Illinois Gives Lovie a Contract Extension

The_Waterboy

Freshman
May 29, 2001
2,490
61
0
Pat Fitzgerald's trap has been sprung on the unsuspecting Ill-Whine-I.

Hurray!!! More seasons of Ill-Annoy ineptitude in the face of a coaching staff composed of collegiate football player teachers rather than professional football talent managers - the difference between Fitz & Doc to Lovie and his Merry Band of NitWIts.

It's difficult to determine who is (or will be) the more azz-clown Ill-Annoy HC - Lovie Smith or Tim Beckman. Personally I still hold the torch for Beckman as the No.1 Ill-Annoy azz-clown HC of all time. But Lovie may surpass the Beck-Meister as the GOAT over the next few years.
 

scru

Redshirt
Sep 4, 2005
2,388
8
0
 

Hungry Jack

All-American
Nov 17, 2008
40,298
8,154
67
Not saying he’s the right coach, but from a PR perspective it’s a good move given all the speculation that Lovie has one foot out the door. Of course, many Illini fans probably want both of Lovie’s feet out the door.
 

FloridAlum

Senior
May 29, 2001
16,227
588
0
That’s what Fitz told Lovie after the game, Hey dude, I pulled out a lot of the starters so you folks could get within Eight, and now maybe your numbnuts athletic director will give you a contract extension. Merry Christmas!
 

hdhntr1

All-Conference
Sep 5, 2006
38,908
1,552
113
Not saying he’s the right coach, but from a PR perspective it’s a good move given all the speculation that Lovie has one foot out the door. Of course, many Illini fans probably want both of Lovie’s feet out the door.
They definitely have talent but the way they put it together...
 
May 29, 2001
7,348
377
56
Thanks to Josh the Illini AC for working on a 2 year extension with Lovie but I think Josh should consider the more stability the better so why just a 2 year extension? Make it 5 or 10 years! Let stability reign/rain down on the Illini program Josh! (Just wish a similar program stability mindset was present when Beckman was HC! He’d still be their coach!) Maybe Josh can figure out a way for to bring back Beckman in some capacity. You just can’t have enough stability Josh!
 

NUCat320

Senior
Dec 4, 2005
19,469
495
0
Thanks to Josh the Illini AC for working on a 2 year extension with Lovie but I think Josh should consider the more stability the better so why just a 2 year extension? Make it 5 or 10 years! Let stability reign/rain down on the Illini program Josh! (Just wish a similar program stability mindset was present when Beckman was HC! He’d still be their coach!) Maybe Josh can figure out a way for to bring back Beckman in some capacity. You just can’t have enough stability Josh!
Ehhh, Beckman used to beat Fitz. We want Lovie! (Maybe he’ll slip next year, though that would require human emotion.)
 

DarthCat

Junior
Jun 5, 2001
3,411
229
63
Ehhh, Beckman used to beat Fitz. We want Lovie! (Maybe he’ll slip next year, though that would require human emotion.)

“Used to beat”? That implies more than once and no. We won in 2012 and ‘13, and only lost in ‘14 because we were without a QBs after Siemian got reinsured vs. Purdue the previous week.
 

zbag51

Senior
Apr 12, 2018
2,705
756
113
I really enjoy that he had to write a very long letter to illinois fans explaining why keeping a terrible coach is a good idea.
 

chitownUofI05

Sophomore
Jan 13, 2011
6,734
195
0
As an Illini fan, this obviously makes me sad because I know (or at least strongly believe now) that Lovie Smith is not the answer to get our program where it should be given natural advantages - a place in the pecking order that, while maybe not immediately competitive like Iowa, Wisconsin, NU and other programs that have displayed on-field success over the last 20 years, should absolutely not be where we are now. However, you either fire him or extend him. Period. Josh decided not to fire him, so there is only other one option. If Lovie doesn't win 6-7 games next year (which he won't), he will be fired. In the meantime, though, you can't NOT extend him. Don't get me wrong, my preferred option is honestly just to start over at this point ... but you either fire him or extend him, no matter what.
 

