A question or two for NASCAR fans...

FQDawg

Senior
May 1, 2006
3,076
618
113
If you're a NASCAR fan, do you also like Formula 1 racing or Indy car? If not, why not? What are the fundamental differences in the sports (besides different cars, obviously)?

And those are honest questions. I'm curious about the similarities/differences in the sports and how much (or little) their fan bases overlap.
 

T-TownDawgg

All-American
Nov 4, 2015
4,833
5,017
113
Natural Light/Stella Artois

I outgrew Nascar long time ago, but when I was into it, the technology of the Indys were far superior to stock cars. It was also exponentially more expensive to be competitive in F1. Also, Nascar is an American sport, F1 is global. These facts made the F1 vs Nascar discussion and it's fans seem more like soccer vs NFL.
 
Last edited:

bigiron.sixpack

Redshirt
Jun 24, 2009
682
0
15
I like to enjoy my spectator sports with others, so I was really into F1 when I worked with a bunch of Europeans and Japanese. That was a long time ago though, and I seldom watch F1 now. Never have been a big Nascar guy because I when I tried to watch it was: watch the start, nap, watch the end.
 

dorndawg

Heisman
Sep 10, 2012
9,495
11,072
113
Pretty much the only Nascar I watch is the Daytona 500 pre-race and first laps; just a good slice of Americana.

I wouldn't say I'm an F1 fan, but will watch a few laps when I see it on. It's bananas how skilled the drivers are and how the cars perform. I think they're up to like 6.5 G's in a few turns and go 220+ on basically city streets. Also the tv production value is amazing, I have no idea how they get some of the shots they do.
 

57stratdawg

Heisman
Dec 1, 2004
148,787
24,678
113
I don’t watch NASCAR anymore (in fact, very few people do), but in general NASCAR races tend to have closer finishes in my experience. Especially the restricter-plate races.
 

kired

All-Conference
Aug 22, 2008
7,200
2,666
113
I quit watching any of it about 10 years ago. But in the 90s there was a split in what's now known as Indycar that really screwed it up for years. Even if you wanted to be a fan, it was hard to follow after that. https://www.roadandtrack.com/motorsports/a29328/the-oral-history-of-the-split/

I was a big F1 fan as a teenager in the 90s, but guess I just lost interest because it was hard to follow with everything being outside the US. Just not much coverage here. Seems like the races used to come on something like the USA network early on Sunday mornings.

So for the years I followed Nascar (early 90s - 2010ish) it was simply the easiest to keep up with and had the most media coverage. Really wasn't much competition for them.

ETA: also much easier to attend different Nascar races living in the southeast US. There's probably half a dozen within reasonable driving distance.
 
Last edited:

GTAdawg

Redshirt
Sep 11, 2010
2,162
25
48
I actively quit keeping up with NASCAR after Jeff Gordon retired. When I was a kid and teenager in the late 90's early 00's I watched the stuff religiously and JG my favorite drive. Through the course of watching NASCAR during that time I enjoyed watching Indycar and CART(Indy spinoff). Never got into F1 that much because it is a totally different style of racing - super dependent on technology. They go so friggin' fast and track such an aggressive line in out of turns that you don't get the traditional "side by side" you see in something like NASCAR.

NASCAR has had a bit of a scale back in viewership the last few years. It's quite an expense to attend, people no longer have the attention span to spend four hours to watch (me included), and the sport has had some big time personalities move on and there just isn't enough big name guys left that move the needle. Unlike what a lot of others think, the actual racing product really isn't any less than what it has been in the last several years though - although I don't agree with their most recent move running restrictor plates on intermediate tracks. Doesn't have nearly the same effect as it does Daytona and Dega. Just makes everyone keep the throttle down but no closer racing.
 

615 Guy

Redshirt
Jun 6, 2018
294
12
18
Recently into F1 and I have no interest in NASCAR. Previous poster describing the difference as Natural Light vs Stella seems about right. I am not convinced the best driver wins in F1, I really think the car has a tremendous amount to do with the outcome. Put Lewis Hamilton in a Renault and Daniel Riccardo in a Mercedes and I'd bet the Mercedes driver places top 3 while the Renault driver places outside the top 5. Also, the tv product is really great not to mention the race locations are a bit more exotic than NASCAR.
 

MagnoliaHunter

All-Conference
Jan 23, 2007
1,885
1,595
113
long post

I watch both a lot. HUGE difference in technology and costs. The highest priced NASCAR teams were in the 20-25 million dollar range per car per year a few years ago. It probably less in the last few years with attendance and TV viewing dropping due in a large part to the idiot in charge changing up a lot of things to try to draw in more viewers which didn't work and alienated hardcore fans. Everything he did was the opposite of a good idea. He makes Larry Templeton look like Billy Bean in Money Ball. NASCAR has 15-20 that could win on any given day with the right luck, even more could win on a speedway. Plus races tend to be much closer and in doubt at the end due to technology being severely restricted by rules to try to keep smaller teams close to the big teams.

