Poll: Rafters, who do we want as our next coach & why?

Who do you want as our next coach and why?

  • Tommy Lloyd (Arizona)

    Votes: 45 25.1%
  • Nate Oats (Bama)

    Votes: 71 39.7%
  • Ben McCollum (Iowa)

    Votes: 21 11.7%
  • T.J. Otzelberger (Iowa St)

    Votes: 18 10.1%
  • Grant McCasland (Texas Tech)

    Votes: 14 7.8%
  • Josh Schertz (Saint Louis)

    Votes: 49 27.4%
  • Jai Lucas (Miami)

    Votes: 36 20.1%
  • Mark Byington (Vanderbilt)

    Votes: 11 6.1%
  • Ryan Odom (Virginia)

    Votes: 22 12.3%
  • Scott Drew (Baylor)

    Votes: 5 2.8%

  • Total voters
    179

Anon1739778738

All-Conference
Feb 17, 2025
863
1,237
93
"For every Todd Golden there are about 10 Shaka Smart’s."

Shaka Smart took VCU to the Final four, he wasn't some unproven, had done nothing coach.
"For every Todd Golden there are about 10 Shaka Smart’s."

Shaka Smart took VCU to the Final four, he wasn't some unproven, had done nothing coach.
Smart hasn't done anything since that final four and is grossly over rated
 

Wildcatmenace

All-Conference
Oct 29, 2025
1,433
2,120
113
B
Not sure you realize how dire it's been in Bloomington.

Since Cal joined UK, they've had 4 coaches.

Since the 2003-2004 season, only made it to tourney 9/23 seasons, haven't gotten past the S16, which Crean did 3x. 10 total tourney wins.

Funny looking back, as the brass there had such a big ego they moved off Crean, who after cleaning up the Sampson fiasco (which was BS in retro), finished off his last 6 seasons with 3 S16s and 4 strong seasons. It's been a disaster ever since. The NCAA has some blame with Indiana going down, as we know now if Sampson stuck, Indiana would have been a winner.

These coaching hires matter.
Bet they wish Sampson was at IU the past few years
 

Wildcatmenace

All-Conference
Oct 29, 2025
1,433
2,120
113
I really like Oats. I like that he had success at Buffalo and Alabama. I like that he took Alabama to the final four and puts good rosters together. I also like his analytical approach and fire like competitiveness. It reminds me of Cal and Pitino
Don’t forget temperament, that’s huge for this job.
 

CrimsonCats_rivals

All-Conference
Mar 22, 2022
1,825
3,783
61
Yeah until something better is offered. Easy to say you’d never date a supermodel when one hasn’t approached you.
He literally turned down UNC earlier this year. As did May, Lloyd, McCollum, and probably Donovan that we pretty well know of publicly. The era of coaches viewing power conference jobs where they’re already winning as merely stepping stones to blue bloods seems to be over.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BookofMormon

The Ganner

All-Conference
Nov 21, 2009
515
1,410
93
He wasn't on any of our lists of even being a possibility until the night it said that he would be hired.

He is undeniably the least accomplished coach to take the reigns here since well before Rupp. At least Gillispie made a Sweet 16 before being hired.
Take away the existing connection to UK. Say it was UNC making a list of coaches to call up about a vacancy. If you made a list with 30 names on it, Pope wouldn't have been one.
 

BookofMormon

All-Conference
Mar 27, 2026
1,501
2,016
113
He literally turned down UNC earlier this year. As did May, Lloyd, McCollum, and probably Donovan that we pretty well know of publicly. The era of coaches viewing power conference jobs where they’re already winning as merely stepping stones to blue bloods seems to be over.
Bingo, pool will not be large.

As for Shaka, he stinks. He's won 3 tournament games total since VCU across Texas & Marquette. I wouldn't surprised if he's on the hot seat after this season at Marquette as players look like they're regressing under him.

The OAD period between 2010-2015 when VCU got to the F4 was perhaps the worst quality of college hoops we've seen in the last 40 years. There were a number of mid majors in the F4, low seeds and OAD champions. None of that is happening today.

