Big Ten Network Original: First Dance - Northwestern vs Rutgers

zazoo2002

All-Conference
Jan 27, 2002
2,929
3,606
61
I just watched the documentary "First Dance" on BTN, which chronicled Northwestern Men's Basketball historic 2016/17 season, culminating in their first NCAA Tournament appearance in program history.

It made me think about Rutgers' institutional identity and how it has influenced the university's historically tenuous - though changing - commitment to the athletic department. Northwestern shares many of the same institutional challenges, which gives me both hope and pause...and inspired me to do a bit of research; some of which I knew, some of which I didn't.

1) After terminating Coach Carmody (2013), who was on the cusp of the NCAA's - making the NIT in 4 of his final 5 seasons - Northwestern athletic director Jim Phillips, who is slated to become the next commissioner of the ACC, "vowed to conduct an extensive coaching search."

2) Northwestern hired Chris Collins - great pedigree on paper. He made gradual progress in the first 2 years, then guided the team to a record of 20 - 12 and 24 - 12 in years 3 and 4.

3) Following their break-out 2016/17 season, Northwestern committed $110m to renovate Welsh-Ryan Arena.

4) In the 4-years since, Collins has gone 16 - 53 in the B1G and 42 - 67 overall.

Gulp. They appeared poised for continued success. What happened? Maybe Collins rode Carmody's players and a carry-over culture?

Conclusion: The B1G is brutal. Unless you're a Blue Blood, there is no room for error. It's both the Jimmies and the Joe's and the X's and the O's. Enjoy the season! There are no future guarantees.
 

RUTRINI_rivals

All-Conference
Jul 18, 2003
1,128
1,014
0
I just watched the documentary "First Dance" on BTN, which chronicled Northwestern Men's Basketball historic 2016/17 season, culminating in their first NCAA Tournament appearance in program history.

It made me think about Rutgers' institutional identity and how it has influenced the university's historically tenuous - though changing - commitment to the athletic department. Northwestern shares many of the same institutional challenges, which gives me both hope and pause...and inspired me to do a bit of research; some of which I knew, some of which I didn't.

1) After terminating Coach Carmody (2013), who was on the cusp of the NCAA's - making the NIT in 4 of his final 5 seasons - Northwestern athletic director Jim Phillips, who is slated to become the next commissioner of the ACC, "vowed to conduct an extensive coaching search."

2) Northwestern hired Chris Collins - great pedigree on paper. He made gradual progress in the first 2 years, then guided the team to a record of 20 - 12 and 24 - 12 in years 3 and 4.

3) Following their break-out 2016/17 season, Northwestern committed $110m to renovate Welsh-Ryan Arena.

4) In the 4-years since, Collins has gone 16 - 53 in the B1G and 42 - 67 overall.

Gulp. They appeared poised for continued success. What happened? Maybe Collins rode Carmody's players and a carry-over culture?

Conclusion: The B1G is brutal. Unless you're a Blue Blood, there is no room for error. It's both the Jimmies and the Joe's and the X's and the O's. Enjoy the season! There are no future guarantees.
Great concluding thoughts here. Rutgers has the potential to get good and sustain success under Pike.
 
  • Like
Reactions: zazoo2002

Caliknight

Hall of Famer
Sep 21, 2001
198,582
151,371
113
I just watched the documentary "First Dance" on BTN, which chronicled Northwestern Men's Basketball historic 2016/17 season, culminating in their first NCAA Tournament appearance in program history.

It made me think about Rutgers' institutional identity and how it has influenced the university's historically tenuous - though changing - commitment to the athletic department. Northwestern shares many of the same institutional challenges, which gives me both hope and pause...and inspired me to do a bit of research; some of which I knew, some of which I didn't.

1) After terminating Coach Carmody (2013), who was on the cusp of the NCAA's - making the NIT in 4 of his final 5 seasons - Northwestern athletic director Jim Phillips, who is slated to become the next commissioner of the ACC, "vowed to conduct an extensive coaching search."

2) Northwestern hired Chris Collins - great pedigree on paper. He made gradual progress in the first 2 years, then guided the team to a record of 20 - 12 and 24 - 12 in years 3 and 4.

3) Following their break-out 2016/17 season, Northwestern committed $110m to renovate Welsh-Ryan Arena.

4) In the 4-years since, Collins has gone 16 - 53 in the B1G and 42 - 67 overall.

Gulp. They appeared poised for continued success. What happened? Maybe Collins rode Carmody's players and a carry-over culture?

Conclusion: The B1G is brutal. Unless you're a Blue Blood, there is no room for error. It's both the Jimmies and the Joe's and the X's and the O's. Enjoy the season! There are no future guarantees.
Recuiting. Facilities aside, NW seems like a hard school to recruit basketball players to.
 
  • Like
Reactions: zazoo2002

zazoo2002

All-Conference
Jan 27, 2002
2,929
3,606
61
Recuiting. Facilities aside, NW seems like a hard school to recruit basketball players to.

Northwestern is definitely a B1G outlier. Curious whether they follow the NCAA minimum admission requirements for athletes? They certainly have much to offer - excellent academics, top-notch facilities, beautiful location on Lake Michigan and nearby Chicago feeder schools.
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Football safety Chris Joines out for rest of 2026 season
  2. 02 The Knight Report Rutgers Basketball HC Brandin Knight's Bryant Postgame Press Conference
  3. 03 The Knight Report Staff Predictions for Rutgers Football versus Nebraska
  4. 04 The Knight Report Rutgers Basketball defeats Bryant behind Davis' Second Half Burst
  5. 05 The Knight Report Potential Transfer Portal Targets for Rutgers Football in 2027: Quarterbacks