I Believe These Players Will Leave

FrankUnderwood

Heisman
May 26, 2017
15,912
27,971
0
As a Cal supporter, no. If we lose 6-9 players off this team and struggle again next year, I will believe the system is broken. Having said that, if we only lose 4 off this team, stay in top 15 next year, win either SEC Regular season or tourney title and go to at least elite 8, I will continue to support Cal and his system.
What would be your reaction to the above scenario?

If the above scenario occurred I would have to at least give some credit where credit is due. Personally I think with this system and Calipari no longer being able to reel in the elites of the elite and very few ever staying past the 2nd year at best will always end in a “pretty good” S16/EE type season and never a true title threat.

But if we were to stay in the top 15, win the SEC title etc obviously I would agree that’s a pretty good season. I would give Cal credit (I’ve lost respect for him but I’m not ridiculous).

That’s the thing though- moving forward are we okay with seasons like the last 6? Early flame outs a couple EE’s and really bad seasons like this one? That’s why I think his system is broken along with his inability to run an actual offense.

If we are going to constantly be a bad- EE type team I’d rather do it with a different coach who recruits to fill needs and builds a team with longevity and cohesiveness as opposed to just casting out a wide net and scooping up a slew of 2nd tier 5 stars, 4 stars and transfers that will inevitably leave early or transfer. It would be more fun to root and cheer on a team we’ve gotten to know with an actual offense get to the S16 as opposed to a brand new team of guys who simply want to leave as quickly as possible get to the S16 ya know?
 
Jan 10, 2015
19,650
33,773
62
Why would he transfer? He plays 30 minutes a game no matter what he does. Why would you leave that?
You never know with these kids today I mean this so called Pandemic, he's from across the country, and we have a record of 7- 13. I mean any of those reasons wouldn't surprise me in the end.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gojvc

jgraf1

All-Conference
Feb 2, 2006
2,060
2,660
113
Right now, the point guard position is again going to be a point of concern. Mintz MUST return, or UK is going to either have persuade Skyy Clark to reclassify or hit a home run with Hickman. If they can get two of Hardy, Sallis, Podziemski, and Keels to sign...backcourt problem solved.

Agree with what you said but specifically this. Even if Askew and Mintz come back and you have Hickman with them, you still need 2 more guards! Cal either needs to get 2 of that group to commit or get 1 and then go get a dynamite scoring guard who can come in right way and play.
 

FrankUnderwood

Heisman
May 26, 2017
15,912
27,971
0


Here are the freshman that should return:

Askew
Ware

I think they can be fine complimentary players, but if you expect them to develop into championship caliber, I think you will be disappointed. There are far too many deficiencies in their games.

If this is writing them off, then so be it.

I really hope I am wrong, BTW.
[/QUOTE]

Isn’t getting them back better then having no players back?

You wouldn’t want a few of these guys back as role players as opposed to having a brand new team or 2nd tier 5 stars and 4 stars and no role players?

We aren’t winning a title next year no matter what. Simply not happening.

But bringing back a few guys would make next year a normal embarrassment as opposed to a paramount embarrassment like this year.

I’d rather win 15-19 games as opposed to winning 10-14 games.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gojvc

jgraf1

All-Conference
Feb 2, 2006
2,060
2,660
113
i posted in another thread but basically next year's team needs to take advantage of the transfer rules AND use the full compiliment of 13 players!

should look something like this:

bigs:
tshiebwe
collins
ware

wings/forwards:
allen
fletcher
brooks
toppin
hopkins


guards:
mintz
askew
hickman

this is assuming sarr, jackson, clarke and boston are gone. that is 11 players. this leaves room for cal to either get 2 more guys possibly 3 if there is another casualty with some combo of the recruits listed here already and a transfer.

with that roster, that is not nearly enough guards. gotta get more.
 

sk73

All-Conference
Feb 16, 2013
3,255
3,354
113
We lose to NBA or other professional league.
Boston
Clarke ----50% chance of coming back. He wont make NBA . The G league maybe.
Jackson
Sarr


Next years team
Askew
Brooks- I think he will be back.
Mintz?
Ware
Fletcher
Toppin
Allen-- Until the last two games he was averaging 16.7 minutes per game. Why leave? If you are as good as many on here say, then stick it out, improve and make a diference. There have been (just as good or better) Kentucky players that did just that. Hawkins and Willis for instance.
Oscar
Collins
Hopkins
Hickman
Another recruit or two.

:
 
  • Like
Reactions: FtWorthCat

bucsrule8872

Heisman
May 30, 2005
24,397
29,352
0
Right now, I think we lose Jackson, Boston, Clarke, and Sarr.

