I dont GAF about records that was one of the greatest victories in Rutgers history

Nyagentman

Sophomore
Jul 31, 2025
162
135
43
Should have won the 2014 game one bad defensive play on the Allan Robinson WR screen that hit for like 75 yards. I remember Clark Harris dropping a potential 1st down with 4 minutes that gave Pedd state the chance
 
  • Like
Reactions: ScarletKid2008

RUboston

All-American
Sep 13, 2002
6,459
9,929
78
As I watched Raymond get swarmed by three PSU defenders and stopped on that swing pass, I immediately thought “same old Rutgers”, what a horrible play call, we’re never going to beat PSU, we can never finish, and then…😂🏈💪
 
  • Like
Reactions: Section124

rob kight

All-American
Oct 22, 2020
5,069
6,488
113
The Raymond pitch to Black was not a planned play. Raymond had the state of mind to pitch the ball despite being tackled by multiple players. Black was also a hero for being in the right place and immediately going in for the TD.
 

RUnTeX

All-Conference
Dec 21, 2001
7,149
4,319
113
Should have won the 2014 game one bad defensive play on the Allan Robinson WR screen that hit for like 75 yards. I remember Clark Harris dropping a potential 1st down with 4 minutes that gave Pedd state the chance
Tyler Kroft, not Clark Harris
 
  • Like
Reactions: RU206

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,219
90,391
113
The Raymond pitch to Black was not a planned play. Raymond had the state of mind to pitch the ball despite being tackled by multiple players. Black was also a hero for being in the right place and immediately going in for the TD.
If you watch the play closely, Ben Black was in his face calling for the ball. They both deserve credit for a heads up, smart football play.
 

Krup062

Sophomore
Jul 2, 2025
150
197
43
Nah… it’s Penn State!! WTF! 38 friggin yearz! Get lost with Fortay
First, I didn’t say the game that ended with the Fortay pass was bigger, I just corrected the opponent.

Second, anyone acting like that Fortay win wasn’t that special is just outing themselves on not knowing much about that game. Not that the opponent was a huge deal (except that Rutgers added to pressure that almost cost Beamer his job just before he turned things around and had a ton of success at VTech), but the way the game went and especially ended.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Section124

Section124

Heisman
Dec 21, 2002
17,629
23,596
96
It's great to beat Penn St, but you guys are nuts saying this was the all-time win. This was a horrible Penn St team. Franklin gutted it. PSU hired Campbell too late and he was stuck with a crap roster. This changes nothing with Schiano. He still needs to be fired.
 

DanRU

Senior
Jun 9, 2008
263
425
63
Schiano, coaches and team have been getting hammered. It was a great win, especially considering all of their injuries. Kudos to all for playing hard. With the season being what it is, It would have been easy for the players to throw in the towel but they didn't.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Foads and Ru-baby

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,722
4,082
108
Good win but the opponent is 6-5. Don’t hype up the jersey. They aren’t good this year - we’ve beaten better teams
Not really. If they win next week against Maryland, they will finish 7-5. I don’t think we have beaten any big 10 teams with this record or better. A big deal has been made about ‘beating teams with a winning record’.

And in terms of momentum, Penn State was not a spiraling team either. They had won three games in a row, most recently blowing Minnesota out.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ru-baby

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,722
4,082
108
It's great to beat Penn St, but you guys are nuts saying this was the all-time win. This was a horrible Penn St team. Franklin gutted it. PSU hired Campbell too late and he was stuck with a crap roster. This changes nothing with Schiano. He still needs to be fired.
Look, I am one of the kings are pragmatism, but hyperbole either direction isn’t helpful

PSU at 6-4 and on a 3 game winning streak isn’t ’a horrible Penn State team’. They just beat Minnesota 42-14 last week.

But, yes. This Penn State team is not as good as they normally are.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ru-baby

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,722
4,082
108
And we went 8-5.

While PSU is 6-5 this year.

Recency bias holding sway here.
I don’t understand your point. You said that Michigan 2014 win was a better win than last night. I don’t agree because Michigan truly was a bad team in 2014 and Rutgers was solid. Rutgers probably should have won that game vs Michigan.

PSU 2026 is a better team than 2014 Michigan by a lot.