F1 cars are a technological marvel. top teams cost 100 million or more per car per year. Unless there is a wreck involving the top 2-3 teams, no one else will win. Most races are not close. Several good F1 drivers have come to NASCAR but with very limited success. they are fun to watch for the amazing speed though. The last place team would blow any other closed circuit car away.

Indy cars look like F1 cars, kind of like your kids baseball team looks like an MLB team. Very limited dollars compared to NASCAR and F1. As a previous poster stated, Indy car series was ruined when tony george, CEO of the Indianapolis Speedway, decided to take his track and leave to start his own series, thinking that he was bigger than the series. Problem was that most teams were contracted by their sponsors to race the existing series. both series almost died. they rejoined several years ago after tony's family kicked him out and took over again, and are just now starting to have decent fields.
 

cowbell88

All-Conference
Jan 11, 2009
3,388
1,138
113
Watch very little NASCAR now, but when I would watch every weekend; the only races that I would miss would be the 2 road courses.

Formula 1 and Indy run on a lot of road courses. Just not appealing to me. Also Indy and F1 cars all look alike and the manufacturer seems to just have an emblem or logo on the nose.

Back when NASCAR was so popular, you could go out and by a car (body style) on Monday like you watched race on Sunday. Now with COT and whatever they running now it’s no individuality any more. One of the many reasons it’s falling in popularity.
 

aTotal360

Heisman
Nov 12, 2009
22,698
16,771
113
F1 and football are my favorite sports. I really like NASCAR too. NASCAR and drag racing fans are a different crowd. They usually only watch that specific sport. Typically F1 fans have a broader palette of motorsports because it's a global sport. Honestly, I'll watch anything with wheels. I think most F1 fans will also follow MotoGP, IMSA, Indy, etc.
 

615 Guy

Redshirt
Jun 6, 2018
294
12
18
I stayed up for it myself. Ferrari has to give Leclerc a better chance, he looks superior to Vettel right now and I don't think any other constructor but Ferrari has a chance to beat either Mercedes consistently. If I am Ferrari I drop Vettel and bring in Verstappen; Leclerc / Verstappen would be a great young duo.
 
Sep 1, 2011
2,571
289
83
NASCAR has basically killed itself by not appealing to the fans that built it. It is crazy to me. I was never the biggest of fans, but it is not fun to watch like it used to be.
 

RocketDawg

All-Conference
Oct 21, 2011
20,618
3,209
113
When NASCAR first started, they used real stock cars ... cars just like you and I could buy at the dealership. They probably had a few tweaks, but they were real cars. Now, they're custom built to rigid specs from the ground up ... engines, frame, body, brakes ... everything. They are FAR from stock cars. The only reason they look like a Toyota or Chevy or whatever is beause they've plastered a few decals on the body that make them look like their namesake (and money sponsor).

But they're far from real stock cars. I like to watch them race occasionally, but I like Indy cars and Formula I much more.
 

conceptDawg

Redshirt
Mar 3, 2008
43
0
0
I'm an F1 and IMSA guy and have been for decades. I never liked NASCAR because "they just turn left." Road courses are so much more appealing to me. I didn't even like the Indy 500 because of this though I watched it for the spectacle, but I still watch when they are doing road courses like COTA and Long Beach.

Oh, and F1 budgets for the big teams are closer to $450 million per team. It's insane. The lower tier teams like Haas run on about $100m a year and they can't sniff the front row unless something crazy were to happen (weather, multiple crashes in qualifying, etc.). The technology on these cars and the mechanics, engineers, and staff needed to run the teams are mind-boggling. Although they look similar—they ARE built to a formula, after all—each team's design is completely bespoke and unique. The only thing they share are the ECUs and kinetic energy control units (built by Merc for all of the teams, I think). Some teams buy engines from suppliers, but other than that the entire car is self-designed and built.

The problem is that Merc and Ferrari (and to some extent Red Bull) have spent everybody else into oblivion. The races have become rote.

IndyCar is a spec series so the costs are relatively small when compared to the completely bespoke cars in F1. They all run the exact same chassis (built by Dallara). They have engine suppliers also, so there's not much difference between the cars, hence the racing is closer. The drivers are usually top notch across the board so there's very little separating winning and losing.

