Will you give Cal another chance if he....

MdWIldcat55

Heisman
Dec 9, 2007
21,719
87,846
113
Well I can guarantee its not a 1 year fix...
Thanks for the guarantee. Based on the intelligence of your posts that's really convincing -- convincing that you are wrong, I mean.

Kentucky is very likely a 20-plus win team next year, and an NCAA level team with a good shot at the Sweet 16 and maybe going beyond that. Players like Oscar and Collins and Grady and Brooks are the foundation of a very good team.

But agreeing or disagreeing with that right now doesn't even make sense until the roster is set.

So the entire premise of this thread is faulty and pointless. "What if your wife has a sex change operation and becomes your husband. Will you stick with him?'
 
Last edited:

chroix

Heisman
Jul 22, 2013
11,176
28,521
113
4-5 more years at least. He gave us one of the greatest stretches of our program from 2011-2015, and has 3 final fours and 1 championship. He is still a top recruiter in the game, come on, you think kids would rather play for Chris Beard or one of the greatest coaches of all time in Cal. There is no better options out there and there wont be for some time unless you want to hire another BCG.
I think OP is BCG
 
  • Like
Reactions: BigCat241

TankedCat

Heisman
Nov 8, 2006
22,792
21,500
0
I appreciate the fact that Cal is taking noticeable steps to go in the right direction

He got fat and happy the last couple of years thinking he could pull of the magic without the effort - which happened to Tubby as well.

I personally believe next year will be better (how can it not when you just turned in the most historically bad season ever at Kentucky) but no one is going to be excited about it. Cal isn't getting the players he wants, he isn't getting plan B, hell, he isn't getting Plan D at PG.

The only real question is will fans give him yet another mulligan while his high dollar assistants try to put together a serious team for 2023.

I just hope that Cal understands he can't go back to putting a crap product on the floor with the promise of March. Alot of people weren't excited about Kentucky basketball when he wasn't stinking it up after 2016, and its completely off the rails with his deer in the headlights season he just turned in.
 

KyFaninNC

Heisman
Mar 14, 2005
195,719
24,518
0
No. After his actions this past year, a big HELL NO. Time for him to move on. He said himself that 10 years is a good life span for a UK coach. Time for him to take his own advice. Half the fan base has been alienated because of his actions and tone. They are not coming back, so the fan base will remain divide till he is gone.
 

irishcat1965

Heisman
Apr 22, 2012
21,799
46,967
113
My question is WHY should the highest paid coach in college basketball , at the premier program in college basketball , ever need to “rebuild”. He has been here over 10 years, every aspect about our current program ‘s “State” is Cal’s doing, his design. Nearly everyone admits things are broken right now and need to be fixed yet many feel the guy who tore the palace apart is the man who should and will fix it. Then I hear all this drivel about we gotta swim or sink with Cal because we can’t get anyone better. Does anyone really rationally believe no coach in the country could not win more than 9 games at Kentucky , really. Then I hear it’s Cal or another BG like there is no middle or higher ground between the 2, what nonsense. UK needs to contend for an SEC title, make the NCAA tournament and win a couple of games next year or Cal needs to move on. Look at our roster for next year and tell me how that’s gonna happen.
Coach K had to rebuild after his 15th year at Duke. Roy had to rebuild after his 16th year at UNC. But that doesn’t fit the agenda does it?
 
  • Like
Reactions: chroix

irishcat1965

Heisman
Apr 22, 2012
21,799
46,967
113
No. After his actions this past year, a big HELL NO. Time for him to move on. He said himself that 10 years is a good life span for a UK coach. Time for him to take his own advice. Half the fan base has been alienated because of his actions and tone. They are not coming back, so the fan base will remain divide till he is gone.
Lol. Total rubbish
 

Short-Dawg-69

All-Conference
Aug 9, 2019
2,628
4,102
0
As I have stated many times I am a Cal supporter and do not want his gone or replaced.

BUT IF.... we have another season like last year or another NIT then its more than likely time to put him in an administration roll and get a new head coach.

