You are spot on.They do already know how to run a deficit...![]()
![]()
You are spot on.They do already know how to run a deficit...![]()
![]()
So Northwestern has a new 35K MAC level attendance stadium, Rutgers, Maryland, and a top 5 UCLA attendanceAccording to the NCAA’s Membership Financial Reporting System, 352 active Division I schools reported athletics expenses and revenues for 2024. The median institution had total expenses of about $109.99 million and generated revenue of $106.93 million, resulting in a net loss of roughly $25 million NCAA.
Profitability in this context means the athletics program’s generated revenue exceeded its total athletics expenses. The NCAA’s 2024 summary found that only 21 FBS and FCS schools met that condition
They share TV money but they don't share ticket, concession, parking, merchandise, etc.So Northwestern has a new 35K MAC level attendance stadium, Rutgers, Maryland, and a top 5 UCLA attendance
looks putrid. How is that equal sharing and i know each school gets even revenue sharing.
Just cut programs that aren't profitable--there's an easy solution.According to the NCAA’s Membership Financial Reporting System, 352 active Division I schools reported athletics expenses and revenues for 2024. The median institution had total expenses of about $109.99 million and generated revenue of $106.93 million, resulting in a net loss of roughly $25 million NCAA.
Profitability in this context means the athletics program’s generated revenue exceeded its total athletics expenses. The NCAA’s 2024 summary found that only 21 FBS and FCS schools met that condition
Wrestling isn't profitable but no way will PSU cut that. Same with Hockey.Just cut programs that aren't profitable--there's an easy solution.
A real breakdown of the P4 schools just regarding football is what is needed--that's not where $ is being lost.
Why can't we cut wrestling? Most schools have eliminated it. It's not competitive.Wrestling isn't profitable but no way will PSU cut that. Same with Hockey.
Programs like women's volleyball, Women's basketball, field hockey, and mens/women's soccer, baseball, and softball are sacred.
So what's left? Swimming and diving? Tennis? Fencing? Golf?
In a fiscally sane world, almost every college sport, men's or women's, would be club sports that play in rather small regional divisions.Why can't we cut wrestling? Most schools have eliminated it. It's not competitive.
Title IX prevents us from cutting most women's sports.
Hockey isn't an issue. We're well funded there.
Cut all men's sports other than football hockey and basketball. That also allows you to cut a ton of women's sports.
If it's truly about profit that's your answer. And it's a simple one.
I would be sad about cutting MVB but that's just how things work.
The PSU would lose their minds if we cut wrestling. Besides wrestling is very popular in the BiG.Why can't we cut wrestling? Most schools have eliminated it. It's not competitive.
Title IX prevents us from cutting most women's sports.
Hockey isn't an issue. We're well funded there.
Cut all men's sports other than football hockey and basketball. That also allows you to cut a ton of women's sports.
If it's truly about profit that's your answer. And it's a simple one.
I would be sad about cutting MVB but that's just how things work.
In a fiscally sane world, almost every college sport, men's or women's, would be club sports that play in rather small regional divisions.
My nephew plays club baseball for a D-1 school in WPA. His team, which actually made his divison's World Series in the spring of 2025 and the playoffs this past season, play teams in its division like YSU, Cleveland State, Akron, John Carroll, CMU, IUP and Duquesne. This program mostly, if not completely, is privately funded. That's the way that most of the college athletic programs at any school should function.Would agree that would make sense until the postseason national playoffs (maybe play a couple games out of region in a tournament or something. But all these sports getting on airplanes every other event for multi-day trips just doesn't make sense.
For sure--and maybe that's what needs to happen aside from football, men's basketball and the women's sport that create balance. Though I'd add hockeyIn a fiscally sane world, almost every college sport, men's or women's, would be club sports that play in rather small regional divisions.
Honest question--do you see wrestling surviving at this level? At it's peak there were about 160 DI programs--now there's less than 80 and dropping. We have probably half or close to it of what existed. It's that sustainable when one program dominates for a decade or longer at a time. I think 11 programs have won a national title in almost 100 years of the sport and almost half of those have only 1 title.The PSU would lose their minds if we cut wrestling. Besides wrestling is very popular in the BiG.
