The top 7 teams on Talia's list return a lot of talent and/or add a bunch of proven transfer stars.
But starting at her #8 Tennessee and going down, there is a bunch of roster turnover, so it is really hard to rank teams this year.
UNC and NCSU both lost 3 of their 4 best players. This is pretty on par for the rest of the top 25 beneath them.
- UNC returns Kelly and Nivar which is pretty similar to NCSU's Zoe Brooks and Tilda Trygger in terms of returning proven talent.
- NCSU probably brought in the best transfer in Pierre, though Harris and Aarnisalo are a great duo collectively.
- Both teams will be relying on young role players to step up into bigger roles: Thomas, Toomey, Grant and Aarnisalo for UNC. Zamareya Jones, Devyn Quigley, Lorena Awou and Qadence Samuels for NCSU.
- To me the difference between the teams is the freshman classes Brooks (#22) and Henderson (#24) are McD A-A level players for UNC. UNC also has middle 4 star level players Quieroz (#77) and Astakhova (International players are not ranked). Whereas NCSU has two middle 4-star level players Adelaide Jernigan (#58) and Ky'She Lunan (#60).
So in fielding a top 5 group of starters there is not much advantage for either team. But UNC (in my opinion) wins on depth and just the number of players with a high ceiling who may prove to be stars.
But I don't have much issue with the rankings. Frankly I am concerned about our unproven ability to play top notch defense, which we have hung our hat on in the Banghart era. But if we do, the sky is the limit.