I don't want Mintz back and why.

uk78_rivals88018

All-American
Feb 6, 2003
12,401
8,783
0
I anticipate criticism and disagreement but let me explain and see who might agree. First, just a few weeks ago there was genuine concern about would we have a dedicated point guard. Then TyTy steps up and commits. Unlike issues I saw with Boston and Askew (and posted pre-season a year ago getting some criticism then as well) I don't see the same issues with Ty Ty. He is a great passer, can shoot the ball, and his deficit will only be gaining college experience and facing upgraded defenses. A week later an experienced very good point guard Wheeler also commits although we don't know if the SEC will approve his immediate eligibilty just yet. It appears likely thought that we will have two very good point guards and others who can play that role if necessary.

Last season there must of been real pressure on Cal to play Boston and Askew and that was to the detriment of Allen and others. Cal would often start Askew over Mintz so what does that tell you about Mintz? If Mintz returns I could see a similar dilemma of having to now play him. How is that even fair to Ty Ty, Wheeler, and especially Allen? If anyone should have transferred after the way he was treated last season was Allen. But, he stuck with it and the team. He deserves much more opportunity. Ty Ty basically rescued this team where a few months ago he wasn't even that strong a recruit for us. He deserves opportunity. Meanwhile, Mintz easily could have stated he is returning but didn't. In fact as of this writing we still don't know. I know many are enamored with him because he got hot in a few games with his shooting. But, for me, I never saw a really good point guard who could handle the ball well and place passes in the right spots to teammates. It is not only about skill though in my view, it is about team chemistry and fairness. I think Ty Ty and Wheeler ultimately bring much more than Mintz plus they showed they want to be on this team. We also got a real offensive player in Kellan Grady at guard and a top shooter in Fredrick. Each of these players transferred all wanting to be here and with skills that deserve being on the court. Mintz returning seems like a challenge to the chemistry and opportunity for others. Plus, like I said, with pressure on Cal to particularly play him. I say adios and the team will be better for it.

Now if Mintz does come back many will celebrate. But, I don't see what others see evidently as it being a good thing.
 
Apr 13, 2002
44,001
97,158
0
Wouldn't say I don't want him back but I definitely think it creates a log jam to the point where he's absolutely only a luxury.

I think he's a really nice piece but last year looked better than he was due to the complete incompetence of askew and Boston. Someone like mintz just cannot be your best perimeter player.

That said I don't see him coming back especially now. A D1 athletes grind is no joke. So I don't see someone going through that for an extra season just to play sparingly off the bench
 

Bkocats

Heisman
Jan 2, 2011
80,908
70,033
67
It’s a good post for discussion and i truly hope that we are able to do so without it degenerating into a pissing match
i cannot entirely agree with OPs comments, but I see where he’s coming from. For myself, it’s all about changing the culture. The ones who put in the work are the ones who should be on the floor. I don’t want TyTy to get preferential treatment simply because he’s a NBA prospect. That’s been a huge part of our problem
we can use Mintz and honestly he’s a known quantity. He also already knows the other players and there is already chemistry there, or he would not be entertaining returning. He’s also older..we need his experience and maturity
TyTy has the talent, but we really have no idea how that will translate to college ball. He’s never played here and we cannot unequivocally state he will save this team
I do agree about Allen. He deserves his chance
What I want to see is the best team on the floor, one that gives us the best chance to win games
That does not necessarily mean the best (on paper) individual player
What it’s going to boil down to is coaching and development.
 

BlueLegends

All-Conference
Apr 21, 2021
988
1,718
0
As someone who has witnessed the cancer caused by a group of disgruntled players unhappy with their playing time, I would disagree.
Are you speaking of the John Wall class? So, whichever class you’re speaking of, how can we at anytime in recent years not go after more talent? I mean, last year there was an abundance of shortage in that department.
 

