Do you agree with this quote from Rosebowl?

msstatelp1

All-Conference
Aug 21, 2012
2,143
1,377
113
Nothing has changed for me. I expected we'll have a great defense and I expect Joe and Bob Shoop to clean up any issues this week.
 

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
61,506
33,382
113
Yeah. The defense overall is very good. But I just kept thinking, those Mississippi receivers are going to have a field day against our corners. We should be in good shape vs pretty much everyone else though.
 
Feb 23, 2008
1,708
0
0
I'm lost as to what he's comparing to. All preseason, the front 7 has been hyped as being one of if not the best groups in the country. So I'm not sure what he felt before the game but to me they handled SFA the way they were expected to. The back 4 is a different story. SFA receivers are not supposed to be running wide open.
 

TheStateUofMS

All-Conference
Dec 26, 2009
10,500
2,503
113
I haven't listened to the Boneyard but here are my thoughts:

DBs gave up some lobs. Our guys weren't out of position but just didn't play it well. Hopefully that can be fixed by watching film and it's not a lack of skill.

Our DL was so dominant they hardly ever ran the ball to the 2nd level, so our LBs had very few tackles.

When we blitzed we overwhelmed them off the edge.

Our DL was smothering most of the time especially when all our starters were in.

Are we better than I thought? Probably not. I wouldn't have thought Dantzler (saved by the refs replay) or Peters would have given up a jump ball. Our front 7 was dominant and overwhelmed them most of the night, but that was expected.

Having said all that, I think our defense is definitely elite and it will get better as the season goes especially at corner.
 
Last edited:

philduckworth

Redshirt
Feb 20, 2015
2,228
0
0
"I feel better about the MSU D today than I did entering the SFA game"?

No, about what I expected. Our D-line is outstanding. Our LB's are good. Our secondary is suspect. We haven't signed a highly recruited corner since Will Redmond.

We gave up 16 first downs and over 300 yards gross to an awful opponent.
 
Last edited:

Trojanbulldog19

All-American
Aug 25, 2014
10,164
5,966
113
I don't really feel any different. I knew that the front 7 was nasty and our safeties were going to be really good. I will say after watching Matt's film review the corners didn't do as bad as I thought. A few were over run or a miscommunication issue between the coverage of who was deep and who was low. that can be cleaned up. I also think Peters was having cramping issues so that may have hurt on a few of those plays in which he got passed or out jumped. I do think really good receivers will give the corners some issues. I expect our front 7, if called the plays are called correctly, won't give enough time for deep throws or mid throws. I expect to see a lot of short throws because of our rush.
 

MSUDawgFan86

Redshirt
Aug 14, 2017
1,331
1
0
"I feel better about the MSU D today than I did entering the SFA game"?

Nah I feel about the same. I don’t know how someone could feel better after playing a FCS team. Some people expected our Defense to be the Steel Curtain. I expected a really good to great Defense and that’s what we have. We can stop the run against anyone. I think We’ll give up some plays in passing game but not like the massive plays we gave up last season.
 

TheStateUofMS

All-Conference
Dec 26, 2009
10,500
2,503
113
No, about what I expected. Our D-line is outstanding. Our LB's are good. Our secondary is suspect. We haven't signed a highly recruited corner since Will Redmond.

We gave up 16 first downs and over 300 yards gross to an awful opponent.

College of Charleston ran for over 200yds against UF. We played 40 players who had never played a snap at MSU I read somewhere. It's okay!
 

MSUDC11

Redshirt
Aug 23, 2012
7,316
0
0
I feel pretty much the same. I still think the secondary woes are being a bit overblown. Dantzler did quite well, actually. Only allowed one catch for five yards in seven targets with three PBU’s. Review saved him once, but even with that play it’s still a solid game for him. Peters had a rough night, but all I heard all camp was how well he was playing. I will give him the benefit of the doubt this one time, though he certainly needs to be better in future games. Overall we still held them to a 40% completion percentage with zero TD’s. It wasn’t like we were constantly getting burned deep. We gave up a handful of 15-25 yard completions against the zone, but no huge coverage lapses. They got inside the red zone twice and never got closer than 16 yards from the end zone.

10 of their 15 drives were 3 or 4 play drives where they did absolutely nothing. They accounted for roughly half their offense for the game on two drives before halftime where we were already up big. Not saying we can’t improve, but some of the reactions have been like this was the 2016 Samford game again.
 

Duncflydawg

Redshirt
Feb 6, 2018
101
0
15
I see what everyone is panicking about, but how many yards of offense did they have in the first half? The second half was mostly reserves and redshirts, etc.
 

