KJ having a hell of game on MNF

RingN2012

Redshirt
Sep 10, 2012
577
0
0
Gruden loves KJ and for good reason. Wish we still had him in the maroon and white, we could use him this year
 

ShrubDog

Redshirt
Apr 13, 2008
5,307
3
38
He lucked out big time by not getting a penalty for batting the ball out of the endzone.
 

Wizard.sixpack

Freshman
Sep 15, 2009
6,511
58
48
[h=3][FONT=arial, sans-serif]Ferrall said last night he had KJ on the phone after the game asking him about it and KJ
told him he was just trying to make a smart play....and KJ hung up on him.

Ferall said that a CBS stringer who was there [/FONT]
[/h]told him that Pete Carroll over heard him telling Ferrall that and walked up and told him to get off the phone....
Funny stuff.
 

thekimmer

All-Conference
Aug 30, 2012
8,962
3,188
113
Yes he did but.....

He lucked out big time by not getting a penalty for batting the ball out of the endzone.

I don't understand why there is a need to make this action illegal.

He could have very easily done the same thing while pretending to recover the ball.

I can see making it illegal to advance the ball by batting it but knocking it out of bounds or out of the endzone? Why should that be illegal and if it is why isn't running out of bounds on purpose.
 

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
61,416
33,232
113
The really ridiculous part of this isn't that he batted the ball out of the end zone. It's that fumbling out of the end zone gives the defense the ball on the 20 to start with. Anywhere else on the field the offense fumbles the ball out of bounds, it keeps possession. The rule needs to be changed that if you fumble the ball out of the end zone, you keep the ball at the spot of the fumble.
 

dogfan96

Redshirt
Jun 3, 2007
2,188
12
66
The end zone isn't out of bounds.. it's the end zone. Two separate things. Just like kicking the ball out of bounds and kicking it out of the end zone aren't the same thing. Just like going out of bounds is going out of bounds and getting tackled in the end zone is a safety. Out of bounds is out of play. The end zone is in play and the primary scoring area.
 
Last edited:

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
61,416
33,232
113
The end zone is in play. You can fumble in the end zone all day long and the ball is still in play to be recovered. But if the ball rolls OUT of the end zone, it is out of bounds and can't be recovered. It's ridiculous to award the defense the football when they never recovered it, and may very well have never even touched it. Stupid rule.
 

Jaqueax

Redshirt
Mar 3, 2008
98
1
8
How about these comparisons

1. KJ kicks the ball out the back of the end zone instead of tapping it with his hand.

2. Punter mishandles snap in his own end zone. He could fall on the ball but instead kicks it out of the back of the end zone for a safety. Is there a flag

3. QB runs out the back of the end zone for a safety.

4. On an onside kick, receiving team taps ball out of bounds (sideline) instead of trying to field the kick.

I thought KJ made a smart play at the time. If you can't be penalized for these 4 things, then KJ shouldn't be penalized for tapping it out of bounds.

In rugby, if you go out of bounds with the ball, it is effectively a change of possession. It really feasible to do that in football since receivers run out patterns all day.
 

FlotownDawg

All-American
Aug 30, 2012
7,396
8,487
113
The rule states the ball can't be batted forward, unless in either end zone

Then it can't be batted in any direction. So punters and quarterbacks batting or kicking the ball out of their own end zone following a bad snap is not a penalty unless they do it with the ball already in the end zone. And in that case, the penalty is enforced from the spot of the foul, which is in the end zone, so it would be a safety. So since the ball got knocked out the back of the end zone anyway, it's a safety regardless, so most refs won't even throw the flag there because it's irrelevant. The rule is so obscure that I've only ever seen it called once in my life, and I have no problem with the ref not throwing the flag on KJ because it didn't affect the play at all. The ball was going out of bounds regardless of whether he touched it or not.
 

jakldawg

Redshirt
May 1, 2006
4,380
5
36
Would KJ have been on the team that basically lost the Arkansas game due to Ballard? fumbling the ball out the back of the end zone?
 

thekimmer

All-Conference
Aug 30, 2012
8,962
3,188
113
That was a good no call.....

Then it can't be batted in any direction. So punters and quarterbacks batting or kicking the ball out of their own end zone following a bad snap is not a penalty unless they do it with the ball already in the end zone. And in that case, the penalty is enforced from the spot of the foul, which is in the end zone, so it would be a safety. So since the ball got knocked out the back of the end zone anyway, it's a safety regardless, so most refs won't even throw the flag there because it's irrelevant. The rule is so obscure that I've only ever seen it called once in my life, and I have no problem with the ref not throwing the flag on KJ because it didn't affect the play at all. The ball was going out of bounds regardless of whether he touched it or not.

The talking heads complaining about how detroit got screwed on that play are full of it. Their player fumbled the ball in the endzone. There wasn't a lions player in the same zip code as the ball and Wright. The play he made did not deprive the lions of any legitimate chance to win the football game. The travesty would have been detroit getting another opportunity over something as irrelevant to the outcome of the game as that. Incidentally despite the play being made by a former bulldog I am not a fan of the seahawks.

If football really wants to stop that from happening they should change the touchback rules for fumbles that go into the endzone. Ball gets knocked out of bounds in the endzone possession stays with the who had it last at whatever point on the field it was fumbled. Recovery in the endzone by D is a touchback.
 

Dawgzilla

Redshirt
Mar 3, 2008
5,406
0
0
1. If KJ had kicked the ball, it would be an illegal kick and the refs almost certainly would have called a penalty. There would still be the question of whether he intentionally kicked it. A Player cannot deliberately kick the football anywhere on the field, except for punts, place kicks, or dropkicks.

2. I have seen punters penalized for batting or kicking a ball out of bounds in that situation. The penalty results in a safety, though, so some refs do not bother throwing a flag.

3. There is no penalty for running with the ball out of the endzone. That one is just a safety.

4. If the receiving team bats the ball forward and out of bounds on a free kick, then they should be penalized 15 yards from the point of batting. Under the old NFL rule, they would probably re-kick, but I think that has been changed.

For Flotown, while it certainly looked like the ball was going out of bounds whether KJ touched it or not, we don't really know. Footballs bounce funny. Plus, there was a Detroit player nearby who could have made a play for the ball if it bounced and didn't go directly out of bounds. KJ just didn't know the rule...if he had made any attempt to field the ball and just "accidentally" knocked it out of bounds, everything would have been kosher.
 
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White Points of Focus from Jeff Lebby in Week 12 media availability
  2. 02 Maroon and White Football What Mississippi State HC Jeff Lebby said about Sunday staff changes
  3. 03 On3 Football Over 35% of Power Four starting quarterbacks missed games with injuries in 2026
  4. 04 Maroon and White Football Sunday Notebook: Auburn 41-9 Mississippi State
  5. 05 Rivals Football Recruiting Biggest rankings risers in the updated 2027 Rivals300 rankings