Eliminating too many mainstream sports might jeopardize our conference affiliation. Besides, PSU is only 1 of 21 schools that still profit from athletics. They might need to trim a little but they don't need a wholesale reduction. The same thing can't be said for the majority of colleges.
If there are going to be only 30 D1 wrestling programs Penn State will be one of them. It is our most successful program by far. If you get rid of wrestling you may as well get rid of everything.Honest question--do you see wrestling surviving at this level? At it's peak there were about 160 DI programs--now there's less than 80 and dropping. We have probably half or close to it of what existed. It's that sustainable when one program dominates for a decade or longer at a time. I think 11 programs have won a national title in almost 100 years of the sport and almost half of those have only 1 title.
I do get what you're saying. I do. And I understand why people love wrestling. I'm not saying we have to eliminate it but I think it's inevitable as other schools start cutting programs. In 10 years, I'd be shocked if there's more than 30 programs at the DI level.
Why? We're discussing profit not winning here. Correct?If there are going to be only 30 D1 wrestling programs Penn State will be one of them. It is our most successful program by far. If you get rid of wrestling you may as well get rid of everything.
I'm talking about winning. If you are talking about money it's football, men's basketball, women's basketball is close to breakeven. The rest are money losers. At least that's how it was a few years ago and I doubt it has changed much. So yeah, if you are talking about Penn State only keeping sports in the black you are looking at those two or three although with the changes associated with NIL and everything else who knows what is going to happen.Why? We're discussing profit not winning here. Correct?
I understand people love wrestling but it's not competitive. We all know that. We could literally get down to 10 programs and we'd still know who was going to win yearly
Right the concern was programs losing money so the solution is eliminating male sports that don't make money (like wrestling) and then eliminating women's sports once you meet Title IX rulesI'm talking about winning. If you are talking about money it's football, men's basketball, women's basketball is close to breakeven. The rest are money losers. At least that's how it was a few years ago and I doubt it has changed much. So yeah, if you are talking about Penn State only keeping sports in the black you are looking at those two or three although with the changes associated with NIL and everything else who knows what is going to happen.
Yes, I can see all of that happening. That would be the end of college sports. I know a lot of people don't agree with me but we are getting to the point where we can shut the whole thing down including football because there is no longer a link between college sports and education, which is the university's primary purpose. Scrap the football program and leave Beaver Stadium for monster truck rallies.Right the concern was programs losing money so the solution is eliminating male sports that don't make money (like wrestling) and then eliminating women's sports once you meet Title IX rules
Wrestling becomes a club spo
I feel like a decent number of people agree with you.Yes, I can see all of that happening. That would be the end of college sports. I know a lot of people don't agree with me but we are getting to the point where we can shut the whole thing down including football because there is no longer a link between college sports and education, which is the university's primary purpose. Scrap the football program and leave Beaver Stadium for monster truck rallies.
Wrestling isn't big nationally but it is big in the Big Ten. PSU, Nebraska, Iowa, OSU, Minny, Mich, Rutgers, Illinois, and Indiana are all ranked in the top 25. Wisconsin also received votes.Right the concern was programs losing money so the solution is eliminating male sports that don't make money (like wrestling) and then eliminating women's sports once you meet Title IX rules
Wrestling becomes a club sport
Is ranked impressive when there's 77 teams?Wrestling isn't big nationally but it is big in the Big Ten. PSU, Nebraska, Iowa, OSU, Minny, Mich, Rutgers, Illinois, and Indiana are all ranked in the top 25. Wisconsin also received votes.
Could a school like Rutgers who is losing money drop wresting? Possibly but they likely have other sports they'd be more inclined to drop.
You can wish it all you want but that's not going to happen.Right the concern was programs losing money so the solution is eliminating male sports that don't make money (like wrestling) and then eliminating women's sports once you meet Title IX rules
Wrestling becomes a club sport
There's no wish here. Wrestling being what it is now has zero impact on me. We're discussing the finances of athletic departments. Wrestling loses money--correct?You can wish it all you want but that's not going to happen.
