Can we discuss this Harold Baines HOF BS?

CochiseCowbell

Heisman
Oct 29, 2012
15,969
15,156
113
How the hell is he in over many, many others (including Dale Murphy, Fred McGriff, Will Clark)?

Now, I know, or at least think I read, that he was in a special Veterans section of Cooperstown. Unfortunately, I've yet to visit, so I'm a little unclear on how the separate exhibits work.

Can someone clue me in here?
 

Drebin

Heisman
Aug 22, 2012
23,177
29,278
113
It's ridiculous.

Keith Hernandez probably didn't do enough to get into the hall of fame, but his right testicle is more qualified for the hall than Harold Freakin' Baines.
 

WutheringDawg

All-Conference
Dec 4, 2010
2,244
1,214
113
It’s not that Baines is in a special sub-section of the Hall, he is a full blown member and will get the whole nine yards. He was selected by a veterans committee that is in place to review the candidacy of players who fell off the BBWAA ballot previously. He and Lee Smith were inducted with the other eight candidates getting fewer than five votes a piece except for Lou Pinella who fell one vote shy of being inducted.

The immediate outrage comes from the fact that Baines was selected on a ballot that included Will Clark, Orel Hershiser, Albert Belle and Joe Carter. All of whom with maybe the exception of cater have a clear cut argument for being enshrined before Baines (by definition an accumulator who had very little impact on the game).

the biggest issue is with the selection process of who is on the committee because there were multiple voters with very close ties to Baines (White Sox GM, Tony LaRussa) that we’re not asked to recuse themselves in the process of discussing Baines candidacy and I don’t really think that lends very much credibility to these committed. Below is an excerpt of how they work taken from Wikipedia.


[FONT=&quot]Separate 16-member subcommittees continue to vote on individuals from different eras of baseball, with candidates still being classified by the time periods that cover their greatest contributions:[/FONT]
  • Early Baseball (1871–1949)
  • Golden Days (1950–1969)
  • Modern Baseball (1970–1987)
  • Today's Game (1988 and later)
[FONT=&quot]All committees' ballots include 10 candidates. At least one committee convenes every December, in the calendar year before the induction ceremony in July. The Early Baseball committee will convene decennially in years ending in 0, and the Golden Days committee will convene every five years, in years ending in 0 and 5. The Today's Game and Modern Baseball committees alternate their meetings in that order, skipping years in which the Golden Days and Early Baseball committees meet.[SUP][3][/SUP][/FONT]
[FONT=&quot]Accordingly, the committees will meet in the following years as part of the elections for the next calendar year: [/FONT]

  • Today's Game – 2021, 2023
  • Modern Baseball – 2019, 2022, 2024
  • Golden Days – 2020, 2025
  • Early Baseball – 2020
 

CochiseCowbell

Heisman
Oct 29, 2012
15,969
15,156
113
"(by definition an accumulator who had very little impact on the game)."

This is one of many reasons I hate the DH.

"The Early Baseball committee will convene decennially in years ending in 0, and the Golden Days committee will convene every five years, in years ending in 0 and 5."

Whoever wrote/edited this dug deep into Greek/Latin roots, yet couldn't be bothered to include pentennially?!

Thesauri: making bad writers look worse for generations.
 

QuaoarsKing

All-Conference
Mar 11, 2008
6,387
3,337
113
This Committee should be (at least in my opinion) considering people who barely missed getting into the Hall, or people who were left out for a specific reason (like McGwire and Sosa).

Baines just barely got over 5% of the vote for his first 4 years on the ballot and then was dropped after the 5th year when he fell below 5%. The voters spoke resoundingly that he didn't make the cut.
 

PineGroveBully

Redshirt
Nov 13, 2007
8,508
2
0
Back in the day when I was collecting cards Harold Baines wasn't good enough to go in my 3 ring binder.

