Jay Bilas takes down unjustifiable NCAA transfer process with reason and logic

mstateglfr

All-American
Feb 24, 2008
17,028
6,859
113
http://www.espn.com/mens-college-ba...le-let-athletes-play-immediately-not-sit-year

Disagreements to this will most likely be emotional and therefore inconsistent.

An student-athlete is a student and an amateur. Theybare in college for an education and should be free to transfer schools like any other student.
De-emphasizing the athlete part of the equation will help place healthy perspectice on college athletics and being cpnsistency to an inconsistent process.
 

Irondawg

Senior
Dec 2, 2007
3,081
709
113
I'm not sure how he can be so naive, but he is. I agree in concept with some of his ideas but they would set the sport as a revenue generator back 30 years.

I can't believe he said with a straight face that there would be no poaching. The top schools and aggressive young coaches would be all over this and nobody would be immune. I think even a lot of top teams would lose depth.

Roster management for coaches would be a nightmare. April would be a huge domino effect as when Player A transfers, Player B on that is already on the new team might realize the new guy is going to take his minutes and decides to transfer. The coach on the original school for player A now needs to replace a player. It would just go and go.

That not even mentioning if a top 20 school had an injury in the spring and could then go poach a replacement. There would literally be no end. It would drive coaches crazy.

The only way to at least temper the poaching is to have massive penalties for anyone caught but we all know that isn't going to happen.

I agree with Jay in concept about punishing the student for a hobby but the truth is these guys aren't like other students. They get a ton of perks.

To implement his policy you'd have to get the schools to going back and treating as a hobby which is never going to happen.

I do see both sides though and not sure what a fair solution really is that is workable in the true environment
 

8dog

All-American
Feb 23, 2008
15,319
7,748
113
Yeah i have no problem with an amateur organization having rules that provide some order. I think this would be a huge mess
 

QuaoarsKing

All-Conference
Mar 11, 2008
6,384
3,324
113
They could limit the no-sit-out-transfers to players who played below a certain % of a team's snaps, so that you do let people who aren't going to play look for a better opportunity but teams can't just poach stars.

It should be noted that it's pretty rare for a stars to get poached as graduate transfers, (like did anyone try to recruit Dak for the 2015 season?), so maybe the fears are a little overblown.
 

Bucky Dog

Redshirt
Nov 10, 2012
904
0
0
I don't get how people say they aren't paid athletes. They are give a free education which probably average $100,000, plus all the other things from meals, to free gear and such.

The transfer just just cannot be Cart Blanche like some say. It would have to have stipulations such as amount of time played during current year, and only if current school allows it. And no same conference transfers.
 

Faustdog

All-Conference
Jun 4, 2007
4,204
2,780
113
Yeah i have no problem with an amateur organization having rules that provide some order. I think this would be a huge mess

Not to mention the fact that the crux of Bilas' argument is academics, and transferring usually hinders a student's progress toward a degree. And transferring multiple times certainly would.
 

thf24

Redshirt
Jan 28, 2011
1,334
3
38
They could limit the no-sit-out-transfers to players who played below a certain % of a team's snaps, so that you do let people who aren't going to play look for a better opportunity but teams can't just poach stars.

That might just encourage players who wanted to transfer to sandbag to get benched. I think it's a slippery slope no matter how you look at it.
 

engie

Sophomore
May 29, 2011
10,764
106
63
This is exactly what we need. To get these underrated players into school and develop them into studs, so they can be recruited for their entire collegiate life, and eventually go play their last year or two title-chasing at Alabama, LSU, etc(at what point does it become a 'business decision' if they are needs for those programs?).

This doesn't offer positives for MSU at all. Nor the players themselves. Just helps the powerhouses. And you can bet Bilas is looking at it from within his Duke prism.

I'm all for paying the players in revenue-generating sports. All for letting them go wherever they want as they currently do. I'm not for allowing 25-50% of the whole country to transfer and shuffle every offseason. It's hard enough to keep up and maintain investment with it in professional sports where there are 1/4 as many teams and 4x the average contract length.

I would argue that the fans drive these sports. Not the athletes. You obviously do not have one without the other. But you take away fan investment and player relationships and it really damages the brand IMO
 
Last edited:

mstateglfr

All-American
Feb 24, 2008
17,028
6,859
113
I don't get how people say they aren't paid athletes. They are give a free education which probably average $100,000, plus all the other things from meals, to free gear and such.

