If Pitno could have a redo:

Bleedin Blue in Ohio

All-Conference
Feb 3, 2013
559
1,173
93
When he left Kentucky, he had UK in the midst of an overtime loss to Arizona from a 3 peat. Had he not left I believe he would have won multiple national titles, and he would have had a run like Saban had at Alabama. The marriage between Rick and UK was perfect. His style of play fit the team and was attractive to recruits. He definitely would have tarnished Coach K's legacy.
 

Jakerz

All-Conference
Jan 13, 2024
868
1,571
0
Rick Pitino would have been considered the greatest coach of all time had he never left.

We wouldn’t know know Coach K as we do.
Kentucky would have 5+ more titles since 96.
He would be the all time wins leader
And most importantly this fan base would all be unified and in agreement.

Love him or hate him, he’s one of the best to ever do it. And he would have been THE best had he not let his ego get the best of him.
 

Ugoff

Heisman
May 7, 2009
16,403
21,489
0
Well he MAY have won more titles, or he MAY have gotten caught ordering the late night red snapper and brought down the shame that lil bro endured.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SemperFiCat

MdWIldcat55

Heisman
Dec 9, 2007
21,728
87,931
113
As an older man, I'm sympathetic with the idea of looking back at a turning point where one had complete control over which path life would take -- and choosing badly.

But I have much less sympathy for Pitino because his motivations were greed and ego. He was a man in his mid-40s, certainly old enough to understand that you don't walk away from happiness and that once you have enough money to make your family secure it shouldn't guide your decisions.

He blew it. And I suspect the day he announced he was taking the Celtics' job, deep down he knew it. That has to feel like hell.
 
Last edited:

Jeff2Reed

Senior
Mar 4, 2024
324
918
0
Many younger guys don’t realize. I’m 38, which is probably the cutoff to really remember the Pitino run. He was every bit the figure coach K was and maybe more especially at that time. Pitino would have Kentucky with somewhere between 3-5 national titles by now. He was a force that most players wanted to play for and he was excellent X’s and O’s. He could have landed just about most he wanted, but liked to find the diamonds he could built the way he wanted to.

Pitino is probably the best coach ever in his prime for college basketball. But he blew it because he made a lot of bad choices, and I knew he overplayed the power of Louisville’s program, and it hurt his image. Louisville is not a big time national brand it’s just that people around Kentucky don’t realize it in state. He really screwed up going there.

As far as a basketball mind with coaching ability and the power of name recognition, Pitino was the best we might ever see.
 

WeWant9

Heisman
Dec 18, 2013
7,073
18,969
113
People need to let the Pitino hate go
Respect what Pitino did at UK, but I had to live in Louisville during his time there and it was constant little pot shots at UK. The man couldn’t even bother to do a short video for the 96-98 celebration, but had no issue sending one to ul to honor the 2013 team. I don’t hate the man, but UK has done enough to honor him and the door should be closed for good now.
 

Midway Cat

All-Conference
Feb 7, 2004
16,225
2,626
113
Respect what Pitino did at UK, but I had to live in Louisville during his time there and it was constant little pot shots at UK. The man couldn’t even bother to do a short video for the 96-98 celebration, but had no issue sending one to ul to honor the 2013 team. I don’t hate the man, but UK has done enough to honor him and the door should be closed for good now.
I have a feeling it's actually the opposite.

We're getting closer to the end of his career, and I expect the door will be open if and when that happens.

He's a huge part of the history of Kentucky Basketball. There's no way around it.
 

WeWant9

Heisman
Dec 18, 2013
7,073
18,969
113
I have a feeling it's actually the opposite.

We're getting closer to the end of his career, and I expect the door will be open if and when that happens.

He's a huge part of the history of Kentucky Basketball. There's no way around it.
You could be right. I don’t deny he is a huge part of the history. Just feel UK has given him many opportunities to be honored and he turns them down.
 

KFuqua

All-Conference
Oct 24, 2001
2,243
2,739
113
He's a piece of garbage to be honest. He's trying to make amends now, but he's said, and done, a lot of things over the years to show his true character. It's impossible to say Kentucky would have more championships if he stayed. It's possible, but the man's character would have shown eventually. I respect what he did when he was at Kentucky, but he made the choice to leave and then has crapped on Kentucky, it's program and it's fans every chance he could get since then. I hope to never see him step foot in Rupp again!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cat_Man_Blue_rivals

ukjenning44

All-American
Nov 21, 2022
3,317
8,785
0
It honestly wouldn’t have been fair to the rest of college basketball if Pitino never left.

