Very interesting article about Brady and deflatriots.....

thekimmer

All-Conference
Aug 30, 2012
8,968
3,192
113
In 2006 Brady lobbied hard with the NFL to change the rule from home team supplies all game balls to each team provides game balls for their offense. Sounds reasonable. As Brady explained, each team/QB likes em a little different. The interesting stat is that one year after this rule change the patriots fumble rate, that was on par with the rest of the league, went down dramatically cut nearly in HALF and is significantly better than the rest of the league to this day! Hmmm.....a drastic reduction in fumbles coincides with a rule change regarding game balls but for just for one team.

Very, very interesting.

Link
 

BulldogBlitz

Heisman
Dec 11, 2008
18,773
27,874
113
as most pats fans will be quick to say the patrtiots/bellichek are just smarter within the rules.

as for the current issue, i have heard the discussion concerning air temperature, but have not seen any calcs. being an engineer, i'd love to see the calcs not just the "it's science!" proclamation
 

OleMissLogo

Redshirt
Dec 28, 2014
15,573
0
0
as most pats fans will be quick to say the patrtiots/bellichek are just smarter within the rules.

as for the current issue, i have heard the discussion concerning air temperature, but have not seen any calcs. being an engineer, i'd love to see the calcs not just the "it's science!" proclamation

Article from Popular Science: http://www.popsci.com/football-physics-and-science-deflategate

A few excerpts:

Regarding temperature change being the reason:

"Last Sunday’s game was played in pouring rain at about 50F, so unless they did the pre-game testing of the balls in a sauna, or the post-game investigation in a meat locker, thermodynamics alone can’t get the Patriots off the hook."

Regarding why the officials didn't notice:

"the volume of a football doesn’t change very much with pressure, so deflating it by 2psi requires reducing the amount of gas inside by about 15%. But air is, by definition, very light. The air in a fully inflated football accounts for only about 10 grams of its mass (about 2.5% of the total) and deflating it would reduce that by maybe a gram or two. (This also explains why the officials didn’t notice anything funny during the game — the change in weight from the missing air is too small to notice, particularly in bad weather, where rain probably added more to the mass of the ball than the deflation took away.)"

Regarding the rationale behind underinflation:

"In the end, the reason for deflating a football owes more to physiology than physics. A slightly deflated ball is a bit softer, making it easier to grip the ball to throw it and reducing the bounce when it hits the hands of a receiver, making it easier to catch." (My own emphasis: this could also explain the fumble rate mentioned above.)
 

seshomoru

Senior
Apr 24, 2006
5,661
454
83
A smart person tweeted this...

For the Patriots to blame a change in temperature for 15% lower-pressures, requires balls to be inflated with 125-degree air.— Neil deGrasse Tyson (@neiltyson)
 

Sutterkane

Redshirt
Jan 23, 2007
5,100
0
0
My only thing is, if the other teams are allowed to do it why aren't they? Also, if it really is that big of an advantage, how is this just now getting noticed? I personally am tired of hearing about Tom Brady's balls.
 

Bulldog from Birth

All-Conference
Jan 23, 2007
2,569
1,185
113
Here's the Math

The relationship is this: Final Pressure / Initial Pressure = Final Temperature / Initial Temperature. But the key is that the pressures and temperatures are absolute temperatures. The NFL ball minimum is 11.5 psig. This is gauge pressure and just means 11.5 psi above atmospheric pressure. To get absolute pressure, you have to add atmospheric pressure (14.7 psi) to it. Same thing with the temperature. Absolute temperature is not Farenheit but Rankin in the English system. So you have to add 460 degrees to deg F to get deg R.

So P2/P1 = T2/T1.
P1 = 11.5 psig + 14.7 psi = 26.2 psia
T1 let's assume is 75 deg F in the locker room = 75 + 460 = 535 deg R.
T2 let's assume is 50 deg F outside = 50 + 460 = 510 deg R.

