Now that it's over grade Howland year 1

Seinfeld

All-American
Nov 30, 2006
11,776
8,248
113
C. I'm encouraged by the progress the team made throughout the season, but I never in a million years thought that we'd miss the NIT by taking last year's team and adding a McD's all American.

No reason to be too hard on the man because this is not a roster he put together, and he's got the #7 dang class in the country coming in, but it's impossible to say that this season was not a disappointment
 

hailstate19

Redshirt
Nov 7, 2015
1,190
41
48
Next year the team will be filled with all Howland recruits except IJ ready. Next year will be the true test.

Hopefully this year will be the last time we as a fan base will have to say next year.
 

grimedawg1

Freshman
Aug 25, 2012
339
77
28
Howland did a really good job

Howland did really well. I am not sure about how much the coaches can work with these guys in the offseason because I don't know the rules. But, I assume coaches can't be with them full time. Howland made comments on just how bad offensively our team was. There was a very long way to go for them offensively in the offseason. Offseason with limited contact with coaches and pre-season practice is just not enough for a team to learn how to play offensive basketball.

Roc Johnson and Black were not back. We started the season with Gavin as the one and only big that could play. And, if you remember, Ray would take Gavin out of games in prior years because he was completely helpless in pick and roll defense. He just could not defend it effectively. These things hurt our defense and rebounding and resulted in the tinkering with the D at the beginning of the year. I think Howland just kept plugging away with the teaching and the team improved on D. But, size was a major problem throughout the year.

Newman and Holman both started out with injuries. No one knew Q would be as good as he was. Howland figured out that Q could be pretty effective just about anywhere in the 2-4 spots. Our young players seemed to get better over the year.

The thing you want to see with coaching is continued improvement. The comparison to what Ray would have done is pretty useless because the schedule was different from this year to last year with different players. This team was generally learning how to play basketball under a competent coach for most of the year. Ray was a great guy, but it was clear we weren't going to be much better under his leadership. For the continued improvement throughout the year, Howland has to get a high grade. B+
 

Philly Dawg

Heisman
Oct 6, 2012
16,410
11,100
113
Our defense under Ray was not good. Our oppoenents' shooting percentages and points per game allowed basically remained the same or were worse than Stansbury's last two years, which were by quite a bit two of the worst defensive teams he had. Our statistics this year were similar, although we improved over the course of the season. I don't think that these seniors had ever been tought the fundamentals of how to play man to man defense.

I hope that the improvement carries over to next year and that we have a good defensive team for the first time in many years.
 

thekimmer

All-Conference
Aug 30, 2012
8,967
3,191
113
The problem is we are comparing a year 1 coach's record with a year 3 coach. There is a learning/adjustment curve here that granted might have been more prolonged that we had liked but it is expected. The other thing that is missed here is statistical improvement. I know the only stat that matters is W/L but I think that is relevant here. We were competitive in more games than we were last year. At least more conference games. Here are a few statistical comparisons to last season.

.....................15-16 14-15
Scoring margin +2.2 -1.7
Turnover margin +0.4 -2.7
Rebounding margin -1.6 +2.6
Assists/TO ...........1.1 0.6

Improvements in 3 of the 4 that did not show up in the W/L but hopefullly will next season.

The biggest thing going for howland though is recruiting. It was worth the change just for that. In 3 recruiting classes Ray signed exactly one player that was ranked at his position and ZERO top 100 players. That one was Gavin Ware. Howland tripled that with his first class and this year just blew that away.
 

esplanade91

Redshirt
Dec 9, 2010
5,656
0
0
Sorry, I never got to TWO. Neither did Howland.**

Keep the Howland Apology Tour moving with your excuses. It's is a super bad mess that RR would have matched the productivity of Howland. RR might not have had MN and Holmon, but he would have had at least Black and Houston. Given the learning curve for MN and Holmon, I don't know if they would have mattered.

I think Howland did a good job. But I don't think that he did a great job. He showed only slight improvement over RR.

What did you realistically expect this season? We had one front court player for 3/5 of the season. We started 4 guards more than once with a freshman SG playing PF. Rick Ray severely mismanaged his roster, which I'm willing to give him SOME slack for, but not when I see where he was going with his final recruiting class... Which was more guards, one of them being ANOTHER undersized guy.

