Who would you prefer as PSU’s 2027 QB

?

  • Alex Manske

  • Ethan Grunkemeyer

  • Jaxon Smolik

  • Malik Washington

  • Other (but you need to name your other)


Results are only viewable after voting.

Bison13

All-American
May 26, 2013
3,915
6,550
113
Prefer Grunk, I think he has the highest ceiling out of the group. Once Rocco came Grunk was leaving though.

I think Manske can be pretty good, especially if he’s got some wide receivers who he can throw to.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bbrown
Dec 14, 2021
571
821
93
Grunk is not coming back. Smolik isn't coming back. Washington is hurt and may or may not have lost the job last weekend. Back-up completed 19 straight passes. While Manske lacks in game experience, he has the advantage of time spent within the system. So, I would vote for Manske or someone better. I'm not saying there's no one out there, I just don't know who it is.
 

LMTLION

All-Conference
Mar 20, 2008
2,254
4,415
112
I would prefer a current backup with potential to compete against Manske for the starting job. We can then use the millions in savings to fill some big voids on the roster, like an elite edge, experienced upper level DT, and an elite wr to pair with Koby. Who knows what they will actually do. The portal season will be as exciting as the regular season.
 

Efejle

All-Conference
Apr 30, 2023
1,439
2,825
113
I hope it’s Manske because it would 100% be the best, most cost-efficient way to fill out the rest of the roster.
This. We have limited money but I think we absolutely have the guy in Manske. Bring in an FCS kid for insurance and allowcate all of the money for the biggest needs: Defensive Line, Wide receiver, and linebacker.

And for the love of Christ get a ******** punter.
 

o_PSUALREADYKNOW

Sophomore
Mar 9, 2022
162
196
43
Have we ever considered a smaller school is currently conveying Manske and has contacted HIM…is PSU unpoachable…what if someone paid him twice what we were planning to…could they flip him to a say “Delaware?” I’m just saying this knife cuts both ways now and the better Manske does…the more you pay him it the more someone else offers to. We are in it now boys…welcome to ‘Nam. Corso style.
 

Bvillebaron

All-Conference
Feb 4, 2004
3,450
3,358
113
Have we ever considered a smaller school is currently conveying Manske and has contacted HIM…is PSU unpoachable…what if someone paid him twice what we were planning to…could they flip him to a say “Delaware?” I’m just saying this knife cuts both ways now and the better Manske does…the more you pay him it the more someone else offers to. We are in it now boys…welcome to ‘Nam. Corso style.
No because that’s preposterous.
 

Steve JG

All-Conference
Mar 25, 2024
1,260
2,056
113
Have we ever considered a smaller school is currently conveying Manske and has contacted HIM…is PSU unpoachable…what if someone paid him twice what we were planning to…could they flip him to a say “Delaware?” I’m just saying this knife cuts both ways now and the better Manske does…the more you pay him it the more someone else offers to. We are in it now boys…welcome to ‘Nam. Corso style.
I have been cautioning this all fall as Becht sucked and Manske sat. I expect others been tampering. Would not be shocked if he portals
 

BCS PSU

All-Conference
Jun 2, 2001
1,551
2,580
113
I have been cautioning this all fall as Becht sucked and Manske sat. I expect others been tampering. Would not be shocked if he portals
Why would he portal if he's the leading candidate to be the starter next season and is playing for the coach who recruited him and whom he followed from his previous school? Unless we can get an elite or really good starter in the portal, which is unlikely, then I think that Manske will be the starter for better or worse next season. Also, you're talking about a kid who hasn't played much in his college career and had heart surgery earlier this year; if he's a candidate to portal, then that's just another sign about how absurd the current system has become. I mean, you're not talking about a Carson Beck, Cam Ward, Mendoza, Leavitt, Mensa, Dampier, etc.,, who actually had been starters for multiple seasons at D-1 schools.
 
Last edited:

Steve JG

All-Conference
Mar 25, 2024
1,260
2,056
113
Why would he portal if he's the leading candidate to be the starter next season and is playing for the coach who recruited him and whom he followed from his previous school? Unless we can get an elite or really good starter in the portal, which is unlikely, then I think that Manske will be the starter for better or worse next season. Also, you're talking about a kid who hasn't played much in his college career and had heart surgery earlier this year; if he's a candidate to portal, then that's just another sign about how absurd the current system has become. I mean, you're not talking about a Carson Beck, Cam Ward, Mendoza, Leavitt, Mensa, Dampier, etc.,, who actually had been starters for multiple seasons at D-1 schools.
$$$$$$$$$
 

Bison13

All-American
May 26, 2013
3,915
6,550
113
Have we ever considered a smaller school is currently conveying Manske and has contacted HIM…is PSU unpoachable…what if someone paid him twice what we were planning to…could they flip him to a say “Delaware?” I’m just saying this knife cuts both ways now and the better Manske does…the more you pay him it the more someone else offers to. We are in it now boys…welcome to ‘Nam. Corso style.
what smaller school has the money to offer him double what PSU would?

