OT: Sad story of Tunica Boom and Bust

garddog

Sophomore
Dec 10, 2008
795
102
43
I'm sure the leadership was awful, which would be par for the course, but I'm not sure it would have mattered. They didn't have a single natural advantage. They had the benefit of being near Memphis and legalizing gambling first. At the end of the day, whatever additional amenities they could put in, they would have made more sense closer to Memphis but for the casinos being there. Same issues the Choctaws have. Creating a destination like that completely inorganically is just hard, and requires you to really go all in from the get go. Pretty much no matter what you do, you're going to be inferior to Vegas on everything except for maybe cost. Anything that is small enough (e.g., a waterpark) that can be supported by a normal small city is better off being at or as near as possible to the small city.

Pretty much the only significant tourist destinations I can think of that developed inorganically and really had staying power are are Las Vegas (which happened so long ago I'm not sure it's relevant) and Orlando, which obviously had Disney. Maybe Cooperstown qualifies? Can't think of any others that had a random, low population area without significant natural attractiosn like beach or mountains that have been able to consistently pull people in for decades.

The Choctaw casino's were run by Boyd gaming for about 10 years. Place was clean and busy. They pushed Boyd out over the revenue share and it has been down hill for the last 20+ years.
 
  • Like
Reactions: patdog

fedxdog

Sophomore
Dec 7, 2008
550
115
38
Tunica came about because the voters in Memphis voted down casinos on Mud Island. If that had gone through, Memphis would still have casinos, Tunica would have the Hollywood Cafe and West Memphis wouldn't have a large Southland Casino.
 

johnson86-1

All-American
Aug 22, 2012
15,311
5,866
113
The Choctaw casino's were run by Boyd gaming for about 10 years. Place was clean and busy. They pushed Boyd out over the revenue share and it has been down hill for the last 20+ years.
I had always heard they pushed Boyd out because Boyd didn't give enough preferential treatment to members of the tribe in hiring and promotion decisions and also in holding employees accountable. Not sure how biased this source was, but the claim was basically that there were enough voting members that wanted to be employed but not actually have to work hard that they were able to boot boyd, and then it went to **** when there was nobody left to do work because they kept hiring and promoting based on politics.
 

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
61,491
33,360
113
I had always heard they pushed Boyd out because Boyd didn't give enough preferential treatment to members of the tribe in hiring and promotion decisions and also in holding employees accountable. Not sure how biased this source was, but the claim was basically that there were enough voting members that wanted to be employed but not actually have to work hard that they were able to boot boyd, and then it went to **** when there was nobody left to do work because they kept hiring and promoting based on politics.
I’m shocked that the Tribe isn’t able to run a casino as well as a professional management company. Greed kills the golden goose. Or in this case moon.
 

OG Goat Holder

Heisman
Sep 30, 2022
14,693
13,514
113
I'm sure the leadership was awful, which would be par for the course, but I'm not sure it would have mattered. They didn't have a single natural advantage. They had the benefit of being near Memphis and legalizing gambling first. At the end of the day, whatever additional amenities they could put in, they would have made more sense closer to Memphis but for the casinos being there. Same issues the Choctaws have. Creating a destination like that completely inorganically is just hard, and requires you to really go all in from the get go. Pretty much no matter what you do, you're going to be inferior to Vegas on everything except for maybe cost. Anything that is small enough (e.g., a waterpark) that can be supported by a normal small city is better off being at or as near as possible to the small city.

Pretty much the only significant tourist destinations I can think of that developed inorganically and really had staying power are are Las Vegas (which happened so long ago I'm not sure it's relevant) and Orlando, which obviously had Disney. Maybe Cooperstown qualifies? Can't think of any others that had a random, low population area without significant natural attractiosn like beach or mountains that have been able to consistently pull people in for decades.
Yep was always doomed to fail. But I will say, in 2005, there was a different air around there. Folks thought it would last.
 