IMSA/BlancPain (LeMan prototypes and GT3), GT4, and the various related series are closer to where NASCAR was a few decades ago when it comes to seeing a car and being able to buy it. There are multiple constructors running what are, for all intents and purposes, the exact same cars you can go in and buy. Now, let's be honest, they've had quite a bit of improvements done to them but they are still the same chassis you can buy at your local Porsche, Ferrari, Bentley, Audi, and Lambo dealers.

They DO use BOP, which is a religious topic I won't get into here but I don't think this series could exist with this many manufacturers if they didn't find some way to keep them competitive with each other on track.

This is my favorite series to watch now because of the varied skill levels of the racers (some are rich amateurs that buy their seats, some are experienced pros) and different cars that I can relate to. It's exciting racing and they run at the top tracks all over the US and the rest of the world. You can catch most of the races a day after they run on YouTube.

Oh, and they run multiple classes (prototypes vs. GTLM vs. GTAm) on the same track at the same time, thereby creating chaos and incredible speed differentials on certain parts of the track.
 

aTotal360

Heisman
Nov 12, 2009
22,698
16,771
113
I don't think LEC was any faster than VET in China. They were justified in letting VET pass at that point in the race. Where I think they screwed up was not leaving LEC out there long enough to see if a different pit strategy would shake things up. The put him right in the middle of the pit window for that compound and it wasn't a strong enough swing to hit a homerun.

Ferrari still doesn't have the pace to keep up with Merc at this moment. And it hurts my soul to say it. Merc is able to dictate race strategy with their superior speed.
 
Nov 12, 2007
26,212
10,366
113
NASCAR has basically killed itself by not appealing to the fans that built it. It is crazy to me. I was never the biggest of fans, but it is not fun to watch like it used to be.


What killed my interest was the aboundance of 180 mph tracks that the winner usually is a lap or more ahead at the end. I will watch the superspeedway and short track races.

That and I can't stand Kurt Busch or the new scoring, but that has really only
grown over the past couple of seasons.
 

JoMo MoJo

Redshirt
Dec 24, 2017
1,895
0
0
There is a awesome series on with Netflix or prime that documents the 2018 or maybe 2017 F1 season. Whenever it was that RedBull broke away from Renault and went to Honda and Force India’s owner had to sell to the Canadian. Also on prime is a very interesting history of the Williams F1 team.
 

aTotal360

Heisman
Nov 12, 2009
22,698
16,771
113
What killed NASCAR's momentum? A combination of 3 things.

1) The Car of Tomorrow
2) JJ's dominance
3) Too many mile and a half tracks replacing classic tracks for just for venue $$$ and not because of the racing.
 

JoMo MoJo

Redshirt
Dec 24, 2017
1,895
0
0
They actually make a template of the shape of a production car from the front tip of the hood to the back edge of the trunk and the race car that is racing as a ford or Chevy or whatever has to match that template.
 

conceptDawg

Redshirt
Mar 3, 2008
43
0
0
Yep. The Drive to Survive series is pretty good. It's a recap and behind-the-scenes of last year's season ( 2018)8 ). Ferrari and Merc didn't give access but it has all of the other teams. Lots of driver/teammate drama and good HD of pits, paddock, racing, etc.

There's another series, Gentleman Driver (I think) that does something similar with the IMSA amateur rich guys (GTAM) that buy their seats on teams. It's interesting.

The Williams documentary is good. I really wish Williams would turn their fortunes around because I like Claire Williams and hope that she does well. There's also a McLaren documentary that's very similar.
 
Last edited:

conceptDawg

Redshirt
Mar 3, 2008
43
0
0
I agree with this. I've seen lots of people saying that Ferrari ruined LEC's race by letting VET through. But LEC wasn't exactly up in the gearbox of the Mercs either. I don't think it changed the eventual outcome of the race much.

The problem with Ferrari (other than not having a car that can keep up with the Merc, obviously) is that they compound their issues by nearly always having really terrible in-race strategy decisions. It's been that way for years. They need to quit firing team bosses and accept that they need better strategists in the back room. Merc takes their lunch money every race just on strategy alone.
 
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White "Give us a chance, we can make the plays": Anthony Evans III speaks on getting the offense firing again
  2. 02 Maroon and White Football Mississippi State offense does enough to overcome errors, early nerves against Tennessee Tech
  3. 03 Maroon and White Rapid Recap: Mississippi State 34-16 Tennessee Tech
  4. 04 Maroon and White Basketball "When you win these type of games, you're gonna learn and grow": Mississippi State tops Tulsa in Jackson
  5. 05 Maroon and White Basketball Mississippi State vs. Tulsa: How, Where, and When to Watch Men's Basketball in Jackson