I tend to agree, more than disagree with you on this issue, but the another factor I'd like to add to this is that JC never jams the ball. He tries to finesse the ball instead of an outright assault on the rim! He misses a bunch of bunnies. My thoughts are that the coaching staff probably should encourage him for a more aggressive attack at the hoop. Maybe then he might impress a bit more?
No doubt.
I've watched this kid for 3 years. He has never stuck me as athletic. He's simply big. My opinion - subject to be wrong of course - is that adding muscle is almost NEVER a negative. The concept of "too bulky" when we're talking about muscle is, to me, misplaced. You look at guys like Bo Jackson, LeBron, some NFL linebackers, Gronk, Zion, and these guys are the best of the best. If you put 20 pounds of pure muscle on the Greek Freak, I think he'd be even more bad ***.
Carlton will never be a great center. Just isn't going to happen. Why? Because the last great center with a 12" vertical was probably Bill Walton, and he was the original Mr. Fundamental.
Love Josh, and I loved that he stayed with the program. I hope he's here tomorrow. But adding 20, taking off 20, and so on, is not going to change who he is as a basketball player. He's methodical, slow, and not particularly athletic.
I would love to see Josh come in next year with a 100% nuts to the sheetrock approach to the game. Give me that, and I'll be super happy.
Anybody expecting this kid to lose 20 pounds and come in and be a world beater is probably in for some disappointment.