They definitely have talent but the way they put it together...Not saying he’s the right coach, but from a PR perspective it’s a good move given all the speculation that Lovie has one foot out the door. Of course, many Illini fans probably want both of Lovie’s feet out the door.
They definitely have talent but the way they put it together...
Wow, I rescind my complaints. Fitz is crazy like a fox
Ehhh, Beckman used to beat Fitz. We want Lovie! (Maybe he’ll slip next year, though that would require human emotion.)Thanks to Josh the Illini AC for working on a 2 year extension with Lovie but I think Josh should consider the more stability the better so why just a 2 year extension? Make it 5 or 10 years! Let stability reign/rain down on the Illini program Josh! (Just wish a similar program stability mindset was present when Beckman was HC! He’d still be their coach!) Maybe Josh can figure out a way for to bring back Beckman in some capacity. You just can’t have enough stability Josh!
Ehhh, Beckman used to beat Fitz. We want Lovie! (Maybe he’ll slip next year, though that would require human emotion.)
Was it AmTrust?“Used to beat”? That implies more than once and no. We won in 2012 and ‘13, and only lost in ‘14 because we were without a QBs after Siemian got reinsured vs. Purdue the previous week.
It strikes me that Whitman did this early. I’d im reading correctly, the extension is two years, through the end of 2023. That means his current contract was through 2021, which is three full seasons from now. I feel like most “normal” coaches are recruiting with about that timespan, though maybe I’m wrong.As an Illini fan, this obviously makes me sad because I know (or at least strongly believe now) that Lovie Smith is not the answer to get our program where it should be given natural advantages - a place in the pecking order that, while maybe not immediately competitive like Iowa, Wisconsin, NU and other programs that have displayed on-field success over the last 20 years, should absolutely not be where we are now. However, you either fire him or extend him. Period. Josh decided not to fire him, so there is only other one option. If Lovie doesn't win 6-7 games next year (which he won't), he will be fired. In the meantime, though, you can't NOT extend him. Don't get me wrong, my preferred option is honestly just to start over at this point ... but you either fire him or extend him, no matter what.
As an Illini fan, this obviously makes me sad because I know (or at least strongly believe now) that Lovie Smith is not the answer to get our program where it should be given natural advantages - a place in the pecking order that, while maybe not immediately competitive like Iowa, Wisconsin, NU and other programs that have displayed on-field success over the last 20 years, should absolutely not be where we are now. However, you either fire him or extend him. Period. Josh decided not to fire him, so there is only other one option. If Lovie doesn't win 6-7 games next year (which he won't), he will be fired. In the meantime, though, you can't NOT extend him. Don't get me wrong, my preferred option is honestly just to start over at this point ... but you either fire him or extend him, no matter what.
As an Illini fan, this obviously makes me sad because I know (or at least strongly believe now) that Lovie Smith is not the answer to get our program where it should be given natural advantages - a place in the pecking order that, while maybe not immediately competitive like Iowa, Wisconsin, NU and other programs that have displayed on-field success over the last 20 years, should absolutely not be where we are now. However, you either fire him or extend him. Period. Josh decided not to fire him, so there is only other one option. If Lovie doesn't win 6-7 games next year (which he won't), he will be fired. In the meantime, though, you can't NOT extend him. Don't get me wrong, my preferred option is honestly just to start over at this point ... but you either fire him or extend him, no matter what.
However, you either fire him or extend him. Period. Josh decided not to fire him, so there is only other one option. If Lovie doesn't win 6-7 games next year (which he won't), he will be fired. In the meantime, though, you can't NOT extend him. Don't get me wrong, my preferred option is honestly just to start over at this point ... but you either fire him or extend him, no matter what.
What “natural advantages?”
I think he presumed you meant advantages over NUI don't expect you to agree. Most outside observers, however, think that the University of Illinois has enough advantages going for it (nearby recruits, large alumni/fan base, good academic reputation, etc.) to at the very least not consistently win 2-3 games per year. To say otherwise is to be either trolling, ignorant or blinded by hate, IMO.
I don't expect you to agree. Most outside observers, however, think that the University of Illinois has enough advantages going for it (nearby recruits, large alumni/fan base, good academic reputation, etc.) to at the very least not consistently win 2-3 games per year. To say otherwise is to be either trolling, ignorant or blinded by hate, IMO.
I don’t think they help themselves by scheduling only cupcakes in OOC. Take on a Texas (like Maryland), a ND (like NU), a LSU ( like Wisky), even a BC (like Purdue). Never know, at some point you may Spring an upset and catapult to relevance. A loss doesn’t kill you unless it is 63-0.Illinois needs to start playing and winning games vs Texas and Florida schools to build its profile. There aren’t nearly enough good players in Illinois and Missouri to buoy that program.
“Used to beat”? That implies more than once and no. We won in 2012 and ‘13, and only lost in ‘14 because we were without a QBs after Siemian got reinsured vs. Purdue the previous week.
I don't expect you to agree. Most outside observers, however, think that the University of Illinois has enough advantages going for it (nearby recruits, large alumni/fan base, good academic reputation, etc.) to at the very least not consistently win 2-3 games per year. To say otherwise is to be either trolling, ignorant or blinded by hate, IMO.
Sure you have advantages vis a vis the MAC but what you need to ask yourself is how does the Illinois football program differentiate itself from its peer group, i.e. other Big Ten programs. What does Illinois have to offer that is clearly different from the programs it competes with? It may have things that are similar or equal but right now I see nothing that differentiates Illinois from the Iowa, Purdue, Michigan State, Minnesota and Indianas of the world. So if that is the situation, what it really comes down to is the coach, the culture and the success of the program. When it comes to these things, Illinois is woefully deficient and I see no indication that Lovie Smith is on a path to change this. That is why keeping Lovie may be a financial necessity, but it does nothing but delay the eventual tear down and rebuilding that once again needs to happen at Illinois. Lovie was the wrong person to hire for the rebuilding of a college program like Illinois and that was evident to anybody at the time who has a clue about what it takes to build a successful college football program. The premise that young High School athletes who were barely toddlers when Lovie Smith was last relevant in the NFL would trip over themselves to commit to Lovie and Illinois was just flawed. A college football head coach needs to be a young and energetic coach who is constantly on the move promoting the virtues of his program and the University to every constituency (recruits, parents, alums, fans, media etc.). Lovie is aloof by nature and came in with the mindset that his track record should speak for itself. It doesn't because college football isn't the NFL. He compounded this problem by mimicking what he did with the Bears, I.e. building a staff with friends/families/loyalists who were just as inexperienced with the college game as he was/is. These were fatal mistakes and at this point I just don't see how Illinois recovers under Lovie. They should start over but obviously they have chosen not to and that is just fine by me as a Northwestern fan.
What “natural advantages?”
I don't expect you to agree. Most outside observers, however, think that the University of Illinois has enough advantages going for it (nearby recruits, large alumni/fan base, good academic reputation, etc.) to at the very least not consistently win 2-3 games per year. To say otherwise is to be either trolling, ignorant or blinded by hate, IMO.
Wildcat Report
Fearless Forecast: Northwestern vs. Minnesota
Wildcat Report
Behind Enemy Lines: Minnesota
Wildcat Report
Northwestern at Ohio State PFF Grades Analysis
Wildcat Report
Northwestern working to support, improve QB Nicco Marchiol ahead of Minnesota
Wildcat Report
Northwestern embarrassed by Columbia, 75-53