AJ Swann officially out.

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
61,472
33,336
113
Not a surprise. So who gets the snaps Saturday? Puckett, McWhorter, or Rashada? Some combination of the three? I think I would had the starting job to McWhorter and let him play the whole game unless he just completely sucks. There's zero future (and really nearly zero present) with either of the other two, so no use wasting snaps on them.
 

GOOD_DAWG

Freshman
Sep 1, 2012
124
57
18
Not a surprise. So who gets the snaps Saturday? Puckett, McWhorter, or Rashada? Some combination of the three? I think I would had the starting job to McWhorter and let him play the whole game unless he just completely sucks. There's zero future (and really nearly zero present) with either of the other two, so no use wasting snaps on them.
Literally anyone but Billy puckett
 

QuadrupleOption

All-Conference
Aug 21, 2012
1,303
1,450
93
Not a surprise. So who gets the snaps Saturday? Puckett, McWhorter, or Rashada? Some combination of the three? I think I would had the starting job to McWhorter and let him play the whole game unless he just completely sucks. There's zero future (and really nearly zero present) with either of the other two, so no use wasting snaps on them.
witcher-****.gif
 

Dawgzilla2

All-Conference
Oct 9, 2022
2,870
3,331
113
Not a surprise. So who gets the snaps Saturday? Puckett, McWhorter, or Rashada? Some combination of the three? I think I would had the starting job to McWhorter and let him play the whole game unless he just completely sucks. There's zero future (and really nearly zero present) with either of the other two, so no use wasting snaps on them.
What difference does it make if he completely sucks?
 

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
61,472
33,336
113
when we played all 3 last weekend, I knew the season was well past lost, and that Lebby has no business as head coach.

my only answer to a good question would be that we play the one who will be the legitimate and serviceable back up to Kamario
In his defense, Swann played until he got injured. He should have never brought him back in after the injury though. After Swann, we're pretty much screwed whatever we do.
 
  • Like
Reactions: skip dog

GOOD_DAWG

Freshman
Sep 1, 2012
124
57
18
I keep thinking that maybe he will develop some, due to the experience.

I think maybe you start him and hope for the best, then bring in McWhorter.
Would not surprise me if they end up splitting snaps.

At this point, the hope has to be that Swann will be healthy for Oxford. Not that it matters lol
 

Bullldawg78

All-Conference
Aug 30, 2018
1,937
1,651
113
when we played all 3 last weekend, I knew the season was well past lost, and that Lebby has no business as head coach.

my only answer to a good question would be that we play the one who will be the legitimate and serviceable back up to Kamario
Is that an option currently on the roster?
 

SanfordRJones

Senior
Nov 17, 2006
1,389
514
113
Swann would have won us games imo

Which ones? Definitely not Alabama or LSU. Maybe Oklahoma? He played against Texas and got his as$ whipped, so definitely not that one. He played in the Vandy game. Maybe if he was healthy the result would have been different, but that was always going to be an impossible task for a statue playing behind that sieve of an offensive line.
 

Chesusdog

All-American
May 2, 2006
5,223
5,741
113
Can you imagine if Rashada plays and he's light years ahead of Puckett and Swann? I don't think Rashada touches the field at all.
I really want to know the story here. From multi-million dollar NIL deal with Florida to Georgia to Sacremento State to here. How does one go from being offered millions to not even being mentioned as a possibility behind the likes of Puckett and Swann?
 

GOOD_DAWG

Freshman
Sep 1, 2012
124
57
18
Which ones? Definitely not Alabama or LSU. Maybe Oklahoma? He played against Texas and got his as$ whipped, so definitely not that one. He played in the Vandy game. Maybe if he was healthy the result would have been different, but that was always going to be an impossible task for a statue playing behind that sieve of an offensive line.
Think LSU, Oklahoma, Auburn, UT all look different with a qb that was capable of throwing the ball down the field. Not saying we would have won all of those games.
 

Seinfeld

All-American
Nov 30, 2006
11,784
8,255
113
when we played all 3 last weekend, I knew the season was well past lost, and that Lebby has no business as head coach.

my only answer to a good question would be that we play the one who will be the legitimate and serviceable back up to Kamario
Yeah, Lebby may as well have been holding a sign that said “I don’t know what the 17 else to do, so if you’re alive and breathing, get your *** out there”
 
Last edited:

GOOD_DAWG

Freshman
Sep 1, 2012
124
57
18
I'm not sure that he would have started at Millsaps or Belhaven.

He started against Texas and got beat by 4 touchdowns.
Im working under the assumption that Swann has been hurt the whole season and was not listed on the injury report for whatever reason. Hence, why Billy Puckett was the first backup we saw after Kamario’s injury
 

Seinfeld

All-American
Nov 30, 2006
11,784
8,255
113
Hand the ball off to Fluff. Don't overthink this, Lebby.

Brandon Scott Jones Ghosts GIF by CBS
 
  • Haha
Reactions: ckDOG

johnson86-1

All-American
Aug 22, 2012
15,303
5,857
113
Not a surprise. So who gets the snaps Saturday? Puckett, McWhorter, or Rashada? Some combination of the three? I think I would had the starting job to McWhorter and let him play the whole game unless he just completely sucks. There's zero future (and really nearly zero present) with either of the other two, so no use wasting snaps on them.

when we played all 3 last weekend, I knew the season was well past lost, and that Lebby has no business as head coach.

my only answer to a good question would be that we play the one who will be the legitimate and serviceable back up to Kamario
This is the answer, with a focus on next year. If McWhorter can't beat Tn Tech, then he's not going to be a serviceable back up next year either, unless there is a reason to think he is way behind in development (like he ran the option in high school or only played QB his last year) and will be serviceable as a backup next year.

If we play Puckett, the bright side is that we will be advertising to a young QB that they can come in and be a backup next year, have a decent chance of playing that year based on KT's injury history so far, and most likely will be first on the depth chart their second year and just have to compete against new recruits and transfers. Although there's a decent chance it will be for a new coach, so...
 

SanfordRJones

Senior
Nov 17, 2006
1,389
514
113
Im working under the assumption that Swann has been hurt the whole season and was not listed on the injury report for whatever reason. Hence, why Billy Puckett was the first backup we saw after Kamario’s injury

Maybe you're right. I just chalked it up to Lebby being a moron.
 
  • Like
Reactions: patdog
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White "There will be an opportunity for Brodie": Mississippi State HC Jeff Lebby sets freshman up for Saturday runout
  2. 02 Maroon and White Chris Jans proud of Mississippi State's "must-win" performance on the road at UCF
  3. 03 Maroon and White Football Injury Update: QB AJ Swann and S Isaac Smith to miss Senior Day game
  4. 04 Maroon and White Football Mississippi State Week 12 Preview: Tennessee Tech Players to Know
  5. 05 Maroon and White Basketball Mississippi State 86-83 UCF: Bulldogs earn road win in fight from start to finish with Golden Knights