Poll: college baseball or MLB?

Do you prefer college baseball or MLB?

  • College baseball

  • MLB


Results are only viewable after voting.

will110

Joined Aug 17, 2018
Jan 20, 2022
14,700
38,123
113
Out of curiosity, with Gamecock baseball getting cranked up tomorrow, does the board prefer MLB or college baseball? This is a general interest poll about the two sports broadly, not about Gamecock baseball or your favorite MLB team specifically. Would you prefer to sit down and watch a random (good) college baseball game or a random MLB game?
 

Sleepyhead

Junior
Jul 23, 2023
446
347
63
I like both but don’t follow very closely. There’s just something laid back about watching an MLB game. I wish they’d play less games to make the games mean more and generate some interest.
 

atl-cock

All-Conference
Jan 18, 2022
3,050
1,583
113
I like both but don’t follow very closely. There’s just something laid back about watching an MLB game. I wish they’d play less games to make the games mean more and generate some interest.
I wish Fox would turn down the drama and make it more laid back as you suggested.
 

will110

Joined Aug 17, 2018
Jan 20, 2022
14,700
38,123
113
I like both but don’t follow very closely. There’s just something laid back about watching an MLB game. I wish they’d play less games to make the games mean more and generate some interest.
How many times does the division race come down to the last couple games of the season? Every game is meaningful (unless you're a Rockies or Nats fan).

That's kinda the point of baseball, though. You're supposed to be able to relax and enjoy the game. It's America's pastime!
 

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
18,971
15,929
113
I like both but don’t follow very closely. There’s just something laid back about watching an MLB game. I wish they’d play less games to make the games mean more and generate some interest.

How many times does the division race come down to the last couple games of the season? Every game is meaningful (unless you're a Rockies or Nats fan).

That's kinda the point of baseball, though. You're supposed to be able to relax and enjoy the game. It's America's pastime!

Yeah, baseball's it's own thing. Unfortunately, it runs counter to societal norms these days. Slowing down to take in a game isn't what people want. And baseball is certainly more cerebral, which runs counter to society. I saw a great clip of Greg Maddux and his catcher at the time talking about how they were facing the Astros and Bagwell (I think) was up to the plate. The game was such that Maddux allowed a meaningless homer to Bagwell. His catcher was annoyed, but Maddux told him "they're a good team, so we'll probably face them in the playoffs. He'll remember that pitch he homered off." Sure enough, a few months later, they are playing the Astros and Bagwell is up with runners on. Maddux used the pitch sequence from the previous game to strike Bagwell out on 3 pitches. His catcher said as they were walking back to the dugout "do you remember that pitch?" He did not and Maddux reminded him of the game in the regular season when Bagwell homered. Catcher just shook his head.

I like the long schedule in baseball. During most of the regular season, no game feels like the entire season hangs in the balance. So it's easier to relax. But it's still neat, as noted above, that even after 162 games, you can come down the final week of the season with divisions still in doubt. The long season also sorts out the real deals from the wannabes. You might play scorching hot for a week or two or even a month, but can you sustain it? Some hitters have put up HOF worthy stats before the All Star break but look like a no-name journeyman after the break.
 

Piscis

All-Conference
Nov 30, 2001
24,738
2,273
113
I like both fairly equally but give college the nod by a slight margin. I like the passion of the players and the rivalries in the college game. MLB players are so good, watching games can be like watching a machine run and the players are usually simply doing a job at a very high level.
 
  • Like
Reactions: o_Bushmaster