Why is our fanbase so demonstrably bad?

Status
Not open for further replies.

kired

All-Conference
Aug 22, 2008
7,192
2,655
113
Pockets of fans, usually passionate students, were repeatedly shouted down by graying, often obese attendees behind them

I call BS... does this really happen that often? I would guess I've been to almost 70 games since I started at MSU in 2001. Spent three years in the student section (01-03), 04 was split between student & west side, season tickets in section G in 2005, bounced all around in 06-09, then season tickets in section F the last three years (different rows).

I've been to all four bowl games in that time, and I've been to multiple road games sitting in the MSU section. I can only remember 1 time, happened in either 06, 07, or 08... when someone asked me to sit down. And I've only seen it happen to others a few times - normally its been one of those "stand for 3.5 hours straight" kind of guys.

I hear folks grumble about people standing from time to time... but I very rarely see anyone ask another MSU fan to sit down.
 

RocketDawg

All-Conference
Oct 21, 2011
20,551
3,161
113
I don't think I've ever actually heard anybody tell someone else to sit down. I've heard a bit of grumbling, like you said, but never someone yelling it out. I certainly don't mind people jumping up and down with the excitement of the game. Don't want 'em standing the entire time like the do in the student section. I'm in the CL and most people there are 30 and up (and a lot of small kids), so their continuous standing years are over anyway. I've heard a few cowbell complaints though ... the answer to that is ear plugs.
 

RocketDawg

All-Conference
Oct 21, 2011
20,551
3,161
113
I have to agree with you

If you gotta stand the entire time, go join the students or stand on the ramp winders. A lot do that. Could be so they can smoke during the game.
 

RocketDawg

All-Conference
Oct 21, 2011
20,551
3,161
113
I've said it elsewhere, but our fan base is the same as it is at any other school and all pro sports in the entire country ... it's mostly ... and that would be in the mid to up 90% ... white. Not sure why, but that's the way it is everywhere.
 

GetHype

Redshirt
Feb 10, 2013
29
0
0
Our fan base sucks so bad that we have one if the most electric home field environments in NCAA football.
I've been to games at Bryant-Denny and Death Valley. Makes us look like Texas middle school team fans. It's not just the numbers, because I know we can't compete there. The unbridled passion from large pockets of fans even when the team is down big is universal to the great fanbases. Ours can't even cheer when it's close.
 

GetHype

Redshirt
Feb 10, 2013
29
0
0
fans who are not you, you could give us a rundown of what your characteristics are so that we can have some comparison.

Are you....

Skinny, full of hair product, trendy dressed, stubbly, and half drunk? Are these what make up a better fan? Also, did you use mom and dad's money to buy a ticket and spend a night in a cheap hotel with your hot girlfriend while the fat blue haired 60 year old parents paid the Bulldog Club bill so you could have half decent seats?




Graduated MSU years ago, TSUN for law school, showed up to V-H decked out both years and made as many home games as I could. It's one thing to sit in the upper deck and stay sitting, but when you're anywhere near the middle or lower sections and you're actively deriding fans actually trying to make a difference, you are literally (and I can't stress that enough) sabotaging our team. Did you see the SF@SEA game this year? The crowd noise turned what might have been a close game into an absolute rout. It's not about getting drunk and rowdy--though I have big respect for those who do as long as they aren't actively harassing people and channeling their energy toward the field. We had maybe five instances, usually 3rd and 1-5 deep in our territory, where everyone finally decides to stand and cheer and I know we got at least one false start. Possibly two, but I can't be sure off-hand. If we had been giving it our all the entire game, the result may have been a much better one for everyone there.

