Metcalf out for season

CochiseCowbell

Heisman
Oct 29, 2012
15,963
15,149
113
I do hope that the young man makes a full recovery and has a successful life as a contributing member of society.

Good luck with the latter part of this.

There are two bothers, their names escape me but they needed to buy a vowel, who have definitely contributed to society & have graciuosly given back to their communities.

Jung, you waded into the wrong thread & have jumped the shark.
 

dawgdr

Redshirt
Feb 27, 2008
425
10
18
Has Jung ever admitted that the hit on Fitz was dirty? I personally have never had a MS fan admit it was. I really hope no one on here is glad kid is hurt. But the thread reads about like I would expect after last years Egg Bowl and their continued play.
 

HammerOfTheDogs

All-Conference
Jun 20, 2001
10,856
1,708
113
If I haven't said it was in poor taste on this board, which I believe I have, then I will be the first to tell you it was and I wish he wouldn't have done it. Invoking karma (********) and saying 17 you to a kid with a season ending injury is also in poor taste. I didn't wake up aiming to set the record for downvotes this morning but I might as well. To whoever said the principle is OT biblical is right, but that doesn't mean the Amalikite women and children would've liked it nor does it make sense for it to be embraced by, I assume, self identified members of so called Christendom over someone doing something merely offensive.
he's not a "kid"...he's a grown MAN! Stop infantilizing men.
 

mstateglfr

All-American
Feb 24, 2008
17,047
6,895
113
I guess the same principle as in baseball when your pitcher hits one of my batters, my pitcher is going to hit one of your batters even though the opposing batter didn't have anything to do with what his pitcher did.

This is absolutely one of the dumbest traditions in sports. A completely unjustifiable and childlike outburst of emotion which all too often leads to both sides being disciplined and sometimes leads to the pitcher being tossed.
Its completely stupid. And its really stupid to justify being happy for someone's injury based on a pitcher retaliating for a teammate being hit by a ball by hitting an opponent with the ball.

Its second only to fighting in hockey where the refs actually join the group on ice watching, and allow it up to a totally random point, and then they declare the fight to be over. So totally dumb.
The counter is that fighting is part of hockey's tradition. Just because something is tradition doesnt mean its good or justifiable.




This place sometimes...I can understand why we are where we are as a country after reading this board.
 

HammerOfTheDogs

All-Conference
Jun 20, 2001
10,856
1,708
113
This is absolutely one of the dumbest traditions in sports. A completely unjustifiable and childlike outburst of emotion which all too often leads to both sides being disciplined and sometimes leads to the pitcher being tossed.
Its completely stupid. And its really stupid to justify being happy for someone's injury based on a pitcher retaliating for a teammate being hit by a ball by hitting an opponent with the ball.

Its second only to fighting in hockey where the refs actually join the group on ice watching, and allow it up to a totally random point, and then they declare the fight to be over. So totally dumb.
The counter is that fighting is part of hockey's tradition. Just because something is tradition doesnt mean its good or justifiable.




This place sometimes...I can understand why we are where we are as a country after reading this board.

There's a reason they let them fight. European hockey has little fighting, but lots of high-sticking. US refs would rather see hockey players hit each other with fists, than weapons.
 

Cap'n Geech

Redshirt
Aug 15, 2018
613
0
0
Hopefully he's OK and just choosing not to risk further injury during a season without the possibility of a postseason. I wouldn't mind the Cowboys drafting him next year.
 

maroonmania

All-Conference
Feb 23, 2008
11,389
1,165
113
This is absolutely one of the dumbest traditions in sports. A completely unjustifiable and childlike outburst of emotion which all too often leads to both sides being disciplined and sometimes leads to the pitcher being tossed.
Its completely stupid. And its really stupid to justify being happy for someone's injury based on a pitcher retaliating for a teammate being hit by a ball by hitting an opponent with the ball.

Its second only to fighting in hockey where the refs actually join the group on ice watching, and allow it up to a totally random point, and then they declare the fight to be over. So totally dumb.
The counter is that fighting is part of hockey's tradition. Just because something is tradition doesnt mean its good or justifiable.




This place sometimes...I can understand why we are where we are as a country after reading this board.

I have no desire for any college player to get hurt ever. But when a player gets injured who plays for a team that specializes in tackling in a way that intends to severely injure opposing QBs I'm certainly not going to get depressed over it. What comes around goes around.
 

HuskyBDawg

Sophomore
Nov 26, 2017
297
102
43
Eye for an Eye vs Standing Up for Yourself

I don't think that the biblical "eye for an eye" analogy completely fits the sports situation.

Retaliation for perceived wrongs done to individuals (or teams, countries, etc.) is sometimes a follow up action intended as a deterrent to the instigator to prevent future wrongs and as a warning to other potential attackers.

