No need to jump in a time machine. It's a simple question- if you could have a generational type of talent, even if it's only for one year, would you take him? If you knew he might win you a title, like Anthony Davis did? The answer HAS to be yes, you would take him.If we're going to jump into the time machine, I'd rather have Issel, Macy, Givens, Minniefield & Mashburn, with Kenny Walker and a healthy Bowie coming off the bench. But whatever.
I don't like one and done, either. I like the "one" part but dislike the "done" part. But if the guys can come in and dominate and give the Cats a legitimate shot at a Final Four or maybe a title, I'd rather have the great player for one year than not at all.
I prefer having upperclassmen on the team, too. This season we have that. This might be a title team. Next year, if the right players return, we may have the best of both worlds- maybe junior and senior leadership AND young talent. That doesn't sound too bad, right?
Should we force these kids to stay, or else? Or just let them play their one year at Duke or Kansas?
You sound like someone looking to hate today. How could you not like this news? The #1 recruit signed with Kentucky. Are you a fan of Kentucky? Do you have clairvoyance? Do you already KNOW the kid will be one and done? He loves Cal. His dad loves Cal. He's gonna be making NIL money, pretty good money. Maybe he will stay. Is it ok if we enjoy his time here or do we have to hate him starting now?