About the incomplete call in the UM-Vandy game.

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
61,529
33,413
113
The rule is terrible. It still was at least a close call even by the rule. If they’d called it complete, I’m not sure it would be overturned. They got screwed. After what happened to us last week, I’m having trouble feeling much sympathy for them though.
 

PBRME

All-American
Feb 12, 2004
11,677
5,918
113
It was the right call. Have to maintain control. He didn’t. If he tucked the ball instead of trying to make style points it would’ve been a completion. If it happened to us I’d still be pissed. No sympathy for them.
 

maroonmania

All-Conference
Feb 23, 2008
11,389
1,165
113
It was the right call. Have to maintain control. He didn’t. If he tucked the ball instead of trying to make style points it would’ve been a completion. If it happened to us I’d still be pissed. No sympathy for them.

Like it or not, the rule is that to establish possession in the end zone you have to maintain possession through the ground. If Brown wasn't hotdogging (as usual) with the ball extended out in his hand when it didn't need to be it wouldn't have ended up being an issue.
 
Jun 30, 2018
1,011
0
0
You're wrong. They did call it complete on the field. Then overturned it upon replay.

I am not sure what many of ya'll are smoking. Brown was showboating trying to hold the ball with one hand and lost it at the end. It was legit and the right call, and the rule should not be changed.
 

Resolved

Redshirt
May 18, 2008
622
0
0
He had control when his *** hit the ground. It was a catch. They got screwed, which is just fine with me. But if it had happened to us, you'd be livid. Let's just agree the SEC refs are inconsistent, to be polite. Let's just hope they don't have a make-up call Thanksgiving night.
 

PBRME

All-American
Feb 12, 2004
11,677
5,918
113
His *** hitting the ground has nothing to do with a completion. It doesn’t matter where on the field you are. If you catch the ball, fall, bobble and drop it then it’s not a catch. Period.
 

thekimmer

All-Conference
Aug 30, 2012
8,970
3,193
113
Despite the satisfaction in that particular play, it is an unfair rule. With that said however, the rule does have some merit to at least provide a tiny counter to the massive advantage given to receivers who are allowed to grab, shove, pull, and push off defenders with impunity while DBs are flagged for looking in the wrong direction. Its so bad that literally every time a pass is broken up at the point of the catch you get the automatic where's-the-flag signal from the receiver.
 
Last edited:

Drebin

Heisman
Aug 22, 2012
23,180
29,284
113
Despite the satisfaction in that particular play, it is an unfair rule. With that said however, the rule does have some merit to at least provide a tiny counter to the massive advantage given to receivers who are allowed to hold, , shove, pull, hand fight and nudge defenders with impunity while DBs are flagged for the slightest touch. Its so bad that literally every instance when a pass is broken up at the point of the catch you get the universal throw-the-flag signal from the receiver.

I agree with this. Between defensive pass interference and random booth reviews, it's getting more and more difficult to sit through an SEC football game.
 

thf24

Redshirt
Jan 28, 2011
1,334
3
38
He had control when his *** hit the ground. It was a catch. They got screwed, which is just fine with me. But if it had happened to us, you'd be livid. Let's just agree the SEC refs are inconsistent, to be polite. Let's just hope they don't have a make-up call Thanksgiving night.

Having control when you hit the ground is not a catch; you have to maintain control through the process of hitting the ground if you haven't already established control while still on your feet. It wasn't a catch because he started flourishing, and lost control in the process, before he'd come to a stop.
 

Funk6652

Redshirt
Oct 24, 2013
98
18
8
In Oxferd that is a catch. Kellum-“TOUCHDOWN!! OLE MISS!!!
Wait. What?!”
I love listening to him when they lose.
 
Aug 22, 2012
2,761
1
31
This rule makes complete sense to me

The rule is terrible. It still was at least a close call even by the rule. If they’d called it complete, I’m not sure it would be overturned. They got screwed. After what happened to us last week, I’m having trouble feeling much sympathy for them though.

I'm not sure why people get so upset about it. You have to survive the ground to establish possession on a catch.

When it's slowed down 4 or 5 times on replay, it looks like a catch because it seems like he had it for a while. But in real time he barely had it in his hands before it was ripped out. I'd be disappointed if that happened to us, but it's the correct interpretation of the rule.
 

Drebin

Heisman
Aug 22, 2012
23,180
29,284
113
I'm not sure why people get so upset about it. You have to survive the ground to establish possession on a catch.

When it's slowed down 4 or 5 times on replay, it looks like a catch because it seems like he had it for a while. But in real time he barely had it in his hands before it was ripped out. I'd be disappointed if that happened to us, but it's the correct interpretation of the rule.

The thing is, it wasn't even ripped out. As he hit the ground, he was hot dogging it by holding the ball in one hand, and the ball popped loose before the Vandy defender made contact with it. That's what made it incomplete. By rule, it was the correct call.
 

Rebeldude

Redshirt
Aug 22, 2012
169
0
16
My biggest thing is AJ got up doing the juggling motion saying it wasn't a catch because he thought it was intercepted.

Then started strutting when he saw the official signaling touchdown.
 

RiverCityDawg

All-American
Dec 30, 2009
3,424
5,462
113
The thing is, it wasn't even ripped out. As he hit the ground, he was hot dogging it by holding the ball in one hand, and the ball popped loose before the Vandy defender made contact with it. That's what made it incomplete. By rule, it was the correct call.

Yeah this is what people seem to be missing in their haste to blame the officials. It came loose in his hand before the Vandy guy ripped it away. Doesn't matter that his but already hit the ground, he has to complete the catch through contact with the ground. That's the rule.

Moral of the story - Tuck the ball away if you have the chance just like coaches teach at every level of football... Though we know from Treadwell that they don't really coach receivers at ole miss.
 
Jun 30, 2018
1,011
0
0
Yeah this is what people seem to be missing in their haste to blame the officials. It came loose in his hand before the Vandy guy ripped it away. Doesn't matter that his but already hit the ground, he has to complete the catch through contact with the ground. That's the rule.

Moral of the story - Tuck the ball away if you have the chance just like coaches teach at every level of football... Though we know from Treadwell that they don't really coach receivers at ole miss.
Yeah it's really not rocket science. They took the time to review it, and made the call. When refs do that, I can't complain. The problem we had in Tuscaloosa was there was NO REVIEW. Then, obviously you cannot review a penalty.

Furthermore, the catch rule is a good rule. It's the difference between passing and rushing.
 
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White "Give us a chance, we can make the plays": Anthony Evans III speaks on getting the offense firing again
  2. 02 Maroon and White Football Mississippi State offense does enough to overcome errors, early nerves against Tennessee Tech
  3. 03 Maroon and White Rapid Recap: Mississippi State 34-16 Tennessee Tech
  4. 04 Maroon and White Basketball "When you win these type of games, you're gonna learn and grow": Mississippi State tops Tulsa in Jackson
  5. 05 Maroon and White Basketball Mississippi State vs. Tulsa: How, Where, and When to Watch Men's Basketball in Jackson