for the most part, there are two ways to really screw up a shrimp boil
I know its been discussed here before but just wanted to get some updated advice. Having a shrimp boil this weekend for my daddy's birthday. What are your recommendations on cooking instructions and times for each item, potatoes, corn, sausage, shrimp?
(1) too much salt and/or seasoning
(2) over cook causing them to be hard to peel
I like the Louisiana brand of shrimp boil (the powder). While you are finding
your correct recipe, be conservative on the shrimp boil spice. It's better to have too mild of salt/spice than too much where it's terrible and you just wasted your investment. You didn't mention how many lbs of shrimp... but to ensure you don't screw it up follow the ratio of shrimp to spice on the package (double it if you are cooking potatos & stuff because they will soak it up more than the shrimp). Doing that, it will be pretty mild. a lot of people talk about how much salt or cayenne or whatever they add but have no mention of the size pot or the amount of water in their pot. By leaving out those types of details, there is a big unknown regarding the ratios of the boil and a risk of screwing it up by someone else trying to follow it on their own.
The other big mistake is the cook time once the shrimp is added to a rolling boil. Not all cookers put out the same BTUs and therefore the time to "return to a boil" that most people reference can vary greatly. The safest way to ensure your shrimp are cooked perfectly is to have the water at a roiling boil, add the shrimp (stirr/push them evenly around with a paddle) and turn off the heat immediately. The shrimp are "cooked" within seconds but now you are just waiting on the seasoning to kick in and the peel to be perfect. after soaking a few minutes, take one out and test peel it. If not quite right, test again in a few min. You can actually just look at it & tell. right behind the head, when the hull begins to separate from the tail meat leaving a small space on the hump, they will be a perfect peel. to prolong this hull separation time a little while allowing them to soak up more spice, do as others said and add ice. (I will freeze a couple of gallon milk jugs of water for this and just set them on top of the boil (ice melts inside the jug and doesn't water down the spices), the shimp will sink a little under the surface as the boil cools slighly. another option is to take your garden hose and just constantly wet the outside of the pot with cool water.)