I'm with you in general, but I don't think they are totally BS. They can tell a story, just not the whole story.
I do think our athleticism will win out in the end, but I don't see a blowout. I guess I could see 20-10 or similar.
They aren't totally BS if we were all playing the same opponents. They would be more reliable if they were conference-only rankings, or even better, division-only rankings.
Overall, yes, they can tell a story. But playing Kentucky, LSU, Florida, Auburn, Texas A&M, Alabama, Arkansas, and Ole Miss is not like playing Minnesota, Indiana, Maryland, Penn State, Purdue, Illinois, and Nebraska.
They've only played two teams ranked in the top 25 currently, and one of them (Northwestern) is barely there.