We return:

Mintz- finishes his degree.
Brooks
Toppin
Allen- decides to stick it out, he’s a Kentucky boy.
Askew
Ware
Fletcher- if he hasn’t already left, why would he leave?

Starters

G Askew
G Mintz
F Brooks
F Collins
F Tshiebwe

Bench

G Hickman
G Allen
F Fletcher
F Hopkins
F Toppin
F Ware
 

G-PIP

All-American
Mar 14, 2014
5,286
5,964
0
If that is close to our actual roster do you ( or others ) see that team as a threat to hang # 9 ? or reach a FF ? I dont . JMHO .
A threat, yes. A favorite, no.

But I think it's the kind of roster UK needs and is constructed to build upon going forward - one where you add a piece or two each season to improve the whole, but don't try to replace the entire offensive output every year with incoming freshmen.

In my opinion, to have a realistic shot, the transfer 2G in my scenario needs to be a battle-tested really good shooter who can get his shot off quickly. Maybe Mintz can be that, but I think with the PGs still being pretty green you probably need a little more high-powered offense from your starting 2G. Also, Allen probably has to come along a little quicker than maybe is fair to expect. But, again, if you're going to construct a roster differently than we have in the past, there is going to be a transition period.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: ManitouDan

ManitouDan_anon

Heisman
Dec 7, 2006
20,073
32,434
0
A threat, yes. A favorite, no.

But I think it's the kind of roster UK needs and is constructed to build upon going forward - one where you add a piece or two each season to improve the whole, but don't try to replace the entire offensive output every year with incoming freshmen.

In my opinion, to have a realistic shot, the transfer 2G in my scenario needs to be a battle-tested really good shooter who can get his shot off quickly. Maybe Mintz can be that, but I think with the PGs still being pretty green you probably need a little more high-powered offense from your starting 2G. Also, Allen probably has to come along a little quicker than maybe is fair to expect. But, again, if you're going to construct a roster differently than we have in the past, their is going to be a transition period.


I cant see enough talent for a John Cal coached team to reach the desired goal of UK hoops , be seriously in the mix to win a title. Cal needs far superior talent to win big . That roster wouldnt have it IMO . Thanks for giving a level headed response with real dialog . Appreciated .
 
  • Like
Reactions: G-PIP

ManitouDan_anon

Heisman
Dec 7, 2006
20,073
32,434
0
Right now, I think we lose Jackson, Boston, Clarke, and Sarr.

We return:

Mintz- finishes his degree.
Brooks
Toppin
Allen- decides to stick it out, he’s a Kentucky boy.
Askew
Ware
Fletcher- if he hasn’t already left, why would he leave?

Starters

G Askew
G Mintz
F Brooks
F Collins
F Tshiebwe

Bench

G Hickman
G Allen
F Fletcher
F Hopkins
F Toppin
F Ware


Thought thought of Askew and Mintz starting again wants me want to puke . I like them , they play hard , but neither is good enough to lead us to where we need to be .. FF . Esp Askew . Just not enough God gifted talent . Mintz is OK . But as a starting 2 guard ? IDK about that .
 

RunninRichie

Heisman
Sep 5, 2019
30,650
74,133
113
Thought thought of Askew and Mintz starting again wants me want to puke . I like them , they play hard , but neither is good enough to lead us to where we need to be .. FF . Esp Askew . Just not enough God gifted talent . Mintz is OK . But as a starting 2 guard ? IDK about that .
Coulda had Jalen Green man!
 

G-PIP

All-American
Mar 14, 2014
5,286
5,964
0
Right now, I think we lose Jackson, Boston, Clarke, and Sarr.

We return:

Mintz- finishes his degree.
Brooks
Toppin
Allen- decides to stick it out, he’s a Kentucky boy.
Askew
Ware
Fletcher- if he hasn’t already left, why would he leave?

Starters

G Askew
G Mintz
F Brooks
F Collins
F Tshiebwe

Bench

G Hickman
G Allen
F Fletcher
F Hopkins
F Toppin
F Ware
I can easily see you being right about that starting lineup and roster. But, good god I think that forecasts as a bad offensive lineup, and team actually. Good players, just not the right pieces together. We would again be playing with a horribly unbalanced roster. If Allen could hold down the starting SF spot and slide Brooks to the PF spot (I would never want him playing SF on my team) then maybe it's a competitive team.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RunninRichie

*CatinIL*

Heisman
Jan 2, 2003
24,651
40,237
113
I’ll be a little more optimistic.

