Do we have one player that would start for UM?

B1G RED RULES

All-Conference
Sep 7, 2013
4,154
1,132
0
How many years have we asked similar questions? Look up the definition of insanity and you will see a pic of our fan base.
 

steinek11

All-Conference
Apr 18, 2004
13,568
1,315
113
I am encouraged by some of the younger guys, but the upper classmen are Frost guys and they are not good enough by a long shot.
 

V-Doub

Heisman
Jul 8, 2007
22,364
29,063
0
Maybe Fidone, maybe Grant or Kemp. Possibly Nash, but I definitely can’t say one player that I 100% believe would start for UM. So no I guess, yeah nobody really…
 

phoenix4nu

All-Conference
May 10, 2009
9,774
2,088
0
Maybe Fidone, maybe Grant or Kemp. Possibly Nash, but I definitely can’t say one player that I 100% believe would start for UM. So no I guess, yeah nobody really…
Fidone and Kemp might make their second team.
 

SLOHusker

Sophomore
Aug 7, 2001
2,740
123
0
I'm not certain.
GBR
No. The talent differential is on display. Nebraska has made mistakes like those irritating false starts, but you can't overcome this much of a talent disparity with coaching. NU has to pull in more 4 and 5 star players.
 

c3o

Sophomore
Apr 24, 2018
6,586
133
0
I’m sure some guys could. The coaching and development are tops in the country there. Let’s just hope Rhule can rebuild a team that can score on them
 

JOHNNY N

Heisman
Sep 24, 2003
109,994
39,220
0
Maybe a couple guys that could crack their two deep. Not sure who those two would even be
 

vs540husker

Heisman
Oct 3, 2004
92,067
10,221
0
This question comes up every single time Nebraska shows its complete inferiority to an opponent.
Callahan's final year every single person on here was adamant, that that roster didn't have a single player on it that could start for a single one of Nebraska's opponents that they lost to. Two years later, while comprised of many of those players, it was one of the best defenses in Nebraska history.
So the only way you're gonna have an answer, is if you take this entire roster from the time they were true freshman, and have them go through the exact same S&C, coaching, and development, that all of the Michigan players have gone through.
But since that's kind of impossible to do, all you're going to be able to say, is "maybe maybe not".
 

GeorgeFlippin

Heisman
May 29, 2001
38,584
35,556
113
This question comes up every single time Nebraska shows its complete inferiority to an opponent.
Callahan's final year every single person on here was adamant, that that roster didn't have a single player on it that could start for a single one of Nebraska's opponents that they lost to. Two years later, while comprised of many of those players, it was one of the best defenses in Nebraska history.
So the only way you're gonna have an answer, is if you take this entire roster from the time they were true freshman, and have them go through the exact same S&C, coaching, and development, that all of the Michigan players have gone through.
But since that's kind of impossible to do, all you're going to be able to say, is "maybe maybe not".
So, you're saying bring Bill Callahan back? ;)
 

Tetonia

Sophomore
Jan 22, 2022
4,580
175
63
That and invest heavily in our NIL program so we can get the caliber of players like Ohio State and Michigan have.
Cally put TALENT into our program. Coaching matters, and his staff was poor, no one ever said otherwise, but it’s MONEY that brings talent, and it’s BY FAR the most influential variable. We lack TALENT, and we’re only ever gonna get what we want by paying for it. Literally nothing else matters until that happens:
 

InMotion

Senior
Dec 12, 2020
1,482
628
113
I didn't look anything up but I would bet money that Michigan's entire 2nd string O-Line is better than our 1st string. Better recruiting and a better o-line coach is a must if we ever want to be good again. This is truth.
 

IdahoHuskerFan

Redshirt
Sep 20, 2023
117
0
0
Ben Scott, Nash, and probably Reimer
Junior Colson - MLB was 2nd team all conference last year - so no way Reimer starts

Michigan’s center was at Stanford last year and made an all conf team - Ben Scott played in the same conference last year and did not - your 0-2

Michigan’s NT backed up a 1st round draft pick last year. Hutmacher didn’t beat out Stephon Wynn. I’m giving the strong edge to Michigan’s NT
 
Last edited:

Bigred_b1624

Freshman
Nov 20, 2018
786
63
28
Junior Colson - MLB was 2nd team all conference last year - so no way Reimer starts

Michigan’s center was at Stanford last year and made an all conf team - Ben Scott played in the same conference last year and did not - your 0-2

Michigan’s NT backed up a 1st round draft pick last year. Hutmacher didn’t beat out Stephon Wynn. I’m giving the strong edge to Michigan’s NT
All 3 players I listed would start. At least try to actually watch football. I played college football and coach the game.