Delaware NIL is under a million total.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NedFromYork

LMTLION

All-Conference
Mar 20, 2008
2,254
4,415
112
Have we ever considered a smaller school is currently conveying Manske and has contacted HIM…is PSU unpoachable…what if someone paid him twice what we were planning to…could they flip him to a say “Delaware?” I’m just saying this knife cuts both ways now and the better Manske does…the more you pay him it the more someone else offers to. We are in it now boys…welcome to ‘Nam. Corso style.
Smaller schools are lining up to poach a backup QB, who has hardly played this year and recently had open-heart surgery. They don’t have the NIL to do it, but they have a lot of good intentions. Ridiculous.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BCS PSU and Bison13

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,240
4,826
113
Have we ever considered a smaller school is currently conveying Manske and has contacted HIM…is PSU unpoachable…what if someone paid him twice what we were planning to…could they flip him to a say “Delaware?” I’m just saying this knife cuts both ways now and the better Manske does…the more you pay him it the more someone else offers to. We are in it now boys…welcome to ‘Nam. Corso style.
It's highly unlikely but also why it was smart not to play him this year
 
  • Like
Reactions: o_PSUALREADYKNOW

BCS PSU

All-Conference
Jun 2, 2001
1,551
2,580
113
It's highly unlikely but also why it was smart not to play him this year
I would've liked to see him play a little more this season to get a better gauge of his abilities (I think that he's has some quality), and hopefully he can get several drives tomorrow if we have a comfortable lead in the second half, and possibly next week although I expect that Maryland will play us tough.
 
Last edited:

TheBigUglies

All-Conference
Oct 26, 2021
1,500
2,431
113
Morelli!!

Sorry, I have this vivid memory of sitting at a game at Beaver Stadium and this older Italian guy yelling "Put in Morelli" at the top of his lungs because the QB at the time was not getting it done. Can't remember the game or who the starting QB was at the time. :cool: 🤷‍♂️
 

ApexLion

Heisman
Nov 1, 2021
6,624
11,150
113
Manske but I also want this guy who apparently the staff knows:

The starting quarterback for the South Dakota Coyotes is redshirt freshman Austyn Modrzewski (#1)
    • Height / Weight: 6'5", 215 lbs [1]
    • Hometown: Littleton, Colorado (Mountain Vista High School) [1]
    • 2026 Stats: 182-of-263 passing (69.2%) for 2,482 yards, 32 passing touchdowns, and 7 interceptions
 

rigi19041

Junior
Apr 1, 2026
553
274
63
It's highly unlikely but also why it was smart not to play him this year

Hide your good players so you don't lose them. Did you support that plan when Franklin didn't play Howard?


Should you hide your good players as you are losing games?
 
Last edited:

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,240
4,826
113
Hide your good players so you don't lose them. Did you support that plan when Franklin didn't play Howard?


Should you hide your good players as you are losing games?
Lol no...if Manske should have started week 1 like Howard should have you play them. Manske was always QB2. Rocco is WAY better than our receivers were last year which his track record proves. The comparison might be one of the dumbest things I've seen my you whichever is impressive. See QB that have got paid handsomely simply based on a scrimmage known as a bowl game.
 

o_PSUALREADYKNOW

Sophomore
Mar 9, 2022
162
196
43
Hide your good players so you don't lose them. Did you support that plan when Franklin didn't play Howard?


Should you hide your good players as you are losing games?
It’s a very tough question…it’s super interesting to consider. The game of college football has become more like finesse poker mixed with who has the biggest wallet. It used to be “I wanted to go to Penn State because my dad wanted to go to Penn State 40 years ago.” Now it’s I want to go wherever I’m paid the most for my services. I think the cherry on top is that numerous college players are likely staying on a roster if possible when not good enough for the NFL and potentially filling a roster spot just to keep a salary.
 
BWI

Latest

  1. 01 BWI Recruiting Inside Lasch: New 2027 RPM logged to kick off massive recruiting weekend for Penn State
  2. 02 BWI Football Penn State 3-2-1: Improving offense, leadership decisions and a test of consistency
  3. 03 BWI Recruiting Over 70 prospects now confirmed for Penn State's home finale
  4. 04 BWI Football Penn State's Five Guys: Key Nittany Lions to watch on Senior Day
  5. 05 BWI Football 5 Penn State-Rutgers bold predictions: Picking a Lion to score his first TD since September; what will the final score be?