IOWA #15 in the 3rd CFP Rankings (Nov 17). "Clearly the decal matters quite a bit to this committee."

Kceasthawk@77

All-American
Feb 2, 2005
5,101
8,710
113
Klatt is roasting the committee, as are many and it needs to be heard whether they listen or not.
Klatt is roasting the committee, as are many and it needs to be heard whether they listen or not.
Literally EVERYONE not tied to the SEC is calling out this sham, and even some of them not named Bama are starting to wonder WTF is going on.....
 

Kceasthawk@77

All-American
Feb 2, 2005
5,101
8,710
113
There is way to much on the line to allow these rankings to play out like this. Literally, tens of millions of $$$. You have legacies, history, jobs are on the line. CFP success effects admissions and university revenue. It effects branding. With home CFP games you get an additional major revenue boost. This effects recruiting and the portal.

I could go on and on. I don’t understand how there can be consensus to this level, yet nothing will change. Even next year when we go to 24.. you can manipulate rankings leading to a bye, a home field advantage, or a favorable matchup.

There’s way to much on the line to allow this level of subjectivity to drive the rankings.


Including that fun thing they like to post how Iowa has the most wins of any team that hasn't made the playoff. I wonder how that keeps happening??
 

Kceasthawk@77

All-American
Feb 2, 2005
5,101
8,710
113
42 pt margin of victory, jumped 2 slots, and in the current CFP.

You're flailing and looking like a bigger fool with every post.

Congrats?
Run back to your little safe space on the other forum.
Lololol.. Literally EVERYONE on here knows you're the biggest tool on this forum, and you're not an Iowa fan. Keep saying you are doesn't make you one either. Keep posting your nonsense though, its entertaining anyway....
 

Nvhwk

Senior
Mar 20, 2025
224
410
63
FOUR 6-4 SEC teams make the Top 25.

The SEC bias and love fest continue.

3 LOSS Ohio State jumps 6 spots (from #20 to #14).

3 LOSS Oregon jumps IOWA, too.

This committee continues to prove that it is an absolute joke.

#14 Ohio State (7-3)
#13 Oregon (7-3)
#12 Texas Tech (9-1)
#11 Wake Forest (9-1)

The CFP Top 25:
  1. Georgia (9-1)
  2. Utah (10-0)
  3. Alabama (8-2)
  4. UCLA (10-0)
  5. Texas (8-2)
  6. Notre Dame (9-1)
  7. Miami (9-1)
  8. Indiana (9-1)
  9. Tennessee (8-2)
  10. BYU (8-2)
  11. Wake Forest (9-1)
  12. Texas Tech (9-1)
  13. Oregon (7-3)
  14. Ohio State (7-3)
  15. Iowa (8-2)
  16. Kentucky (7-3)
  17. Boise State (9-1)
  18. USC (7-3)
  19. Arizona (7-3)
  20. Houston (7-3)
  21. South Carolina (6-4)
  22. Oklahoma (6-4)
  23. Louisville (7-3)
  24. Florida (6-4)
  25. Ole Miss (6-4)


Scott Dochterman

45m ago
Scott Dochterman·
Staff Writer, Big Ten

Interesting that the committee moved Ohio State up six spots after beating Northwestern 28-19 at home one week after Iowa beat Northwestern 24-10 in Evanston. Clearly the decal matters quite a bit to this committee.
It is all about the money.
 

BigOHawk1

All-Conference
Oct 27, 2001
679
1,263
93
I wonder if there is any type of correction next week or does the 'committee' double or triple down on this sham of a rankings system. I've never seen such a vile reaction nationally to something like this outside of ESPN and the SEC conf. Literally paid big time media members on FOX, etc calling it out and bascially putting their own necks on the line. Hmmm...
 

BigOHawk1

All-Conference
Oct 27, 2001
679
1,263
93
For me, now it's about getting ahead of OSU and Oregon to prove a point, I'm not sold on Wake/Tech/BYU, etc losing so it might give the fans and team some juice and vindication getting back ahead of the so called blue bloods. As mentioned, a Gopher win in NO WAY would've punched a 100% ticket to the playoff, I think they would've called it a non quality win and kept us at 12-13 until somebody in front went down.
 

iahawkeyes17

All-Conference
Apr 22, 2014
967
2,428
83

Anon1755405505

Freshman
Aug 16, 2025
70
90
18
It is all about the money.