So yeah, maybe I am a little ageist against those who willingly choose to sit with passionate fans and deride their attempts to help the team instead of staying silent but supportive or, god forbid, moving to the deserted upper rows where you can fall asleep at halftime and wake up midway through the fourth quarter. You seem to be mistaking your place as a State fan at a football game. It's not about you. It's not about your experience, how much fun you had, whether a drunken frat boy accidentally whacked you in the head once after a big third down stop and you pouted for the rest of the game. It's about them. The players. The student-athletes who basically live with two jobs, getting paid nothing but living expenses, in a truly unselfish tribute to tradition and the school. So yeah, maybe I don't get mad at the row of freshmen with fake IDs who stand up and belt out an off-key rendition of Hail State during a replay challenge. That's because I know at least they get it more than you do. They might be drunken, stupid, ignorant 18 year olds, but they're willing to embarrass themselves a little to express pride for their university. I'd rather have one row of those than a hundred rows of you.
 

GetHype

Redshirt
Feb 10, 2013
29
0
0
Here we go with another "our fans suck" post. Yep our fans do suck - beginning with YOU.
No, many of our fans are great. I love Mississippi State fans and, god bless me, I love the Junction more than I love the Grove. I had three years with each and I know why a lot of people obviously prefer the latter, but the Junction has a feeling of brotherhood/sisterhood and sincerity that the Grove lacks. Check the wording of the topic carefully. I didn't say our fans were bad. I said our fanbase was bad. Those shouting down people trying to generate penalties on defense should have in turn been drowned out by the surrounding fans. I've absolutely seen that happen at other games, including SEC teams.
 

RocketDawg

All-Conference
Oct 21, 2011
20,551
3,161
113
Have to disagree with you there. Never been to LSU, but I think we compete very well in enthusiasm with Alabama. I don't recall ever being to Bryant Denny and not being able to talk to the person next to me; not so in Davis Wade. We are painfully loud at times.
 

GetHype

Redshirt
Feb 10, 2013
29
0
0
I don't think I've ever actually heard anybody tell someone else to sit down. I've heard a bit of grumbling, like you said, but never someone yelling it out. I certainly don't mind people jumping up and down with the excitement of the game. Don't want 'em standing the entire time like the do in the student section. I'm in the CL and most people there are 30 and up (and a lot of small kids), so their continuous standing years are over anyway. I've heard a few cowbell complaints though ... the answer to that is ear plugs.
This was my reaction. Like I said, I was totally floored. I've got a lot of friends in a lot of places around the world through various internship programs, and in all the games I've attended I've never seen anything like it.

Hell, I went to a ULLaf game years ago, not long after they were USL (read: very bad), where there were picnickers sitting on a knoll near the game. On a big third down, a bunch of people stood up and went bananas. Know what the grandmothers and grandfathers did in response? Slapped on a toothy Cajun grin (or, in some cases, gummy!) and clapped and gave their quiet, but heartfelt bursts of support in appreciation of the younger, more spry fans who were pulling extra weight.

So yeah, maybe you're old. Maybe you can't stand and ring and yell for four straight quarters. That doesn't mean you should be barred from attending games. That means you leave the noisemaking and excitement to the new generation instead of torpedoing the crowd's efforts to create a home team advantage. Maybe you suffer a little more from the noise, or some piss drunk sorority girl nails you with a whiskey coke after a touchdown. I'll take all that and more for a couple games turned from Ls into Ws by critical forced-error penalties.
 

RocketDawg

All-Conference
Oct 21, 2011
20,551
3,161
113
Went to the Florida game that we won in Gainesville a couple years ago and was seated right next to their student section. Had a drunk Florida coed want to sit in my lap. I didn't complain ....

Their student section seemed a lot more subdued than ours. Might have been the sub-par season they were having. Most didn't even seem interested in the game.
 

GetHype

Redshirt
Feb 10, 2013
29
0
0
I don't mind if someone stands. I'm up and down all game long. It's the jackass that is the only one in his section that stands the entire game that pisses me off. Not to yell or make noise, but to stand there with his arms folded on his stomach the whole game. What does that prove other than being an attention *****?
You know, I'll hesitantly agree with you, but only because he's obviously just pouting. If a couple brothers who love their State and want to grind hard for their State all game want to stand for every play, yell and ring on every defensive play, and you want them to stop, you are the problem.