I can think of a 100 players who aren't in for this reason or that that are much more deserving.
 

johnson86-1

All-American
Aug 22, 2012
15,317
5,868
113
BS?!?!

Somebody didn't play RBI baseball growing up.

At least I think Baines was one of the good players on that? Basically McGuire then baines as the best hitters maybe?
 

Drebin

Heisman
Aug 22, 2012
23,177
29,278
113
BS?!?!

Somebody didn't play RBI baseball growing up.

At least I think Baines was one of the good players on that? Basically McGuire then baines as the best hitters maybe?


Ha, I remember the game.

I know you're joking here (or at least I think you are). Baines was a good player and had some good years. But if he is a hall of famer, there are at least 100 others out there that should be immediately enshrined as well.
 

Drebin

Heisman
Aug 22, 2012
23,177
29,278
113
The glory days of baseball.....when **** got handled on the field, instead of this sissy stuff we see today.
 

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
61,503
33,381
113
Murphy and Clark were great in their prime, but both of their primes were short. Baines has 100 more HRs than Clark and over 400 more RBIs. Murphy does have 16 more HRs, but 350 fewer RBIs and a significantly worse batting average. Crime Dog should absolutely be in the HOF, and it's not even close.
 

8dog

All-American
Feb 23, 2008
15,333
7,763
113
Dale murphy won two mvp awards. He led the NL in HR two straight years neither of which were his mvp years. 7 all star games and 5 gold gloves. He and baines shouldnt be in the same sentence. Not to mention murphy is a huge reason an entire region followed baseball growing up
 
Last edited by a moderator:

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
61,503
33,381
113
But Murphy was really only an above average player for 6 years. The other 12 years of his career were pretty ugly. Not saying he doesn't belong in the HOF, but over the course of a career, I'd take Baines every day.
 

PineGroveBully

Redshirt
Nov 13, 2007
8,508
2
0
The saddest thing is the MLB HOF was the one that really meant something. All of the others are pretty much the hall of pretty good, but you knew if you were enshrined at Cooperstown, by God it meant something, you knew you were among the great of the greats. That's why those introduction speeches were so great, they felt the weight of the room around them. I seldom missed an introduction, some of my favorite speeches were Ricky Henderson, Bob Uecker, Chipper, and Jr. Griffey. As a Cards man I thought Lee probably deserved it, but even his induction is tainted.

this thread reminded me of a great painting I saw with all the greats pictured, I first saw it after Jr was inducted. I would love to have it framed but it's a bit salty at the time

View attachment 11952
 

PreacherDog

Redshirt
Nov 10, 2017
199
0
16
Harold Baines best season isn't as good as Barry Bond's worst season. Let that sink in.

While I agree with the sentiment, this is a terrible take. Baines best was not bad [25 hrs 113 rbis] (but certainly not hall worthy). Bonds first 4 seasons were nothing to write home about. His first big season 90.
 

Arthur2478

Redshirt
Oct 17, 2010
1,407
2
38
Murphy and Clark were great in their prime, but both of their primes were short. Baines has 100 more HRs than Clark and over 400 more RBIs. Murphy does have 16 more HRs, but 350 fewer RBIs and a significantly worse batting average. Crime Dog should absolutely be in the HOF, and it's not even close.

Murphy was the most feared hitter in the NL for several years. That's more than Baines could ever say. It's the Hall of Fame, not the Hall of pretty good. If Baines is in, then Murphy should be in. Their accolades aren't even close to being equal:

Murphy:


Baines:

 
Last edited:

msudawg1200

All-Conference
Sep 19, 2012
1,094
1,043
113
First of all, I think Harold Baines was a very good baseball player, but both the Baseball and Football HOF'S are putting way to many people in. It is supposed to be a Hall of Fame, not a Hall of Very Good. Harold Baines is not a HOFer, but many in both Hall's aren't either. You shouldn't seen many HOFers in your lifetime. You should be one of the best at your postion for a long period of time. You don't need to put undeserving players in every year justto have a ceremony. Both Hall's are becoming a joke.
 