The transfer just just cannot be Cart Blanche like some say. It would have to have stipulations such as amount of time played during current year, and only if current school allows it. And no same conference transfers.

Students are also recruited by schools, given $ to attend, and can leave when they want for another school. No different.

Furthermore, the transfer rule of sitting out 1 year doesnt apply to many college sports. That is a main point in the article and isnt justifiable because it doesnt consistently apply.
 

DerHntr

All-Conference
Sep 18, 2007
16,209
3,714
113
Where his logic is wrong is unfortunately a lot of these students wouldn't get into or stay in the universities they play for from an academic standpoint if they weren't athletes. He states they would have to meet certain academic standards. How about make them meet the academic standards that the rest of the students have to meet since they are no different from the other students and just happen to have a hobby. After all, you said they are there to get an education. I'm pretty sure Duke, Vanderbilt, UNC, Michigan, and many others would be against the rule.
 

Dogariffic

Redshirt
Aug 21, 2012
1,243
0
0
Ok if players want to transfer without consequences then their verbal scholarships before signing can be rescinded and scholarships not renewed annually ... oh wait!
 

AssEndDawg

Freshman
Aug 1, 2007
3,183
54
48
No different.
I can't tell if you are playing Devil's Advocate or if you are so naive as to be unbelievable. College Football is different. Love it or hate it, there is nothing in college that remotely compares to it. Trying to act like it is just a normal part of college life is idiotic. The fans don't want it to be normal, the players don't want it to be normal, the coaches don't want it to be normal. As far as I can tell only a handful of writers and some SJWs want to pretend that college football is part of a normal college experience.

Free transfers would certainly help some people, but it is more likely to hurt the sport, cause confusion, and ultimately hurt players as they are denied the opportunity they came to school for because a team can just poach players from "lower" teams who are proven commodities. Coaches get paid a LOT of money to win and they will do whatever they can do within the rules to get that "W". Anyone who doesn't think this would turn into a disaster has a childlike view of the world. Fair or not, it's a stupid thing to do.
 

mstateglfr

All-American
Feb 24, 2008
17,028
6,859
113
This doesn't offer positives for MSU at all. Nor the players themselves. Just helps the powerhouses. And you can bet Bilas is looking at it from within his Duke prism.
high profile recruits who have been 'the man' and expect to play right away but dont get the opportunity due to depth could leave blue blood schools without penalty. Other schools would then benefit by getting those players.

All for letting them go wherever they want as they currently do.
But players cant just go wherever they want right now. They are consistently blocked by coaches and administration from going to certain schools for varying reasons.

I would argue that the fans drive these sports. Not the athletes. You obviously do not have one without the other. But you take away fan investment and player relationships and it really damages the brand IMO
College athletics survived and thrived 70 years ago, 50 years ago, and 30 years ago without the insane salaries, constant facilities overhauls, or commoditization of 12-17 year olds. Fans existed then in what was a simpler time and shows that de-emphasizing the revenue side of college athletics doesnt necessarily mean fan interest will go away.
 

aTotal360

Heisman
Nov 12, 2009
22,679
16,733
113
Bilas is fine with it because blue chippers would freely transfer to Duke.
 

mstateglfr

All-American
Feb 24, 2008
17,028
6,859
113
Where his logic is wrong is unfortunately a lot of these students wouldn't get into or stay in the universities they play for from an academic standpoint if they weren't athletes. He states they would have to meet certain academic standards. How about make them meet the academic standards that the rest of the students have to meet since they are no different from the other students and just happen to have a hobby. After all, you said they are there to get an education. I'm pretty sure Duke, Vanderbilt, UNC, Michigan, and many others would be against the rule.

I certainly would be all for athletes getting in on academic merit measurements which are equitable with the general school population.
 

mstateglfr

All-American
Feb 24, 2008
17,028
6,859
113
Bilas is fine with it because blue chippers would freely transfer to Duke.

