*****Montana St vs Iowa Game Thread*****

Anon1750875978

Heisman
Dec 26, 2018
10,483
18,059
113
Teagan was not a bad fit. She left for personal reasons that we all sympathize with. Addie could have fit if she would have taken a different approach
Emily was a bad fit but the athleticism made her a reasonable gamble.
Dani is in her own head IMO. Trying to live up to the rep she brought from Georgia. I think she will adjust but we do have other options
Gee, if it's not the players....????
 
  • Like
Reactions: IowaCityLit

IowaCityLit

All-Conference
Aug 30, 2025
1,802
2,883
113
Dani Carnegie has a career 15.2 ppg/41%fg and is currently averaging 14.2ppg/44%

🙄
That’s misleading and lacks improtant context. She averaged 18 pts last year and had shown you improvement. And she had raised her 3p percentage to 35 percent. Career average?

JJ offense isn’t exactly made for offensive talent to shine. Unless your a big who benefits (sometimes) from players lobbing the ball into you or trying to on nearly every possession.

I worry about MW in this offense too. We shall see:
 

AFM22

Heisman
Oct 31, 2022
23,917
45,962
113
Teagan was not a bad fit. She left for personal reasons that we all sympathize with. Addie could have fit if she would have taken a different approach
Emily was a bad fit but the athleticism made her a reasonable gamble.
Dani is in her own head IMO. Trying to live up to the rep she brought from Georgia. I think she will adjust but we do have other options
Deal and Mallegni are putting up solid stats against pretty poor competition. Their best game is against Marquette and they both kind of disappeared offensively. Look at ERod's competition this year and you'll see why her stats are so high.

Iowa SOS - 4
Wisconsin SOS - 39
Syracuse SOS - 67
 

AFM22

Heisman
Oct 31, 2022
23,917
45,962
113
That’s misleading and lacks improtant context. She averaged 18 pts last year and had shown you improvement. And she had raised her 3p percentage to 35 percent. Career average?

JJ offense isn’t exactly made for offensive talent to shine. Unless your a big who benefits (sometimes) from players lobbing the ball into you or trying to on nearly every possession.

I worry about MW in this offense too. We shall see:
And your posts weren't misleading? We all know Carnegie is having a slow start, but she's not far off her mark besides 3pt%.

And why do we have to worry about MW? She's a true freshman averaging 10/6/1.
 

KyleHuesmann

Heisman
Staff member
Dec 9, 2022
17,385
50,385
113
JJ offense isn’t exactly made for offensive talent to shine. Unless your a big who benefits (sometimes) from players lobbing the ball into you or trying to on nearly every possession.
They shot 33 threes on 71 possessions, so it’s not only passing to the post.

Also the offense isn’t the Jan Jensen offense. It’s one of the most widely known offenses in all of basketball.
 

IowaCityLit

All-Conference
Aug 30, 2025
1,802
2,883
113
And your posts weren't misleading? We all know Carnegie is having a slow start, but she's not far off her mark besides 3pt%.

And why do we have to worry about MW? She's a true freshman averaging 10/6/1.
I’m not the one suggesting Dani be replaced as a starter. I think averaging close to last years average would be reasonable. Just not sure the offense is optimal for that. But it’s still early so we will see.

MW stats are great for a frosh. I’m interested in how she develops and is utilized under JJ.
 

AFM22

Heisman
Oct 31, 2022
23,917
45,962
113
I’m not the one suggesting Dani be replaced as a starter. I think averaging close to last years average would be reasonable. Just not sure the offense is optimal for that. But it’s still early so we will see.

MW stats are great for a frosh. I’m interested in how she develops and is utilized under JJ.
You didn't suggest she be replaced.

This is what you were suggesting:
How many more bad fits and underutilization of talent before it’s JJs fault? Because it is.
 

Scott559

Heisman
Mar 16, 2010
3,916
12,969
113
Teagan was a bad fit. Averaging 18 pts a game

Addie was a bad fit. Averaging 15 pts a game.

Emily was a bad fit. Averaging 14 pts a game.

