Five star players request to be released from commitments

herkhatescy2

All-Conference
Dec 2, 2024
1,722
2,375
113
According to Talia Goodman, five star Trinity Jones(previously committed to Clemson) and five star Oliviyah Edwards (previously committed to Tennessee) have both requested to be released from their respective school selections. Trinity Jones is from Naperville, Illinois. A wild and crazy world is overtaking basketball.
Didn't Jones visit?
 

Jonesy5960

Heisman
Feb 1, 2023
5,399
10,914
113
I hope JJ reaches out to Trinity Jones
I'm not even sure at this point that paying 2 5 stars for their freshman years is a wise financial decision. It's almost like you need to limit your investments in highly touted freshmen in favor of proven college players. Would you rather spend $1mm on a freshman that could easily struggle or 2 proven backcourt players? For every Jazzy Davidson there are probably 10 Addie Deals.
 

stillh8unlv

All-Conference
Mar 30, 2007
1,591
3,632
113
Are the women more volatile than the men?
Wot Wheel Of Time GIF by BarkerSocialMarketing
 

HawksGoneWild1

Redshirt
Sep 25, 2024
5
9
3
I'm not even sure at this point that paying 2 5 stars for their freshman years is a wise financial decision. It's almost like you need to limit your investments in highly touted freshmen in favor of proven college players. Would you rather spend $1mm on a freshman that could easily struggle or 2 proven backcourt players? For every Jazzy Davidson there are probably 10 Addie Deals.
Do you believe Iowa was still in the thick of it with Lewis and Bjorn to the very end before they committed?
If so, how would you reconcile that if one or both selected IA also?
Was thinking Jan placed lower values on them to effectively take IA out of the running.
However, I know Jan went to see Jenica play not to long before see committed to ND.
Plus, Jan and Abby went to see Bjorn in-home sometime around when McW had her official visit.
I would say that indicates Jan was still serious about landing both of them.
Seems like some serious cash for the 3 of them in the same frosh class.
Maybe the Deal situation will make her rethink her path (unknown HS dev vs proven portal) going forward to more of what you stated.

EDIT: Just recalled I came across this woman who got some insight as to what's going on with players and coaches now.
Iowa’s Transfer Exodus & The Portal Problem Explained | Court Vision Breakdown / Just Woman's Sports

What players are doing:
"@7:40[ Well actually I was talking about other people during the tournament about decisions that players are making now because of the transfer portal. Like you might decide like the most important thing as a player is going to a program where you can have playing time because you might go to a program, get the playing time, showcase what you can offer, and then do all that only with the goal of being able to hit the transfer portal and get the bag. So, if you're at a program where you're not even playing and you average 2.5 points per game, when you hit the portal, you can't demand 300,000. But you at a program where you're averaging, you know, 19 points per game and playing all the time, there's, you know, at least the mid- major to a contending team that's going to bring you in for 250 to $400,000 and want you to come to their program and contribute seven points per game for that bag. Yeah. So, like you might be making decisions not even about like what program you're joining. You're making a decision on what program best sets me up to hit and make the hit the lotto in the portal. Which program best sets me up for the portal? Wow. That could be your mindset. Yeah."

What coaches are doing:
"@8:46 Crazy. And then it also affects coaching. So, I was talking with coaches who was like, "We don't recruit projects anymore. We We're not in the business of that. If you're g we don't we'd rather actually get a transfer player than a freshman that needs work because a transfer player can help impact whatever we trying to do in this season right now versus I bring in a freshman develop them for a season and then someone else takes them when they're ready to really be good. Never thought about it like that. Interesting. So, even like how you recruit and it's a skill now to be a coach who can hit the portal, get a certain kind of kid and turn out individual successful seasons and like that's the goal. Like what is what's going to happen in this next season? Who do I got? And how do we go far in it? And like that's a skill set."
 
Last edited:

Manfredi

All-Conference
Jan 5, 2023
1,034
1,790
113
Maybe the Deal situation will make her rethink her path (HS dev vs portal) going forward to more of what you stated.
Regardless if the player is HS or portal there will be few who you can "develop" over time. If they aren't going to start or play a ton of minutes and they are highly rated...they are gone after the first year.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Amahawk

Kceasthawk@77

All-Conference
Feb 2, 2005
2,096
3,851
113
That can't be. I was told here by a poster that McKenna was "locked in" and had no option but to stay committed to Iowa. Not that I wanted her too obviously, nor did I say she would leave, I said It was concerning with Deal leaving, and I hoped it would not make her reconsider. There are NO rules at this point , and the school really has little choice but to release them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Amahawk

Old_wrestling_fan2

All-Conference
Mar 2, 2009
562
2,851
93
I'm not even sure at this point that paying 2 5 stars for their freshman years is a wise financial decision. It's almost like you need to limit your investments in highly touted freshmen in favor of proven college players. Would you rather spend $1mm on a freshman that could easily struggle or 2 proven backcourt players? For every Jazzy Davidson there are probably 10 Addie Deals.
Yeah, I said in another thread that the play today may be to just go out and hire the better sophomores. Think of the savings on not recruiting these snots and their stars.
 

fish1hawk

Junior
Jan 11, 2005
121
204
41
I'm not even sure at this point that paying 2 5 stars for their freshman years is a wise financial decision. It's almost like you need to limit your investments in highly touted freshmen in favor of proven college players. Would you rather spend $1mm on a freshman that could easily struggle or 2 proven backcourt players? For every Jazzy Davidson there are probably 10 Addie Deals.
I agree high school stars getting higher offers than then the majority of W players and pro players worldwide with free room and board. Some as you say will struggle, some will get injured. Even if things go well, the money is in college ,why graduate to take a pay cut. Be a career student player
 

Amahawk

Senior
May 1, 2002
3,351
620
113
Sometimes I wish that I was an agent with about eight superb women's hoops players. I would rent the squad out each season to get a national championship for schools.
 

Zach Jump

All-Conference
Jun 24, 2022
2,686
4,595
113
That can't be. I was told here by a poster that McKenna was "locked in" and had no option but to stay committed to Iowa. Not that I wanted her too obviously, nor did I say she would leave, I said It was concerning with Deal leaving, and I hoped it would not make her reconsider. There are NO rules at this point , and the school really has little choice but to release them.

You state there are no rules...and follow it with they little choice but to release them.

So basically there are rules.

Some programs release the individual, some don't. This part of college recruiting is nothing new.
 

Kceasthawk@77

All-Conference
Feb 2, 2005
2,096
3,851
113
You state there are no rules...and follow it with they little choice but to release them.

So basically there are rules.

Some programs release the individual, some don't. This part of college recruiting is nothing new.
That's not a rule, but most schools aren't going to keep a player that doesn't want to be there. Especially a team like Iowa where they preach culture. That's probably out the window going forward to though with what's going on now,,,
 

Kceasthawk@77

All-Conference
Feb 2, 2005
2,096
3,851
113
not really. timing with the portal opening tomorrow for the ladies. You want to get released and get a destination before teams fill rosters with portal openings.
not really. timing with the portal opening tomorrow for the ladies. You want to get released and get a destination before teams fill rosters with portal openings.
I doubt that matters for the top incoming players. They'll have their pick of schools.....