I honestly think the pool of candidates for this job will be Oats and then up & comers.
 

JakeKx

All-Conference
Oct 5, 2023
1,524
2,962
112
I don’t like oats but at this point there’s simply no better options.
the names you would want simply aren’t coming here
 

L.O.D.

All-Conference
Feb 4, 2024
1,374
1,785
77
Donovan, Pearl, Vogel should be asked first . Then Oats welcomed in. Donovan would be a splash that fixes brand instantly imo thata what we need. I wouldn't cry over Oats tho
 
  • Like
Reactions: jrpross_rivals

BookofMormon

All-Conference
Mar 27, 2026
1,501
2,016
113
Donovan, Pearl, Vogel should be asked first . Then Oats welcomed in. Donovan would be a splash that fixes brand instantly imo thata what we need. I wouldn't cry over Oats tho
Oats is a better selection than Donovan. Anyone wanting Donovan loves his name. Oats is current, has a system, experienced in NIL/portal, knows the SEC, is much younger.
 

aTinWoodsman

All-Conference
Mar 9, 2015
946
1,631
93
Jai Lucas, dude knows the ins and outs of college basketball and has extremely deep recruiting roots. Give him 20+ million NIL and we're probably going to the elite 8 year 1.
 

HeismanWinner

All-Conference
Sep 12, 2025
1,521
3,630
113
He literally turned down UNC earlier this year. As did May, Lloyd, McCollum, and probably Donovan that we pretty well know of publicly. The era of coaches viewing power conference jobs where they’re already winning as merely stepping stones to blue bloods seems to be over.
That’s correct. But who knows what happens in a year. Life is funny. We do have more money than Iowa State though.
Bingo, pool will not be large.

As for Shaka, he stinks. He's won 3 tournament games total since VCU across Texas & Marquette. I wouldn't surprised if he's on the hot seat after this season at Marquette as players look like they're regressing under him.

The OAD period between 2010-2015 when VCU got to the F4 was perhaps the worst quality of college hoops we've seen in the last 40 years. There were a number of mid majors in the F4, low seeds and OAD champions. None of that is happening today.

I honestly think the pool of candidates for this job will be Oats and then up & comers.
Alabama has more money than we do. What would be the point?
 

BigBlue1992

All-Conference
Apr 17, 2011
2,053
3,839
81
I disagree with those wanting an up and comer. The last two up and comers we got failed miserably. And if you don’t consider Billy and Pope up and comers, then I’ll label them as non qualified.

After Cal left, I thought hiring Pitino would be great. I feel that his time has now passed. First choice is Billy Donovan for me. Second option might be Pearl but I’d have to think about it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BlueSince92

HeismanWinner

All-Conference
Sep 12, 2025
1,521
3,630
113
No they don’t. They’re tier 3 in NIL. UK is tier 1.
Bama has way more money than we do in terms of revenue. They're like a top three school in the country regarding that.

NIL wise, our money is more concentrated in basketball whereas most of their's is focused on football but Bama absolutely has more money than UK in terms of an athletic department.
 

RunninRichie

Heisman
Sep 5, 2019
30,772
74,479
113
Bama has way more money than we do in terms of revenue. They're like a top three school in the country regarding that.

NIL wise, our money is more concentrated in basketball whereas most of their's is focused on football but Bama absolutely has more money than UK in terms of an athletic department.
They’re below UK in basketball NIL. Oats would have double the NIL here.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HeismanWinner

KyWilson239

Senior
Jan 17, 2016
254
555
93
Oats is a good coach and would do well here. My pick was Mccasland if I could have anyone, but I would be fine with either. Problem as I see it is, Popes buyout is around $17M, Oats buyout is $18M. So now we are $35M in and we will need to pay Oats $8-10M per on top of that. Plus Stein will need a raise if we don't want to lose him.
UK spent $22M in basketball and $25M in football on NIL. By comparison, Texas spent $52M in football NIL alone. I cant see us spending north of $50M in buyouts and coaches salaries and then getting an increase on our $50M or so NIL. So I think the realistic thing is a coach without a buyout. Which brings me back to Pearl. Added bonus for Pearl....he could be here by the time we lace em up against Indiana
Oats is the guy IMO. I believe Oats drops to $12m after April 1. As long as Pope doesn't reach a s16 his buyout would be about $9m on the same date, it also is paid out in monthly installment and would require him to seek other jobs in which the salary would offset his buyout. Not chump change, but I bet we have boosters that would pay to make it happen. An Oats contract probably starts around $8m, with an average salary in the $9m range over 5-6 years.

