Toggle sidebar

No take down

G

greatwhitepoke

Freshman
Sep 17, 2003
1,946
59
0
Can someone explain why it wasn't a take down at the end of the 1st period of 157 between Nolf and Hidlay? If it was a timing issue why did they restart the period with 05 seconds on the clock?
 
M

mickpsu

Freshman
Jul 27, 2014
61
93
18
Cowguy said:
Which even the announcers thought was wrong
Click to expand...

not much difference between that ruling and the one with RBY and Desanto...I think was exactly the ruling ...that Nolfs hands were not on the mat when they awarded Hadley the TD
 
C

Cowguy

All-Conference
May 29, 2001
12,580
2,666
0
07mantle said:
not much difference between that ruling and the one with RBY and Desanto...I think was exactly the ruling ...that Nolfs hands were not on the mat when they awarded Hadley the TD
Click to expand...

I didn’t not see the rby match, but I watched the slow motion of the Nolf match. Behind with three points down. It sure looked like a takedown. Neutral twitter people seemed to think so too.
 
chasepollard

chasepollard

Heisman
Nov 25, 2005
93,375
15,733
48
There's a PSU bias. From the seeds, to the officiating, there IS a bias.

It's normal, we had it in the early 2000s.
 
C

CowboyUp61

Senior
May 22, 2016
1,077
729
83
Even Nolf thought it was a takedown. Not that Hidlay was guaranteed the win if he got it, but would liked to have seen it scored properly.
 
P

pokefan4life

Redshirt
Feb 23, 2003
168
30
0
Hidlay also seemed to have the winning take down at the end of the match but they ruled for Nolf again. Not that Nolf did not deserve to be in the finals again but Hidlay wrestled a hell of a match and deserved to win.
 
T

turfpoke

All-Conference
Dec 10, 2003
2,630
1,645
0
IMO, they should just do away with review unless someone other the the mat refs are reviewing it. The Nolf/Hilday match, the Deakin/Young match were a couple that were called correctly on the mat and then mysteriously reversed. They were both obvious live.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
O State Illustrated

Latest

  1. 01 O State Illustrated Football Mestemaker delivers as No. 18 Oklahoma State tops UCF 42-28
  2. 02 O State Illustrated Staff Picks: UCF at Oklahoma State
  3. 03 O State Illustrated Football OSI Preview Week 6 | Oklahoma State vs. UCF
  4. 04 O State Illustrated Football Ask the Expert: UCF at Oklahoma State
  5. 05 Rivals Football Recruiting Oklahoma State hosting a few 2027 recruits, key flip targets, and coveted 2028 and 2029 quarterbacks for UCF game
Top Bottom