NCAA EVALUATION TOOL CHANGES

nevadanatural

All-American
Dec 3, 2003
13,338
7,772
113
Actually dropping score margin will probably help us. We tend to let games end up closer than they should be. These changes get us almost back to RPI.
 

URedskin54

All-American
Jun 13, 2005
9,801
8,724
112
Could be wrong but it looks like they're just keeping RPI and Efficiency and removing the things that are just duplication of portions of those
 

ctt8410

All-Conference
Dec 4, 2003
6,845
3,872
0
Mostly because we don't tend to be an efficient scoring team. Teams that rely on defense to win close games are going to be hurt.

Efficiency margin. Both offensive and defensive efficiency. If uncapped, there's actually a tendency for those metrics to overrate good defensive teams that play a slow pace. When Virginia beats Maine 46-26, that's equivalent to an 84-47 win.

They've removed the separate 10-point MOV, but efficiency margin already counted MOV, so it's just no longer double counting.

I'm most interested in the verbiage surrounding SOS. The release says "strength of schedule is based on rating every game on a team's schedule for how hard it would be for an NCAA tournament-caliber team to win" which sounds an awful lot like Wins Above Bubble. That would represent a significant improvement in the methodology and would do a much better job of valuing each individual win and loss.

Unfortunately, they're also sticking with the Q1/Q2/Q3/Q4 system. That particular system will always favor the big schools that have an easier time racking up Q1 games on their schedule.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Loca5174

I.I.

Heisman
Dec 4, 2003
20,971
16,025
113
We just need to beat a bunch of teams that barely end up in Q1. And not lose to Q4.
 

aTUfan_rivals

Senior
Apr 18, 2011
9,327
879
0
Some 4 to 7 place team in a p5 will get equal or better seeding than a top team in the AAC, in the tourny.

Ie. upset special.
 

noble cane

All-Conference
Feb 25, 2002
9,575
3,206
0
In a further simplification...

The NCAA announces that 58 P5 teams plus half the new big east and Gonzaga are now guaranteed berths.

The rest of you... can suck it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Weatherdemon