VegasDawg13

Freshman
Jun 11, 2007
2,191
80
48
The saddest thing is the MLB HOF was the one that really meant something. All of the others are pretty much the hall of pretty good
What makes you say that about the Pro Football HOF? I don't really have an opinion on the players from before the 90's, but the players that are in that I do have an opinion on, there are very few, if any, that I would argue aren't HOF-worthy.

The most recent class, for example, was some old timers I had never heard of, plus Randy Moss, TO, Urlacher, Ray Lewis, and Brian Dawkins. That's pretty unassailable imo. Admittedly, not every class is *that* good, but I don't see many head-scratchers this century.

Obviously baseball and football are about as different as they can be. Baseball's best players can be mostly defined by stats. Stats are completely useless for most positions in football. So it's hard to compare them.
 

dorndawg

Heisman
Sep 10, 2012
9,495
11,070
113
Bonds WAR 1st 3 full seasons (87, 88, 89): 5.8, 6.3, 8.0

Baines best WAR (1984): 4.3

Honestly, the more I look at his stats, Baines shouldn't even be in the Hall of Really Good, much less the HoF. He's Ron Gant if Gant had had a healthier career.
 

Bulldog Bruce

All-American
Nov 1, 2007
5,306
6,592
113
It is the Hall of FAME. Talk about all the numbers you want, but I like to think of it as if you wrote a overview of baseball every decade, would that person appear in that article. Dale Murphy absolutely would. Orel Hersheiser absolutely would. George Steinbrenner absolutely would. I don't think Harold Baines would make the article. If you want to tell someone about the 1980's in baseball those are the names that would come up that are not in the HOF. Harold Baines would only come up if you were talking about people who might be underrated.
 
Last edited:

VegasDawg13

Freshman
Jun 11, 2007
2,191
80
48
It is the Hall of FAME. Talk about all the numbers you want, but I like to think of it as if you wrote a overview of baseball every decade, would that person appear in that article. Dale Murphy absolutely would. Orel Hersheiser absolutely would. George Steinbrenner absolutely would. I don't think Harold Baines would make the article. If you want to tell someone about the 1980's in baseball those are the names that would come up that are not in the HOF. Harold Baines would only come up if you were talking about people who might be underrated.
The problem with this argument, which I don't think is without merit, is that it will unfairly benefit 1) players from major media markets, 2) players with media-friendly personalities, and 3) players on great teams. The first two allow them to be more famous than their small-market or introverted equals. The third allows them more chances to have important moments. You can't tell the story of baseball in the 2000's without Aaron Boone, for example.
 

Bulldog Bruce

All-American
Nov 1, 2007
5,306
6,592
113
I understand what you are saying, but Aaron Boone was not twice the best player in the league or the best pitcher in the league for a year or two. Ralph Kiner and Sandy Koufax had relatively short careers but were very good over those years and got into the HOF. I just have an issue when the talk gets to having 15 or 20 years to be HOF worthy. Players that have popularity or are known for a single event get to be in Cooperstown in the museum, but not in the HOF. So when a player is the best for a 5 year period he should not be disqualified because it was not long enough compared to Willie Mays, Stan Musial or Henry Aaron.
 
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White Basketball Mississippi State vs. Tulsa: How, Where, and When to Watch Men's Basketball in Jackson
  2. 02 Maroon and White Football Keys to Victory for Mississippi State vs. Tennessee Tech
  3. 03 Maroon and White Football Recruiting Top 10 2027 QB Gavin Hampton and Bulldog commit highlights mental and physical improvements to his game
  4. 04 Rivals Basketball Recruiting Exclusive: NC State, Virginia Tech, South Carolina & more pursuing 4-star Micah Gunter
  5. 05 Maroon and White Mississippi State Soccer hosts Samford in NCAA Tournament on Friday