Spin Off from Shaq Thread: Here's how I rank the SEC

57stratdawg

Heisman
Dec 1, 2004
148,785
24,669
113
*Football programs only*

Tier 1) Bama, LSU & UF
Tier 2) UGA, Auburn & TAM
Tier 3) UT, ArK, MSU, OM & SC
Tier 4) Missouri, Vandy, & UK

If this was a non-MSU board, most would relegate us to Tier 4. Whatever. I understand some might want to drop A&M down, but they're a better job due to resources and talent proximity.

Its hard for me to imagine a decade+ of football where one program moves more than 1 tier up or down.
 

Joe Schmedlap

Redshirt
Aug 11, 2010
1,334
33
48
Alabama is in an elite tier all you itself. No one else comes close.

LSU, AU, "maybe" UF in the next tier. And to be honest, I'm not sure any SEC East team deserves to be in this second tier. Any SEC West school, any of them, could have achieved UF's level of success in the past 4 or 5 years given the same schedule. So 17 it, take UF out and throw them in with the rest.

I think all the rest are interchangeable in any given year except for the bottom feeders. Yes, some have tradition and recruiting advantages over others, but when it comes to current overall strength of the program, everyone else is within striking distance of each other.

Now, Missouri and Vanderbilt currently do reside in the basement. Ole Miss could join them there soon if they are hit with the NCAA sanctions that they have earned if the NCAA simply follows its own punishment matrix.
 

Hoover Dawg

Redshirt
May 16, 2016
1,584
0
0
Texas A&M has never done it, that's the difference between them their financial peers.

In only see 3 tiers at most, with a fast-shrinking middle class:

1 - Alabama, LSU, Florida, Georgia, Auburn - these teams can win national titles
2 - Tennessee, Texas A&M - shrinking middle class
3 - Arkansas, MSU, South Carolina, Ole Miss, Missouri, Vanderbilt, Kentucky - can't compete for national titles

Tennessee used to be Tier 1. Texas A&M seemingly is better than Tier 3 but never made it happen. The only thing that keeps Tier 2 afloat is that they MAY be able to win the conference. I have my doubts on Texas A&M.
 

Drebin

Heisman
Aug 22, 2012
23,131
29,160
113
Texas A&M has never done it, that's the difference between them their financial peers.

In only see 3 tiers at most, with a fast-shrinking middle class:

1 - Alabama, LSU, Florida, Georgia, Auburn - these teams can win national titles
2 - Tennessee, Texas A&M - shrinking middle class
3 - Arkansas, MSU, South Carolina, Ole Miss, Missouri, Vanderbilt, Kentucky - can't compete for national titles

Tennessee used to be Tier 1. Texas A&M seemingly is better than Tier 3 but never made it happen. The only thing that keeps Tier 2 afloat is that they MAY be able to win the conference. I have my doubts on Texas A&M.

This is how it breaks down:

Tier 1: Alabama - undisputed
Tier 2: LSU, Auburn, Florida, Georgia - most likely to shock Alabama
Tier 3: Arkansas, A & M, MSU, Ole Miss, Tennessee, South Carolina - evenly matched teams that beat up each other
Tier 4: Missouri, Vanderbilt, Kentucky - door mats.

LSU is probably the team closest to jump to Tier 1.
Ole Miss probably drops to Tier 4 this year.
 

Hoover Dawg

Redshirt
May 16, 2016
1,584
0
0
I run into this confusion with a buddy of mine all the time, when discussing this sort of thing. You have to define the discussion - is it a snap shot of 'right now' or are you looking at any random 10-20 year period? My rankings are looking at a random period of time. Going into 2017, in present day, I'd agree with you.

When talking in general, you have to look past current coach, SEC TV deals, etc. Have to look at staying power. Program muscle.
 

Drebin

Heisman
Aug 22, 2012
23,131
29,160
113
I run into this confusion with a buddy of mine all the time, when discussing this sort of thing. You have to define the discussion - is it a snap shot of 'right now' or are you looking at any random 10-20 year period? My rankings are looking at a random period of time. Going into 2017, in present day, I'd agree with you.

When talking in general, you have to look past current coach, SEC TV deals, etc. Have to look at staying power. Program muscle.

The problem is that you can't do it any other way than current day.