BUT... I feel strongly that will not happen I think Cal is going after another National Championship then retire while on top.
 

fastpaste101

All-Conference
Feb 10, 2021
1,051
1,421
0
Cal needs to win 25+ games and make a deep tourney run next year. Otherwise his seat is going to get very hot.
Hate to say it but I am closer to this than the guy that said 3-4 years.

I think if cal cannot get 20 wins and field a pretty damn competitive team then I will lose faith. To be clear, I spent most of the last season thinking many of you were being too hardcore in a covid year. Next will not be that so expectations rose for me... by a lot.
 

uk78_rivals88018

All-American
Feb 6, 2003
12,401
8,783
0
OF course this is all hypothetical (the question). So, hypothetically speaking, if we have a similar outcome next season Cal should be fired no matter the contract.

This is KENTUCKY F'N BASKETBALL! I can't believe some of the responses that would excuse this again. It is already concerning enough that as elite facilties, history, fan base, arena, reputation, that our program has over almost any other program we are losing recruits to football schools and lesser programs sharing none of what our program offers. You don't have one if not the highest paid basketball coaches at these other schools for a reason. There are many reasons we can debate about why we just had the worst season for Kentucky in the modern era. OK, it happened and as some point out for different reasons it has happened elsewhere. But, this isn't a "rebuilding" situation because of 4 year graduations, a super-star player moving on, you just won a championship or came close, injuries, etc.

The final outcome of recruiting remains to be seen. But, it is Cal's responsibility as head coach to have teams at a program like Kentucky compete for National Championships, not just to get to the NCAA tourney (or less).
 

kyjeff1

Heisman
Sep 8, 2012
52,112
73,688
113
Is there a coach who we can hire that will automatically bring 2 top 10 players with him just because they wanted to play for them like Cousins and Wall?
Well, lets disect this a little bit. You just insinuated that it would take John Wall and Cuz type talents to go from what was 20/21 to a 2010 type season, but I'll ask you this, is Knight/Lamb/Jones/Jorts better that Wall/Cuz/Bledsoe/Patterson?
The 2014 team didn't have a wall or Cuz on it either.

Look, it doesn't take a team full of top 3 high school kids to go from suck to great when you have a transfer portal and immediate eligibility.

Cal has all the things he needs to be great in 21/22. Oscar and Collins can easily be as good or better than Jorts and Jones. Oscar is going to be a junior and Collins is a top 10 kid. If Cal lands Carr, Mintz and a couple other guards, which shouldn't be that difficult to do, given the fact that there are a gazillion guards in the portal, then he will have a roster full of damn good experienced players at every position.

Fact is, Cal has rebuilt the roster every year he has been here, now he has an added tool to use via immediate eligibility. I see no reason why 21/22 has to be terrible, if he can't put a legit FF threat type lineup out there with Orlando, Chin and Lucas recruiting for him, then he needs to donate his pay back to UK.

As far as those that think it’s okay to take 3 years to rebuild UK basketball… . ummmm no it's not. Y'all act like Cal is just now taking over the program. No, he created this mess, he's the highest paid coach in cbb and this is Kentucky, that **** won’t fly.
 

Rondoed

Junior
Jul 1, 2008
761
309
0
Fans of other schools who are not Kentucky fans would love for Kentucky not to get Dajuan Wagner, Jr., etc., in 2023 just like they would have loved and praised Tubby Smith to continue on as Kentucky coach
 

KYCAT78

All-American
May 24, 2006
7,858
6,073
0
No problem giving him 3 years to get us back to an elite 8. Landscape is changing and things are going to be wildly different but I don’t see a better realistic option out there and honestly I like the guy a lot and he’s earned plenty of good will from me and I believe he can adapt. The off season changes and statements show his willingness to evaluate himself but it might not be a 1 year fix.
Program should not be in the shape it is in with our Brand and the money we are paying our Coach and Staff. If Cal cannot make the Sweet16 every year at UK he should be fired. If he has a losing record on 1/1/22 he should be fired that day. Many if not most of the Cal supporters wanted Tubby out yet Tubby record over the last 5 years is not much different from Tubby's and Tubby never had a losing record. So would you keep Tubby?
 