Now Dani is a bad fit and should be benched in favor of (name your favorite).

How many more bad fits and underutilization of talent before it’s JJs fault? Because it is.

Id keep an eye on MW.
Big difference between bad fit and unable to earn minutes.

Do you think Teagan starts ahead of McKenna if she stayed?

Do you think Addie starts ahead of Amari if she stayed?

In Wisconsin’s offense Teagan and Addie are allowed to be volume shooters, Teagan is averaging 33% from 3, Addie 30%. Aside from Green Bay who is a solid mid major, Wisconsin has played a weak non conference schedule, The Badgers non conference schedule is predicted at 335 out of 363.

I think before we proclaim Teagan and Addie to be coaching failures at Iowa, Let’s see how they fare when they face real competition with Wisconsin, Them being leading options at Wisconsin is quite different than being possible viable options at Iowa.
 

Jonesy5960

Heisman
Feb 1, 2023
7,739
16,078
113
That’s misleading and lacks improtant context. She averaged 18 pts last year and had shown you improvement. And she had raised her 3p percentage to 35 percent. Career average?

JJ offense isn’t exactly made for offensive talent to shine. Unless your a big who benefits (sometimes) from players lobbing the ball into you or trying to on nearly every possession.

I worry about MW in this offense too. We shall see:
It's actually not misleading. Her overall FG% was 42% and her EFG% was 51% last year. It's 43% and 50% this year. She's shooting a much higher percentage on her 2 point shots and a much lower percentage on her 3 point shots and free throws. She's on a team with more offensive talent at the guard position so you would expect her efficiency to go up while ppg remain about the same or even drop a little bit. She's actually taking more shots and scoring more points on a per 40 basis this year than last.

In short, she's never been a super efficient player, and she's still not a very efficient player this year, except when driving to the basket where she's shooting a truly excellent 71%. Her 3 point shooting is down 12 points, but she's getting wide open shots in this offense just like she did last night. She's just not hitting them.

MW has looked great so far. She's going to be an All American at Iowa before she's done. You're reaching.
 

Hawkeye_Miguel

All-Conference
Apr 7, 2025
356
1,133
93
Wow there's a lot of negativity after a win on here. I for one left Carver happy that the team got a bit of an early wake-up call and was still able to grind out a 16 point win.

Contrast this performance to the NCAA Tournament games from last year, where the 3s were also not falling. This one didn't feel in doubt in the 2nd half. That 1st round game against FDU was a 2 pt game with ~5 minutes left, and we know how the Virginia game ended. This year's team has more ways to score when the threes aren't falling.

Also, per Torvik, Montana State is the 3rd best non-conference opponent on Iowa's schedule, slightly ahead of Iowa State and Utah. Would we be so up-in-arms after a 16 point win over Iowa State?
 

Jonesy5960

Heisman
Feb 1, 2023
7,739
16,078
113
Wow there's a lot of negativity after a win on here. I for one left Carver happy that the team got a bit of an early wake-up call and was still able to grind out a 16 point win.

Contrast this performance to the NCAA Tournament games from last year, where the 3s were also not falling. This one didn't feel in doubt in the 2nd half. That 1st round game against FDU was a 2 pt game with ~5 minutes left, and we know how the Virginia game ended. This year's team has more ways to score when the threes aren't falling.

Also, per Torvik, Montana State is the 3rd best non-conference opponent on Iowa's schedule, slightly ahead of Iowa State and Utah. Would we be so up-in-arms after a 16 point win over Iowa State?
Definitely a glass half full perspective, but it was a 7 point game with 7 and a half minutes left, and it was actually very reminiscent of last year's FDU game against an opponent that Iowa should have beaten handily were it not for abysmal 3 point and free throw shooting. I know this is a better team with better parts than last year, but the 3 point and free throw shooting along with an inordinate number of turnovers is going to start costing them games against better competition in the months to come.
 

Kceasthawk@77

All-American
Feb 2, 2005
5,107
8,721
113
That’s misleading and lacks improtant context. She averaged 18 pts last year and had shown you improvement. And she had raised her 3p percentage to 35 percent. Career average?