P2 = P1 x T2 / T1 = 25 psia.
P2 also = 25 psia - 14.7 psia = 10.3 psig if you convert it back to gauge pressure, which is how everyone is describing it.

In this example, the ball lost 1.2 psi. But this is less than 5% of its ABSOLUTE pressure. It only takes a loss in about 8% of its absolute pressure to explain a 2 psi loss in ball pressure. The smart-guy Tyson's math is either wrong or deceptive when he refers to a 15% loss in ball pressure. But I think he's confused gauge and absolute pressure.

So what has to happen for the ball to lose 2 psi? If the final temperature is 50 deg F, then the initial temperature had to have been 92 deg F. On the surface, this suggests the Patriots cheated. But what is not known is how the balls were inflated? Was it a manual air pump or a compressor? If a compressor is used, then that heats up the air as it is compressed. You'd need to see the compressor performance curve to know how hot the air was as it entered the football. But it is certainly feasible for a compressor to heat air to higher temperatures than 92 F. But you'd also have to know how much air was in the football already. Because the ball likely wouldn't have been filled completely with 100 deg F compressed air....only supplemented with it.

If the Patriots wanted to skirt the rules legally, then they could have completely deflated the football, filled it with warm compressed air up to 11.5 psig, gotten it ok'd by the referee, and then the ball would have seen significant deflation without any further tampering. Would've been legal by the rulebook but probably unethical and questionable behavior.
 

jakldawg

Redshirt
May 1, 2006
4,380
5
36
In the same way that Alabama's offensive line NEVER holds...maybe they're just fundamentally so much better it's hard to fully appreciate it. Or you could just subscribe to some crazy conspiracy theory that they cheat their asses off and never get popped due to their favored status in the league.
 

thekimmer

All-Conference
Aug 30, 2012
8,968
3,192
113
Impressive...Maybe they did just that....

[B said:
If the Patriots wanted to skirt the rules legally, then they could have completely deflated the football, filled it with warm compressed air up to 11.5 psig, gotten it ok'd by the referee, and then the ball would have seen significant deflation without any further tampering. Would've been legal by the rulebook but probably unethical and questionable behavior[/B].

Of course one would have to either maintain the balls at elevated temperature (see sauna) or time their hot air inflation immediately prior to the refs check. Then there is the matter of the balls feeling noticeably warm when the refs do their check.

Easier just to take em in the john and let a little air out before taking em to the field. I must say though that doing that to a dozen balls in 90 seconds is impressive.
 
Last edited:

thekimmer

All-Conference
Aug 30, 2012
8,968
3,192
113
Maybe the others just aren't as smart....

My only thing is, if the other teams are allowed to do it why aren't they? Also, if it really is that big of an advantage, how is this just now getting noticed? I personally am tired of hearing about Tom Brady's balls.

Despite the cheating aspect I really have to admire the pats genius if they thought this through to that level. Also, it dovetails nicely with Brady preferring to throw a flatter ball.
 
Last edited:

BulldogBlitz

Heisman
Dec 11, 2008
18,773
27,874
113
thanks for that info.

it's also possible that they use something other than air to inflate, but again, living in that grey area.

if they used some warm compressed air or filled it in the sauna, that seems easy enough for them to come clean on... yet here we sit with nothing more than brady and bellichek claiming ignorance that there is even an inflation pressure range mandated
 

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
61,497
33,372
113
Bottom line is, the NFL got caught with their pants down when a team took advantage of a very loose rule. If the NFL gave a **** about ball pressure, why don't they just supply all the balls and not have one set dedicated for 1 team to use and another set for the other team.
 

Bulldog from Birth

All-Conference
Jan 23, 2007
2,569
1,185
113
The balls would only feel warm if it was the "sauna" example. If it was simply hot compressed air, then the balls would never feel warmer. The mass of the leather is significantly more than the mass of the air. There's too much mass for its temperature to change significantly from the energy the warm air was holding.