Then why do FCS teams keep joining FBS? See South Dakota State, Sacramento State, Delaware & Missouri State recently. Idaho's the only team I can even recall leaving. UAB got rid of football for a while but brought it back. I feel like people just talk about what they want to see happen as opposed to what is likely.What I think is neat is that they are going to have a 24 team playoff when it ten to fifteen years they only have about twice that number playing FBS football.
What really needs to happen is a bunch of FBS teams to commit to they arent going to play the game anymore and allow the teams that want to play semi pro football to play semi pro football. All they give the kids a free education and nothing more than that, and if a kid can get more than that let them go play for pay. Why are large group of FCS teams havent figured out that this would work is beyond me?
They could have FBS (semi pro) and FBS (college divisions).
What I think is neat is that they are going to have a 24 team playoff when it ten to fifteen years they only have about twice that number playing FBS football.
What really needs to happen is a bunch of FBS teams to commit to they arent going to play the game anymore and allow the teams that want to play semi pro football to play semi pro football. All they give the kids a free education and nothing more than that, and if a kid can get more than that let them go play for pay. Why are large group of FCS teams havent figured out that this would work is beyond me?
They could have FBS (semi pro) and FBS (college divisions).
Penn State's 1929 Football De-Emphasis: "The Noble Experiment"
In 1929, Penn State’s administration, led by University President Ralph Hetzel and athletic director/head coach Hugo Bezdek, initiated a drastic de-emphasis of the varsity football program [source: 17]. This decision aimed to pull Penn State out of the hyper-commercialized "arms race" of college football and return the school to strict, pure amateurism [source: 17].
Several key factors drove this radical shift:
1. The Carnegie Foundation Report of 1929
In October 1929, the Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching published Bulletin Number Twenty-Three, a massive, highly publicized exposé on the widespread commercialization, corruption, and "athletic recruiting" in American college sports [source: 28].
- The report criticized the practice of paying players, giving athletic scholarships, using alumni "slush funds" to pay recruits, and employing professional coaches whose only job was winning [source: 17].
- While many major colleges ignored the report's warnings to protect their football revenues, President Hetzel took the findings incredibly seriously [source: 17]. He wanted Penn State to serve as a national beacon of academic integrity and pure amateurism [source: 17].
2. Radical Structural Changes
Under Hetzel’s "noble experiment," Penn State implemented sweeping changes that crippled the football team's ability to compete on a national stage [source: 17]:
- Eliminated Athletic Scholarships: Penn State completely renounced athletic scholarships [source: 17]. Every student-athlete had to be a regular student receiving no special financial aid or subsidies [source: 17].
- Banned Recruiting & Scouting: The university banned the practice of sending scouts to spy on rival teams and prohibited the active recruiting of high school stars [source: 17].
- Abolished "Training Tables": To eliminate any special treatment, the athletic department shut down the special dining halls (training tables) that fed football players high-protein meals [source: 17].
- Downgraded the Schedule: Penn State intentionally dropped major national powerhouses like Notre Dame, Georgia Tech, and their fierce rivals, the University of Pittsburgh, from their schedule [source: 17]. They replaced them with much smaller schools like Waynesburg, Western Maryland, and Dickinson [source: 17].
3. The Shift to "Athletics for All"
Bezdek and Hetzel believed that university resources should not be poured into a small group of "semi-professional" football players. Instead, they redirected athletic funding toward a massive intramural sports program designed to keep the entire student body physically fit [source: 17]. They believed that physical education should serve the student body rather than outside spectators [source: 17].
Ultimately, Penn State’s "noble experiment" was a massive failure on the field and financially naive [source: 17]:
Common Pitfalls: The Financial Backfire
- Losing Records: Bob Higgins took over as head coach in 1930, but without scholarships, the Nittany Lions compiled a miserable 26–36–3 record over the next eight seasons [source: 17].
- Isolation: Penn State expected other major colleges to follow their lead and form an amateur "Eastern Conference." [source: 17] Instead, schools like Pitt, Syracuse, and Fordham ignored the Carnegie Report and grew even more commercialized [source: 17]. Penn State became an athletic outsider [source: 17].