You are selfish. The student-athletes aren't playing for you. They're playing for a century of tradition and pride that those guys get and you, while you may have had once, may not ever have again. Because your comfort, your little needs are not why these boys work their asses off four, five and sometimes six years. Maybe they get some personal glory, and a precious few move on for us to cheer on in the NFL for another decade, but for most of them they play to represent something greater than themselves, something embodied by State and the fanbase. If you want to sit in the upper decks and enjoy the game, fine. No one wants to set an age limit. But if we want to win enough to stand and fight in our own little way, in arms with our brothers on the field, and you want to make that stop, you already missed the point.
 

GetHype

Redshirt
Feb 10, 2013
29
0
0
I can't reply in earnest until I understand your user name. Should it have been GetHyped? I know that some people speak it as gethype, and leave the d off, but spoken language can afford more leniency than written language. I'm worried that you might not have even realized that you needed a "d" on the end. Well, that would just throw into question the entire legitimacy of your post. How do I really even know what you meant? There could be extra or missing consonants or vowels all over the place! For all I know, you intended to be positive about our third bowl in a row and just goofed it up. Until I know that you are serious about your English language skills, I can't be for sure what to make of your post. Until you get a grasp on it, I'd suggest not posting again...
This has to be the microcosm of the topic, thank you sir! Refusing to acknowledge a different point of view because you missed the development of an entire culture alongside yours would be symptomatic of some of the behavior I'm talking about, definitely. Sometimes people like to spell what they say like they say it, as a vehicle of expression, and as a message of individuality against those who would judge on external appearance, rather than the content of one's character.

Alternatively, if Dr. King won't satisfy you, it can be read as "to acquire hype" in "the King's English," which the Bulldogs certainly did leading up to the Alabama game! Hopefully, we'll "Get Hype" in spades before our next meeting with the Tide.
 

thekimmer

All-Conference
Aug 30, 2012
8,957
3,187
113
Which came first? The chicken or the egg?.....

I've been to games at Bryant-Denny and Death Valley. Makes us look like Texas middle school team fans. It's not just the numbers, because I know we can't compete there. The unbridled passion from large pockets of fans even when the team is down big is universal to the great fanbases. Ours can't even cheer when it's close.

I've never been to either place but, are the fans at BDS and DV filled with unbridled passion even when down big because the team's winning history has made them that way or was it the unbridled passion of the fans that molded the program into a winner?

I submit that the team is what leads the way for the fans. My evidence? Exhibit A: If the two aforementioned fanbases are just naturally filled with passion why would it not extend to sports that they are not so good at? Coleman and the PMC are pretty run of the mill places when the teams suck. Exhibit B: Alex Box (a mississippian) Stadium is a mecca for baseball but it did not become that way until AFTER bertman put a consistently elite team on the field. Prior to bertman you could have fired a shotgun in the bleachers on an SEC weekend and likely never hurt a soul among that passion filled fanbase. Exhibit C; People are people. Fans from alabama or louisiana aren't just simply more motivated. If our history was like their history we would be just a passion filled. For years we had a passion filled baseball fan base. Why? One word. Success. The same thing will happen in FB based on success. I personally think we have a pretty good fanbase for football. Much better than our history would warrant but that's just my opinion.
 

GetHype

Redshirt
Feb 10, 2013
29
0
0
Went to the Florida game that we won in Gainesville a couple years ago and was seated right next to their student section. Had a drunk Florida coed want to sit in my lap. I didn't complain ....

