Try another analogy...
Let's say a coach was selling drugs to kids at a football camp out of a college practice facility. Not even performance enhancing drugs, just narcotics.
To me, the act alone of someone, in their capacity on the coaching staff of a D1 football team, selling drugs to kids inside that team's athletic facility should trigger an NCAA investigation. Maybe not sanctions, but at least an investigation.
If the coach is fired as soon as he is discovered, then that should be the end of it. The school could probably self impose something stupid like losing half a practice day and it would go away.
That's not what happened here, so now, let's take it a step closer.
Let's say that other coaches, including the head coach, were aware that the coach was witnessed by a staff member selling drugs to children, again, in that college's facilities, and did not report it to the authorities and kept the coach on staff and free reign of campus facilities.
Wouldn't the involvement of the coaching staff (including the head coach) be enough to trigger an NCAA investigation and probably sanctions?
Now, let's take it a step further.
Let's say that not only were the coaching and athletic department staff aware, but some of the children came forward and identified the coach and the university leadership was made aware and still did not report it to the authorities and kept the coach on staff and free reign of campus facilities.
Wouldn't the involvement, and lack of action, by the athletic department and university leadership be enough to trigger an NCAA investigation and definite sanctions?
Now let's take it a step further.
Let's say that not only did the athletic department and university leadership not report this blatantly illegal act to the authorities, but they were complicit, if not active, in its cover up and the coach was still put into situations by the university where he still came into contact with children.
You really don't think that this institutional cover up of a crime where children were victimized is deserving of the most severe NCAA sanctions?
Now, replace selling drugs with one of the most heinous and disgusting crimes that a human being can commit.
The idea that somehow the fact that it was a crime should eliminate any NCAA penalties is beyond me.
If the university covers up for otherwise legal payments to a player, throw the book at them.
If the university covers up for a child predator, eh, the guy is already going to prison. Why punish the school?
That logic just doesn't hold up friend.