Either way we embarrassed ourselves and none of this matters.
 

Monsterback

All-Conference
Sep 30, 2009
1,835
1,513
93
I know Rhule wants to be the developer of undiscovered kids. TO did it extremely well, but it's different now and I'm not sure that is going to work. You can develop skills, but you have to recruit talent. Barry Switzer had it right...it's not about X's & O's, it's about Jimmy's & Joe's. We just need to get a bunch of Jimmy's and Joe's and invest in their talent.
 

ivan brunetti

Heisman
Nov 26, 2003
16,448
26,638
0
That and invest heavily in our NIL program so we can get the caliber of players like Ohio State and Michigan have.

Michigan's NIL money is used to keep proven players from transferring away. Michigan so far has not used NIL money to attract recruits. Ohio State and Penn State use NIL money for recruiting.
 

HuskerHusaria

All-Conference
Jun 4, 2017
7,417
2,212
113
Michigan's NIL money is used to keep proven players from transferring away. Michigan so far has not used NIL money to attract recruits. Ohio State and Penn State use NIL money for recruiting.
They probably use it for their AC helmets too. Was on full display yesterday
 

SLOHusker

Sophomore
Aug 7, 2001
2,740
123
0
I know Rhule wants to be the developer of undiscovered kids. TO did it extremely well, but it's different now and I'm not sure that is going to work. You can develop skills, but you have to recruit talent. Barry Switzer had it right...it's not about X's & O's, it's about Jimmy's & Joe's. We just need to get a bunch of Jimmy's and Joe's and invest in their talent.
You also just don't get the time you once did. Kids can transfer without sitting out and will do it more than once with the waivers being approved for any old reason. The days of a player sticking with it and working his way up the depth chart are going away. These days if a kid isn't starting or just sees a better NIL deal elsewhere he's gone.
 

19Football19

All-Conference
Dec 2, 2015
2,517
1,050
65
I am encouraged by some of the younger guys, but the upper classmen are Frost guys and they are not good enough by a long shot.
Quit blaming Frost. You’ll blame Rhule in 3 years when he’s gone. We’re 5 or 6 coaches deep and Everton lanes the previous coach. See politics. We’re the new Minn or Iowa. Accept it or you’ll be disappointed. Mid 3* U is real. Parity hit us harder than any school and it’s not changing.
 

phoenix4nu

All-Conference
May 10, 2009
9,774
2,088
0
We shouldn't have to worry about Michigan trying to poach any of our players after this game.
 

NUSouth

Sophomore
Oct 25, 2009
2,927
128
0
Announcers made an interesting comment yesterday that Harberg use to have 3 & 4 star players, now he has 4 & 5 star players and coaches them up. So doesn’t matter how good a coach you are if you don’t have the talent. I think the #1 quality in a great coach is being able to recruit the elite talent and then make them even better.
 

Hairliphenry

Freshman
Jun 1, 2022
1,075
75
37
Quit blaming Frost. You’ll blame Rhule in 3 years when he’s gone. We’re 5 or 6 coaches deep and Everton lanes the previous coach. See politics. We’re the new Minn or Iowa. Accept it or you’ll be disappointed. Mid 3* U is real. Parity hit us harder than any school and it’s not changing.
Take that loser mentality back to the iowa board.
 

InMotion

Senior
Dec 12, 2020
1,482
628
113
We shouldn't have to worry about Michigan trying to poach any of our players after this game.
Hey. Maybe our players can go watch a few of Michigan's practices and they can learn some new things that our coaches don't know how to teach. Especially the O-line.
 

huskercabby

Redshirt
Dec 2, 2002
4,087
0
0
Announcers made an interesting comment yesterday that Harberg use to have 3 & 4 star players, now he has 4 & 5 star players and coaches them up. So doesn’t matter how good a coach you are if you don’t have the talent. I think the #1 quality in a great coach is being able to recruit the elite talent and then make them even better.
ie. Dion Sanders. Interesting when I googled him he came up after typing in Dion. Rule didn't come up even after I typed in Matt Rule. :)