We would’ve had multiple back to back championship seasons. Possibly a 3peat.

At least one undefeated season.

Many Maui and Phil Knight Invitational Tournament titles.



We have a coach now that can’t even win the SEC 🙄
 

Jeff2Reed

Senior
Mar 4, 2024
324
918
0
Respect what Pitino did at UK, but I had to live in Louisville during his time there and it was constant little pot shots at UK. The man couldn’t even bother to do a short video for the 96-98 celebration, but had no issue sending one to ul to honor the 2013 team. I don’t hate the man, but UK has done enough to honor him and the door should be closed for good now.

I couldn’t imagine dealing with Louisville people when he decided to go there. It would have been enough to make you hate him for sure.

For me in Tennessee, people were a little suprised, but Louisville is so overshadowed by UK nationally, they just thought he went to a smaller program in Kentucky to get back in the state.
 

Jeff2Reed

Senior
Mar 4, 2024
324
918
0
He's a piece of garbage to be honest. He's trying to make amends now, but he's said, and done, a lot of things over the years to show his true character. It's impossible to say Kentucky would have more championships if he stayed. It's possible, but the man's character would have shown eventually. I respect what he did when he was at Kentucky, but he made the choice to leave and then has crapped on Kentucky, it's program and it's fans every chance he could get since then. I hope to never see him step foot in Rupp again!

Im a Pitino guy I can’t help it. Grew up hating Calipari and was firmly camp Pitino, but I get it. I don’t know why the guy didn’t just take Michigan or something and wait for UK to come calling. I will always believe he wanted the job immediately and we said no because our brass was pissed he had one foot out the door the entire tenure and they were sick of it. I think his ego told him he can turn the state red and shove it in their face.

He learned the hard way.
 

gojvc

All-American
Feb 5, 2005
28,744
7,273
0
As an older man, I'm sympathetic with the idea of looking back at a turning point where one had complete control over which path life would take -- and choosing badly.

But I have much less sympathy for Pitino because his motivations were greed and ego. He was a man in his mid-40s, certainly old enough to understand that you don't walk away from happiness and that once you have enough money to make your family secure it shouldn't guide your decisions.

He blew it. And I suspect the day he announced he was taking the Celtics' job, deep down he knew it. That has to feel like hell.
At the time no coach had won the NCAA Championship and an NBA Championship. I think he wanted to be the first and believed he could do it. Who knows, if the draft lottery balls had bounced the right way and he got Tim Duncan he probably would have done it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: nickhorvathsuxazz

gojvc

All-American
Feb 5, 2005
28,744
7,273
0
Im a Pitino guy I can’t help it. Grew up hating Calipari and was firmly camp Pitino, but I get it. I don’t know why the guy didn’t just take Michigan or something and wait for UK to come calling. I will always believe he wanted the job immediately and we said no because our brass was pissed he had one foot out the door the entire tenure and they were sick of it. I think his ego told him he can turn the state red and shove it in their face.

He learned the hard way.
Michigan and UNLV were both open when he chose U6. South Carolina too IIRC.
 

Jeff2Reed

Senior
Mar 4, 2024
324
918
0
Michigan and UNLV were both open when he chose U6. South Carolina too IIRC.

Yea the smart play would have been to take Michigan / UNLV and wait for a few years. Eventually I think he would have been back at UK and tubby would have called it sooner. Louisville just doesn’t have the name pop nationally and it made him seem smaller of a figure. It’s all ego, the guy didn’t think he needed brand he thought he was the brand.

Louisville is not only not really acknowledged nationally, but they’re totally overshadowed by UK in ways no other in state rival is. This isn’t like Clemson / USC, it’s closer to UT / Memphis. Why he thought it would work for his brand I’ll never know. I mean, Kentucky played games in their arena for the fans of the area to see UK play when he was there. In what world is that a good idea if you’re Pitino?

I still believe Louisville would have fallen off years ago had he not gone there. They’ve kept up because of the Pitino name, but it’s over now. I think they are about to become what they really are, a city college without much bang and back to mid major status.
 

Padsfs07

All-Conference
Jan 19, 2013
4,087
4,016
108
When he left Kentucky, he had UK in the midst of an overtime loss to Arizona from a 3 peat. Had he not left I believe he would have won multiple national titles, and he would have had a run like Saban had at Alabama. The marriage between Rick and UK was perfect. His style of play fit the team and was attractive to recruits. He definitely would have tarnished Coach K's legacy.

Pitino in 98 is interesting as McGrady said he would've came here. If you put McGrady on that team, even as a freshman, I think they would have killed it.

