If you split the divisions across all sports and keep a 64 team 'FBS' tourney field, you're only culling like 90ish teams. A decent close and Alabama is suddenly a bubble team in that scenario. You don't breach into an overall losing record, but you'll start breaching into teams with losing conference records.
ETA: Also, the Ivy League won't be going FBS in our lifetime, but won't be willing to give up the NCAA tournament either.
I think that's OK.
Let's say the 10 FBS football conferences elect to remain FBS. Add in the Big East, Atlantic 10, and Missouri Valley, which are consistently good conferences, and throw in (for example) the Horizon, West Coast, and Big West to get us to 16. A few more programs from outside these 16 could slide into these conferences. Or, if the Ivy League really wants in, merge the Big West and WCC and make the Ivy League the 16th, or something along those lines.
Either way, Lunardi's current field of 68 has this breakdown of the conferences I've listed:
7 Big 12
7 Big Ten
6 Big East
6 SEC
6 ACC
4 American
3 Pac-12
2 Atlantic 10
2 CUSA
2 Missouri Valley
2 Mountain West
1 Big West
1 Horizon
1 MAC
1 Sun Belt
1 West Coast
That's 52 teams. If you guarantee each conference two bids, that bumps up to 57. That leaves only 7 extra teams to get into the tournament that wouldn't under the current format. Lunardi's first 7 out are St. John's, UCLA, George Washington, Purdue, Boise State, Oregon, and Rhode Island.
I would rather see those 7 in the tournament than teams like St. Francis, Texas Southern, High Point, Colgate, etc., who have virtually no chance whatsoever to advance.