  • Like
Reactions: KFuqua

kb22stang

All-Conference
Dec 11, 2005
10,902
4,384
0
Well I can guarantee its not a 1 year fix, but a sub 20 win season next year your fine with? I'm sure a lot won't be. Hes the top paid coach in the country, you cant just **** the bed year after year consecutively.

You people keeping bringing up his salary, which is ridiculous. He's paid that way because he's one of the top coaches in the game. A down season or two doesn't change that.

I judge next season on improvement. If there isn't significant improvement then I think his seat starts to get warm. But otherwise it's up to Cal.
 

TankedCat

Heisman
Nov 8, 2006
22,792
21,500
0
At the time, K had two titles. So magically that extra title after 15 years afforded him that? 😂
yes it does, Cal had 17 years as a college coach prior to UK.

To date there is nothing that should lead anyone to believe that Cal is working toward another title as a college coach - he's actually moving further away from it. His "rebuild" was more of a slow downward spiral beginning with the 2016 season and then accelerated to light speed going off a cliff last year.

Tubby Smith wasn't afforded this career second chance at Kentucky and he never turned in a season as bad as Cal (amazingly, no coach at UK has), yet Tubby is also a championship winning coach.

No Tubby wasn't fired, but Mitch stepped in and told him to get rid of his staff and essentially let him know he was on a short leash. Cal has 1 NIT with a first round loss and one season where UK wasn't even good enough to be in the NIT. With the highest of highs, Cal is more than capable of the lowest of lows.

Who knows, maybe Mitch stepped in and told Cal to jettison his staff, which would inspire even less confidence.
 
Last edited:

TankedCat

Heisman
Nov 8, 2006
22,792
21,500
0
7 years with no final four is on par with UK's historical average guy. Add to that the fact that there is a lot more parity in college ball right now and it makes sense.
I remember that parity argument being tossed around to justify Tubby's performance
and I remember people saying BCG needed 5 years to rebuild

then Calipari came in , developed a team of studs in 1 year and it was clear there was no college parity for several years when you see UNC, Duke and Kentucky win championships in a 5 or 6 year span.

Parity is an excuse for your coach sucking.
 
Last edited:

irishcat1965

Heisman
Apr 22, 2012
21,799
46,967
113
yes it does, Cal had 17 years as a college coach prior to UK.

To date there is nothing that should lead anyone to believe that Cal is working toward another title as a college coach - he's actually moving further away from it. His "rebuild" was more of a slow downward spiral beginning with the 2016 season and then accelerated to light speed going off a cliff last year.

Tubby Smith wasn't afforded this career second chance at Kentucky and he never turned in a season as bad as Cal (amazingly, no coach at UK has), yet Tubby is also a single championship winning coach.

No Tubby wasn't fired, but Mitch stepped in and told him to get rid of his staff and essentially let him know he was on a short leash. Cal has 1 NIT with a first round loss and one season where UK wasn't even good enough to be in the NIT. With the highest of highs, Cal is more than capable of the lowest of lows.

Who knows, maybe Mitch stepped in and told Cal to jettison his staff, which would inspire even less confidence.
Love how the goal posts change with people like you. First he should not be rebuilding after ten years. Then I show two HOF coaches had to do it later in their careers and then suddenly well that’s ok they have more than one title. 😂

Why don’t you put your money where your piehole is. If UK doesn’t win 20 games or more and go to the ncaa tournament, I will pay you $250. If they do, you owe me $250. Deal?
 
  • Like
Reactions: chroix

kyjeff1

Heisman
Sep 8, 2012
52,112
73,688
113
7 years with no final four is on par with UK's historical average guy. Add to that the fact that there is a lot more parity in college ball right now and it makes sense.
Yeah, but that doesn't make it okay.

Rupp, Hall, RP and Tubby didn’t have the facilities Cal has right now, they also didn't get 9 million a year to keep UK on top.

Also, they never had a transfer portal with immediate eligibility.

