Flim-Flam: A book review

CoolDawg

Redshirt
Oct 20, 2013
522
0
0
I just completed reading the book Flim Flam and thought I would share my thoughts. I am someone that absolutely detests everything Ole Miss. The arrogance of the fans, their we can do no wrong attitude, Colonel Rebel, the Black Bear, The Lyceum, the fact that they call their university president Chancellor, the 18 mph speed limit, the Grove, and the Mannings. Nothing short of the death penalty and expulsion from the SEC would satisfy me as far as NCAA sanctions are concerned.

Despite my feelings about OM, I have only casually kept up with the investigation into their football program. I knew the basics, but not all the facts surrounding the case. Steve Robertson does an excellent job of laying out a bill of particulars in the indictment against the OM football program. He explains every facet of the case against them. It is very timely since Monday is their day of reckoning.

Steve comes across as a very decent person. He could easily have named the name of a middle aged woman posing as a 20 year old student, using the name of Analesa Preley, who became somewhat of an OM internet sensation writing about their football program. He could also have named the name of a man making death threats against him. In both instances, these individuals wished to see Steve professionally or personally harmed. However, he took the high road and spared them embarrassment. As someone who would like every sordid detail of anything relating to OM, I would love for him to have named names. However, I have great respect for Steve for not doing so.

The book answered the question concerning whether Riley Blevins left the Clarion-Ledger of his own accord. Short of that, the book didn't have any startling revelations. Again, however, what the book did was connect all the dots and thoroughly lay out the case against OM. The only real complaint that I have, and it is somewhat minor, is that Steve had a tendency to repeat himself a little too often. A good book editor would have caught it when he did that.

I believe the book is a must read for anyone that feels the same way about OM as I do. However, I think that it would also be an eye opener to the many OM fans who have drunk the Kool-Aid and believe that either "everyone does it", or that they are being picked on because of recent football success. Eventually the adults at OM will take charge and Bjork, Vitter, and Luke will be gone. Reading this book would help their successors understand the OM culture and the difficulty that they will have in keeping their rogue fans in check when the rebuilding begins.

I would encourage everyone to go out and purchase this book. Even if you have no plans to ever read it, Steve Robertson deserves to be rewarded for his efforts in rooting out a story that everyone else in the media chose to ignore.
 
Last edited:

torbida

Redshirt
May 30, 2010
66
0
0
I just got finished with book and all I can say is come Monday as I get through Irma, the COI needs to drop the Hammer
 

missouridawg

Junior
Oct 6, 2009
9,407
309
83
I'm about half way through the book and here are some thoughts from me...

Riley stated in the book that he wasn't forced out by the CL. He left on his own accord. I guess the harassment from fans helped in the decision.

I still do not believe the catfish lady. There is no chance that OM was so coordinated behind that account for it to be a random middle aged woman.

Daniel Paulling is a moron. A big one.

I just finished the first Tunsil chapter. What a helluva fun night that was.
 

CochiseCowbell

Heisman
Oct 29, 2012
15,911
15,062
113
I just got my pre-order signed copies on Tuesday (I live two states away and am completely ok with it). I'm a third of the way through. So far, I'm thoroughly enjoying it.

"He explains every faucet of the case against them."

I was unaware that Ole Miss had a vocational plumbing program.

"A good book editor would have caught it when he did that."
 

MaroonOldCrow

Senior
Aug 22, 2012
592
485
63
I finished the other day and my thought is that while the book is entertaining for us in the here and now, its real value will in ten or fifteen years when people ask, "Why does Ole Miss football suck so bad?" all you'll have to do is hand them a copy of the book.
 

tatedog

Redshirt
Mar 28, 2015
8,739
0
0
I'm about half way through the book and here are some thoughts from me...

Riley stated in the book that he wasn't forced out by the CL. He left on his own accord. I guess the harassment from fans helped in the decision.

I still do not believe the catfish lady. There is no chance that OM was so coordinated behind that account for it to be a random middle aged woman.

Daniel Paulling is a moron. A big one.

I just finished the first Tunsil chapter. What a helluva fun night that was.


100% agree. Women don't impersonate women on the internet. Men do.
 

dawgdoug1962

Redshirt
Oct 14, 2013
279
8
18
I finished the other day and my thought is that while the book is entertaining for us in the here and now, its real value will in ten or fifteen years when people ask, "Why does Ole Miss football suck so bad?" all you'll have to do is hand them a copy of the book.

Plus it will come in handy in a decade or two when some of the second generation fans try to deny that it was all that bad.....lol
 

pDigital32Dawg

Freshman
Aug 29, 2009
2,996
85
48
I don't disagree that it is a woman behind the account.