This is why people believe that they must stand up to bullies. The belief is that retaliation keeps the bully from escalating attacks and discourages others from engaging in bullying actions.

The Cold War between the US and the Soviet Union was based on a concept of massive retaliation. According to Wikipedia, "the aim of massive retaliation is to deter another state from initially attacking." Secretary of State John Foster Dulles also stated, "A potential aggressor must know that he cannot always prescribe the battle conditions that suit him."

The recent SixPack debate about the absence of a flag planting scene involves this concept. It was significant that the United States was first to successfully land a moon mission, because it signaled to the Russians (and the world) that USA had advanced technology, which equates to power. Mutual respect for the rival's capabilities may well have been responsible for keeping the peace throughout the Cold War. I realize that this is not the point of the film and don't have an opinion on the lack of a flag planting scene.

This post has nothing to do with the original post about karma, but flows along the branch of the thread about retaliation in sports. It does bring to mind that you wouldn't expect a team to deliberately injure their opponents out of fear of retribution.


tl;dr - If you don't want me to hit you, then don't hit me.
 

L4Dawg

All-American
Oct 27, 2016
12,212
8,661
113
I don't ever wish for opposing players to be hurt period, and I hope our fans wouldn't either. But that said, if you think the touchdown celebration was just a touchdown celebration, I wonder what you would think of a "leg humper" who raised his leg on the sacred grounds of Oxford during the egg bowl? It was in poor taste and I have yet to see one Shark fan say that it was.

They all thought it was great.
 

Bruce Dakinson

Redshirt
Nov 14, 2015
111
0
16
Did I miss something? Why exactly are we happy about the Metcalf injury? Dude is a college football player. We praised Nickoe for his actions at the eggbowl with Ole Bro Wallace.

[FONT=&quot]¯\_(ツ)_/¯[/FONT]
 

mstateglfr

All-American
Feb 24, 2008
17,047
6,895
113
Just couldn’t stand it could you?

That wasnt a political comment- it was a comment on us as a society.

People excited that a football player is injured so badly they are out for the season is sad.
People claiming said football player is injured due to karma(for Nick's injury or for pretending to raise a leg and pee) is sad.
People claiming being happy about the injury is justified because a player of ours was injured last season playing against them is sad. This isnt biblical eye for an eye ****- its just college football.


I dislike where we are as a country right now and I think that a lot of it has to do with our collective inability to let **** go, our collective inability to feel sympathy or empathy for those we are 'against', and our collective joy in being happy/justified for the suffering of others.

Again- not political.
 

mstateglfr

All-American
Feb 24, 2008
17,047
6,895
113
There's a reason they let them fight. European hockey has little fighting, but lots of high-sticking. US refs would rather see hockey players hit each other with fists, than weapons.

Mutt- get the 17 out of here with this.

Fighting can be punished and rules can be created/enforced to ensure illegal hits and contact doesnt happen. You are giving a false choice in claiming its either staged fights or dangerous high sticking. There absolutely can be a game that is played without fighting or high sticking.

Fighting in hockey borders on junior high fighting where the fights are often premeditated. Its like telling a kid you hate to meet you across the street at 3:15. And everyone on the ice then groups up to watch the fight...just like junior high.
That **** on the ice is barely better than WWE wrestling. The unwritten code which governs fighting is inconsistent at best and a massive problem in a sport with rules.


Any time there is a fight- penalize those fighting. Penalty box at least and possible suspension for each fight. Then call anything illegal on the ice like hooking or high sticking that could lead to fights. Call it evenly and play will be free flowing and fun.

The NFL, where players literally crash into one another over and again for an hour, has significantly less fights than the NHL. Its because the NFL refs penalize cheap shots and dangerous play.
 
Sep 2, 2012
188
18
18
Did I miss something? Why exactly are we happy about the Metcalf injury? Dude is a college football player. We praised Nickoe for his actions at the eggbowl with Ole Bro Wallace.

[FONT=&quot]¯\_(ツ)_/¯[/FONT]

You talking about the little helmet tap after the fumble? (After Bo had been talking smack ALL game)? Apples to oranges.
 
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White Mississippi State Soccer hosts Samford in NCAA Tournament on Friday
  2. 02 Maroon and White Football Mississippi State Week 12 Preview: Who carries the load?
  3. 03 Maroon and White Basketball Bulldogs prepare for mid-major test against Tulsa in Jackson
  4. 04 On3 Football Mississippi State RB Fluff Bothwell re-signs with Bulldogs for 2027
  5. 05 Maroon and White "There will be an opportunity for Brodie": Mississippi State HC Jeff Lebby sets freshman up for Saturday runout