OT (Fishing): Question about shiners/minnows

[aTotal360]

Is it true that shiners die more quickly if they are kept in a square container as opposed to a round one? First I've ever heard of this.

I assume its has to do with them swimming constantly around in a circle as opposed to balling up in a corner.

 

[ShrubDog]

Minnow buckets are round.

 

[aTotal360]

that's the "science" backing this up. just wondering if it's true.

 

[WrapItDog]

Minnow buckets are round.

Minnow tanks at the bait shop are square

 

[missouridawg]

I fish Okeechobee every year with shiners. If you keep the live well aerated and cool, shiners can live in the square live well for more than 72 hours.

Also of note, for shiners specifically, the live well pump is too harsh for them. It knocks their scales off and injures them before they even go on the hook. This is crucial because bass want to eat something that looks live. Use a live well bubbler instead. If you need direction in finding one, Let me know. I got two for my dad for Christmas last year and they worked great in February for us.

 

[SedLexDuraLex]

Is it true that shiners die more quickly if they are kept in a square container as opposed to a round one? First I've ever heard of this.

I assume its has to do with them swimming constantly around in a circle as opposed to balling up in a corner.

The only possible explanation -- other than an enclosure that does not allow room for normal swimming -- would be water circulation, which is necessary for oxygentation. An airstone would make the shape of the container essentially irrelevant.