Biggest NU recruit who flopped?

Nate004

Junior
Feb 13, 2007
2,401
361
0
I’m willing to throw internet hands 😂 with anybody who mentions Marlon Lucky in this topic. No he wasn’t great but he was by no means a flop either. I just say that because his name usually pops up in topics like this. The dude rushed well for being in Callahan system and caught about a half billion screen passes that always seem to go for 5-10 yards minimum. Very good but not great player.
 

jflores

All-Conference
Feb 3, 2004
8,993
2,783
0
There's been a bunch. Curt Dukes and Cody Green come to mind. There were several folks in Cally's number one class who never saw the field for a variety of reasons.
 

Shimmer003

All-Conference
Feb 25, 2005
10,027
2,631
96
Aaron green didn’t stick around, but is up there. Harrison beck. Tyjon Lindsey. Jamal turner always seemed like the best athlete on the field that never did much. Deangelo evens might be the most talented player that never performed up to his talent level. Like lucky, he wasn’t bad, but could have been much more.
 

TFrazier_rivals269992

All-Conference
Jun 8, 2001
7,429
3,298
0
I'll start with Harrison Beck.


 

jozimmer

Redshirt
Sep 3, 2005
176
13
0
I’m willing to throw internet hands 😂 with anybody who mentions Marlon Lucky in this topic. No he wasn’t great but he was by no means a flop either. I just say that because his name usually pops up in topics like this. The dude rushed well for being in Callahan system and caught about a half billion screen passes that always seem to go for 5-10 yards minimum. Very good but not great player.
The same Marlon Lucky who has the single-season receptions record for NU at 75? The guy in the top 10 of several school records? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nebraska_Cornhuskers_football_statistical_leaders

Nobody should say he was a flop.
 
Jan 13, 2015
5,771
6,533
97
Aaron green didn’t stick around, but is up there. Harrison beck. Tyjon Lindsey. Jamal turner always seemed like the best athlete on the field that never did much. Deangelo evens might be the most talented player that never performed up to his talent level. Like lucky, he wasn’t bad, but could have been much more.

Deangelo, and some big creighton prep o linemen

This is from DeAngelo’s bio on Huskers.com

“As a true freshman in 1996, Evans made a huge impact for the Huskers. Evans was the Huskers' second-leading rusher, backing up sophomore starter Ahman Green and alternating with senior Damon Benning. Evans had one start--against Texas in the Big 12 Championship. Although he played the last nine games with a nagging groin/pelvic injury, Evans had the third-best freshman rushing season for the Huskers with 776 yards on 148 carries for a 5.2 yards per carry average.”


My recollection is they ruined him by continuing to play him through the injury, when we didn’t even need him because we had Green and Benning. He sat out the entire 1997 season and just never looked the same again. So the question is, is someone who was misused, a flop when he never recovers from the injury the coaches played him through?
 
Last edited:

redwine65

All-Conference
Jun 23, 2010
10,875
2,188
113
This is from DeAngelo’s bio on Huskers.com

“As a true freshman in 1996, Evans made a huge impact for the Huskers. Evans was the Huskers' second-leading rusher, backing up sophomore starter Ahman Green and alternating with senior Damon Benning. Evans had one start--against Texas in the Big 12 Championship. Although he played the last nine games with a nagging groin/pelvic injury, Evans had the third-best freshman rushing season for the Huskers with 776 yards on 148 carries for a 5.2 yards per carry average.”


My recollection is they ruined him by continuing to play him through the injury, when we didn’t even need him because we had Green and Benning. He sat out the entire 1997 season and just never looked the same again. So the question is, is someone who was misused, a flop when he never recovers from the injury the coaches played him through?
I'm just saying for a 5 star he kinda fell off the map...thunder seemed to do more
 

putemintheaisles

Redshirt
Apr 29, 2022
353
0
0
Aaron green didn’t stick around, but is up there. Harrison beck. Tyjon Lindsey. Jamal turner always seemed like the best athlete on the field that never did much. Deangelo evens might be the most talented player that never performed up to his talent level. Like lucky, he wasn’t bad, but could have been much more.
I saw Jamal Turner with his girlfriend and daughter at the Runza in the student Union right before he left. He had so much potential.
 

Headcard

Heisman
Feb 2, 2005
192,517
20,928
113
Cally had a bunch.

Andre Jones
Leon Jackson
Justin Tomerlin
Kenny Wilson
Harrison Beck
 

STUCKNKS

All-American
Jan 2, 2012
18,274
6,175
113
Aaron green didn’t stick around, but is up there. Harrison beck. Tyjon Lindsey. Jamal turner always seemed like the best athlete on the field that never did much. Deangelo evens might be the most talented player that never performed up to his talent level. Like lucky, he wasn’t bad, but could have been much more.
D'Angelo Evans was unreal but battled injury.
 
Feb 16, 2011
1,979
807
0
Anyone remember a guy from Maryland named Norvell Jackson(?). Late 70’s or early 80’s I think. He was supposed to be a stud running back that everyone wanted. I do t think he ever played a down here.
 

3fingershomer

Redshirt
Feb 8, 2022
426
0
0
Terry Rodgers, 1985 California Player of the Year. Got hurt here. Having Dad around probably didn’t help either.
 

schuele

All-American
Apr 17, 2005
21,124
5,734
0
Terry Rodgers, 1985 California Player of the Year. Got hurt here. Having Dad around probably didn’t help either.
People remember him as a legacy who didn’t pan out, but Rodgers showed some serious potential before he wrecked his knee.
 

bob5150

Senior
Dec 30, 2004
1,327
485
0
Simi Kuli. Class of 2007. Commited to Osborne. 5* DE. Flipped to Oregon State, then never made it to campus
 

timnsun

All-American
Jan 25, 2008
13,815
7,519
3
People remember him as a legacy who didn’t pan out, but Rodgers showed some serious potential before he wrecked his knee.
We took Rodgers over Barry Sanders, didn’t we? If only we could go back…
 

schuele

All-American
Apr 17, 2005
21,124
5,734
0
We took Rodgers over Barry Sanders, didn’t we? If only we could go back…
Well sure, Sanders was a huge miss. But my point is that NU didn’t just sign Rodgers because he was JR’s kid. He might have had a good career at NU if his knee didn’t explode. Von Shepherd was similar. He was a big-time wingback/KR out of the Twin Cities whose knees just wouldn’t hold up.

For me that’s a lot different than guys who just couldn’t cut it.
 

schuele

All-American
Apr 17, 2005
21,124
5,734
0
Not sure how highly rated he was, but Dante Wiley was touted as a huge LB recruit but never really got on the field.