2014 Rutgers was at home. This game was on the road.
 
Last edited:

Jtung230

Heisman
Jun 30, 2005
19,536
12,654
82
Good win but the opponent is 6-5. Don’t hype up the jersey. They aren’t good this year - we’ve beaten better teams
It’s a game no one expected us to win. I didn’t think we could win that game until we won. We definitely beat better opponents but none were that big of an upset. Add the fact that it was PSU and a 26 yr streak. I stand by it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ScarletKid2008

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,722
4,082
108
It’s a game no one expected us to win. I didn’t think we could win that game until we won. We definitely beat better opponents but none were that big of an upset. Add the fact that it was PSU and a 26 yr streak. I stand by it.
What better opponent did Rutgers beat? This has been the entire issue with never beating power conference teams with winning records. If I’m not mistaken, PSU was flirting with the top 25 with this win
 

RU05

All-American
Jun 25, 2015
15,330
9,523
113
I don’t understand your point. Somebody said that Michigan 2014 win was a better win than last night. I don’t agree because Michigan truly was a bad team in 2014 and Rutgers was solid. Rutgers probably should have won that game vs Michigan.
Still a win over Big 10 royalty. In what was a huge season for Rutgers.

Yes this was a huge upset, but it's in the midst of a terrible season. And it's not like PSU is good.

Not saying this wasn't a big win. But I think Michigan was bigger.
 

RUChet

All-Conference
Apr 8, 2023
3,486
4,244
113
Not really. If they win next week against Maryland, they will finish 7-5. I don’t think we have beaten any big 10 teams with this record or better. A big deal has been made about ‘beating teams with a winning record’.

And in terms of momentum, Penn State was not a spiraling team either. They had won three games in a row, most recently blowing Minnesota out.
Nobody saying it’s not a good win. I’m just not ready to say it’s a top program win ever as PSU isn’t good this year

If PSU ends 7-5 then this is one of our better B1G wins - agree. But not ready to say one of our best wins ever in program history.
 

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,722
4,082
108
Still a win over Big 10 royalty. In what was a huge season for Rutgers.

Yes this was a huge upset, but it's in the midst of a terrible season. And it's not like PSU is good.

Not saying this wasn't a big win. But I think Michigan was bigger.
I agree with you in terms of importance to the season….but maybe?

Rutgers would have been bowl eligible either way in 2014. Only time will tell, but if Rutgers comes back next week with a win, suddenly it’s 4-8 with a 2 game winning streak and 2 close losses and maybe vibes and narratives in the program get significantly better.
Remember that every single player on this roster can hit the transfer portal and this thing must have gotten pretty toxic. And every single fan can opt not to renew their tickets. Maybe this program is destined to continue spiraling but if it comes back strong next season, it’s possible this was the pivot point.
 

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,722
4,082
108
Nobody saying it’s not a good win. I’m just not ready to say it’s a top program win ever as PSU isn’t good this year

If PSU ends 7-5 then this is one of our better B1G wins - agree. But not ready to say one of our best wins ever in program history.
Well, you just moved the goal post. You originally said they aren't good and we have beaten better teams.

I don’t think either of those statements are true outside of Lville 2006. Even our second best win that season, I don’t think was a better team than this Penn State team. The 1.0 era lacked upset wins also, mostly beating the teams we should and losing to the better teams.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tru2ru1

RUboston

All-American
Sep 13, 2002
6,459
9,929
78
The Raymond pitch to Black was not a planned play. Raymond had the state of mind to pitch the ball despite being tackled by multiple players. Black was also a hero for being in the right place and immediately going in for the TD.
Everybody knows it wasn’t a planned play. And let’s face it, it was a terrible play call at that location and situation that had little to no chance of success. Raymond and Black probably broke the huddle thinking “WTF”. It was their heads up play which saved the coaches. RU won in spite of that play call, not because of it. Kudos to Raymond and Black. As a long suffering RU fan, who remembers listening to the 1988 win in his Hoboken apartment, I will forever remember yesterday’s win and be thankful for Raymond and Black’s heads up play.
 
Last edited:

RU05

All-American
Jun 25, 2015
15,330
9,523
113
I agree with you in terms of importance to the season….but maybe?