DerekMcPwn

Heisman
Sep 13, 2016
5,937
19,655
0
I anticipate criticism and disagreement but let me explain and see who might agree. First, just a few weeks ago there was genuine concern about would we have a dedicated point guard. Then TyTy steps up and commits. Unlike issues I saw with Boston and Askew (and posted pre-season a year ago getting some criticism then as well) I don't see the same issues with Ty Ty. He is a great passer, can shoot the ball, and his deficit will only be gaining college experience and facing upgraded defenses. A week later an experienced very good point guard Wheeler also commits although we don't know if the SEC will approve his immediate eligibilty just yet. It appears likely thought that we will have two very good point guards and others who can play that role if necessary.

Last season there must of been real pressure on Cal to play Boston and Askew and that was to the detriment of Allen and others. Cal would often start Askew over Mintz so what does that tell you about Mintz? If Mintz returns I could see a similar dilemma of having to now play him. How is that even fair to Ty Ty, Wheeler, and especially Allen? If anyone should have transferred after the way he was treated last season was Allen. But, he stuck with it and the team. He deserves much more opportunity. Ty Ty basically rescued this team where a few months ago he wasn't even that strong a recruit for us. He deserves opportunity. Meanwhile, Mintz easily could have stated he is returning but didn't. In fact as of this writing we still don't know. I know many are enamored with him because he got hot in a few games with his shooting. But, for me, I never saw a really good point guard who could handle the ball well and place passes in the right spots to teammates. It is not only about skill though in my view, it is about team chemistry and fairness. I think Ty Ty and Wheeler ultimately bring much more than Mintz plus they showed they want to be on this team. We also got a real offensive player in Kellan Grady at guard and a top shooter in Fredrick. Each of these players transferred all wanting to be here and with skills that deserve being on the court. Mintz returning seems like a challenge to the chemistry and opportunity for others. Plus, like I said, with pressure on Cal to particularly play him. I say adios and the team will be better for it.

Now if Mintz does come back many will celebrate. But, I don't see what others see evidently as it being a good thing.
Absolutely heinous take.

What pills does a person have to wash down with wood alcohol to believe that a recruit who has never played a single game in a Kentucky jersey “rescued the team” and “deserves opportunity” over the team’s actual returning leader in points, assists, and 3PFGs?
 

MdWIldcat55

Heisman
Dec 9, 2007
21,725
87,897
113
So, it summarize: You don't want Mintz back because

1. He hasn't sent the fan base a message as of May 31 saying he is all in with Kentucky and
2. You are afraid that a hall of fame coach who sees him and all the other players every day in practice will irrationally play him instead of more deserving players.

I want him back because 1. As long as he is there for Midnight Madness I'm good and 2. If TyTy or Allen or anyone else deserves his minutes, they'll get them. Why people think a coach whose career and reputation is at stake would sabotage himself to play guys who shouldn't play has always been a mystery to me. Just accept that no one sees these players as much as the coach, or is in as good of a position to make that decision.
 

turkeywildturkey

All-Conference
Oct 23, 2003
2,647
2,202
0
I anticipate criticism and disagreement but let me explain and see who might agree. First, just a few weeks ago there was genuine concern about would we have a dedicated point guard. Then TyTy steps up and commits. Unlike issues I saw with Boston and Askew (and posted pre-season a year ago getting some criticism then as well) I don't see the same issues with Ty Ty. He is a great passer, can shoot the ball, and his deficit will only be gaining college experience and facing upgraded defenses. A week later an experienced very good point guard Wheeler also commits although we don't know if the SEC will approve his immediate eligibilty just yet. It appears likely thought that we will have two very good point guards and others who can play that role if necessary.

Last season there must of been real pressure on Cal to play Boston and Askew and that was to the detriment of Allen and others. Cal would often start Askew over Mintz so what does that tell you about Mintz? If Mintz returns I could see a similar dilemma of having to now play him. How is that even fair to Ty Ty, Wheeler, and especially Allen? If anyone should have transferred after the way he was treated last season was Allen. But, he stuck with it and the team. He deserves much more opportunity. Ty Ty basically rescued this team where a few months ago he wasn't even that strong a recruit for us. He deserves opportunity. Meanwhile, Mintz easily could have stated he is returning but didn't. In fact as of this writing we still don't know. I know many are enamored with him because he got hot in a few games with his shooting. But, for me, I never saw a really good point guard who could handle the ball well and place passes in the right spots to teammates. It is not only about skill though in my view, it is about team chemistry and fairness. I think Ty Ty and Wheeler ultimately bring much more than Mintz plus they showed they want to be on this team. We also got a real offensive player in Kellan Grady at guard and a top shooter in Fredrick. Each of these players transferred all wanting to be here and with skills that deserve being on the court. Mintz returning seems like a challenge to the chemistry and opportunity for others. Plus, like I said, with pressure on Cal to particularly play him. I say adios and the team will be better for it.