I was hoping for the NIT, I'll be honest, but that was also factoring in that I thought Fred would average more than 5 ppg and some of the other older and somewhat unknown players would turn the corner. Sword had maybe his worst season as a bulldog, and it wasn't a particularly bad one.

I just think some people had some unrealistic expectations. I would imagine that Howland's first UCLA team was better than this team and still finished with a losing record.

Howland came in and distrupted everyone's routine. That rarely means a winning record in year #1
 

121Josey

Redshirt
Oct 30, 2012
7,503
0
0
I thought that the NIT was the floor. Then when SEC play began, I thought .500 overall and SEC was the watermark.

Howland was the one who trimmed the roster. He gets no free pass for lack of inside depth.

I don't know how a team could be so futile against a zone defense. Just playing street ball would have been better than that cluster17.
 

3000lbchicken

Senior
May 1, 2006
2,015
484
83
A

Team bought in to what the coaches were teaching them and they finally figured out they weren't going to change and it showed at the end of the season. Great foundation for those returning to show the new guys.
 

esplanade91

Redshirt
Dec 9, 2010
5,656
0
0
Howland gets no slack for inside depth? HOWLAND? We entered the season with 4 post players, and I'm being liberal with that term, which isn't enough to begin with... and 2 of those were hurt to start the season. Strugg never got healthy. Holman missed the entirety of summer ball and rehabbed a surgery. Ndoye doesn't belong anywhere near organized basketball, God love him.

Houston would have provided nothing to this team, and from what I've been told HE determined his exit. I posted on here long before the season started when there was question about who would be exiting early that it was Houston because he wasn't getting along with the current staff. He was suspended and kicked off a few weeks later.

I think you're playing both sides on this issue. You can't be mad about the shape of the program and then expect Howland to make any sizable difference in his first calendar year anywhere outside of recruiting. He came in after this past season's signing day (the one that counts, usually), he was handed a senior laden team... who weren't very good as a whole, and his style of play is a 180 degree difference in his predecessor's. I would imagine that some of our players haven't played man defense in organized basketball... Ever. They're not recruits from LA, they're coming from the mean streets or Montgomery and Starkville. Hard to imagine any high level "street ball" going on.

ETA: Houston, Zapparardo, and Ndoye are all people I'm considering when I say I expected them to contribute more than they did in order for us to make the NIT. They obviously didn't. And a lot of people are unfairly putting the weight of a bad season squarely on Malik Newman's shoulders. He had a better freshman season than all the seniors your bragging about, and that's coming off the bench with lingering injuries.
 
Last edited:

121Josey

Redshirt
Oct 30, 2012
7,503
0
0
Howland gets no slack for inside depth? HOWLAND? We entered the season with 4 post players, and I'm being liberal with that term, which isn't enough to begin with... and 2 of those were hurt to start the season. Strugg never got healthy. Holman missed the entirety of summer ball and rehabbed a surgery. Ndoye doesn't belong anywhere near organized basketball, God love him.


I think you're playing both sides on this issue. You can't be mad about the shape of the program and then expect Howland to make any sizable difference in his first calendar year anywhere outside of recruiting. He came in after this past season's signing day (the one that counts, usually), he was handed a senior laden team... who weren't very good as a whole, and his style of play is a 180 degree difference in his predecessor's. .

Who's mad? You and Snubdawg seem butt-sore defending Howland. I'm not mad. I'm just saying Howland didn't meet expectations. Anybody who gives him an A is just looking through maroon glasses, looking at what he's done in the past and has promised to do. If he makes the NIT next year, does he get an A+? I can hear it now, "He had so many freshmen, and if they just had another year, they would have made the tourney."

You have 1 quality post player, yet you cut two? I don't care who they are. You can't coach height. That's like saying, "Dak is our QB. All other QB's can transfer to JUCO before the season starts. We won't need you this year." If Howland cut them, he sleeps in the bed that he made. #Crxxmtastic

And for somebody that talked about playing with tempo, Howland did none of that. It was about as disappointing as the "NASCAR on Grass" for this year's football team - unless Derunnya got the analogy confused with smokin' tires.** State should have been running "small ball" and they're grinding it out in the half-court.

