Pro/rel will never happen in this country. EVER.
One of the reasons Eric Wynalda is PNG is his detailed discussions publicly about how a group of NFL owners, some in the MLS, some out of the league, back in the early 2000s when MLS was days from bankruptcy, structured investments with MLS, individual clubs, their stadium authorities, broadcasters, how the commissioner of MLS is compensated and controlled, etc to always control where clubs in the top division will be located and always in NFL cities with owners approved by MLS and therefore the interests of the NFL. As a result, the franchise fee went from $10 million to $500 million in less than 20 years. There is now a critical mass of heavily invested clubs who will always play each other and always have the cash reserves to acquire talent superior to any fledgling league that might aspire to challenge them. Indeed, they have the cash to buy any players any other league might sign before such a league could gain traction to challenge. And those clubs are controlled by, directly or indirectly, NFL properties.
Listen closely when Garber speaks. He’s openly stated his dream job is being commissioner of the NFL. He used to work for them. Listen to his very careful words about expansion, especially why Saint Louis and San Diego, and where they are going in the future.
As for Tulsa and MLS, the USFL folding here doomed any MLS talk 10 years later and the current structure of league franchise agreements would make a man a fool to put money into it. Not only must the league approve locations and they have openly stated the league isn’t interested in expanding to any city without a current or past NFL team, the agreements now specifically state that the league can move the franchise if they want to at any time and so can the owners, but only under certain league agreed circumstances. They aren’t parking clubs in second tier NHL cities like Columbus anymore. OKC could have a soccer following the size of Saint Louis and not get a club. Prestige and branding is everything now.
People can criticize Lalas all they want, but he got that part absolutely right as the GM of the Galaxy. People remember him as a player, but he was a pretty sophisticated league official and club employee before going into TV. He believes Men’s soccer will fold as much as women’s soccer in this country until small slivers of the world market care about US soccer. and you do that by marketing the recognition of the cities abroad. Nobody in Paris knows where Tulsa is. Nobody in NYC wants to be a fan of a club or league that plays games in front of 10,000 in the middle of the country in a state most people view as backward. So nobody wants to invest in a set up like that.
And the monarchy insisting there be pro/rel in England isn’t just another thread, it’s a book.