Now if Mintz does come back many will celebrate. But, I don't see what others see evidently as it being a good thing.
Good that you’re not calling the shots here. If Cal wants him back, Cal knows he can help this team. Leave it to Cal.
 

Wunky

Heisman
Jan 16, 2021
4,527
18,942
78
It’s a good post for discussion and i truly hope that we are able to do so without it degenerating into a pissing match
i cannot entirely agree with OPs comments, but I see where he’s coming from. For myself, it’s all about changing the culture. The ones who put in the work are the ones who should be on the floor. I don’t want TyTy to get preferential treatment simply because he’s a NBA prospect. That’s been a huge part of our problem
we can use Mintz and honestly he’s a known quantity. He also already knows the other players and there is already chemistry there, or he would not be entertaining returning. He’s also older..we need his experience and maturity
TyTy has the talent, but we really have no idea how that will translate to college ball. He’s never played here and we cannot unequivocally state he will save this team
I do agree about Allen. He deserves his chance
What I want to see is the best team on the floor, one that gives us the best chance to win games
That does not necessarily mean the best (on paper) individual player
What it’s going to boil down to is coaching and development.

This is spot on. And not to hijack the thread, but all I want is for Cal to quit playing lineups that lack scoring ability.
 

ABlockalypseBrow

All-Conference
May 26, 2018
1,534
3,183
0
In the end it sounds like you’re concerned a lesser player will take time from better players, to me that’s a coaching concern not a concern with Mintz.

If Cal isn’t capable and/or willing to put the best players out there and get the team to work together for the greater good then we’re in trouble no matter who is on our roster.
 

sk73

All-Conference
Feb 16, 2013
3,253
3,351
113
I do not expect Mintz to be part of this UK team. He is 23 years old and it is probably time for him to take the next step in his life. He has more than likely known for a long while that he will not be selected in the NBA draft. Whatever his plans may be, I wish he would announce those plans and move in or move on.
 

Cawood86_rivals

Heisman
Feb 20, 2005
36,711
64,715
0
We all know why Cal started Askew over Mintz. It wasn't because Askew was the better talent or player. That all proved out. If Cal had started him from the get go, things might have been a little better.
Mintz can shoot and with the nature of injuries and freshman getting acclimated to college ball, Mintz is definitely a player I want back.
 

FirewithFire

Heisman
Jan 16, 2021
4,932
15,920
0
So, it summarize: You don't want Mintz back because

2. You are afraid that a hall of fame coach who sees him and all the other players every day in practice will irrationally play him instead of more deserving players.
If you are going to use that as a talking point you might want to consider that the HoF coach you are talking about did just that last year and many of the years before that as well. Just saying.

I never thought Mintz would return and have taken some **** for saying so. That said, I hope he comes back because I want Cal to be in a position where he needs to play a four guard line up. That way the team has a real reason to run when he stomps his feet and screams, GOOOOOOOOOOOO! We might actually score some points too.
 

MdWIldcat55

Heisman
Dec 9, 2007
21,725
87,897
113
See 1994 UNC. Most of the ‘93 title team, the freshman would be the core of the 1995 FF team. But the Young Guns and the Seniors never mixed quite right, and that became the squad to break the S16 streak.
A collection of 30 players between 93-95 with a combined four hours in the classroom - and 345 A-plus grades in African American studies. Six of them, like Rashad McCants later, made the Dean's List at Chapel Hill.
 
Last edited:

bucsrule8872

Heisman
May 30, 2005
24,397
29,352
0
I want Mintz back. He’s the main reason we won those 9 games last season. He’s a winner. He’s a leader. He’s a glue guy. If you don’t want him back, that’s fine, but I see no reason not to welcome him back with open arms. He’s not the type of player that causes locker room problems. Actually quite the opposite. He will help pull this team together. If the new players can’t handle him being back, then they are the problem and probably will be a problem even if Mintz doesn’t come back.
 