NUCat320

Senior
Dec 4, 2005
19,469
495
0
As an Illini fan, this obviously makes me sad because I know (or at least strongly believe now) that Lovie Smith is not the answer to get our program where it should be given natural advantages - a place in the pecking order that, while maybe not immediately competitive like Iowa, Wisconsin, NU and other programs that have displayed on-field success over the last 20 years, should absolutely not be where we are now. However, you either fire him or extend him. Period. Josh decided not to fire him, so there is only other one option. If Lovie doesn't win 6-7 games next year (which he won't), he will be fired. In the meantime, though, you can't NOT extend him. Don't get me wrong, my preferred option is honestly just to start over at this point ... but you either fire him or extend him, no matter what.
It strikes me that Whitman did this early. I’d im reading correctly, the extension is two years, through the end of 2023. That means his current contract was through 2021, which is three full seasons from now. I feel like most “normal” coaches are recruiting with about that timespan, though maybe I’m wrong.
 

Gocatsgo2003

All-Conference
Mar 30, 2006
47,638
4,409
78
As an Illini fan, this obviously makes me sad because I know (or at least strongly believe now) that Lovie Smith is not the answer to get our program where it should be given natural advantages - a place in the pecking order that, while maybe not immediately competitive like Iowa, Wisconsin, NU and other programs that have displayed on-field success over the last 20 years, should absolutely not be where we are now. However, you either fire him or extend him. Period. Josh decided not to fire him, so there is only other one option. If Lovie doesn't win 6-7 games next year (which he won't), he will be fired. In the meantime, though, you can't NOT extend him. Don't get me wrong, my preferred option is honestly just to start over at this point ... but you either fire him or extend him, no matter what.

What “natural advantages?”
 

Max_Power

Senior
May 29, 2001
3,145
608
101
As an Illini fan, this obviously makes me sad because I know (or at least strongly believe now) that Lovie Smith is not the answer to get our program where it should be given natural advantages - a place in the pecking order that, while maybe not immediately competitive like Iowa, Wisconsin, NU and other programs that have displayed on-field success over the last 20 years, should absolutely not be where we are now. However, you either fire him or extend him. Period. Josh decided not to fire him, so there is only other one option. If Lovie doesn't win 6-7 games next year (which he won't), he will be fired. In the meantime, though, you can't NOT extend him. Don't get me wrong, my preferred option is honestly just to start over at this point ... but you either fire him or extend him, no matter what.

If it does not increase the buyout, which I understand drops from $12 million to $4 million next year, it means nothing. Illinois was stuck with Lovie for at least 12 months bc of the $12 million reasons so this changes nothing.
 

BleedPurple2009

Freshman
Sep 3, 2009
524
70
28
However, you either fire him or extend him. Period. Josh decided not to fire him, so there is only other one option. If Lovie doesn't win 6-7 games next year (which he won't), he will be fired. In the meantime, though, you can't NOT extend him. Don't get me wrong, my preferred option is honestly just to start over at this point ... but you either fire him or extend him, no matter what.

I agree with this if his buyout is unchanged, but as far as I know that info isn’t public yet, right? Also what’s the incentive for Lovie to sign an extension that doesn’t change any of the terms of his contract if he really thinks he’s making progress and the team will be better next year? Wouldn’t you (if you were Smith) wait to sign an extension until you can get a raise or a better buyout or some advantage? Most of this year’s class is already committed, why rush to sign a meaningless contract the day after the season ends if you think you have any leverage whatsoever to get more money.

That’s why I think one of two things is true, either:

1. Smith knows his team will be just as awful next year and therefore doesn’t feel like he has any leverage to negotiate.

Or

2. He did get something out of the extension in terms of salary or buyout.

In any case, I think it’s dumb because I completely agree that Lovie is not the answer and this extension just delays the inevitable by another year (or more).
 

chitownUofI05

Sophomore
Jan 13, 2011
6,734
195
0
What “natural advantages?”

