Re: Carter Stewart- Braves twittersphere saying..

maroonmania

All-Conference
Feb 23, 2008
11,389
1,165
113
THREE WORDS: Athletic Training Staff. The Athletic training staff he would receive at a major university for rehab and recovery is a thousand times better than he would receive at a JUCO. And I know some good JUCO training staffs.

Yes, and an MLB training staff is even better than ours. So I don't feel that really answers the question because if the Braves thought their training staff could have him ready to go next baseball season then why would they be lowballing him so bad? Sounds like they potentially think this injury could affect him long term.
 

HueFreeze

Redshirt
Aug 22, 2012
611
0
0
not about getting better he is good enough. he just has to show healthy ...juco gets you eligible for the draft in 1 year where as you have to turn 21 or be in year 3 at MSU.


my question was can you just enroll in any juco this late? is he already committed to a juco?
 

G-Dawg

Sophomore
Sep 6, 2012
1,191
107
63
Yes, and an MLB training staff is even better than ours. So I don't feel that really answers the question because if the Braves thought their training staff could have him ready to go next baseball season then why would they be lowballing him so bad? Sounds like they potentially think this injury could affect him long term.

You're absolutely right about MLB being better than MSU. But with them offering him only 40% of slot, I think they've made up their mind they aren't serious about signing him. SO, my answer was more to the effect of why it would be better for him to come to MSU than go the JUCO route. Obviously, I'm biased.
 

maroonmania

All-Conference
Feb 23, 2008
11,389
1,165
113
not about getting better he is good enough. he just has to show healthy ...juco gets you eligible for the draft in 1 year where as you have to turn 21 or be in year 3 at MSU.


my question was can you just enroll in any juco this late? is he already committed to a juco?

So he passes up 4 million to go JUCO so he can try and get 5 or 6 next year when, in fact, if his pitching at JUCO does show effects from his wrist injury he might just as easily slide way down in the draft to a small fraction of what he's getting offered now? Almost sounds like a pride thing run amuck if he is going to pass this up just to go play at some JUCO somewhere. At least at a major college you get fans there to watch with the chance of going to the CWS.
 

maroonmania

All-Conference
Feb 23, 2008
11,389
1,165
113
All this to say that I fully expect a nut punch on Stewart coming to State. It's just really come out of nowhere as an even remote possibility. To such an extent that no one from our side has seemingly followed his career that closely or had a line of communication open to him to share insight into his thought process. Obviously, this is with zero insight and just feeling the retard karma coming on.

He and Ginn together would be absolutely monumental. It feels weird to even post this out loud -- but by prospect level, they are almost the equivalent of what Will and Rafi were when they left MSU, as they enter MSU. Thunder and lightning went #2 and #22 in the draft in 85. These guys went #8 and #30 in 2018 out of high school. It's just insane to even consider really.

Sounding like the nut punch will be a JUCO.
 

HueFreeze

Redshirt
Aug 22, 2012
611
0
0
sounds like offer is closer to the 40% of slot ...which means 2 to 2.5 million ...i read an agent told family or Carter he was worth 7M so they want to retry next year.
twitter is my source IDK
 

maroonmania

All-Conference
Feb 23, 2008
11,389
1,165
113
sounds like offer is closer to the 40% of slot ...which means 2 to 2.5 million ...i read an agent told family or Carter he was worth 7M so they want to retry next year.
twitter is my source IDK

That makes more sense but his family better be darn sure that he can come back 100% from the wrist injury to throw away even 2 million for the hope of getting 2 or 3 times that. 2 million is still 2 million. Ginn is a different situation because his decision is not about the money anyway, Stewart appears to be all about the money. Would be curious to know if Lemonis has been in contact with him much?
 
Last edited:

maroonmania

All-Conference
Feb 23, 2008
11,389
1,165
113
No- its “3 years before making money vs 1 year”

Or a lot of money now versus a very little money later if he doesn't show that the injury has no lingering effects on his pitching ability. If making money the soonest was an issue then he had 2mil on the table immediately.
 

8dog

All-American
Feb 23, 2008
15,333
7,763
113
Im telling you what stewart likely sees in this decision. So to frame it as “lemonis vs juco” is dumb
 

HueFreeze

Redshirt
Aug 22, 2012
611
0
0
lemonis is the spokesperson for msu baseball is all i am saying it isn't lemonis vs juco ...i didn't imply that at all

I was just saying Stewart has 2 choices now MSU or juco ...so if he is the best recruiter, i can't wait to see if he can sell it to him.

Going to a MSU for 3 years has its distinct advantages.
 

PreacherDog

Redshirt
Nov 10, 2017
199
0
16
That makes more sense but his family better be darn sure that he can come back 100% from the wrist injury to throw away even 2 million for the hope of getting 2 or 3 times that. 2 million is still 2 million. Ginn is a different situation because his decision is not about the money anyway, Stewart appears to be all about the money. Would be curious to know if Lemonis has been in contact with him much?

Not sure I see how the two situations are different other than Stewart's injury. Ginn would have gone if he got the money he was asking for. The reason he didn't get offered that much was due to slot money. The truth is the Braves got greedy here and used the injury to seriously lowball him in order to get Hess too. The Dodgers offered above slot value. They were serious. But Ginn wanted more money in order to skip college.
 

bsquared24

Sophomore
Jul 11, 2009
738
160
43
Any chance we can get an 8bit tracker recap from someone who knows this stuff for baseball seeing how this is, at least at the top end, one of the best classes in recent memory.
 