Rumor is that there is already $40m+ promised to Stein for football next year, his staff will most likely get raises, but he is likely to stay on the same contract.
 

Blue Jesus

Senior
Aug 24, 2013
582
883
93
Rafters, who would you realistically want as UK's next basketball coach, and why? I'm not talking about making a rushed hire. I'm curious who you hope Batt is already quietly putting feelers out to and who you believe could actually get us back to competing for Final Fours and national championships.
I'm curious why Schertz has more votes than McCollum, who, along a similar trajectory, has been more successful and is younger than Schertz, unless it's just people think it's less likely McCollum would take the job since he's at Iowa vs St Louis (probably true, but certainly worth a shot). It will be interesting to see how McCollum looks this year without his stud PG. But as it stands now I would love to see UK go after McCollum. I especially liked the way he went right back at Todd Golden in the NCAA tournament last year.
 

BookofMormon

All-Conference
Mar 27, 2026
1,501
2,016
113
I'm curious why Schertz has more votes than McCollum, who, along a similar trajectory, has been more successful and is younger than Schertz, unless it's just people think it's less likely McCollum would take the job since he's at Iowa vs St Louis (probably true, but certainly worth a shot). It will be interesting to see how McCollum looks this year without his stud PG. But as it stands now I would love to see UK go after McCollum. I especially liked the way he went right back at Todd Golden in the NCAA tournament last year.
Probably because Schertz is much more realistic. McCollum ain't moving, UNC went after him and he said no thanks. Iowa already lost a close one to Creighton.
 

peterpiper09

All-Conference
Mar 19, 2006
1,535
3,080
112
My thinking has changed a whole lot over the years and right now my thinking is this:

I wish there’s some way we could put Kelvin Sampson in a Time Machine and go back 10 years and hire him. His teams play so hard and exert so much effort, especially on defense. It’s hard to tell what he could have accomplished here with our resources. There’s a reason they say defense wins championships. He has freaking Houston right there every year. They just said that they have 9 or 10 new players and they’re playing right with Florida. You have to find the right dudes who are willing to put out 100% effort on the floor.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Anon726530

Ukbrassowtipin

Heisman
Aug 12, 2011
82,426
90,544
113
I disagree with those wanting an up and comer. The last two up and comers we got failed miserably. And if you don’t consider Billy and Pope up and comers, then I’ll label them as non qualified.

After Cal left, I thought hiring Pitino would be great. I feel that his time has now passed. First choice is Billy Donovan for me. Second option might be Pearl but I’d have to think about it.
So you would've passed on Todd golden and dan hurley before florida and uconn hired them
 

BigBlue1992

All-Conference
Apr 17, 2011
2,053
3,839
81
So you would've passed on Todd golden and dan hurley before florida and uconn hired them
That’s two out of how many that fail? Especially at blue blood programs. Anything past getting to the tournament at Florida is a bonus for Todd Golden. He has a fraction of the pressure there as he’d have at UK.

And that’s kinda silly of a statement. Every good coach, player, whatever was once an up and comer lol. I’m just saying MANY never pan out or become qualified for top tier jobs.
 
Last edited:
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Football Kenny Darby makes Kentucky history with two freshman receiving records
  2. 02 KSR Football LIVE BLOG: No. 16 Kentucky at Missouri
  3. 03 KSR Football Listen to KSR's Pregame Show before Kentucky vs. Mizzou
  4. 04 KSR A Brief History of Weird Football Between Kentucky and Missouri
  5. 05 KSR Football Chops Comes Home: The Man Behind the Meme