JJ offense isn’t exactly made for offensive talent to shine. Unless your a big who benefits (sometimes) from players lobbing the ball into you or trying to on nearly every possession.

I worry about MW in this offense too. We shall see:
That makes no sense. MW can shoot from outside, in the lane and drive to the rim. She NEVER had the offense run through her in high school, yet she was an AA and top 6 ranked players. She's not looking to lead the team in scoring, (certainly not now anyway). She'll find what she needs, in the same way Journey is very productive in her minutes.
 

Kceasthawk@77

All-American
Feb 2, 2005
5,107
8,721
113
I’m not the one suggesting Dani be replaced as a starter. I think averaging close to last years average would be reasonable. Just not sure the offense is optimal for that. But it’s still early so we will see.

MW stats are great for a frosh. I’m interested in how she develops and is utilized under JJ.
She's going to be fine. She can do literally everything on either end of the floor, and were only 5 -6 games in.
 

oldxbbc

All-American
Sep 19, 2013
2,186
7,714
113
Definitely a glass half full perspective, but it was a 7 point game with 7 and a half minutes left, and it was actually very reminiscent of last year's FDU game against an opponent that Iowa should have beaten handily were it not for abysmal 3 point and free throw shooting. I know this is a better team with better parts than last year, but the 3 point and free throw shooting along with an inordinate number of turnovers is going to start costing them games against better competition in the months to come.
Give them a couple mor games to get used to each other. Turnovers will decrease and I think Wolzelko (sp) will make her presence more felt than now.
 

Scott559

Heisman
Mar 16, 2010
3,916
12,969
113
I still believe that this Iowa team has the talent and pieces to be very good

I don't agree with all of these, but there are certainly some bad trends with Jan the clapper's teams.



So just ignore the actual fact that Ava took 7 shots and the rest of the team attempted 60 shots? If you don’t like Jan,You don’t like her, But ignoring things like her running a 5 out offense at times with no post player in the game is just being intellectually dishonest. Iowa’s one play offense has generated a large quantity of wide open 3 point shots. Hopefully they start falling.
 

AFM22

Heisman
Oct 31, 2022
23,917
45,962
113
I still believe that this Iowa team has the talent and pieces to be very good

I don't agree with all of these, but there are certainly some bad trends with Jan the clapper's teams.


Iowa takes 33 3pt shots -- "This team needs to spread the perimeter and let it fly"
 
  • Like
Reactions: Scott559

AFM22

Heisman
Oct 31, 2022
23,917
45,962
113
So is this your account or Anon's account?
I thought Jan actually did a pretty good job coaching. She used her timeouts well to sub when MS came out aggressive. She put a squad out there that countered that. If the shots actually fell, it would be a different story.

Also... putting in Medina?? lol She has like 8 mintues and 2 shots on the year. What kind of spark are we expecting she'd give?

We need to stop giving these Hawkeye "fan accounts" so much credibility.
 

Jonesy5960

Heisman
Feb 1, 2023
7,739
16,078
113
I still believe that this Iowa team has the talent and pieces to be very good

I don't agree with all of these, but there are certainly some bad trends with Jan the clapper's teams.


This account is like a circle jerk of bad takes. I don't know who should be more embarrassed. The guy who created this or the guy who's reposting it.
 

AFM22

Heisman
Oct 31, 2022
23,917
45,962
113
Are we really posting that unhinged Twitter account on here now? A team that shot 33 3pt shots is feeding the post too much? Put Ava and Layla in at the same time, but stop feeding the post!!!
 
Hawkeye Report

Latest

  1. 01 Hawkeye Report Basketball Top takeaways from the Hawkeyes win over Montana State
  2. 02 Hawkeye Report Basketball PHOTO GALLERY: Iowa Women's Basketball vs Montana State
  3. 03 Hawkeye Report Football Game Preview: Iowa at Illinois
  4. 04 Hawkeye Report Basketball Tip Time Preview: Iowa at Xavier
  5. 05 Hawkeye Report Football The Friday Five