From what I gather, Howland wrote off the season before it even started. So, give him the grade of R+ for his RR impersonation.
 

mstateglfr

All-American
Feb 24, 2008
17,036
6,878
113
Oliver Black transferred last June. Had Howland kept him, he would have been yet another post presence.
You mention ndoye. He could have played but Howland chose to bench him. Justified?...i would guess so, but its still another big man who would have been available and actually was available.

Howland was not short on bigs when he took the job. Dont rewrite history.
They may have sucked, argue that, but they were available.
 

Philly Dawg

Heisman
Oct 6, 2012
16,410
11,100
113
Even if the jury is still out on Howland at MSU, Rick Ray was and is an absolutely awful coach. He is probably the worst head basketball coach in the country. Howland at least has his past accomplishments to fall back on. Ray has nothing but failure to fall back on.
 

Dawg1976

All-Conference
Aug 22, 2012
8,520
3,096
113
C+. First year with RR's guys is hard to judge. Ask me again next year.
 

karlchilders.sixpack

All-American
Jun 5, 2008
21,430
5,096
113
I saw this same **** on another site

I personally do not think this year was anywhere near a failure.
It was just working with what you had. A few more points per game early on makes a big difference.

Trolls are everywhere.
 

ShrubDog

Redshirt
Apr 13, 2008
5,307
3
38
From what I gather, Howland wrote off the season before it even started. So, give him the grade of R+ for his RR impersonation.

Good gosh man you are the ultimate troll. You have no understanding of the game of basketball.

Howland knows more about who he should keep on the team than you.
 

KurtRambis4

Redshirt
Aug 30, 2006
15,926
0
36
You gotta

understand that this is the same buddy that, based on all of his years playing ymca basketball, essentially said the only skill required to be a good pg was the ability to dribble.
 

coach66

Junior
Mar 5, 2009
12,720
347
83
There are a few things I worry about

Ben Howland isn't one of them. We will
be playing for an Sec title in 2 to 3 years.
 

ShrubDog

Redshirt
Apr 13, 2008
5,307
3
38
Thanks for pointing out I got floor and ceiling mixed up. I dont completely read everything you say. But I do notice when you start WWE threads. You may want to stick to critiquing wrestling.
 

UpTheMiddlex3Punt

All-Conference
May 28, 2007
18,270
4,468
113
I'll go with a B- (almost a C+) mainly because there would have to be room in the grading scale for better things we didn't achieve. Going .500 (or winning 2 in the SECT) would have been a B and going a couple games above would have been a B+. An NIT berth would have been an A- at the very least and a tourney bid would have been an A or A+. His recruiting is very good, but that will improve his grade for next year.
 

Palos verdes

Redshirt
Aug 22, 2012
1,839
36
48
Overall he would get a C+ from me. It took a while to get a consistant effort out of those seniors. Too long. But the future is bright with Howland. If we hold on to him, and I certainly hope we're prepared to do that, we will have the best stretch of success in our program history in the coming years.
 

Junction John

Redshirt
Oct 22, 2014
3,249
0
0
^^This is the correct answer^^

Everything we needed to happen happened.

It would have been nice to win some more games, but it would have been terrible to sacrifice anything for the future just to maybe make the NIT. Much better to tear down bad habits where necessary, even if it resulted in worse play initially.


Well said. We needed a complete rebuilding job, so this was the painful - and necessary - part of that. Good times are ahead, people. Let the man work the plan.
 
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White Football Mississippi State Week 12 Preview: Tennessee Tech Players to Know
  2. 02 Maroon and White Basketball Mississippi State 86-83 UCF: Bulldogs earn road win in fight from start to finish with Golden Knights
  3. 03 Maroon and White Basketball Mississippi State 88-46 Alabama State: Bulldogs beat the Hornets in annual Kids' Day game
  4. 04 Maroon and White Basketball Mississippi State at UCF: How, Where, and When to Watch Men's Basketball on the road
  5. 05 Maroon and White Football Sanfrisco Magee's "detail" and consistency carrying Mississippi State offense through tough times