And transfer out too. Blue chippers typically want to see the court- having 12 blue chippers would be a tough task to keep everyone happy...as in it wouldnt happen.
 

aTotal360

Heisman
Nov 12, 2009
22,679
16,733
113
Ok then. Let's just have all the 5 stars play musical chairs between Duke, UNC, UK, and Arizona.
 

dawgoneyall

Junior
Nov 11, 2007
3,431
210
63
Yeah i have no problem with an amateur organization having rules that provide some order. I think this would be a huge mess

No high school player is required to play college football. Don't like the rules play field hockey.
 

engie

Sophomore
May 29, 2011
10,764
106
63
Ok if players want to transfer without consequences then their verbal scholarships before signing can be rescinded and scholarships not renewed annually ... oh wait!

Yeah, as if it's a one sided deal where the player released all of his power by making that verbal pledge and never leaves the school at the altar**
 

turkish

Junior
Aug 22, 2012
998
377
63
Accountability for decisions one makes in life -- what has happened in this country? Downright scary.
 

engie

Sophomore
May 29, 2011
10,764
106
63
This whole deal is typical glfr.

high profile recruits who have been 'the man' and expect to play right away but dont get the opportunity due to depth could leave blue blood schools without penalty. Other schools would then benefit by getting those players.
Those players don't ever even end up with the blue bloods at all in your scenario. Why would those schools even bother recruiting "high profile" guys out of highschool who have a 50/50 chance of working out for them? They wouldn't. Another risk removed from the elite teams' scenario. They just go and get all of the ALREADY proven best college players out of(truly free) free agency and let everyone else be their farm squads with the high profile highschool guys. If they actually did what you are championing -- it's a 20 team world and the rest of us might as well call ourselves FCS. We literally become NFL AA. While the Alabamas of the world are AAA.

But players cant just go wherever they want right now. They are consistently blocked by coaches and administration from going to certain schools for varying reasons.
Yeah. And the coaches get blown up in the media -- and the restrictions get removed. A "block" is toothless anyway. Just says they can't go immediately onto full financial aid at the next stop. Doesn't prevent them from going if they so desire. But goodness forbid they pay a semester like the rest of us or go JUCO for a year.

College athletics survived and thrived 70 years ago, 50 years ago, and 30 years ago without the insane salaries, constant facilities overhauls, or commoditization of 12-17 year olds. Fans existed then in what was a simpler time and shows that de-emphasizing the revenue side of college athletics doesnt necessarily mean fan interest will go away.
Thrived huh? Had they TRULY thrived, all of the palaces, facilities, and salaries would have ALREADY been in place inthose decades. That's part of the gig on thriving in a competitive market.

You don't de-emphasize ANYTHING in order to thrive at that thing. Just not how the world works. I'm not surprised you are in rainbowland on this though.
 

Original48

Redshirt
Aug 9, 2007
3,322
0
0
Just imagine post signing day friendship between Freeze and Chris Jones if he was still available.
 

paindonthurt_

All-Conference
Jun 27, 2009
9,528
2,046
113
Student athletes are free to transfer whenever they want. They don't even have to sit out. They just can't play the sport they are playing for 1 year. They have a choice.

This scenario is dumb. If you think it's good for the student athletes in the long run, you are dumb, dumb, dumb.
 

KurtRambis4

Redshirt
Aug 30, 2006
15,926
0
36
I agree with this.

You have to have some order, otherwise it would be chaos.

The top tier schools would have a field day with this.
 

engie

Sophomore
May 29, 2011
10,764
106
63
And transfer out too. Blue chippers typically want to see the court- having 12 blue chippers would be a tough task to keep everyone happy...as in it wouldnt happen.

The only transferring out of "blue chippers" that would be seen at Duke in your scenario would be to the NBA.

You are really going against your core ideology on this -- in wanting to give the rich a new, much more lucrative method to get richer.
 

mstateglfr

All-American
Feb 24, 2008
17,028
6,859
113
Accountability for decisions one makes in life -- what has happened in this country? Downright scary.

Ha, wt17 does this even mean?
Are you seriously suggesting a student athlete deciding to attend another school is evidence of the country going down hill and there not being accountability in life?
17 that.
Students have transferred schools for decades. Centuries even. 17ing centuries.