Rutgers would have been bowl eligible either way in 2014. Only time will tell, but if Rutgers comes back next week with a win, suddenly it’s 4-8 with a 2 game winning streak and 2 close losses and maybe vibes and narratives in the program get significantly better.
Remember that every single player on this roster can hit the transfer portal and this thing must have gotten pretty toxic. And every single fan can opt not to renew their tickets. Maybe this program is destined to continue spiraling but if it comes back strong next season, it’s possible this was the pivot point.
Maybe if Surace turns into a player this get's an added boost.

But I'm still taking the Michigan win in this debate.
 

RUChet

All-Conference
Apr 8, 2023
3,486
4,244
113
Well, you just moved the goal post. You originally said they aren't good and we have beaten better teams.

I don’t think either of those statements are true outside of Lville 2006. Even our second best win that season, I don’t think was a better team than this Penn State team. The 1.0 era lacked upset wins also, mostly beating the teams we should and losing to the better teams.
OP said this was one of best wins in RU history.

He didn’t say in B1G history or even GS history. He said in program history which goes back to the 1800s.

I hold to my point that no, this was not one of the greatest wins in RU history.

Beating Lville and S Florida in the regular season under GS1.0 were bigger as
bowl wins.

And there are wins prior to GS that are
Bigger.

Where I agree is that this might be the best GS2.0 win but it’s not saying much given how bad we’ve been almost the whole 2.0 tenure
 
  • Like
Reactions: NickRU714

NickRU714

Heisman
Aug 18, 2009
14,451
13,341
113
OP said this was one of best wins in RU history.

He didn’t say in B1G history or even GS history. He said in program history which goes back to the 1800s.

I hold to my point that no, this was not one of the greatest wins in RU history.

Beating Lville and S Florida in the regular season under GS1.0 were bigger as
bowl wins.

And there are wins prior to GS that are
Bigger.

Where I agree is that this might be the best GS2.0 win but it’s not saying much given how bad we’ve been almost the whole 2.0 tenure

2007 USF was #2 at the time
Finished 9-3 and Top 25 ranked to end regular season

They lost the Sun Bowl and finished out of the rankings
 
  • Like
Reactions: RUChet

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,722
4,082
108
06 Louisville was the best team RU beat
I don’t think there’s any doubt about that. It wasn’t really an upset but obviously was monumental in importance and really got Rutgers on the national map.

But beyond that win, there’s a strong argument that this is the best win we have had since the 1980s. Michigan 2014 was 5-7. That game had some importance to show that Rutgers could beat a brand name in the Big Ten and that was important at the time but Rutgers was the better team and Michigan was not good.
 

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,722
4,082
108
OP said this was one of best wins in RU history.

He didn’t say in B1G history or even GS history. He said in program history which goes back to the 1800s.

I hold to my point that no, this was not one of the greatest wins in RU history.

Beating Lville and S Florida in the regular season under GS1.0 were bigger as
bowl wins.

And there are wins prior to GS that are
Bigger.

Where I agree is that this might be the best GS2.0 win but it’s not saying much given how bad we’ve been almost the whole 2.0 tenure
I think in terms of talking about the entire program history, most of us didn’t experience a lot of of that time era :)

I was just responding to the words you used in your post, not the OP. Penn State is not bad even if this season they are far below their historic level.

I also completely agree that if this is the best win other than Louisville 2006 since the 1980s, it is really more of a statement on how bad this program has been more than the fact that the win last night was truly something extra extraordinary.
 

Scarlet16e2

All-Conference
Nov 22, 2005
9,006
4,070
113
Aside from the obvious glee at beating Penn State after 18? Consecutive losses, this win feels a lot like the season-ending win over Syracuse in 2003. That was the start of something special IMO.

note that after that win, a promising start to the 2004 season was quickly derailed following “the accident”. But then came 2005 and the Insight Bowl followed by everything that was 2006. So this win may be an ice-breaker that gets things rolling, but that does not mean there won’t be adversity along the way.
 
Last edited:

RUChet

All-Conference
Apr 8, 2023
3,486
4,244
113
I think in terms of talking about the entire program history, most of us didn’t experience a lot of of that time era :)

I was just responding to the words you used in your post, not the OP. Penn State is not bad even if this season they are far below their historic level.