I don't expect you to agree. Most outside observers, however, think that the University of Illinois has enough advantages going for it (nearby recruits, large alumni/fan base, good academic reputation, etc.) to at the very least not consistently win 2-3 games per year. To say otherwise is to be either trolling, ignorant or blinded by hate, IMO.
 

seavue617

Sophomore
May 21, 2014
1,004
136
61
2. He did get something out of the extension in terms of salary or buyout.
[/QUOTE]

I think it is conceivable that if UofI gets bowl-eligible next year that the deal includes a provision by which the buyout would increase. That outcome is at least remotely possible since they have three non-conference cupcakes plus Rutgers so they would only have to win two games from their remaining schedule.
I frankly doubt that the fanbase would stand for an increase in salary considering the won-loss record.
 

phatcat_rivals223240

All-Conference
Nov 5, 2001
19,302
1,401
113
I don't expect you to agree. Most outside observers, however, think that the University of Illinois has enough advantages going for it (nearby recruits, large alumni/fan base, good academic reputation, etc.) to at the very least not consistently win 2-3 games per year. To say otherwise is to be either trolling, ignorant or blinded by hate, IMO.
I think he presumed you meant advantages over NU
 

Gocatsgo2003

All-Conference
Mar 30, 2006
47,638
4,409
78
I don't expect you to agree. Most outside observers, however, think that the University of Illinois has enough advantages going for it (nearby recruits, large alumni/fan base, good academic reputation, etc.) to at the very least not consistently win 2-3 games per year. To say otherwise is to be either trolling, ignorant or blinded by hate, IMO.

Win more than 2-3 games per season, sure. Suddenly become a consistent B1G power, no. I'm honestly asking what you perceive as Illinois' "natural advantages" in football recruiting.

Not sure how the "nearby recruits" angle works when the closest metro area is St. Louis, which is a 2.5-3 hour drive and will consistently see stiff competition from Mizzou for recruits. Same for Chicago, a 2+-hour drive with consistent competition from NU.

And "lots of alums with a good academic reputation" is something that can be sold by pretty much any state university, especially B1G schools (AAU members, mostly flagship institutions, major research universities, etc.).
 
Last edited:

Hungry Jack

All-American
Nov 17, 2008
40,298
8,154
67
Illinois needs to start playing and winning games vs Texas and Florida schools to build its profile. There aren’t nearly enough good players in Illinois and Missouri to buoy that program.
 

Purple Pile Driver

All-Conference
May 14, 2014
29,589
4,865
113
Illinois needs to start playing and winning games vs Texas and Florida schools to build its profile. There aren’t nearly enough good players in Illinois and Missouri to buoy that program.
I don’t think they help themselves by scheduling only cupcakes in OOC. Take on a Texas (like Maryland), a ND (like NU), a LSU ( like Wisky), even a BC (like Purdue). Never know, at some point you may Spring an upset and catapult to relevance. A loss doesn’t kill you unless it is 63-0.
 

BosCat

Junior
Nov 29, 2008
1,338
276
83
“Used to beat”? That implies more than once and no. We won in 2012 and ‘13, and only lost in ‘14 because we were without a QBs after Siemian got reinsured vs. Purdue the previous week.

"Discount double-check"
"We know a thing or two because we've seen a thing or two"
"You're in good hands"
"Fifteen minutes could save you fifteen percent or more on car insurance"
 

corbi2961

Senior
Sep 9, 2005
30,524
786
0
I don't expect you to agree. Most outside observers, however, think that the University of Illinois has enough advantages going for it (nearby recruits, large alumni/fan base, good academic reputation, etc.) to at the very least not consistently win 2-3 games per year. To say otherwise is to be either trolling, ignorant or blinded by hate, IMO.