No different from a person leaving one job for another...which has also gone on for centuries and really millennia, but i just dont know how often a blacksmith back in 840ad left to become a seamstress or what the 17 else there was back then.
 

mstateglfr

All-American
Feb 24, 2008
17,028
6,859
113
The only transferring out of "blue chippers" that would be seen at Duke in your scenario would be to the NBA.

You are really going against your core ideology on this -- in wanting to give the rich a new, much more lucrative method to get richer.

I didnt follow part of your previous post where you said 'typical golfer' since you misinterpreted a point of mine and ranted about that misinterpreted view. I let it go, but it looks like you did it again here so ill try to respond.

1- great recruits leave Duke right now, even though they have to sit a year. So it stands to reason great recruits would leave Duke if the transfer restriction were removed. You are flat out wrong to say the only transferring of blue chippers in my scenario would be to the NBA. It happens now, so it could happen in a changed transfer scenario too.

2- When has my core ideology ever been to want the rich to get a new more lucrative way to get richer? I am accused here of usually being of the opposite viewpoint on that.
Either way- whether you misunderstand my core ideology or you cant type clearly and meant something different with that point, ill let you in on some core ideology of mine- treat student athletes like students first and foremost and athletes second. Emphasize the former versus the latter. Look thru my history of posts on this and related topics and you will see that is accurate. I dont want the rich to get richer and i dont want the poor to get richer- neither is a motivation when it comes to my views on student athletes having more say and power in the process.
 

mstateglfr

All-American
Feb 24, 2008
17,028
6,859
113
Yup. Lower tier teams will be a farm league for the elite.

Thats how it is for coaches right now. Why shouldnt a student athlete be free to move to a more competitive landscape without penalty? Students do it all the time- both ways. Some go from prestigious schools to common state schools because the new school fits better for whatever reason(s). And other students move from community colleges(even if they fully qualified) to more highly ranked colleges.

Along this analogy- why is it just chicken little the sky is falling around here and only players going from weak to strong programs are discussed? Why arent you recognizing that for this to happen, talented players at strong schools will therefore move to weaker schools?
example- say Duke has 5 post players who are 5*. Their talented backcourt is drafted and the replacement group is young and thin in numbers. In comes a talented JR year transfer from say Lipscomb to help add numbers to the backcourt. Meanwhile, post players are frustrated sharing limited numbers with so many talented players so to make room for the Lipscomb player, 1 or 2 of the 5* players transfers out. They are still extremely talented, they just couldnt get significant play because of depth at their position.
This is a very real scenario that plays out across the country a lot. It isnt some wild *** hypothetical.

Players may go to blue blood schools, but they will transfer out too, just like they already do.
 

aTotal360

Heisman
Nov 12, 2009
22,679
16,733
113
And imagine the constant tampering and year recruiting you'll have to do to keep your star player around. Sounds like fun.
 

Go Budaw

Redshirt
Aug 22, 2012
7,321
0
36
Student athletes are free to transfer whenever they want. They don't even have to sit out. They just can't play the sport they are playing for 1 year. They have a choice.

This scenario is dumb. If you think it's good for the student athletes in the long run, you are dumb, dumb, dumb.

Exactly. They only even have to sit out if they are transferring within the same division classification. If being a "student" really is what is most important, then any player at MSU, OM, etc. can transfer to Millsaps or Birmingham Southern and play immediately. That allowance already exists.

And if they want to go to a school in the sane divisional classification, they can still be put on scholarship immediately. Bilas' logic makes no sense.
 

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
61,416
33,228
113
Jay Bilas is either an idiot or he's trolling. You'd turn college sports into European soccer. Every time a Watford gets a young player who turns out to be good, a Manchester United swoops him up in the transfer window. Instead of deemphasizing the athlete part of the equation, it would just shift it that much more to that side. I can promise you LSU's not going to poach LA Tech's best players because of their chemistry department.
 
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White Points of Focus from Jeff Lebby in Week 12 media availability
  2. 02 Maroon and White Football What Mississippi State HC Jeff Lebby said about Sunday staff changes
  3. 03 On3 Football Over 35% of Power Four starting quarterbacks missed games with injuries in 2026
  4. 04 Maroon and White Football Sunday Notebook: Auburn 41-9 Mississippi State
  5. 05 Rivals Football Recruiting Biggest rankings risers in the updated 2027 Rivals300 rankings