It’s funny I read this article and thought iowa will sure be on it. Nope, not even an honorable mention. Not one single word but they include 2 loss Tennessee who is already in the top 10 and an unranked 6-4 mizzou.

Wait until next year when they start putting the 5 loss SEC teams in the playoffs.;)
 

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,314
29,542
113

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,314
29,542
113
We sure did find out.

full text of the tweet (before the top 25 were revealed):

Tonight we find what this committee is all about.

Bama beat 4-6 Vandy and its resume still took three hits. It's "best" wins all lost. Kentucky. LSU. South Carolina got blown out 34-6 at Arkansas.

Last week the committee dropped Indiana five spots on a BYE week, so if Alabama is still No. 3 on Tuesday night, we'll all know exactly what this is.


 

LetsGoHawks83

All-American
Mar 20, 2015
4,024
7,983
113
Don't trip on their dicks against Minn and Iowa is in. Gave the committee a reason to leave them out. Nothing Iowa can do to get in at this point. Is what it is.

It's the FACT that the logo on your helmet has this much.

You know that OSU with the EXACT same results in the exact same games as Iowa would be ranked about #10.

Iowa with the EXACT same results as OSU in the EXACT same games... I'm guessing they are in the 20s.

That's bias and it's BS that they are doing so blatantly and they really don't care
 

LetsGoHawks83

All-American
Mar 20, 2015
4,024
7,983
113
Oregon lost to Illinois. If we beat them, we have a direct comparable data point. Lots of games left to be played. I’ll let it all play out before passing judgment on whether the best 11 teams made it or not.

The committee has made it clear. If all teams keep winning, we aren't jumping OSU or Oregon. They jump us when we both win, but not the other way around.

Remember we beat NW easily on the road and barely moved. OSU beat them by less and jumps 6 spots and jumps us.

Logo is the only difference. Logo
 

LetsGoHawks83

All-American
Mar 20, 2015
4,024
7,983
113
South Carolina (6-4) gets destroyed by 6 LOSS Arkansas and is still ranked.


The CFP Top 25:
  1. Georgia (9-1)
  2. Utah (10-0)
  3. Alabama (8-2)
  4. UCLA (10-0)
  5. Texas (8-2)
  6. Notre Dame (9-1)
  7. Miami (9-1)
  8. Indiana (9-1)
  9. Tennessee (8-2)
  10. BYU (8-2)
  11. Wake Forest (9-1)
  12. Texas Tech (9-1)
  13. Oregon (7-3)
  14. Ohio State (7-3)
  15. IOWA (8-2)
  16. Kentucky (7-3)
  17. Boise State (9-1)
  18. USC (7-3)
  19. Arizona (7-3)
  20. Houston (7-3)
  21. South Carolina (6-4)
  22. Oklahoma (6-4)
  23. Louisville (7-3)
  24. Florida (6-4)
  25. Ole Miss (6-4)

Yea.... That's insanity. If we lost to Purdue, we would have dropped to like 30. Complete BS
 
  • Like
Reactions: Franisdaman

LetsGoHawks83

All-American
Mar 20, 2015
4,024
7,983
113
The thing is.... Since it is humans on this committee, they are probably going to just dig in further after getting called out all week.

Bring back the computers! Yes, you can still end up with bias, but at least you can systematically reduce those and have a committee with equal conference representation sign off on the metrics used.

You can run multiple PREVIOUS seasons worth of results to see what the end results are and if that is anywhere close to how the results on the field during the playoffs finished.

Then you have the computer SET and unadjusted during the year, so there's no human element deciding based on emotions or outside pressure.
 
Hawkeye Report

Latest

  1. 01 Hawkeye Report Football Recruiting Inside the rankings on Iowa's 2028 recruiting class
  2. 02 Hawkeye Report Football Recruiting Tracking where Iowa's recruits play this week
  3. 03 Hawkeye Report Football Throwback Thursday: Looking back at Illinois' starters as recruits
  4. 04 Hawkeye Report Football Throwback Thursday: Looking back at Iowa's starters as recruits
  5. 05 Hawkeye Report Basketball Ben McCollum talks recruiting, previews Xavier