IOWA #15 in the 3rd CFP Rankings (Nov 17). "Clearly the decal matters quite a bit to this committee."

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,300
29,526
113
The results of last night are nothing more than the PR machine pushing brands and it started last Sunday…

Nothing else can explain 3 teams in the same conference completely switching places a week after all 3 teams won their games…

And oddly enough, teams 13 and 14 beat two teams at home this past weekend that Iowa beat on the road earlier this year as well…yet we stay put and they move up…

If the order wasn’t so drastically different last week, it may make sense…but that’s not the case…


 

Kohawks99

Junior
Jan 3, 2023
82
246
33
He speaks the truth. So I ask again WHERE is Petitti in all of this? Quite as a church mouse. I'd bet if the roles were reversed you'd be hearing plenty from Greg Sankey
He should definitely be saying something about the BIG as a whole, but I doubt he'd say anything about Iowa specifically, because the other two teams that jumped us, for no reason, are BIG teams also
 

iahawkeyes17

All-Conference
Apr 22, 2014
967
2,427
83

His analogy was spot on. When talking about ranking bama too high and it’s like when driving when you get lost and refuse to admit it. Committee refuses to do so with them.

another interesting point he said reason 13-15 goes that order was Oregon beat OSU who beat Iowa. But then committee ignores that some logic when it ranks 2 loss sec teams with bama, Texas and Tenn.
 

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,300
29,526
113
His analogy was spot on. When talking about ranking bama too high and it’s like when driving when you get lost and refuse to admit it. Committee refuses to do so with them.

another interesting point he said reason 13-15 goes that order was Oregon beat OSU who beat Iowa. But then committee ignores that some logic when it ranks 2 loss sec teams with bama, Texas and Tenn.

that's why i honestly think you need to enter consistent, fair data into computers each week and have the computers rank the teams

this way the goal post never moves, even though you may not like the output

humans, clearly, really suck at this
 

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,300
29,526
113
There is way to much on the line to allow these rankings to play out like this. Literally, tens of millions of $$$. You have legacies, history, jobs are on the line. CFP success effects admissions and university revenue. It effects branding. With home CFP games you get an additional major revenue boost. This effects recruiting and the portal.

I could go on and on. I don’t understand how there can be consensus to this level, yet nothing will change. Even next year when we go to 24.. you can manipulate rankings leading to a bye, a home field advantage, or a favorable matchup.

There’s way to much on the line to allow this level of subjectivity to drive the rankings.

 

10001110101

All-Conference
Sep 1, 2003
1,333
1,792
113
His analogy was spot on. When talking about ranking bama too high and it’s like when driving when you get lost and refuse to admit it. Committee refuses to do so with them.
I think it's a bad analogy. Getting lost while driving is accidental.

None of the committee's bias and corruption is accidental.

The "refuse to admit it" part is spot on. But of course they're not gonna admit they have no integrity.
 

RuggieC

All-Conference
Mar 30, 2014
658
1,309
93

So true....I was listening thinking "are they going to say something???" What a joke this committee is. Such a heavy lean to the SEC and a few name brands with too many losses. Shut this damn thing down for next year otherwise you will see 10 SEC teams in the 24 team field. Many with 4 losses. Joke.
 

Kceasthawk@77

All-American
Feb 2, 2005
5,101
8,709
113
He should definitely be saying something about the BIG as a whole, but I doubt he'd say anything about Iowa specifically, because the other two teams that jumped us, for no reason, are BIG teams also
It would be nice if he would say something. And for the record he's supposed to be the commish for the conference NOT teams that start with an O.
 

Kceasthawk@77

All-American
Feb 2, 2005
5,101
8,709
113
I think Iowa jumps Oregon if the hawks beat Illinois. That supplies another kicker since Oregon lost to Illinois by 11.
I'll eat some crow , willingly, if Iowa ends up a head of OSU and Oregon after the last regular season game. More then a week ago they were talking about OSU and Oregon being still in the hunt, and NEVER once mentioned an Iowa team that was several spots a head of them in the poll. I think they moved them up knowing 1) neither of them is getting in anyway 2) because that way they can fend off some of the complaining about highly ranked SEC teams with multiple losses.
 

Kceasthawk@77

All-American
Feb 2, 2005
5,101
8,709
113
that's why i honestly think you need to enter consistent, fair data into computers each week and have the computers rank the teams

this way the goal post never moves, even though you may not like the output

humans, clearly, really suck at this
that's why i honestly think you need to enter consistent, fair data into computers each week and have the computers rank the teams

this way the goal post never moves, even though you may not like the output

humans, clearly, really suck at this
BUT, WHO is entering the data? Garbage in equals garbage out.....
 
Hawkeye Report

Latest

  1. 01 Hawkeye Report Football Recruiting Tracking where Iowa's recruits play this week
  2. 02 Hawkeye Report Football Throwback Thursday: Looking back at Illinois' starters as recruits
  3. 03 Hawkeye Report Football Throwback Thursday: Looking back at Iowa's starters as recruits
  4. 04 Hawkeye Report Basketball Ben McCollum talks recruiting, previews Xavier
  5. 05 Hawkeye Report Basketball Iowa Women's Basketball Tip Time Preview: Montana State Bobcats