You can say Cal is on the same pace as all our previos coaches, well that's great, but he was supposed to be better. He is paid to be better, UK paid for and built facilities to help him and they are paying his assistants more than they did those other coaches.

But also, if you're going to compare wins, you need to compare losses too, so that 9-16 season really stings if you're a Cal excuse maker.

The bottom line is UK didn’t make Cal the highest paid coach in the history of cbb just so he can be Tubby Smith's equal, no, Cal used UCLA to gain a lifetime deal worth $9,000,000.00 a year, when you do that, you better make sure UK stays on top.
 

BassProCat

Heisman
Jan 5, 2017
12,200
28,206
81
Tell me every player that’s going to be on the roster next year and I’ll tell ya my expectations.......

spoiler alert-you don’t have a ****** clue.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KyFaninNC

irishcat1965

Heisman
Apr 22, 2012
21,799
46,967
113
Your coach love exceeds your program love. I find that very telling as to where your priorities are, but you seem happy supporting coach over program, so, to each his own.
Lol. So I don’t agree with you so I’m a fan of Cal and not UK? I have two degrees from UK. I have zero loyalty to Cal. Zero. You make horseshit statements that Cal has lost half the fanbase. Explain to me how you know this and based on what information? I didn’t realize you were so connected sitting in North Carolina. Enlighten me on how you know the pulse of the fan base?
 
  • Like
Reactions: BassProCat

kyjeff1

Heisman
Sep 8, 2012
52,112
73,688
113
Love how the goal posts change with people like you. First he should not be rebuilding after ten years. Then I show two HOF coaches had to do it later in their careers and then suddenly well that’s ok they have more than one title. 😂

Why don’t you put your money where your piehole is. If UK doesn’t win 20 games or more and go to the ncaa tournament, I will pay you $250. If they do, you owe me $250. Deal?
Idk man, if Cal won the title in 2015, giving him 2 titles at UK, I don't think there would be as much anger as there is now. Roy and K have multiple titles, when you do that, the fans lay off quite a bit longer. Heck, K built duke into what it is today, he literally could jump up on the scoreres table and piss all over the student section every game and they would STILL support him.

You have to admit, losing most of your team every year, some to the GL, then continuously coming up short, then watching Isaiah Briscoe type players leave after 2 years is getting really old. The 9-16 debacle caused the volcano to blow.
 

LEDGENDARY

Senior
Apr 27, 2021
288
454
0
So you admit to being a troll. What retread are you? BallerCal?
How so? Just because I find it amusing that Cal's actions impact your life in any way, I must then be a troll? That's some hillbilly logic.
That my friend is called being a cuck
Or it's called telling it like it is.
If he goes winless then he won’t be here for you to support.
You got the money laying around for a buyout?
 

TankedCat

Heisman
Nov 8, 2006
22,792
21,500
0
Love how the goal posts change with people like you. First he should not be rebuilding after ten years. Then I show two HOF coaches had to do it later in their careers and then suddenly well that’s ok they have more than one title. 😂

Why don’t you put your money where your piehole is. If UK doesn’t win 20 games or more and go to the ncaa tournament, I will pay you $250. If they do, you owe me $250. Deal?
talk about moving the goal posts. 20 games? that's the litmus for a return to greatness?

No, put some real faith in your coach. $250 for a final four. Hows your piehole now?
 

irishcat1965

Heisman
Apr 22, 2012
21,799
46,967
113
talk about moving the goal posts. 20 games? that's the litmus for a return to greatness?

No, put some real faith in your coach. $250 for a final four. Hows your piehole now?
He is UK’s coach, not my coach. You have made it clear you don’t think they are are going anywhere this year. However, to make things interesting, I will agree to a final 8 appearance. You game?
 

Cats192

Heisman
Apr 22, 2011
14,924
17,879
93
One of my favorite things about Cal is how crazy he drives some of you. He can go winless next season and I would likely still support him for that reason alone.
LOL. Glad to know how much people on this message board impact your life.

I care about winning. I don't care about how random people on the internet feel or respond to a coach. I just want to win.