OG Goat Holder

Heisman
Sep 30, 2022
14,693
13,514
113
The flood was the final death blow. I used to do some work at the Tunica airport. That's a very interesting place. Very nice airport right on the outskirts of poverty and cotton fields. But at one time it was the 3rd busiest airport in the state by passenger count. The casinos were flying two 737s in and out every day. People would fly in, bus to the casinos, gamble for 2-3 days, and then bus back to the airport and fly home.
Lot of gov money spent on that airport. Now it’s largely vacant.
 
  • Like
Reactions: patdog

rumsearch

Redshirt
Mar 3, 2008
393
23
18
I’m shocked that the Tribe isn’t able to run a casino as well as a professional management company. Greed kills the golden goose. Or in this case moon.
Boyd provided the capital to build the Silver Star and it was done in accordance with the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act. Under IGRA, the developer is entitled to repay itself via a significant annual management fee. The Silver Star was so successful that the tribe was able to buy out the management agreement early Which made a lot of financial sense.

The tribe grew the resort for multiple years thereafter. Then there was a leadership change and performance at the resort started facing headwinds. The growth of gaming in Alabama has redirected a significant part of their customer base. Haven’t been to PRR or Tunica in years but I’d hazard a guess that the tribe is keeping PRR going better than Tunica is keeping its gaming resort assets going.
 

OG Goat Holder

Heisman
Sep 30, 2022
14,693
13,514
113
All government money. As are all airports. Last I was there they doing a pretty good business building hangars & leasing them out to private planes. But that’s been about 6 years.
Oh I know. There a little pulse there but not enough. A decade (or more) ago there was momentum for an airport in Desoto/Coldwater area. The money that had been spent in Tunica quelled that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: patdog

garddog

Sophomore
Dec 10, 2008
795
102
43
Boyd provided the capital to build the Silver Star and it was done in accordance with the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act. Under IGRA, the developer is entitled to repay itself via a significant annual management fee. The Silver Star was so successful that the tribe was able to buy out the management agreement early Which made a lot of financial sense.

The tribe grew the resort for multiple years thereafter. Then there was a leadership change and performance at the resort started facing headwinds. The growth of gaming in Alabama has redirected a significant part of their customer base. Haven’t been to PRR or Tunica in years but I’d hazard a guess that the tribe is keeping PRR going better than Tunica is keeping its gaming resort assets going.
I had two council members at the tribe state that when it came to the renewal they didn't want to pay Boyd the fee they asked for.

All the problems with cleanliness and staffing started as soon as Boyd left. There was a lot of the payroll that just never showed up to work.
 
  • Like
Reactions: patdog

OG Goat Holder

Heisman
Sep 30, 2022
14,693
13,514
113
Tunica came about because the voters in Memphis voted down casinos on Mud Island. If that had gone through, Memphis would still have casinos, Tunica would have the Hollywood Cafe and West Memphis wouldn't have a large Southland Casino.
It's amazing how much you cost yourself when you fight progress.

There are people in Jackson who think a casino would revive downtown Jackson.
Well, it would definitely help.
 

stateu1

All-Conference
Mar 21, 2016
3,222
1,258
113
Tunica came about because the voters in Memphis voted down casinos on Mud Island. If that had gone through, Memphis would still have casinos, Tunica would have the Hollywood Cafe and West Memphis wouldn't have a large Southland Casino.
Believe DeSoto voted em down too.
 

o_Hot Rock

Senior
Jan 2, 2010
2,098
983
113
I stopped in one day a few years ago to check it out as I was over there for work. I had not been in years and it had been busy teeming with people in almost every corner back in the day. It was a sad experience, no one was there. It was mid-week just after lunch but I had spent days playing golf in the day, enjoying the buffet with some light gambling at night and even catching some shows. I had never seen it empty like that.