Of course one would have to either maintain the balls at elevated temperature (see sauna) or time their hot air inflation immediately prior to the refs check. Then there is the matter of the balls feeling noticeably warm when the refs do their check.

Easier just to take em in the john and let a little air out before taking em to the field. I must say though that doing that to a dozen balls in 90 seconds is impressive.
 

thekimmer

All-Conference
Aug 30, 2012
8,968
3,192
113
Isnt that why tires are often inflated with nitrogen?...

thanks for that info.

it's also possible that they use something other than air to inflate, but again, living in that grey area.

if they used some warm compressed air or filled it in the sauna, that seems easy enough for them to come clean on... yet here we sit with nothing more than brady and bellichek claiming ignorance that there is even an inflation pressure range mandated

Supposedly they are less likely to lose pressure.
 

OleMissLogo

Redshirt
Dec 28, 2014
15,573
0
0
The relationship is this: Final Pressure / Initial Pressure = Final Temperature / Initial Temperature. But the key is that the pressures and temperatures are absolute temperatures. The NFL ball minimum is 11.5 psig. This is gauge pressure and just means 11.5 psi above atmospheric pressure. To get absolute pressure, you have to add atmospheric pressure (14.7 psi) to it. Same thing with the temperature. Absolute temperature is not Farenheit but Rankin in the English system. So you have to add 460 degrees to deg F to get deg R.

So P2/P1 = T2/T1.
P1 = 11.5 psig + 14.7 psi = 26.2 psia
T1 let's assume is 75 deg F in the locker room = 75 + 460 = 535 deg R.
T2 let's assume is 50 deg F outside = 50 + 460 = 510 deg R.

P2 = P1 x T2 / T1 = 25 psia.
P2 also = 25 psia - 14.7 psia = 10.3 psig if you convert it back to gauge pressure, which is how everyone is describing it.

In this example, the ball lost 1.2 psi. But this is less than 5% of its ABSOLUTE pressure. It only takes a loss in about 8% of its absolute pressure to explain a 2 psi loss in ball pressure. The smart-guy Tyson's math is either wrong or deceptive when he refers to a 15% loss in ball pressure. But I think he's confused gauge and absolute pressure.

Your math is right, but your rule is wrong. The NFL minimum is 12.5 psig not 11.5. Which means that the ball lost 2.2 psig.

And the 15% from the article is referring to volume not pressure.
 

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
61,497
33,372
113
Air is already 78% nitrogen. You're only getting an additional 20% or so if you fill the tires with nitrogen.
 

Bulldog from Birth

All-Conference
Jan 23, 2007
2,569
1,185
113
I guess so. Had 11.5 psig in my head for some reason. But even so, the conclusions are still all right. It doesn't change anything really. Even if you say it started with 12.5 psig initial pressure, a drop from 75 F to 50 F gives you roughly the same 1.3 psi pressure loss. And it takes a 91 deg F to 50 deg F drop in temperature to generate a 2 psi pressure loss. Instead of the 92 degrees in the 11.5 psig example

And I don't understand what volume has to do with it. Even if you argue it's volume changing and not pressure, volume is directly proportional to pressure. 15% loss in volume is equivalent to 15% rise in pressure with the same original volume. But regardless, volume is a silly way to talk about this anyway. The volume of the NFL football has not changed during this controversy. It's the pressure that's changing. Tyson needs to spend more time worrying about his basic science skills instead of worrying about how to cleverly mock religion.

Your math is right, but your rule is wrong. The NFL minimum is 12.5 psig not 11.5. Which means that the ball lost 2.2 psig.

And the 15% from the article is referring to volume not pressure.
 
Last edited:

Dawgzilla

Redshirt
Mar 3, 2008
5,406
0
0
The general public still has a lot of unknowns in the calculations. We don't know when or where the balls were initially measured, what the actual measurements were before the game and at halftime, or whether the same gauges were used to make the measurements. Most everyone's calculations are based on the vague allegation that at least some of the balls were about 2psi below spec. We don't know if that's even true, much less what the actual measurements were.