I also completely agree that if this is the best win other than Louisville 2006 since the 1980s, it is really more of a statement on how bad this program has been more than the fact that the win last night was truly something extra extraordinary.
You can’t put this win over a 6-6/7-5 PSU over our win vs USF when ranked 2nd and finished ranked

Believe 2 or 3 yrs ago didn’t we beat another B1G team that finished 7-5 too?

all of these are better wins than last
Night

Nov. 9, 2006 Louisville #3 / #4 W 28–25
Oct. 18, 2007 South Florida #2 / #2 W 30–27
Oct. 25, 2008 Pittsburgh #17 / #20 W 54–34
Nov. 12, 2009 South Florida #23 / #24 W 31–0

all bowl wins better too
 

Scarlet16e2

All-Conference
Nov 22, 2005
9,006
4,070
113
You can’t put this win over a 6-6/7-5 PSU over our win vs USF when ranked 2nd and finished ranked

Believe 2 or 3 yrs ago didn’t we beat another B1G team that finished 7-5 too?

all of these are better wins than last
Night

Nov. 9, 2006 Louisville #3 / #4 W 28–25
Oct. 18, 2007 South Florida #2 / #2 W 30–27
Oct. 25, 2008 Pittsburgh #17 / #20 W 54–34 in
Nov. 12, 2009 South Florida #23 / #24 W 31–0

all bowl wins better too
There’s more to making a win great than the rankings of the opponent. It’s great to win against ranked teams, but there is something to be said for beating your rivals, even (especially) if they don’t think it’s a rivalry. And moreso when it’s been 38 years since the last win.
 

RUfan1977

All-Conference
Mar 24, 2024
1,102
1,605
113
It's #1 now over
  • Jeremy Ito's game-winning FG vs. Louisville (2006)
  • Tim Brown's late TD catch vs. Connecticut (2006)
  • Fortay to Brantley vs. Syracuse (1998)
  • Kenny Britt's 67-yard catch and fumble recovery vs. Louisville (2006)
  • Gary Nova's late TD pass vs. Michigan (2014)
  • Mohamed Sanu's game-winning TD vs. South Florida (2011)
This was a great ending and should stick with many of the fans that have watched it. Marco Battaglia had an incredible game against Penn State in 1995, but ultimately Penn State pulled ahead in the 4th quarter and ran up the score with about a minute left.

In football, there is no team that I want Rutgers to beat more than Penn State.
 

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,722
4,082
108
You can’t put this win over a 6-6/7-5 PSU over our win vs USF when ranked 2nd and finished ranked

Believe 2 or 3 yrs ago didn’t we beat another B1G team that finished 7-5 too?

all of these are better wins than last
Night

Nov. 9, 2006 Louisville #3 / #4 W 28–25
Oct. 18, 2007 South Florida #2 / #2 W 30–27
Oct. 25, 2008 Pittsburgh #17 / #20 W 54–34
Nov. 12, 2009 South Florida #23 / #24 W 31–0

all bowl wins better too
USF 2007 did not finish ranked but that was a fun night and a nice win. Even though USF was ‘meh’, the win got national attention and furthered the Schiano brand which was growing at the time.

I was actually at the Pitt 2008 game. We are using the word ‘better’ in two different contexts. One is which win was better and one is which opponents were better. I am going to argue this PSU team is better than 2008 Pitt but I see the argument that the 2008 win is a better win. Rutgers was reeling and went in the road and blew out a hot Pitt team who was ranked.

And I feel the same way about South Florida in 2009 who finished 8-5 and 3-4. That was not a ‘good’ USF team, they were ranked but I think this PSU team would dismantle that USF team.
 

Nyagentman

Sophomore
Jul 31, 2025
162
135
43
Sorry but on no universe is a win over South Florida better than a win over Penn state. I have seen 2 wins over my lifetime 38 years apart .
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers vs Michigan State odds: Point spread released on Scarlet Knights, Spartans
  2. 02 The Knight Report Football Every throw from Rutgers Football QB AJ Surace versus Penn State
  3. 03 The Knight Report Join The Knight Report TODAY and get it for 50% off!
  4. 04 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Postgame Show: Penn State Nittany Lions Edition - TKR Pod
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Football HC Greg Schiano's Penn State Postgame Press Conference