What do the Steelers do at QB next season?

BCS PSU

All-Conference
Jun 2, 2001
1,559
2,585
113
Is it Allar or Howard or Rudolph? Make a trade? Do we dare try the draft yet again?
I say this as a Steelers' season ticket holder, but that organization is so scared of doing what the Colts and Eagles now are doing and rebuilding properly while suffering through two or three bad seasons. So, because of this, you're left with playing with a 42 year old qb who no longer can throw deep balls.

They won't be in a positiopn to draft a really good college qb in 2027 (are there really any good ones this season anyway?), so my guess is that they will play with Rudolph, Howard and Allar, with Rudolph probably starting the season. I'd actually trade a No. 1 for Herbert, but the Chargers probably will try one more season with him.
 
Last edited:

PSUForever

All-Conference
Feb 17, 2007
2,207
2,249
113
I say this as a Steelers' season ticket holder, but that organization is so scared of doing what the Colts Eagles now are doing and rebuilding properly while suffering through two or three bad seasons. So, because of this, you're left with playing with a 42 year old qb who no longer can throw deep balls.

They won't be in a positiopn to draft a really good college qb in 2027 (are there really any good ones this season anyway?), so my guess is that they will play with Rudolph, Howard and Allar, with Rudolph probably starting the season. I'd actually trade a No. 1 for Herbert, but the Chargers probably will try one more season with him.
I have been saying for years that they need to rebuild. Because they have had an incompetent GM for many years along with Tomlin staying 5 years too long the Steelers are in this bad position. I like the idea of trading for Herbert. Not sold that Allar, Howard or Rudolph is the answer.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bison13

BCS PSU

All-Conference
Jun 2, 2001
1,559
2,585
113
I have been saying for years that they need to rebuild. Because they have had an incompetent GM for many years along with Tomlin staying 5 years too long the Steelers are in this bad position. I like the idea of trading for Herbert. Not sold that Allar, Howard or Rudolph is the answer.
I think that once Herbert gets away from the Chargers, he could be like a Jim Plunkett when he went to the Raiders; he has all of the tangibles, but his intangibles are questionable. However, I just think that he's been beaten down by playing for that organization.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MacNit and Bison13

rigi19041

Junior
Apr 1, 2026
563
283
63
I think that once Herbert gets away from the Chargers, he could be like a Jim Plunkett when he went to the Raiders; he has all of the tangibles, but his intangibles are questionable. However, I just think that he's been beaten down by playing for that organization.

Mario Cristobal ruined him.
 

LionJim

Heisman
Oct 12, 2021
16,933
23,231
113
I think that once Herbert gets away from the Chargers, he could be like a Jim Plunkett when he went to the Raiders; he has all of the tangibles, but his intangibles are questionable. However, I just think that he's been beaten down by playing for Jim Harbaugh.
Fixed.
 

LionJim

Heisman
Oct 12, 2021
16,933
23,231
113
0-1 for the Redskins.
Huh.

Edit: Kruczek started one game for Washington, in 1980. I was in Knoxville at the time which is my excuse for not knowing of his connection to the Redskins. Seven games started, zero touchdown passes. 👍🏻 All respect, he has two Super Bowl rings.
 
Last edited:

PSUForever

All-Conference
Feb 17, 2007
2,207
2,249
113
I think that once Herbert gets away from the Chargers, he could be like a Jim Plunkett when he went to the Raiders; he has all of the tangibles, but his intangibles are questionable. However, I just think that he's been beaten down by playing for that organization.
He has regressed this year and it probably started last year going from 3 picks in '24 to 13 in '25. He is only 28 so young enough to still have a lot in the tank.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bison13

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,485
4,859
113
Wait--does anyone want Herbert right now? Honestly, the Chargers will keep him though and hope that adding Jeremiah Smith or Charlie Becker can solve their problems.
 

Bison13

All-American
May 26, 2013
3,921
6,556
113
Who do we give up to get Herbert? Not that the Stillers have the balls to do it.
Unless he is this bad all year, I would guess he still would be worth a #1 this year, a #1 the next and another mid round pick. His biggest issue may be his contract though, trading him is a 72 million cap hit to the chargers, so I doubt he goes anywhere.
 

Still in State Colllege

All-Conference
Oct 12, 2021
641
1,088
93
Wait--does anyone want Herbert right now? Honestly, the Chargers will keep him though and hope that adding Jeremiah Smith or Charlie Becker can solve their problems.
I know I'm in the minority but I don't think Smith is as much of a lock as some think. I thought Harrison was as much of a sure thing as there could be. I saw Indiana clamp down Smith.
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,485
4,859
113
I know I'm in the minority but I don't think Smith is as much of a lock as some think. I thought Harrison was as much of a sure thing as there could be. I saw Indiana clamp down Smith.
Anything is possible. Harrison lacked speed but I did think he was going to be great like his dad. Going off memory but Smith had a handful of catches for 75ish yards and a score against a team that doubled him on 95% of plays. That's impressive to me. Sayin was a bigger issue than Smith to me. JMO
 

PSUForever

All-Conference
Feb 17, 2007
2,207
2,249
113
It would be cool to see Allar do well as the starter for the Stillers buy I'm not holding my breath.

Maybe if Allar, Howard and Rudolph all bomb and the Stillers lose 13 games next year (not intentionally) then we are in position for a top 5 pick at QB.
 

Bvillebaron

All-Conference
Feb 4, 2004
3,460
3,361
113
Anything is possible. Harrison lacked speed but I did think he was going to be great like his dad. Going off memory but Smith had a handful of catches for 75ish yards and a score against a team that doubled him on 95% of plays. That's impressive to me. Sayin was a bigger issue than Smith to me. JMO
👍
 

Dbsteel

Junior
Jan 15, 2014
219
310
63
They are afraid to tank. So they will probably start with Mason and hope for 9-8.

I'm fine with starting with Mason if the plan is to bring in Allar the second he starts bombing. They could draft a first rounder too. And they better get receivers or its more of the same crap offense.

They need to dump some high priced old guys though including TJ Watt, Heyward, etc.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bbrown

Yogiman71

Senior
Oct 20, 2001
565
863
93
Some talk about MсСarthy having good results working with Drew among Pittsburgh media and local podcasts there. I hope Drew gets a good shot.
 
BWI

Latest

  1. 01 BWI Football Tony Rojas leads Penn State's defense, undecided on future
  2. 02 BWI Football 7 things I think after Penn State's stunning loss to Rutgers: Matt Campbell and co., have a big problem on their hands
  3. 03 BWI Football Everything Matt Campbell said after Penn State's loss to Rutgers
  4. 04 BWI Football What did Rutgers coach Greg Schiano, Penn State players, say about the Scarlet Knights' upset win?
  5. 05 BWI Football Why did Zion Tracy not play on Saturday, and what did Matt Campbell think of the Penn State defense without him?