Toggle sidebar

Steelers

W

WVUATL1

Senior
Jan 5, 2008
10,238
749
113
******** on the NFL. I am never watching another **** game in this League ever. This is just ******** to overrule that call.
 
W

WVUJabroni_rivals

All-Conference
Dec 14, 2006
66,639
4,984
0
WVUATL1 said:
******** on the NFL. I am never watching another **** game in this League ever. This is just ******** to overrule that call.
Click to expand...

I don't like the rule but, by the rule, that is the correct call. Have to maintain possession all the way through and that ball spun from his grasp and appeared to be trapped on the ground.
 
K

KingofTowers

Redshirt
Dec 4, 2013
15,204
0
0
I’m not a Steelers fan but I’m confused on the call. He wasn’t even touched until he was in the endzone.
 
Keenan Cummings

Keenan Cummings

Heisman
Staff member
Sep 16, 2007
98,364
26,132
98
Honestly by the catch rule it looked like the right call. Had he just gone to the ground instead of stretching it out he would have been fine.
 
smooter

smooter

All-American
Mar 20, 2002
34,504
5,714
113
Keenan Cummings said:
Honestly by the catch rule it looked like the right call. Had he just gone to the ground instead of stretching it out he would have been fine.
Click to expand...
Honestly, I thought that rule applied to someone catching the ball and going straight to the ground. He caught the ball went to his knees...pivoted and lunged, which to me is a football move forward. I thought it was a catch and a fumble.
 
K

KingofTowers

Redshirt
Dec 4, 2013
15,204
0
0
Football has to fix the rules and review system. I shouldn’t need a referee to tell me if it was a good play.
 
W

WVU285

Sophomore
Dec 19, 2010
3,549
114
0
Tom Brady eats **** !! :angry:The NFL also eats it !!:angry: The ref`s eat it !!.....:angry:
 
Tin10Ten

Tin10Ten

All-Conference
Jan 18, 2007
13,929
1,739
113
 
MoTownWV

MoTownWV

All-American
May 29, 2001
61,471
5,597
112
WVUJabroni said:
I don't like the rule but, by the rule, that is the correct call. Have to maintain possession all the way through and that ball spun from his grasp and appeared to be trapped on the ground.
Click to expand...

If that is the rule, the rule sucks. He caught the ball with his hand and pull it in to his gut (catch at that point) before extending it it again to cross the goal line. That is when he lost the grasp.
 
Keenan Cummings

Keenan Cummings

Heisman
Staff member
Sep 16, 2007
98,364
26,132
98
smooter said:
Honestly, I thought that rule applied to someone catching the ball and going straight to the ground. He caught the ball went to his knees...pivoted and lunged, which to me is a football move forward. I thought it was a catch and a fumble.
Click to expand...

I’m not saying I agree with it. But by the “rule” it was the right call.
 
MoTownWV

MoTownWV

All-American
May 29, 2001
61,471
5,597
112
What I don’t understand is not doubling Gronk on that last drive and forcing someone else to beat you. They didn’t give any help to their smaller coverage guys even on the 2 pt conversion.
 
smooter

smooter

All-American
Mar 20, 2002
34,504
5,714
113
MoTownWV said:
What I don’t understand is not doubling Gronk on that last drive and forcing someone else to beat you. They didn’t give any help to their smaller coverage guys even on the 2 pt conversion.
Click to expand...
Or throwing a crossing route on that last play
 
M

mac101520

Redshirt
Jan 22, 2017
1,976
0
0
So if RB breaks plane with the ball its td but if wr breaks plane with the ball its no td?

Got it. Makes perfect sense lol

My black and gold still have the division so we’ll most likely see these guys again

Sad that the refs have to decide the game
 
W

wvtinman

Redshirt
Jan 6, 2006
3,299
16
0
The mixed opinions here about whether it was a catch or not, seems to say that the call on the field should not have been overturned. 100% without a doubt? Nah, not on that one.#ButIdon'tgiveashit
 
B

bayfronteer

Sophomore
Aug 21, 2009
1,153
120
0
Love it and couldn’t happen to a better fan base.

That call being overturned and ensued fan reaction is the perfect microcosm of the Steelers dire jealousy of everything with the NE Patriots. Brady owns that franchise!
 
J

jray1350

Freshman
Feb 5, 2003
3,673
81
48
WVUATL1 said:
******** on the NFL. I am never watching another **** game in this League ever. This is just ******** to overrule that call.
Click to expand...

It’s a horrible rule. A running back pushes the ball out and as soon as it touches the goal line it’s a TD and the play is immediately over. Same thing should apply on this play.
 
MoTownWV

MoTownWV

All-American
May 29, 2001
61,471
5,597
112
mac101520 said:
So if RB breaks plane with the ball its td but if wr breaks plane with the ball its no td?

Got it. Makes perfect sense lol

My black and gold still have the division so we’ll most likely see these guys again

Sad that the refs have to decide the game
Click to expand...

Pittsburgh’s problem is they can’t beat New England at home so how do they ever expect to beat them on the road.

Everyone wants to talk about Heinz Field being so tough but the Steelers are dreadful in big games at home.
 
C

CpEER

Senior
May 29, 2001
45,701
759
0
This thread gives me life


Not a catch. The moose out front with the rule book should have let you know.
 
S

Still...AllDayLong

All-Conference
Jun 30, 2005
27,043
2,072
48
Keenan Cummings said:
Honestly by the catch rule it looked like the right call. Had he just gone to the ground instead of stretching it out he would have been fine.
Click to expand...

Wrong. The ball is allowed to move. Plus, his hand was under the ball the whole time. Refs missed blatant PI on the last play too.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
WV Sports

Latest

  1. 01 WV Sports Michael Benson: Wren Baker continues to elevate WVU athletics
  2. 02 WV Sports Five West Virginia 2025 statistics that must be at least the floor in 2026
  3. 03 WV Sports Ross Hodge addresses final West Virginia roster opening, avenues
  4. 04 WV Sports NCAA waiver denied for Javan Buchanan, so process moves to next phase
  5. 05 WV Sports Ross Hodge press conference summary: 7-30
Top Bottom