UK-Chulo

All-American
Mar 22, 2007
3,472
5,005
98
I anticipate criticism and disagreement but let me explain and see who might agree. First, just a few weeks ago there was genuine concern about would we have a dedicated point guard. Then TyTy steps up and commits. Unlike issues I saw with Boston and Askew (and posted pre-season a year ago getting some criticism then as well) I don't see the same issues with Ty Ty. He is a great passer, can shoot the ball, and his deficit will only be gaining college experience and facing upgraded defenses. A week later an experienced very good point guard Wheeler also commits although we don't know if the SEC will approve his immediate eligibilty just yet. It appears likely thought that we will have two very good point guards and others who can play that role if necessary.

Last season there must of been real pressure on Cal to play Boston and Askew and that was to the detriment of Allen and others. Cal would often start Askew over Mintz so what does that tell you about Mintz? If Mintz returns I could see a similar dilemma of having to now play him. How is that even fair to Ty Ty, Wheeler, and especially Allen? If anyone should have transferred after the way he was treated last season was Allen. But, he stuck with it and the team. He deserves much more opportunity. Ty Ty basically rescued this team where a few months ago he wasn't even that strong a recruit for us. He deserves opportunity. Meanwhile, Mintz easily could have stated he is returning but didn't. In fact as of this writing we still don't know. I know many are enamored with him because he got hot in a few games with his shooting. But, for me, I never saw a really good point guard who could handle the ball well and place passes in the right spots to teammates. It is not only about skill though in my view, it is about team chemistry and fairness. I think Ty Ty and Wheeler ultimately bring much more than Mintz plus they showed they want to be on this team. We also got a real offensive player in Kellan Grady at guard and a top shooter in Fredrick. Each of these players transferred all wanting to be here and with skills that deserve being on the court. Mintz returning seems like a challenge to the chemistry and opportunity for others. Plus, like I said, with pressure on Cal to particularly play him. I say adios and the team will be better for it.

Now if Mintz does come back many will celebrate. But, I don't see what others see evidently as it being a good thing.
TyTy and Wheeler will play. Allen will if he earns it.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Jmeeks54thebest

catswin

Heisman
Jan 3, 2003
10,082
12,710
0
I remember back in the 80s and 90s when Vandy always had those great shooters and many of them were from Kentucky. I would always wish we had those players. They always looked so good. But Vandy would always go around 15-16.

Average players look a lot better on bad teams. They are not players that put a team in the elite group. Mintz transferred from Creighton because he wasn’t going to start there. He came to UK and was the leader of the worst team in UK history.
 

BlueLegends

All-Conference
Apr 21, 2021
988
1,718
0
OP is at the barber shop on this great holiday today:

 

TBCat

Heisman
Mar 30, 2007
14,317
10,332
0
Admittedly Mitz's role just got reduced. By a lot I think. He's basically going to be 3rd at both guard spots. With that said he is exactly the kind of player we need to stick around. We can account for top 10 picks in the draft leaving. The problem the last few years is that everyone is leaving including the guys you look at as glue guys. Trust me guys like Mintz will make Washington and Grady better. Part of the reason why guys like Clarke and Boston failed to develop was because there was nobody on the roster that forced them to do so. Boston was going to play no matter what. TyTy won't play if he shoots 20% from 3. He's going to have to develop into a college player just to get on the floor. Boston to this day still looks like a high school player. If you look back over the Cal era you will see that the freshmen develop better and faster when they join a roster that has effective and experienced upper classmen.
 

Wildcats1st

Heisman
Sep 16, 2017
18,949
28,911
0
It really is an awful perspective. You act like mintz has left the program while the new guys have come in and made the sacrifices. That’s absurd. Mintz hasn’t gone anywhere. He’s testing the waters. Until he says he’s gone he’s still part of the program and the chemistry will revolve around him not wheeler or freshman who is an unknown. Mintz knows the system has a man who has played for cal who has put it all out there doing whatever he was asked. As for the he got hot in a few games comment. Those games were down the stretch and a teaser of what mintz might do now that he’s acclimated. This is perhaps the worst thread of the year. I can’t believe Someone would say he doesn’t want mintz bc of newcomers who will probably be half the player mintz will to start the year.
 