Go Budaw

Redshirt
Aug 22, 2012
7,321
0
36
Then why not go ahead and sign? Are you going to get better playing JUCO?

If the injury is relatively minor (meaning, less than a year before complete recovery), it’s a way to get out there in front of a radar gun and prove to be healthy for next year’s draft. The competition level is way lower than SEC ball and the season is also shorter. Both of those mean lower pitch counts and less risk of aggravted injury. Not to mention only requiring one year instead of 3.

Honestly, JUCO makes the most sense if either of two scenarios are in play with the wrist injury:
1) It really is minor and just needs time to heal by rest / minor therapy
2) It is somewhat major, but can still be healed within a year after surgery with no lingering side effects.

The only way that coming to MSU makes sense is if there is some other imminent issue with the arm that presents high risk of an extended absence that could force him out of action for over a year (like potential for needing TJ surgery). In that case, MSU does make sense because he can rehab for 12-18 months and then have 1-1.5 seaasons to prove healthy for scouts in 2020-2021 before getting drafted again. He would, of course, have to do this because no one would take him anywhere near the first round after such a surgery unless he proved his worth against good competition. Also, if you’re gonna be on the shelf for the better part of 2 years, you might as well be at a good 4-year school with a solid training staff as opposed to JUCO.
 
Last edited:

Philly Dawg

Heisman
Oct 6, 2012
16,418
11,123
113
The point stands. If a player of a certain quality is in JUCO, it won't prevent him from being drafted high.
 

maroonmania

All-Conference
Feb 23, 2008
11,389
1,165
113
Not sure I see how the two situations are different other than Stewart's injury. Ginn would have gone if he got the money he was asking for. The reason he didn't get offered that much was due to slot money. The truth is the Braves got greedy here and used the injury to seriously lowball him in order to get Hess too. The Dodgers offered above slot value. They were serious. But Ginn wanted more money in order to skip college.

Well, Ginn got an above slot offer and still didn't sign because he really wanted to come to MSU. IMO the main reason he put the number up where he did was because he knew there was very little chance the Dodgers would hit that number. I mean really, if you want to sign, is 3.1m THAT much of a difference from 2.4m when you are already getting above what your draft status says you should? Carter, on the other hand, would have absolutely signed had the Braves offered the appropriate slot amount given where they drafted him. Probably would have even signed for less but what the Braves offered was not even first round money, more like mid-second round. So the difference is Ginn always wanted to go the school route, Carter was backed into that because of the Braves undercutting his offer.
 
Last edited:

msstate7

Redshirt
Nov 27, 2008
10,388
10
38
Not sure I see how the two situations are different other than Stewart's injury. Ginn would have gone if he got the money he was asking for. The reason he didn't get offered that much was due to slot money. The truth is the Braves got greedy here and used the injury to seriously lowball him in order to get Hess too. The Dodgers offered above slot value. They were serious. But Ginn wanted more money in order to skip college.

I think you're wrong about the braves. The braves didn't draft this kid thinking we'll offer 1.9. They offered the bare minimum to keep the pick next season. That tells me they think that wrist is a pretty big deal. AA is a newly hired GM... there's no way he envisioned not being able to sign his first freaking pick as the braves' GM.
 

maroonmania

All-Conference
Feb 23, 2008
11,389
1,165
113
I think you're wrong about the braves. The braves didn't draft this kid thinking we'll offer 1.9. They offered the bare minimum to keep the pick next season. That tells me they think that wrist is a pretty big deal. AA is a newly hired GM... there's no way he envisioned not being able to sign his first freaking pick as the braves' GM.

Exactly, and that's why I am not counting on him contributing for us as a FR even if he comes to MSU. Would love to be wrong, but if the Braves thought he would be full go next baseball season then I see no reason for them to have lowballed him like they did.
 

MeridianDog

Freshman
Sep 3, 2008
3,226
80
48
Comment not addressed at anyone specific. Is Carters high spin rate what led to his wrist injury. If so, will he only injure it more this year and kill any chances he has for a good draft in the future. High spin rate on a pitch and wrist damage seem to go together to me.

Any thoughts?
 

maroonmania

All-Conference
Feb 23, 2008
11,389
1,165
113
Comment not addressed at anyone specific. Is Carters high spin rate what led to his wrist injury. If so, will he only injure it more this year and kill any chances he has for a good draft in the future. High spin rate on a pitch and wrist damage seem to go together to me.

Any thoughts?

He claims the injury occurred swinging a bat.
 
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White Basketball "When you win these type of games, you're gonna learn and grow": Mississippi State tops Tulsa in Jackson
  2. 02 Maroon and White Basketball Mississippi State vs. Tulsa: How, Where, and When to Watch Men's Basketball in Jackson
  3. 03 Maroon and White Football Keys to Victory for Mississippi State vs. Tennessee Tech
  4. 04 Maroon and White Football Recruiting Top 10 2027 QB Gavin Hampton and Bulldog commit highlights mental and physical improvements to his game
  5. 05 Rivals Basketball Recruiting Exclusive: NC State, Virginia Tech, South Carolina & more pursuing 4-star Micah Gunter