Sure you have advantages vis a vis the MAC but what you need to ask yourself is how does the Illinois football program differentiate itself from its peer group, i.e. other Big Ten programs. What does Illinois have to offer that is clearly different from the programs it competes with? It may have things that are similar or equal but right now I see nothing that differentiates Illinois from the Iowa, Purdue, Michigan State, Minnesota and Indianas of the world. So if that is the situation, what it really comes down to is the coach, the culture and the success of the program. When it comes to these things, Illinois is woefully deficient and I see no indication that Lovie Smith is on a path to change this. That is why keeping Lovie may be a financial necessity, but it does nothing but delay the eventual tear down and rebuilding that once again needs to happen at Illinois. Lovie was the wrong person to hire for the rebuilding of a college program like Illinois and that was evident to anybody at the time who had a clue about what it takes to build a successful college football program. The premise that young High School athletes who were barely toddlers when Lovie Smith was last relevant in the NFL would trip over themselves to commit to Lovie and Illinois was just flawed. A college football head coach needs to be a young and energetic coach who is constantly on the move promoting the virtues of his program and the University to every constituency (recruits, parents, alums, fans, media etc.). Lovie is aloof by nature and came in with the mindset that his track record should speak for itself. It doesn't because college football isn't the NFL. He compounded this problem by mimicking what he did with the Bears, I.e. building a staff with friends/families/loyalists who were just as inexperienced with the college game as he was/is. These were fatal mistakes and at this point I just don't see how Illinois recovers under Lovie. They should start over but obviously they have chosen not to and that is just fine by me as a Northwestern fan.
 
Last edited:

DarthCat

Junior
Jun 5, 2001
3,411
229
63
Sure you have advantages vis a vis the MAC but what you need to ask yourself is how does the Illinois football program differentiate itself from its peer group, i.e. other Big Ten programs. What does Illinois have to offer that is clearly different from the programs it competes with? It may have things that are similar or equal but right now I see nothing that differentiates Illinois from the Iowa, Purdue, Michigan State, Minnesota and Indianas of the world. So if that is the situation, what it really comes down to is the coach, the culture and the success of the program. When it comes to these things, Illinois is woefully deficient and I see no indication that Lovie Smith is on a path to change this. That is why keeping Lovie may be a financial necessity, but it does nothing but delay the eventual tear down and rebuilding that once again needs to happen at Illinois. Lovie was the wrong person to hire for the rebuilding of a college program like Illinois and that was evident to anybody at the time who has a clue about what it takes to build a successful college football program. The premise that young High School athletes who were barely toddlers when Lovie Smith was last relevant in the NFL would trip over themselves to commit to Lovie and Illinois was just flawed. A college football head coach needs to be a young and energetic coach who is constantly on the move promoting the virtues of his program and the University to every constituency (recruits, parents, alums, fans, media etc.). Lovie is aloof by nature and came in with the mindset that his track record should speak for itself. It doesn't because college football isn't the NFL. He compounded this problem by mimicking what he did with the Bears, I.e. building a staff with friends/families/loyalists who were just as inexperienced with the college game as he was/is. These were fatal mistakes and at this point I just don't see how Illinois recovers under Lovie. They should start over but obviously they have chosen not to and that is just fine by me as a Northwestern fan.

Um, they do get their Decembers free.
 

Catreporter

Senior
Sep 4, 2007
5,117
683
113
With Lovie returning and guaranteed inexperience at quarterback, selling tickets for those non-conference cupcakes and Rutgers will be a huge lift for Illinois next year.
 

EvanstonCat

Senior
May 29, 2001
50,888
892
73
I don't expect you to agree. Most outside observers, however, think that the University of Illinois has enough advantages going for it (nearby recruits, large alumni/fan base, good academic reputation, etc.) to at the very least not consistently win 2-3 games per year. To say otherwise is to be either trolling, ignorant or blinded by hate, IMO.

You're right. With those natural advantages, you should be winning 4-5 games a year.
 
Wildcat Report

Latest

  1. 01 Wildcat Report Fearless Forecast: Northwestern vs. Minnesota
  2. 02 Wildcat Report Behind Enemy Lines: Minnesota
  3. 03 Wildcat Report Northwestern at Ohio State PFF Grades Analysis
  4. 04 Wildcat Report Northwestern working to support, improve QB Nicco Marchiol ahead of Minnesota
  5. 05 Wildcat Report Northwestern embarrassed by Columbia, 75-53