Catswin9

Senior
Jun 24, 2015
567
868
0
I anticipate criticism and disagreement but let me explain and see who might agree. First, just a few weeks ago there was genuine concern about would we have a dedicated point guard. Then TyTy steps up and commits. Unlike issues I saw with Boston and Askew (and posted pre-season a year ago getting some criticism then as well) I don't see the same issues with Ty Ty. He is a great passer, can shoot the ball, and his deficit will only be gaining college experience and facing upgraded defenses. A week later an experienced very good point guard Wheeler also commits although we don't know if the SEC will approve his immediate eligibilty just yet. It appears likely thought that we will have two very good point guards and others who can play that role if necessary.

Last season there must of been real pressure on Cal to play Boston and Askew and that was to the detriment of Allen and others. Cal would often start Askew over Mintz so what does that tell you about Mintz? If Mintz returns I could see a similar dilemma of having to now play him. How is that even fair to Ty Ty, Wheeler, and especially Allen? If anyone should have transferred after the way he was treated last season was Allen. But, he stuck with it and the team. He deserves much more opportunity. Ty Ty basically rescued this team where a few months ago he wasn't even that strong a recruit for us. He deserves opportunity. Meanwhile, Mintz easily could have stated he is returning but didn't. In fact as of this writing we still don't know. I know many are enamored with him because he got hot in a few games with his shooting. But, for me, I never saw a really good point guard who could handle the ball well and place passes in the right spots to teammates. It is not only about skill though in my view, it is about team chemistry and fairness. I think Ty Ty and Wheeler ultimately bring much more than Mintz plus they showed they want to be on this team. We also got a real offensive player in Kellan Grady at guard and a top shooter in Fredrick. Each of these players transferred all wanting to be here and with skills that deserve being on the court. Mintz returning seems like a challenge to the chemistry and opportunity for others. Plus, like I said, with pressure on Cal to particularly play him. I say adios and the team will be better for it.

Now if Mintz does come back many will celebrate. But, I don't see what others see evidently as it being a good thing.
Just outright silly. Did you really watch the games? Without Mintz, our record would have been...you figure it out. I will take a proven player over any freshmen, no disrespect intended to Ty Ty.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RunninRichie

irishcat1965

Heisman
Apr 22, 2012
21,849
47,055
113
I think he provides value for next year’s team. I hope he returns but I am not convinced he does at this point.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kygrandpa

track42

Heisman
Feb 18, 2017
6,597
15,048
0
We need guys like Mintz and Brooks back for the experience.We have new players with experience coming in but they aren't used to Cal and what he wants.It will be new to them as much as the freshmen.
 

uk78_rivals88018

All-American
Feb 6, 2003
12,401
8,783
0
I do prefer most players return just not in this case. And, no it isn't the worst take again tell me how Cal didn't favor certain players over others. Hopefully, he learned from that terrible error. But, why have the possibility of that situation again?

It's also true that last year's team might have lost more games without Mintz, or we might have won more games if certain players weren't granted playing time over others.

No offense to some, but I remember, like I said, getting attacked especially by those posting Boston, Clarke, and Askew were going to be the greatest guard combination in the history of Kentucky. Where are you now, those who said this? So, no I don't believe Freshman are automatically going to be great. But, I do believe Ty Ty is going to be the right person for this group backed up by Wheeler who will compete with him every day.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kygrandpa
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR KSR Show, 11/18: Ask Anything Wednesday, live from 10-noon
  2. 02 KSR Basketball Heshimu Evans arrested on domestic violence charge in Lexington
  3. 03 KSR KSR Today: Mark Pope previews Indiana, Will Stein previews Missouri
  4. 04 KSR Football Kentucky Drops Out of 12-Team Field in Latest CFP Top 25 Rankings
  5. 05 KSR Football CFP Rankings Reaction: How Does Kentucky Get Back Into 12-Team Field?