I wandered over the bar to get soda, and the only sadder thing I saw that day was a guy sitting on a chair at the bar, disheveled, unkept and looked to be hung over nursing a beer. I had to do a double take as I sat down one chair away. It was Bill Engvall and he looked like ****. He did not want to be there for sure. He saw me recognize him, I looked away and we never spoke.
 

99jc

Senior
Jul 31, 2008
2,565
566
113
Back in the day there was a Bulldog fan used to live next to Stansbury at that lake they built a subdivision around. He owned all the land on the HWY TO THE CASINOS. He leased it out to billboards and i saw his checks every month 69K just on the rent on those billboards.
 
  • Like
Reactions: patdog

johnson86-1

All-American
Aug 22, 2012
15,311
5,866
113
It's amazing how much you cost yourself when you fight progress.

I don't know that most casinos count as progress. River boats certainly didn't help the Greenville area. I don't think they're an obvious plus for Vicksburg. If it's not a big enough of an investment to bring in tourists or at providing another alternative to an existing tourism base, I think it just reshuffles existing disposable income in the area, with a slight boost from drive in traffic that is offset, either partially or completely and then some, by the problems the gambling causes. I'm not necessarily against casinos. There are things that are bad that the government still shouldn't prohibit, but I don't think people voting against them are voting against progress.

Well, it would definitely help.

I think a casino would be awful for Jackson. It's highly unlikely Jackson would be able to sustain a nice casino. It'd end up being a ****** one with lots of slots and low limit tables and clientele people with money don't want to be around. And I don't think the population of Jackson really needs any more unproductive ways to spend money.
 

hatfieldms

All-Conference
Feb 20, 2008
8,803
2,618
113
It's partially to do with it. But the decline in Tunica started long before that. In fact, it's far more likely that Southland is taking advantage of it, not causing it.
Southland has definitely had an impact over the years. Over they turned it into a real casino people did not have to drive to tunica anymore to gamble
 

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
61,491
33,360
113
I don't know that most casinos count as progress. River boats certainly didn't help the Greenville area. I don't think they're an obvious plus for Vicksburg. If it's not a big enough of an investment to bring in tourists or at providing another alternative to an existing tourism base, I think it just reshuffles existing disposable income in the area, with a slight boost from drive in traffic that is offset, either partially or completely and then some, by the problems the gambling causes. I'm not necessarily against casinos. There are things that are bad that the government still shouldn't prohibit, but I don't think people voting against them are voting against progress.



I think a casino would be awful for Jackson. It's highly unlikely Jackson would be able to sustain a nice casino. It'd end up being a ****** one with lots of slots and low limit tables and clientele people with money don't want to be around. And I don't think the population of Jackson really needs any more unproductive ways to spend money.
The one place casinos have helped the economy is the Coast. And I agree about a Jackson casino. I doubt any decent one would want to do business in Jackson after seeing what they're up against dealing with the crime, flight out of the city (I wouldn't even call it white flight since blacks who can get out are getting out too), and corruption. And I don't see a lot of the suburbanites going downtown for any reason, casino or not.
 

L4Dawg

All-American
Oct 27, 2016
12,211
8,661
113
I went to Tunica on and off for about 20 years for conventions, basically from 2000 till 2019. The change was slow at first but it picked up speed. I hated it because I'm not a gambler. There just wasn't anything at all for me to do other than the convention stuff.
 

doobeeadawg

Freshman
Dec 8, 2022
108
55
28
The one place casinos have helped the economy is the Coast. And I agree about a Jackson casino. I doubt any decent one would want to do business in Jackson after seeing what they're up against dealing with the crime, flight out of the city (I wouldn't even call it white flight since blacks who can get out are getting out too), and corruption. And I don't see a lot of the suburbanites going downtown for any reason, casino or not.
The problem is that are some very
recognizable names pushing extremely hard. Odds are their favor it happens. I’ve been told it’s a done deal. Im personally totally against for numerous reasons.
 