Jackson - NBA
Boston - NBA
Clarke - NBA
Saar - D/G League/Overseas
Mintz - Return
Brooks - Return
Allen - Transfer
Ware - Return
Fletcher - Transfer
I would agree with this.
Regarding Askew, he's already getting a boatload of PT at UK already. Despite UK's sucky record this season, they still get National coverage every game...if you factor in that most people have DTV/Cable/Internet TV. I don't see him going anywhere.
 

Montana81

Heisman
Aug 12, 2004
82,727
29,410
113
I don’t think Ware is going anywhere. Supposedly him and his people are happy with the current path hes on.

they knew he’d need time I guess. How about that.

the rest of them...yeah I wouldn’t be surprised.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RunninRichie

kyjeff1

Heisman
Sep 8, 2012
52,125
73,712
113
He took a small step back last night, but I think he's been on a slightly upward trajectory over the last 3/4 games.
He's a 4 year player that is being thrown to the wolves in year 1 and he happens to play the one position that has the most pressure and controls the game.

He's the type of player that blossoms in year 3 and I'm concerned that Cal doesn’t have a better option at pg yet for next year.

He has said many times this year that he doesn't have a guy that can go by defenders. That's been one of his many excuses, well, Askew won't be able to get by anyone next year either. If he doesn't fix that issue, we're sweet 16 good at best.
 
  • Like
Reactions: FtWorthCat

kyjeff1

Heisman
Sep 8, 2012
52,125
73,712
113
Askew is getting 90% of the point guard time at a blue blood school and at this point in time, Cal has not recruited anyone better, so I'm not sure why Askew would leave.
Good point on the Ware situation. Hopefully he stays though.
Hickman will at least challenge him for minutes and I think either Clark or another PG comes in as well, like I said, it’ll be three PG’s on the roster like Quade, Hagans and Quick, if Askew stays. I think he will and I honestly want him too, just hope he’s ok playing a backup role, Quade clearly was not.
[/QUOTE]
We need to learn our lesson here. Skyy Clark is a junior in hs and Hickman is a 4* IIRC. I just don't see it. Neither one will be good enough to run this team. Neither is transcendent and that's what it takes to be successful in this system when you are that young.

Having 3 point guards doesn’t do you any good if none of them can beat their man off the bounce.
 
Oct 9, 2015
14,287
38,081
78
Boston, Clarke, Jackson - NBA
Sarr - Overseas
Mintz - return
Brooks - return
Allen - return
Ware - return
Fletcher - transfer
Toppin - return
Askew - return

add the new guys
Add another unknown, maybe two (freshmen, transfers, grad transfer)

this is my hope.
 
Mar 19, 2006
1,138
771
113
Here are the freshman that should return:

Askew
Ware

I think they can be fine complimentary players, but if you expect them to develop into championship caliber, I think you will be disappointed. There are far too many deficiencies in their games.

If this is writing them off, then so be it.

I really hope I am wrong, BTW.

Isn’t getting them back better then having no players back?

You wouldn’t want a few of these guys back as role players as opposed to having a brand new team or 2nd tier 5 stars and 4 stars and no role players?

We aren’t winning a title next year no matter what. Simply not happening.

But bringing back a few guys would make next year a normal embarrassment as opposed to a paramount embarrassment like this year.

I’d rather win 15-19 games as opposed to winning 10-14 games.
[/QUOTE]

15-19 wins is not going to be enough, by UK's standards.

I guess I am still optimistic and am not going to predict next year's results on the outcome of this anomalous. season.

I believe UK will be back in the national conversation next year.

Its OK to disagree.
 

mustnotsleepnow

All-Conference
May 18, 2011
1,923
1,328
57
Honestly, I think only Ware, Toppin and Askew return.

I'd be thrilled if we got those three along with Brooks, Mintz and Allen but I've learned not to get my hopes up.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KyFaninNC
Mar 13, 2004
14,745
12,925
0
I highly doubt Fletcher came back to sit half a semester when he easily could have left already. So it seems logical he would stick it out.

This is why I'm not with the "Fletcher definitely leaves" crowd. His suspension came before Christmas, he could have just left the team and transferred somewhere for 2nd semester, and been eligible for 2nd semester next year. Why come back only to leave and then sit a year?
 

ManitouDan_anon

Heisman
Dec 7, 2006
20,073
32,434
0
I remember hearing the same things coming into the season.

Based on what? A 10 point outburst at Florida last year?

I don't see it.

He doesn't start on the worst team in UK history. He is 6th in minutes per game, and that is only because Jackson can't stay out of foul trouble.

He was absolutely owned by Disu last night and has shown little development this season. He is taking more three's, but at at 22.7% clip.