In the mid 2000s, Alabama wasn't ALABAMA. The day will come again when they are down.
Tennessee hasn't done anything notable in football since Bill Clinton was president.
We keep penciling Georgia in the upper tier but they haven't won a damn thing in 40 years.
Florida was **** in the 80s, Spurrier brought them to relevance, Meyer won big, and now they are a notch below
LSU is up and down.
We are much more competitive than we were historically.
Three years ago, most of us would've had Missouri in or near that second tier.

There is way too much fluidity year over year to speak to a general ranking system, so there's no such thing as staying power. It has to be where they are today. That's why we're a better program than UT is today.
 

johnson86-1

All-American
Aug 22, 2012
15,292
5,848
113
The correct rankings:

Tier 1: Bama, LSU, and Florida. All three have the ability to go on multi-year runs. Them being good does not require any luck, just them not screwing up a coaching hire. A good hire and/or some luck puts them in the national championship discussion regularly.

Tier 2: UGA, A&M, Auburn. UGA and A&M should be a hair behind Bama, LSU, and Florida, but forwhatever reason, underachieve. Auburn should be behind UGA and A&M, but they have actually achieved recently.

Tier 3: UT, Ark, USCe, MSU. All of these could win their division if things fall their way, but are going to have to get somewhat lucky with a coaching hire or just catch some breaks. Probably not going to win a national championship. This is below UT's history, but I think it's where they belong now. MSU is the most questionable member of this group. Do Jackie and Mullen represent the new normal, with one god awful hire by Templeton costing us half a decade? Or are Jackie and Mullen exceptions?

After that, in ordert:

OM - no reason they couldn't be in Tier 3 except they've never won their division and it's not clear what normal is for them if they are doing "normal" SEC level cheating.

Mizzou - I really have no clue where to put them. Two to four years ago it looked like they would belong with USCe. Now it looks like UK would be an optimistic scenario.

UK - Always going to be held back by being a basketball school.

Vandy - always going to be held back by being Vandy (but at least they get to be competitive with Ole Miss).
 

johnson86-1

All-American
Aug 22, 2012
15,292
5,848
113
The problem is that you can't do it any other way than current day.

In the mid 2000s, Alabama wasn't ALABAMA. The day will come again when they are down.
Tennessee hasn't done anything notable in football since Bill Clinton was president.
We keep penciling Georgia in the upper tier but they haven't won a damn thing in 40 years.
Florida was **** in the 80s, Spurrier brought them to relevance, Meyer won big, and now they are a notch below
LSU is up and down.
We are much more competitive than we were historically.
Three years ago, most of us would've had Missouri in or near that second tier.

There is way too much fluidity year over year to speak to a general ranking system, so there's no such thing as staying power. It has to be where they are today. That's why we're a better program than UT is today.


There is fluidity year to year, but certain programs are going to perform well unless they screw up, whereas other programs are going to perform poorly unless they make really good/lucky decisions. It's not a matter of luck that Alabama is good again; it's a matter of having crazy fans willing to push them to be way better than their natural advantages would suggest. It won't be a matter of luck when Florida is good again. They just need a pretty good hire and they will be competitive again.
 

BiscuitEater

Redshirt
Aug 29, 2009
4,178
0
36
Texas A&M has never done it, that's the difference between them their financial peers.

In only see 3 tiers at most, with a fast-shrinking middle class:

1 - Alabama, LSU, Florida, Georgia, Auburn - these teams can win national titles
2 - Tennessee, Texas A&M - shrinking middle class
3 - Arkansas, MSU, South Carolina, Ole Miss, Missouri, Vanderbilt, Kentucky - can't compete for national titles

Tennessee used to be Tier 1.

Any CURRENT list of 'Tiers' would have MSU and Tennessee in the same tier (or one could make the argument that MSU should be listed in a higher tier). Since Dan's arrival, MSU has had a 61- 42 record in the West .. while UT has been 52 - 48 record in the East.

I would also argue that if MSU had swapped places with UT, we would have had a better chance than UT to make the SECC.
 

FQDawg

Senior
May 1, 2006
3,076
618
113
Based on the last 20 years...

Maybe 25 years...

I think it has to look like this:

Tier 1: Bama
Tier 2: Florida, LSU
Tier 3: Auburn, Georgia, Tennessee
Tier 4: Texas A&M
Tier 5: South Carolina, Arkansas, Missouri
Tier 6: Miss. State, Ole Miss
Tier 7: Kentucky
Tier 8: Vanderbilt

The top four tiers could easily win a national championship. Or, I should say, I wouldn't be surprised if anyone in the top 4 tiers won a national championship. Tiers 5 and 6 could win their division and the SEC only if things really break right for them in a given year but really have no hope of ever winning a national title in the next 20 years. Tiers 7-8 should stick to basketball.
 