Steve goes on to attack the married men that were hitting on her, but he doesn't acknowledge that she was doing the same thing with the guys as a married woman.

Another weird thing about the account, @FinsUpAP, is that they tweeted as recently as August 15. The account is still active on Twitter with the stolen pictures of the GA girls.

https://twitter.com/FinsUpAP/status/897609567923826688

[TWEET]
[/TWEET]
 

00Dawg

Senior
Nov 10, 2009
3,352
619
93
There were a lot of things a good editor would've caught.

There weren't a ton of out-and-out typos, but there was plenty of incorrect phrasing, misplaced punctuation, and confusing sentence structure. I also thought the decision to shift the time period being covered back and forth wasn't the best one. That being said, in the modern era of printing this book is far, far from the worst edited I've seen. Steve has some writing talent, as many of us knew.

On content, as you say there wasn't anything truly groundbreaking in the book if you've been following the investigation to any detailed extent. I do wish there had been further exposition on the possibilities of the Tunsil cash-from-coaches statement, a summary paragraph in each chapter on why the contents pointed to an increasingly corrupt culture, and a wrap-up chapter that went more into how these are just the known and provable infractions that are going to be their downfall. However, that may best be saved for the second edition.
 

sayit

Redshirt
Sep 15, 2014
115
0
0
I agree with Cooldawgs assessment. I'd also like to know who the female committee member in Jackson was that excused herself when Steve's case came up and again when the vote took place.
 

Junction John

Redshirt
Oct 22, 2014
3,249
0
0
Keep in mind, Steve started writing this book before a lot of this was public.

Short of that, the book didn't have any startling revelations.

Imagine how different the revelations in this book would have been received if, for example, Hugh's phone records hadn't gotten out a few weeks ago... This would be a national story.
 

memphisbulldog

Redshirt
Apr 5, 2009
287
28
26
I'm about half way through the book and here are some thoughts from me...

Riley stated in the book that he wasn't forced out by the CL. He left on his own accord. I guess the harassment from fans helped in the decision.

I still do not believe the catfish lady. There is no chance that OM was so coordinated behind that account for it to be a random middle aged woman.

Daniel Paulling is a moron. A big one.

I just finished the first Tunsil chapter. What a helluva fun night that was.


I was surprised it was a woman also. But Steve figured out who she was. He apparently verified the identity. I'm not sure why anyone would at this point doubt that. Also, the female voice with the same discussions was on Ole Miss radio discussions several times. Case closed. Let's move on with that subject.
 

BlueRidgeMtns

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2016
5,604
3,509
113
I haven't read my copy yet, but I aim to knock it out this weekend. Thanks for the review.
 

jdbulldog

Junior
Oct 27, 2007
2,594
368
83
It seems the hacker if Steve's account didn't know what he/she was doing. A thorough hack would have exposed a lot of things Steve was keeping to himself.
 

MaroonNation

Redshirt
Jun 9, 2015
3,729
0
0
Riley stated in the book that he wasn't forced out by the CL. He left on his own accord. I guess the harassment from fans helped in the decision.
.

Blevins stated in the book there's no way what little he was getting paid was worth the headache of covering OM for the C-L, so, directly or indirectly, the CL forced him out.
 

Resolved

Redshirt
May 18, 2008
622
0
0
My favorite phrase was when he referenced the "hostage video" and said Freeze looked like a ***** in church while listening to his boss detail all the major infractions that took place under his watch.

If Bjerk or anyone else in that administration survives this, it will be a travesty.
 

HammerOfTheDogs

All-Conference
Jun 20, 2001
10,853
1,705
113
We know what Steve wrote because we've been following it since the beginning

However, 98% of the rest of the College Football fan world who doesn't keep up with om or The Mississippi State University, are looking at what Steve uncovered for the first time....and what they see is bad.

ole msis has shown themselves to be the most corrupt, venal, Athletic Organization in the history of America.
 

missouridawg

Junior
Oct 6, 2009
9,407
309
83
I was surprised it was a woman also. But Steve figured out who she was. He apparently verified the identity. I'm not sure why anyone would at this point doubt that. Also, the female voice with the same discussions was on Ole Miss radio discussions several times. Case closed. Let's move on with that subject.

Sorry Acey, but until you spill the beans and admit it I will continue to be skeptical.
 
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White Football Mississippi State Week 11 Preview: Run vs. Run
  2. 02 Maroon and White Basketball Mississippi State 79-57 Troy: Bulldogs build big early lead in home win over Trojans
  3. 03 Maroon and White Football Kamario Taylor speaks on return to Mississippi State for 2027
  4. 04 On3 NIL Kamario Taylor's $7.5M deal sets new bar in college football
  5. 05 Softball America 2027 Mississippi State Preview