OG Goat Holder

Heisman
Sep 30, 2022
14,693
13,514
113
I don't know that most casinos count as progress. River boats certainly didn't help the Greenville area. I don't think they're an obvious plus for Vicksburg. If it's not a big enough of an investment to bring in tourists or at providing another alternative to an existing tourism base, I think it just reshuffles existing disposable income in the area, with a slight boost from drive in traffic that is offset, either partially or completely and then some, by the problems the gambling causes. I'm not necessarily against casinos. There are things that are bad that the government still shouldn't prohibit, but I don't think people voting against them are voting against progress.

I think a casino would be awful for Jackson. It's highly unlikely Jackson would be able to sustain a nice casino. It'd end up being a ****** one with lots of slots and low limit tables and clientele people with money don't want to be around. And I don't think the population of Jackson really needs any more unproductive ways to spend money.
You're missing my point. I'm not trying to debates the merits of anywhere having a casino and how much it helps. "Progress" in my sense was gambling. It was coming, no way around it. You/me/anyone may or may not agree with it but the people want it. Most places put up roadblocks for moral reasons, others leaped at the opportunities. If Memphis had leaped at the opportunity, they'd have thrived due to them.

I'm not trying to get into another Jackhole bashing ceremony. Or Vicksburg or Greenville. But I will guarantee the latter 2 would rather have the casino than not.

The one place casinos have helped the economy is the Coast. And I agree about a Jackson casino. I doubt any decent one would want to do business in Jackson after seeing what they're up against dealing with the crime, flight out of the city (I wouldn't even call it white flight since blacks who can get out are getting out too), and corruption. And I don't see a lot of the suburbanites going downtown for any reason, casino or not.
Well yeah, smart development is the key to anything. The Coast did it right, while Tunica didn't, which is kind of the point of the video.

I mean you could say the same thing with data centers. In MS we tend to think this is a new deal, but northern Virginia, ATL and DFW got on board with them, smartly, years ago and are now printing money due to it.
 
Nov 16, 2005
29,789
25,504
113
You're missing my point. I'm not trying to debates the merits of anywhere having a casino and how much it helps. "Progress" in my sense was gambling. It was coming, no way around it. You/me/anyone may or may not agree with it but the people want it. Most places put up roadblocks for moral reasons, others leaped at the opportunities. If Memphis had leaped at the opportunity, they'd have thrived due to them.

I'm not trying to get into another Jackhole bashing ceremony. Or Vicksburg or Greenville. But I will guarantee the latter 2 would rather have the casino than not.


Well yeah, smart development is the key to anything. The Coast did it right, while Tunica didn't, which is kind of the point of the video.

I mean you could say the same thing with data centers. In MS we tend to think this is a new deal, but northern Virginia, ATL and DFW got on board with them, smartly, years ago and are now printing money due to it.
But the coast has other attractions, that’s what “makes it work”. The casinos are the only thing in Tunica and it’s miles to anything else.
 
  • Like
Reactions: patdog

L4Dawg

All-American
Oct 27, 2016
12,211
8,661
113
You're missing my point. I'm not trying to debates the merits of anywhere having a casino and how much it helps. "Progress" in my sense was gambling. It was coming, no way around it. You/me/anyone may or may not agree with it but the people want it. Most places put up roadblocks for moral reasons, others leaped at the opportunities. If Memphis had leaped at the opportunity, they'd have thrived due to them.

I'm not trying to get into another Jackhole bashing ceremony. Or Vicksburg or Greenville. But I will guarantee the latter 2 would rather have the casino than not.


Well yeah, smart development is the key to anything. The Coast did it right, while Tunica didn't, which is kind of the point of the video.

I mean you could say the same thing with data centers. In MS we tend to think this is a new deal, but northern Virginia, ATL and DFW got on board with them, smartly, years ago and are now printing money due to it.
Years from now historians will probably have a field day on how China beat the US in the data race.
 