If has another sub 20 win season, may not matter how any of us feel.
 

irishcat1965

Heisman
Apr 22, 2012
21,799
46,967
113
Idk man, if Cal won the title in 2015, giving him 2 titles at UK, I don't think there would be as much anger as there is now. Roy and K have multiple titles, when you do that, the fans lay off quite a bit longer. Heck, K built duke into what it is today, he literally could jump up on the scoreres table and piss all over the student section every game and they would STILL support him.

You have to admit, losing most of your team every year, some to the GL, then continuously coming up short, then watching Isaiah Briscoe type players leave after 2 years is getting really old. The 9-16 debacle caused the volcano to blow.
I have made myself clear that this year was unacceptable and frankly, didn’t give a **** if Cal left. However, he isn’t leaving and I happen to think getting Antigua and Chin are really good steps in the right direction. Now whether that helps get a legit point guard for next year, I have no idea. Pressure is on Cal to get that accomplished to have any measurable success next year. I think the rest of the roster will shake out fine if he gets the point guard.
 

TankedCat

Heisman
Nov 8, 2006
22,792
21,500
0
He is UK’s coach, not my coach. You have made it clear you don’t think they are are going anywhere this year. However, to make things interesting, I will agree to a final 8 appearance. You game?
An elite 8?

ok, as a policy I don't bet against UK, but I will take a stand. $250 UK elite 8.

save it for posterity. Its not like I'd be spending it on final four tickets anyways.
 

LEDGENDARY

Senior
Apr 27, 2021
288
454
0
LOL. Glad to know how much people on this message board impact your life.

I care about winning. I don't care about how random people on the internet feel or respond to a coach. I just want to win.

If has another sub 20 win season, may not matter how any of us feel.
Lol, they do? I think you miscomprehended what I wrote. 🤣

I want to win as well, but seeing the misery Cal causes some of you by not pandering to your all's ignorant, outdated beliefs is amusing.

Unless you all have a spare 50 million laying around, Cal will still be here.
 
  • Like
Reactions: chroix
Jan 3, 2003
145,534
15,709
0
No matter what, 30 wins ain't happening next year. Even 25 wins will be tough unless something big happens like add Hardy, IJ returns, or we get 2-3 of top guys who bail out of the draft.
But less than 20 wins (unless Covid limits # of games) is not acceptable after last year. NEED to see significant progress, so an NCAA invite at minimum.
 

irishcat1965

Heisman
Apr 22, 2012
21,799
46,967
113
An elite 8?

ok, as a policy I don't bet against UK, but I will take a stand. $250 UK elite 8.

save it for posterity. Its not like I'd be spending it on final four tickets anyways.
It’s a deal. Elite 8 or better. You have been around here a while so will take you at your word. That last poster I made a bet with on here (that Zion and company wouldn’t make the final four) proved to be a POS and didn’t keep his word to delete his account when they didn’t make the final four. He still posts to this day. People that don’t keep their word are worthless.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KyFaninNC

TankedCat

Heisman
Nov 8, 2006
22,792
21,500
0
It’s a deal. Elite 8 or better. You have been around here a while so will take you at your word. That last poster I made a bet with on here (that Zion and company wouldn’t make the final four) proved to be a POS and didn’t keep his word to delete his account when they didn’t make the final four. He still posts to this day. People that don’t keep their word are worthless.
I'll be around.

I'll also throw in the pandemic caveat. Should college basketball see the need to alter or cancel the NCAA tournament other than the standard approach, I won't expect you to honor the bet.
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Volleyball Kentucky VB closes regular season strong, locks up No. 2 seed in SEC Tournament
  2. 02 KSR Cats in the NBA BBNBA: Anthony Davis is finally healthy and playing like it
  3. 03 KSR Women's Basketball KSR Rapidly Reacts to Clara Strack's career day in another big Kentucky WBB win
  4. 04 KSR Basketball So... Will Wade might have himself a squad at LSU
  5. 05 KSR Women's Basketball FINAL: Clara Strack sets new career high, Kentucky beats Eastern Michigan by 34