Last edited:

johnson86-1

All-American
Aug 22, 2012
15,292
5,848
113
Any CURRENT list of 'Tiers' would have MSU and Tennessee in the same tier (or one could make the argument that MSU should be listed in a higher tier). Since Dan's arrival, MSU has had a 61- 42 record in the West .. while UT has been 52 - 48 record in the East.

I would also argue that if MSU had swapped places with UT, we would have had a better chance than UT to make the SECC.

If you just looked at it and ignored history, you would think UT would be basically as good as UK in football. They're just not in real football territory and have no reason to be good, except that they used to be good and therefore have the type of money and crazy fans that are generally required to be good. Still a lot of disadvantages to overcome though, and if they don't have some good years soon, so much time will have passed that I'm not sure they can leverage their past success anymore.
 

Hoover Dawg

Redshirt
May 16, 2016
1,584
0
0
We simply disagree. Program potential is a real thing and Tennessee's is higher than our's.

Take Nick Saban at Tennessee vs. Nick Saban at MSU in random year 2025. Tennessee wins that game 80% of the time. Tennessee probably wins a few national championships in that time frame, MSU probably goes 10-2 and maybe flirts with the playoff. That's the difference.

And don't get hung up on the name Nick Saban. Insert any coach and, over time, they'll win more at Tennessee than MSU.

How to change this? Enlarge our fanbase and resources to match Tennessee's. Make Starkville and MS and more attractive place than Knoxville and TN. That's the cold hard reality.
 

Hoover Dawg

Redshirt
May 16, 2016
1,584
0
0
I do agree with this, Johnson. It seems the statute of limitations from their 1998 national championship is about up. Usually about 20 years will do that. Clemson went 36 years before returning, and for a lot of that time, they were not considered a national power.
 

aTotal360

Heisman
Nov 12, 2009
22,685
16,753
113
Bama and MSU are 1a and 1b. 2nd tier is LSU, UGA, aTm, Ark, Auburn, SC, Vandy, Mizzou, UK, UF, and Tenn. Alone in the 3rd tier is Old Miss.
 

Drebin

Heisman
Aug 22, 2012
23,131
29,160
113
We simply disagree. Program potential is a real thing and Tennessee's is higher than our's.

Take Nick Saban at Tennessee vs. Nick Saban at MSU in random year 2025. Tennessee wins that game 80% of the time. Tennessee probably wins a few national championships in that time frame, MSU probably goes 10-2 and maybe flirts with the playoff. That's the difference.

And don't get hung up on the name Nick Saban. Insert any coach and, over time, they'll win more at Tennessee than MSU.

How to change this? Enlarge our fanbase and resources to match Tennessee's. Make Starkville and MS and more attractive place than Knoxville and TN. That's the cold hard reality.

This is just factually incorrect. Do you think Dan Mullen would win bigger at UT? We bemoan his recruiting now, but as we've said earlier, you have to be able to recruit nationally at UT.

Also, if you're going to weigh a program's resources, you also have to weigh a program's resourcefulness. We are a better program than UT today and have been for the past decade, despite resource disadvantages. Not only have we been better on the field, but the program has been managed better off the field. It doesn't matter how much money you have if you mismanage it and run your program in the red. Despite our disadvantage, we have some of the very best facilities in the conference (which rarely gets discussed), and we have a much more consistent record of success on the field over the last decade than many others in our tier, including Tennessee, South Carolina, Arkansas, and Ole Miss.

I have admitted that UT has more upside as a program so I don't know what you're arguing with me about other than to say UT is a better program than MSU today, which is not true by any measure other than how much they spend on their program.
 
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White Basketball Mississippi State 86-83 UCF: Bulldogs earn road win in fight from start to finish with Golden Knights
  2. 02 Maroon and White Basketball Mississippi State 88-46 Alabama State: Bulldogs beat the Hornets in annual Kids' Day game
  3. 03 Maroon and White Basketball Mississippi State at UCF: How, Where, and When to Watch Men's Basketball on the road
  4. 04 Maroon and White Football Sanfrisco Magee's "detail" and consistency carrying Mississippi State offense through tough times
  5. 05 Maroon and White Points of Focus from Jeff Lebby in Week 12 media availability