MSUDC11

Redshirt
Aug 23, 2012
7,316
0
0
No, about what I expected. Our D-line is outstanding. Our LB's are good. Our secondary is suspect. We haven't signed a highly recruited corner since Will Redmond.

We gave up 16 first downs and over 300 yards gross to an awful opponent.

300 yards gross, so you conveniently omitted the school record for TFL’s that we set. That’s a big part of the equation for our defense. We don’t have the best secondary in the country, but they are at least competent and our pass rush will offset a large amount of issues they could have.
 

PiedmontDawg

Redshirt
Aug 22, 2012
307
1
17
Charleston So ran triple offense, and prob had less than 50 plays ran last year. Total yards isn't end all be all. The key stat to compare is YPP and I bet they are similar from last year vs CHSO. We may give up more yards this year overall based on the fact we should increase our big play ability on offense.
 

maroonmania

All-Conference
Feb 23, 2008
11,389
1,165
113
I feel pretty much the same. I still think the secondary woes are being a bit overblown. Dantzler did quite well, actually. Only allowed one catch for five yards in seven targets with three PBU’s. Review saved him once, but even with that play it’s still a solid game for him. Peters had a rough night, but all I heard all camp was how well he was playing. I will give him the benefit of the doubt this one time, though he certainly needs to be better in future games. Overall we still held them to a 40% completion percentage with zero TD’s. It wasn’t like we were constantly getting burned deep. We gave up a handful of 15-25 yard completions against the zone, but no huge coverage lapses. They got inside the red zone twice and never got closer than 16 yards from the end zone.

10 of their 15 drives were 3 or 4 play drives where they did absolutely nothing. They accounted for roughly half their offense for the game on two drives before halftime where we were already up big. Not saying we can’t improve, but some of the reactions have been like this was the 2016 Samford game again.

Biggest issue at DB is that even though we have good athletes we don't have any guys much with great ball skills. Its not like guys are blowing by them or they are just out of the picture but when its time to make a play on the ball they often don't aren't able to do it. Either the WR high points the ball over them or blocks them out or often our DBs don't even have a clue the ball is coming in to do something if they wanted. A lot of that is natural ability to be able to play the ball and I'm not too sure how much of it is really even teachable. I would think that our DBs should be able to do a better job of reading the WR's eyes and body language to know when the ball is about to be there.
 

ababyatemydingo

All-Conference
Nov 27, 2008
4,171
3,210
113
"I feel better about the MSU D today than I did entering the SFA game"?

I think opponents are going to figure out that they will have to use tight ends and slot receivers a lot against us, and they may give us fits doing that. I don't think the line will give QB's enough time to consistently throw deep balls on target. That will help the CB's. Other than that, what i saw was pretty solid.
 
R

RPOdawg

Guest
We played a lot of zone coverage on the plays sf Austin had success through the air. It happens. You can’t shut down an offense entirely when you play zone. There are ways to defeat the zone. Our secondary isn’t “suspect”. Not yet anyways. We will know more after this week.
 

Cap'n Geech

Redshirt
Aug 15, 2018
613
0
0
I think State fans underrate our secondary. We quietly gave up the 4th fewest pass yards per game in the SEC last year. This is true whether you look at all games or Power 5 opponents only. 5th best if you look at SEC only.
 

NWADawg

Senior
May 4, 2016
1,255
761
113
I believe SFA had more time of possession too. It's because we scored very quickly (9 times). Last year we would have beat them 42-0 because we had all 8-play or more touchdown drives. SFA would not have had near as many possessions and therefore less offense.
 

DAWG61

Redshirt
Feb 26, 2008
10,111
0
0
We had several dropped shoulda been interceptions. At least 2-3. Would there still be bitching if we won 84-6?
 

War Machine Dawg

Redshirt
Oct 14, 2007
2,832
24
38
I think State fans underrate our secondary. We quietly gave up the 4th fewest pass yards per game in the SEC last year. This is true whether you look at all games or Power 5 opponents only. 5th best if you look at SEC only.

We don't have Lashard Durr this year. He was very quietly an outstanding CB. It was rare to see a QB throw at him. They picked on the other side of the field. That says a whole lot about what opposing offenses thought of Durr.

That said, I still think our CBs will be ok. They aren't going to be asked to cover as long with our front 7. And I think Cam Dantzler is really going to take a big step forward. Peters is running second string. And to be fair to him, while he hasn't been great at corner, the SFA game was the first time I've ever thought he looked completely terrible. Could have just been an off night.
 

War Machine Dawg

Redshirt
Oct 14, 2007
2,832
24
38
We had several dropped shoulda been interceptions. At least 2-3. Would there still be bitching if we won 84-6?