Then I believe he would have kept Michael Bradley obviously so the lull in the 99-02 timeframe wouldn't have happened. Likewise, we probably could've gotten a top-notch PG in that era rather than Saul Smith, who blocked some guys from committing.

Then by 02/03, he could've kept the run going, mixing in some of the UL guys that honestly went there just for him. Taquan Dean from Jersey, Francisco Garcia from Connecticut, Otis George from the DR, Tello Palacios from New York. Also maybe Larry O'Bannon, even though he's from Louisville, and Marvin Stone had a decent senior season after transferring from UK to UL.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jeff2Reed

SemperFiCat

Heisman
Mar 2, 2009
14,566
30,005
0
I'm 45, and missed a lot of golden Kentucky basketball. But I wish our younger fans could've gotten to experience just how much damn fun Kentucky and Pitino were to watch. There's just no way to put into words want it felt like to see that press mixed with that offense, and the cast of players doing it. That friends, is Kentucky basketball.
 

Jeff2Reed

Senior
Mar 4, 2024
324
918
0
Pitino in 98 is interesting as McGrady said he would've came here. If you put McGrady on that team, even as a freshman, I think they would have killed it.

Then I believe he would have kept Michael Bradley obviously so the lull in the 99-02 timeframe wouldn't have happened. Likewise, we probably could've gotten a top-notch PG in that era rather than Saul Smith, who blocked some guys from committing.

Then by 02/03, he could've kept the run going, mixing in some of the UL guys that honestly went there just for him. Taquan Dean from Jersey, Francisco Garcia from Connecticut, Otis George from the DR, Tello Palacios from New York. Also maybe Larry O'Bannon, even though he's from Louisville, and Marvin Stone had a decent senior season after transferring from UK to UL.

Not to mention the players he was able to get to Louisville that would have played for him at UK. During that time program power meant so much, there’s definitely players he missed because he didn’t have the UK brand. Who knows.
 

Padsfs07

All-Conference
Jan 19, 2013
4,087
4,016
108
At the time no coach had won the NCAA Championship and an NBA Championship. I think he wanted to be the first and believed he could do it. Who knows, if the draft lottery balls had bounced the right way and he got Tim Duncan he probably would have done it.

It's funny since Calipari could've taken Kobe in the 96 draft, but settled/ended up with Kittles, while Pitino could've gotten that first pick in 97 and had Duncan rather than Billups and Mercer. (Also McGrady went just after Mercer in that draft at #9)

Likewise, Cal had a chance to get McGrady, but drafted Tim Thomas at #7 instead and then traded him for the #2 pick, Keith Van Horn)

Just a disaster of a draft for both coaches over those two years.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gojvc
Mar 2, 2024
352
415
0
A redo isn’t gonna make him magically start winning more games or championships. Most overrated coach of my lifetime, maybe ever. Got outcoached routinely and still does to this day. Passss….
 

wildcatdon

Heisman
Oct 17, 2012
10,699
13,748
113
I'm 45, and missed a lot of golden Kentucky basketball. But I wish our younger fans could've gotten to experience just how much damn fun Kentucky and Pitino were to watch. There's just no way to put into words want it felt like to see that press mixed with that offense, and the cast of players doing it. That friends, is Kentucky basketball.
Bingo
 

KFuqua

All-Conference
Oct 24, 2001
2,243
2,739
113
Im a Pitino guy I can’t help it. Grew up hating Calipari and was firmly camp Pitino, but I get it. I don’t know why the guy didn’t just take Michigan or something and wait for UK to come calling. I will always believe he wanted the job immediately and we said no because our brass was pissed he had one foot out the door the entire tenure and they were sick of it. I think his ego told him he can turn the state red and shove it in their face.

He learned the hard way.
Fair enough. I can understand that. I was around long before the Pitino days, but I loved him as Kentucky's coach before he left, but with the way he turned out, I just think he was a ticking time bomb.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jeff2Reed
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Basketball Milan Momcilovic weighs in on Kentucky's issues after his epic 1st half goes to waste
  2. 02 KSR Basketball WATCH: KSR's Rapid Reaction to Kentucky's 90-76 loss to Indiana in Lucas Oil
  3. 03 KSR Basketball Kentucky couldn't stop fouling and Indiana made them pay
  4. 04 KSR Basketball FINAL: Indiana lives at the FT line, takes down Kentucky 90-76 in Indy
  5. 05 KSR Basketball IT'S A MILAN MOMCILOVIC PARTY AND YOU'RE INVITED!