Their student section seemed a lot more subdued than ours. Might have been the sub-par season they were having. Most didn't even seem interested in the game.
I hope we never become that! I love State, but I'm also proud to say I'm a native Louisianan myself and I've been to multiple home games of all the current D1 schools. Even when they were bad, LSU had Death Valley borderline painful to exist in every SEC or major cross-conference game. As a result, they've been more successful over time and I'm confident it has to do with the culture cultivated by a rowdy, tough to play fanbase for home games and even neutral site games. I'm excited for the additions to Davis-Wade and the concentration of sound and shaking they'll bring. It'll make opposing QBs slough through a nightmare to get plays called at the line when the fans "get hyped" and I love the sound of that (no pun intended). I'll be bringing my full voice, cowbell, and a mean disposition to cheer on our boys in Houston some months from now and it would make my year to have Reliant Stadium sounding like a home game.

On an unrelated note, I think many fans misunderstand the acoustics behind cowbells versus yelling. Always do both, but if you have to pick one, go with yelling! It's more disruptive for the opposing QB.
 
Last edited:

DerHntr

All-Conference
Sep 18, 2007
16,209
3,714
113
Holy **** fella. Can you not understand that he was screwing with you?
 

GetHype

Redshirt
Feb 10, 2013
29
0
0
Threads like this are exactly why no new posters could sign up during recruiting season. Count yourself among those awful fans buddy.

Exactly who the 17 do you think gives most of the money to build basketball practice facilities, additions to Davis Wade, and the new football facility? I will answer it for you..... It is those same old fat lazy fans that worked their asses off their whole lives and watched more ****** football than you can ever imagine yet still helped us set a school record for sell outs..

My advice to you is to have a tall glass of STFU and just enjoy the game next time.
This is such a fascinating point of view, because I guess I wasn't aware of such a large blind spot in the eyes of fans like yourself. These fans you're crying about are doing exactly what you're doing: trying to help our team win in the best way they can. Your voice might not last the first half, nor your legs, but I don't think a single person would discount your contribution to the team. On the other hand, when fans without large deposits of expendable money, but big heart and love for their State, want to help the team in the only way they can, the response is derision and dismissal. Might as well set out the welcoming mat for the opposing quarterback while you're at it. Don't worry about the money this time, we'll cover this one.
 

GetHype

Redshirt
Feb 10, 2013
29
0
0
For that matter why do you choose to so flippantly alienate a significant part of the the fanbase like this? 'Old/graying' bad. Young good. Just remember this buddy. I know you don't believe it right now but unless you die young you WILL get 'old' (I'm guessing that's around 40 to you) one day and sooner than you think.
Because I've never, ever seen a student trying to shut down cheering fans. I've seen them get depressed, maybe cool down once the game is out of hand, but I can't help but smile when we're down 3+ scores and whole rows are still trying to rally the crowd, turn the tide (if you will). Again, this shows a fundamental disconnect between the two groups I'm talking about. One distinctly seems to think that football games are held for their amusement, or even in part to honor their contribution to the team's success. How narcissistic! The younger generations definitely get it. It's about the student-athletes, the tradition, the school, and supporting those who would uphold them as brothers-in-arms. No one gets a brick for being the tipping voice that caused the left tackle to start and forced the offense to pass instead of run on 4th down, falling incomplete as time expired. No one ever asked for one. An unearned sense of entitlement is a big part of the problem here, it looks like.
 

futaba.79

Redshirt
Jun 4, 2007
2,296
0
0
this can't be real..........

somebody please see through this idiocy and treat it accordingly.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White Football Jeff Lebby fires assistants Phil Loadholt and Cliff Odom after Auburn loss
  2. 02 Maroon and White Mississippi State PFF Grades from 41-9 loss to Auburn
  3. 03 Maroon and White Football Lopsided analytics illustrate Mississippi State's collapse against Auburn
  4. 04 Maroon and White Football "Not good enough": Jeff Lebby answers questions of performance and job security following blowout loss to Auburn
  5. 05 Maroon and White Football Rapid Recap: Auburn 41-9 Mississippi State