You know there would. Every time we play one of these garbage teams, Matt Wyatt makes a great point afterwards: As fans we expect everything to go our way and for our guys to look like Superman. It's an impossible expectation level. Therefore the errors seem magnified when we play these types of games.

As I said in my game review, we scored 63 points, had an all-new starting WR corps from 2017, and didn't play our starting QB. If you can't be happy with that and understand how good a performance it actually was, why are you a fan? You'll never be happy because you're expectation level can never be satisfied.
 

engie

Sophomore
May 29, 2011
10,764
106
63
There's no 17'n telling what Engie has in his SPS database, but the fact he had it as his fingertips ready to whip out on a dime is strange. His internet cred has to be considered the pinnacle at this point.

I had to go looking for that one. Just remembered it because it was an outlier at the time and this one gave me deja vu. Also found a Cohen GEM from 2015 complete with $500 bets he'd never make it back to Supers that will need recycling in the next good lull...
 

boatsandhoes

Junior
Sep 6, 2012
2,151
208
63
Same.

We lost on some weird balls underthrown and late. Awkward throws. danzler is going to be solid, so solid we’re going to be able to leave him man up some. His body, movements, and swivel reminds me of banks. Peters is still raw, and technically not there....yet.

DL is nasty and deep. I doubt anyone but Bama will be able to block them. Ppl will have trouble running it. LB’s will be fine, and gay jr just needs reps. Gay Is fast enough to cover mismatches, but he maybe needs to put on a little weight while maintaining his speed.
 

Uncle Ruckus

All-American
Apr 1, 2011
15,528
7,069
113
I don’t know why people keep saying this. Peters is not 2nd string, he is a starter along with Dantzler.
 

Bulldogg31

Redshirt
Dec 9, 2013
8,263
0
0
I know it’s still SFA, but their QB made some really nice throws when he had time. Seemed like he had a really strong arm and a quick release. Threw a couple of nice back-shoulder type throws a few times.

I looked up the starting QB, Sawyer Foster, and saw was a 6-5 four-star recruit out of HS, led his team to back-to-back state titles in Texas, and had offers from Oklahoma and Alabama. Rated #2 Pro-Style passer in Texas, so the kid is obviously talented. Looks like he hasn’t been able to stay healthy, thus the transfer to
SFA.

If he doesn’t learn to get out of the pocket he’s not gonna stay healthy at SFA either, but this at least explains why he threw such a good ball.
 

EngDawg

Redshirt
Mar 29, 2016
2,037
4
38
I think I remember telling everyone a few weeks ago that the secondary was looking suspect in practice, and I also remember being universally blasted for it.

ETA: Upon further review, it was only MSUDawgFan86 that blasted me so I’m not sure that counts.
 
Last edited:

Cooterpoot

Redshirt
Aug 29, 2012
4,239
2
0
We mixed and matched personnel the entire game. Normal rotations weren’t even used beyond the starters because they wanted to see everybody. We played 40 first time players. You think teams are going to have time to throw with our regular rotations? No, not often. The DBs are ok but will be up and down.
We played basic coverages and basic defense as a whole. Same with offense.
You’ll see a completely different approach this week. If KSU throws it around on us, then you can raise hell.
 

drumrcraig

Redshirt
Aug 22, 2012
348
23
18
True. Total yards are not the end all, so I looked up the box score for both games. We gave up 18 yards rushing (and 33 total) on 39 carries for a 0.5 yards per carry average. Florida gave up 222 yards on 43 attempts for a 5.2 yards per attempt average. They did beat us on passing yards as they only gave up 3 yards on 5-16 passing while we gave up 15 yards on 3-8 passing. All and all looks like we had a far more dominant performance. If we gave up 5 yards a carry to Charleston Southern this board would be in meltdown on how bad our run defense is. SFA was 15-37 passing for 177 and the board is melting over our secondary.
 
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White Basketball "When you win these type of games, you're gonna learn and grow": Mississippi State tops Tulsa in Jackson
  2. 02 Maroon and White Basketball Mississippi State vs. Tulsa: How, Where, and When to Watch Men's Basketball in Jackson
  3. 03 Maroon and White Football Keys to Victory for Mississippi State vs. Tennessee Tech
  4. 04 Maroon and White Football Recruiting Top 10 2027 QB Gavin Hampton and Bulldog commit highlights mental and physical improvements to his game
  5. 05 Rivals Basketball Recruiting Exclusive: NC State, Virginia Tech, South Carolina & more pursuing 4-star Micah Gunter