- The Return to Growth: By the late 1930s, facing dwindling ticket sales and alumni outrage, Penn State quietly began rolling back these restrictions—reintroducing radio broadcasts, expanding Beaver Field with steel stands, and eventually adapting to modern college football [source: 17].
Did not know this. Huh. I thought U of Chicago did this all by their lonesome.Penn State's 1929 Football De-Emphasis: "The Noble Experiment"
In 1929, Penn State’s administration, led by University President Ralph Hetzel and athletic director/head coach Hugo Bezdek, initiated a drastic de-emphasis of the varsity football program [source: 17]. This decision aimed to pull Penn State out of the hyper-commercialized "arms race" of college football and return the school to strict, pure amateurism [source: 17].
Several key factors drove this radical shift:
1. The Carnegie Foundation Report of 1929
In October 1929, the Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching published Bulletin Number Twenty-Three, a massive, highly publicized exposé on the widespread commercialization, corruption, and "athletic recruiting" in American college sports [source: 28].
- The report criticized the practice of paying players, giving athletic scholarships, using alumni "slush funds" to pay recruits, and employing professional coaches whose only job was winning [source: 17].
- While many major colleges ignored the report's warnings to protect their football revenues, President Hetzel took the findings incredibly seriously [source: 17]. He wanted Penn State to serve as a national beacon of academic integrity and pure amateurism [source: 17].
2. Radical Structural Changes
Under Hetzel’s "noble experiment," Penn State implemented sweeping changes that crippled the football team's ability to compete on a national stage [source: 17]:
- Eliminated Athletic Scholarships: Penn State completely renounced athletic scholarships [source: 17]. Every student-athlete had to be a regular student receiving no special financial aid or subsidies [source: 17].
- Banned Recruiting & Scouting: The university banned the practice of sending scouts to spy on rival teams and prohibited the active recruiting of high school stars [source: 17].
- Abolished "Training Tables": To eliminate any special treatment, the athletic department shut down the special dining halls (training tables) that fed football players high-protein meals [source: 17].
- Downgraded the Schedule: Penn State intentionally dropped major national powerhouses like Notre Dame, Georgia Tech, and their fierce rivals, the University of Pittsburgh, from their schedule [source: 17]. They replaced them with much smaller schools like Waynesburg, Western Maryland, and Dickinson [source: 17].
3. The Shift to "Athletics for All"
Bezdek and Hetzel believed that university resources should not be poured into a small group of "semi-professional" football players. Instead, they redirected athletic funding toward a massive intramural sports program designed to keep the entire student body physically fit [source: 17]. They believed that physical education should serve the student body rather than outside spectators [source: 17].
Ultimately, Penn State’s "noble experiment" was a massive failure on the field and financially naive [source: 17]:
Common Pitfalls: The Financial Backfire
- Losing Records: Bob Higgins took over as head coach in 1930, but without scholarships, the Nittany Lions compiled a miserable 26–36–3 record over the next eight seasons [source: 17].
- Isolation: Penn State expected other major colleges to follow their lead and form an amateur "Eastern Conference." [source: 17] Instead, schools like Pitt, Syracuse, and Fordham ignored the Carnegie Report and grew even more commercialized [source: 17]. Penn State became an athletic outsider [source: 17].
- The Return to Growth: By the late 1930s, facing dwindling ticket sales and alumni outrage, Penn State quietly began rolling back these restrictions—reintroducing radio broadcasts, expanding Beaver Field with steel stands, and eventually adapting to modern college football [source: 17].
BWI Football
Penn State running back Carson Hansen is now doubtful for Saturday's matchup with Rutgers
BWI Recruiting
Inside Lasch: New 2027 RPM logged to kick off massive recruiting weekend for Penn State
BWI Football
Penn State 3-2-1: Improving offense, leadership decisions and a test of consistency
BWI Recruiting
Over 70 prospects now confirmed for Penn State's home finale
BWI Wrestling
Which Penn State wrestlers are going to the CJ Morgan Invitational at Army? Here's the list, plus other thoughts