If you take away the Tennessee game he is averaging 8.6 ppg, or just over 1 ppg more than Askew.

His rebound rate per minute is on pace with Ware. You are pretty much looking at a glorified EJ Montgomery, right now.

He could be all SEC next year....but the trajectory is not close (yet).

Brooks drives me nuts .. sometimes he mentally there , sometimes acts checked out . Not a guy you can rely on IMO . I think he tries to leave if anyone will pay him a few grand to play .
 

FrankUnderwood

Heisman
May 26, 2017
15,912
27,971
0
Possibly for sure

You can always tell a player has improved... not by success on the court, or less turnovers, or more points, or running plays and getting guys the ball... or finding the open man and setting the offense up but by his body language!

Im willing to bet his body language is on point next game. Then the next game his body language will be even more on point.

I know I know- you’ll comment agreeing as a way to skirt the absurdity of your initial comment but it is what it is.
 

FtWorthCat

All-Conference
Aug 21, 2001
6,721
4,532
0
Gone: Sarr/Boston/Clarke/Jackson/Brooks

But, obviously I would love to have any of them back.

For the rest, my thoughts are:

Allen-he is essentially a freshman (because this year doesn't count) playing meaningful minutes at UK, his dream school. Plus he almost single handedly ended UK's longest losing streak in like, forever. In short, he should be proud of what he has accomplished in his first year of actually playing at UK, and be looking to build on that by improving his game, not by looking for a place to run.

Fletcher-Probably gone, but I would love to have him and Oscar next year playing together. That's a lot of beef. I like his body language the last few games on the bench, so I haven't given up on him and Cal working things out and being able to coexist moving forward. I think he has a ton of talent, and he's going to showcase it somewhere next season, might as well be at UK.

Mintz-If he is going to be on campus getting a graduate degree, he might as well play and be the team leader of our resurgence, and experience UK Basketball when things are going good, as they surely will be next year.

Toppin-We need more Toppins. This is the kind of player I want more of. He listens to Cal, and his game is improving, and we all get to witness the improvement. That's what makes college basketball fun to watch, seeing the team and players improve.

Askew-Unless he transfers back west, I expect him to be here. Cal asked more of him this season, that he had the capability of providing. That is on Cal.

Ware-see Toppin. We've watched his game come quite a way this year. He shouldn't have had to play as many minutes as he did early, but again that is on Cal. I like his demeanor, effort, etc., and I would love to have a big send off for him and Allen three years from now on Senior Night.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: G-PIP

bucsrule8872

Heisman
May 30, 2005
24,397
29,352
0
If you’re right I guess we’re going be “grinding it out” a lot next season.
Thought thought of Askew and Mintz starting again wants me want to puke . I like them , they play hard , but neither is good enough to lead us to where we need to be .. FF . Esp Askew . Just not enough God gifted talent . Mintz is OK . But as a starting 2 guard ? IDK about that .
I can easily see you being right about that starting lineup and roster. But, good god I think that forecasts as a bad offensive lineup, and team actually. Good players, just not the right pieces together. We would again be playing with a horribly unbalanced roster. If Allen could hold down the starting SF spot and slide Brooks to the PF spot (I would never want him playing SF on my team) then maybe it's a competitive team.

That lineup will be better than this year’s with several guys returning to the program.

Shooting will be an issue with that lineup, but that’s normal for Cal.

I think this team will be a “back to normal” lineup. I’m thinking a 2016 or 2018 type season. If Tshiebwe plays up to his potential, then maybe a 2017 or 2019 type season.
 

cats#1again

All-Conference
Nov 27, 2011
8,011
4,587
0
You can always tell a player has improved... not by success on the court, or less turnovers, or more points, or running plays and getting guys the ball... or finding the open man and setting the offense up but by his body language!

Im willing to bet his body language is on point next game. Then the next game his body language will be even more on point.

I know I know- you’ll comment agreeing as a way to skirt the absurdity of your initial comment but it is what it is.
No, you can tell alot about a player by watching his confidence grow.
I knew last year IQ was one game away from being a star at the first of the season.
He didn't show any of it until Jan.
That should tell you that you're incorrect but being the stubborn guy you are, you will continue to disagree
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Football Playoff Viewing Guide: What games Kentucky fans need to follow in Week 11
  2. 02 KSR Basketball Kentucky vs. Indiana: Preview, Odds & How to Watch
  3. 03 KSR Football Chops Comes Home: The Man Behind the Meme
  4. 04 KSR Basketball Sources Say goes LIVE to talk Kentucky vs. Indiana and the latest in recruiting
  5. 05 KSR Football SEC Availability Report: What to know about Thursday's update