the practices, sat in the QB meeting room reviewing film w/them, known not only the outcome of plays, but the actual plays called, seen how the QBs interact w/the team in the locker room, have in-depth knowledge of the QB's personalities, etc.

Because, based on the aggressively stated opinions in some of the posts in this thread, it sure seems like we must have a whole bunch of current or former D1 coaches with even greater access than Flood, Fridge and the rest of the staff to all the information necessary to make a truly informed decision about who should get the nod at starting QB.

So all you posters with more D1 experience and who've had more access to the QBs than Flood and crew, please raise your hands. Don't be shy.

That way, you see, we know which of our posters we should actually pay attention to when they critique the coaching staff's decisions and which of our posters are just your typical blowhard sports fans. Not that there's anything wrong with that.
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,185
90,330
113
While I understand the attachment people have to their opinions, and I'm just as guilty of that as the next guy, I'm also kind of curious how many people posting in this thread have coached D1 football.

I'm also curious about how many of those posters have observed all the practices, sat in the QB meeting room reviewing film w/them, known not only the outcome of plays, but the actual plays called, seen how the QBs interact w/the team in the locker room, have in-depth knowledge of the QB's personalities, etc.

Because, based on the aggressively stated opinions in some of the posts in this thread, it sure seems like we must have a whole bunch of current or former D1 coaches with even greater access than Flood, Fridge and the rest of the staff to all the information necessary to make a truly informed decision about who should get the nod at starting QB.

So all you posters with more D1 experience and who've had more access to the QBs than Flood and crew, please raise your hands. Don't be shy.

That way, you see, we know which of our posters we should actually pay attention to when they critique the coaching staff's decisions and which of our posters are just your typical blowhard sports fans. Not that there's anything wrong with that.
End of thread. That was beautiful. It made me cry. No post in this thread will have a higher ceiling. [banana]
 

Tango Two

Heisman
Aug 21, 2001
60,106
38,172
78
For those stating that Laviano shouldn't start cause he got in trouble, should that also apply to Carroo and the others. You can't mete out punishment based on who you want to see play.


Carroo and the others broke curfew. Laviano broke curfew, AND the law, as minor as some want it to be.
 

garyrc70

Junior
Aug 1, 2001
2,409
265
83
It shouldn't matter since RU will run the ball 30+ times and attempt to control the clock. If the game turns into a shoot out, I think Rettig should get the majority of the snaps.
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,185
90,330
113
Carroo and the others broke curfew. Laviano broke curfew, AND the law, as minor as some want it to be.
So if Laviano was your son, you would be OK with him losing the starting job, and hearing from the coaches--"he was actually our choice to be the starter, but rules are rule, and when they are broken, we need to send a message. Your son will not start."
 

Ru-baby

All-Conference
Aug 11, 2001
6,879
3,369
66
One of you needs to let it breathe a little here.

Flood being flood. Its arguable that qb had been floods complete blindspot his whole tenure.

As someone said here the concern we all have it it's going to take a bad loss - or worse a few as in the past-before there's a change .
 
  • Like
Reactions: T2Kplus10

Tango Two

Heisman
Aug 21, 2001
60,106
38,172
78
So if Laviano was your son, you would be OK with him losing the starting job, and hearing from the coaches--"he was actually our choice to be the starter, but rules are rule, and when they are broken, we need to send a message. Your son will not start."


Absolutely, especially when a law was broken.

Flood's track record on second chances isn't really good right now
 

RU#1fan

Heisman
Mar 7, 2003
24,477
13,091
113
:uzi:
You should choose your words more carefully. I know a lot of people who go to clubs that don't drink. Maybe he just wanted to hang out in the club. How can you say what you said if you were not there?

Yeah, that's why he got the fake ID.
 

Ru-baby

All-Conference
Aug 11, 2001
6,879
3,369
66
Very short memory. Its early but the fear is part deux of the ridiculousness. Nova was the clear choice and should have played last year- and he did well.
The othe years, at worst, he needed to be pulled when he was having a bad day maybe after three interceptions?? Other than flood how many other coaches allowed 6 to occur?

It was hope that Flood would show growth in this one area that he has really really struggled. By seeing Dunleavey's quote its not hard to believe he's getting into that same favored nation status that no matter what the other player does they can't get on the field.

Believe it or not most people here value fairness and if they see something that seems unfair it rubs them the wrong way. It doesn't mean anyone is rooting against our beloved rutgers it just means that the unfairness appearance- and stubborness-is not sitting well.
 

Virginiarufan

All-Conference
Jul 26, 2001
3,924
3,055
113
I want to add to the group that feels Rettig is beyond a doubt the better QB. Thankfully, it looks like Laviano is better than Nova was at the same stage in their careers. It does look like Flood is favoring Laviano just like he did Nova even though Rettig looked better.
I feel bad for Rettig. He mentioned over the summer how hard it was coming to a new team and learning a system etc. It has to be hard getting accepted when there's already a QB there that's been part of the team. It looks like it's going to take a slam dunk better performance from Rettig to make Flood change his mind. Doubt Rettig transfers again. He's too good for FCS and he can't sit out another year.
 

BoroKnight

All-Conference
Mar 13, 2010
11,091
2,093
0
Hilarious that KF let espn scoop nj.com

Would have been better if another NJ outlet scooped nj.com. ESPN is not exactly our favorite place either. From the other perspective, it makes it seem more "important" for ESPN to get it and thus not as insulting to nj.com than another NJ outlet getting it.

But not really important in the big picture -- which is all Flood should be concerned about right now.
 

Ru-baby

All-Conference
Aug 11, 2001
6,879
3,369
66
* Asked whether he is considering playing both QBs, Flood reiterated Laviano is his starter and he doesn't want anyone looking over their shoulder at that position.///////:

Just saw above. Appearance of fairness again voided. Shame. At the very least seeing what we have you play two and give them chances.

Nothing more to say on this, other than thought the favorite days were done w nova completinh his days. Guess its how flood operates.
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Injury Report: Latest ahead of the Penn State game
  2. 02 The Knight Report Rutgers Football vs. Penn State Preview + Players Era 8 Basketball Recap - TKR Pod
  3. 03 The Knight Report Join The Knight Report TODAY and get it for 50% off!
  4. 04 The Knight Report WAR ROOM: Latest Recruit Scoop and Team News on Rutgers Athletics
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Women's Basketball HC Gary Redus II's Maryland Eastern Shore Press Conference