That said, it seems highly unlikely that the footballs lost significant air pressure just by being roughed up by the Patriots prior to use. If it turns out they only lost a half pound of pressure or so, then maybe, but if it really is closer to 2 pounds then it seems unlikely.

My guess is that the Patriots have been doing the same things with the their footballs for years, and either didn't know or didn't care that the low air pressure was below spec. The NFL never called them on it, so they just kept doing it. Now they are scrambling to come up with excuses, while Belicheck, Brady, and now Kraft are putting their necks on the line and claiming everything was done by the book....

My guess is that the excuse will ultimately be sabotage by a rouge ballboy. They will blame the ballboy, but then they will have to explain why a ballboy would take it upon himself to deflate footballs for the AFC Championship game if he hasn't been doing it all season. They will claim he was trying to screw with the game for some reason, and that none of the Patriots knew what was going on.
 

RocketDawg

All-Conference
Oct 21, 2011
20,571
3,179
113
The relationship is this: Final Pressure / Initial Pressure = Final Temperature / Initial Temperature. But the key is that the pressures and temperatures are absolute temperatures. The NFL ball minimum is 11.5 psig. This is gauge pressure and just means 11.5 psi above atmospheric pressure. To get absolute pressure, you have to add atmospheric pressure (14.7 psi) to it. Same thing with the temperature. Absolute temperature is not Farenheit but Rankin in the English system. So you have to add 460 degrees to deg F to get deg R.

So P2/P1 = T2/T1.
P1 = 11.5 psig + 14.7 psi = 26.2 psia
T1 let's assume is 75 deg F in the locker room = 75 + 460 = 535 deg R.
T2 let's assume is 50 deg F outside = 50 + 460 = 510 deg R.

P2 = P1 x T2 / T1 = 25 psia.
P2 also = 25 psia - 14.7 psia = 10.3 psig if you convert it back to gauge pressure, which is how everyone is describing it.

In this example, the ball lost 1.2 psi. But this is less than 5% of its ABSOLUTE pressure. It only takes a loss in about 8% of its absolute pressure to explain a 2 psi loss in ball pressure. The smart-guy Tyson's math is either wrong or deceptive when he refers to a 15% loss in ball pressure. But I think he's confused gauge and absolute pressure.

So what has to happen for the ball to lose 2 psi? If the final temperature is 50 deg F, then the initial temperature had to have been 92 deg F. On the surface, this suggests the Patriots cheated. But what is not known is how the balls were inflated? Was it a manual air pump or a compressor? If a compressor is used, then that heats up the air as it is compressed. You'd need to see the compressor performance curve to know how hot the air was as it entered the football. But it is certainly feasible for a compressor to heat air to higher temperatures than 92 F. But you'd also have to know how much air was in the football already. Because the ball likely wouldn't have been filled completely with 100 deg F compressed air....only supplemented with it.

If the Patriots wanted to skirt the rules legally, then they could have completely deflated the football, filled it with warm compressed air up to 11.5 psig, gotten it ok'd by the referee, and then the ball would have seen significant deflation without any further tampering. Would've been legal by the rulebook but probably unethical and questionable behavior.

You should send this to Bellechick and Brady. I doubt that Tyson even did any calculations, or perhaps used F or C instead of Rankin. I've never been all that impressed with Tyson.
 
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White Mississippi State Soccer hosts Samford in NCAA Tournament on Friday
  2. 02 Maroon and White Football Mississippi State Week 12 Preview: Who carries the load?
  3. 03 Maroon and White Basketball Bulldogs prepare for mid-major test against Tulsa in Jackson
  4. 04 On3 Football Mississippi State RB Fluff Bothwell re-signs with Bulldogs for 2027
  5. 05 Maroon and White "There will be an opportunity for Brodie": Mississippi State HC Jeff Lebby sets freshman up for Saturday runout