L4Dawg

All-American
Oct 27, 2016
12,211
8,661
113
But the coast has other attractions, that’s what “makes it work”. The casinos are the only thing in Tunica and it’s miles to anything else.
Yep. My wife used to have a convention she had to attend on the coast. I always took off and went with her. There is plenty to do down there if you don't gamble.
 

OG Goat Holder

Heisman
Sep 30, 2022
14,693
13,514
113
But the coast has other attractions, that’s what “makes it work”. The casinos are the only thing in Tunica and it’s miles to anything else.
Tunica in this sense is the Memphis Metro (which has the factors to make it work). Memphis itself passed, Tunica jumped at the opportunity. There's no question it would have been better for the overall area for casinos to be closer to the city. No overall development plan or unity there.
 

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
61,491
33,360
113
But the coast has other attractions, that’s what “makes it work”. The casinos are the only thing in Tunica and it’s miles to anything else.
Exactly. When gambling became legal in pretty much every state, Tunica was always going to decline significantly, even without the flood and mismanagement.
 

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
61,491
33,360
113
The problem is that are some very
recognizable names pushing extremely hard. Odds are their favor it happens. I’ve been told it’s a done deal. Im personally totally against for numerous reasons.
They've been pushing for the Jackson casino for 25 years. I doubt it will happen in the next 20 years.
 
Nov 16, 2005
29,789
25,504
113
Tunica in this sense is the Memphis Metro (which has the factors to make it work). Memphis itself passed, Tunica jumped at the opportunity. There's no question it would have been better for the overall area for casinos to be closer to the city. No overall development plan or unity there.
It’s barely metro. It’s 40 minutes from downtown to Goldstrike
 

HWY51dog

Junior
Jul 24, 2013
369
224
43
First mistake that was made was not having them in a strip with easier access. That would have made development easier with restaurants and attractions. Being spread out like they are is just dumb and a killer for development added into all the other economic issues and flood that was mentioned.
 

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
61,491
33,360
113
Let me back up and put this plainly. If Memphis had developed casinos:

1) The area would have thrived moreso than Tunica-only;
2) Tunica likely doesn't develop many casinos;
3) The overall Memphis region would have been better off than it is now.
1. There's nothing metro about Tunica.
2. Tunica did develop the casinos. Those two fully loaded 737s flying in every day weren't coming from Memphis. That's about 250 people per day who are going to gamble pretty much full time for 2-3 days before leaving.

But yeah, if Memphis or Desoto County had legalized gambling back then, yes those people would be flying into Memphis and bussing to those casinos and the Tunica airport probably wouldn't exist.
 

johnson86-1

All-American
Aug 22, 2012
15,311
5,866
113
You're missing my point. I'm not trying to debates the merits of anywhere having a casino and how much it helps. "Progress" in my sense was gambling. It was coming, no way around it. You/me/anyone may or may not agree with it but the people want it. Most places put up roadblocks for moral reasons, others leaped at the opportunities. If Memphis had leaped at the opportunity, they'd have thrived due to them.

I'm not trying to get into another Jackhole bashing ceremony. Or Vicksburg or Greenville. But I will guarantee the latter 2 would rather have the casino than not.

Gambling is always coming. If everybody allows it, it all ends up being pretty ******. But the incentive once gambling is close is to allow it. Memphis wouldn't have thrived due to gaming. Maybe they would have ended up better off since they have gambling close enough that they mostly have to deal with the downsides anyway, so it might as well be in their city.

I don't know that Vicksburg or Greenville would rather have the casino than not. Certainly now eliminating them would cause a hole in their budget. But Vicksburg and Greenville lost a lot of small businesses due to them. I'm not sure the consensus among the residents would be that they are better off because of the casinos.

Well yeah, smart development is the key to anything. The Coast did it right, while Tunica didn't, which is kind of the point of the video.

I mean you could say the same thing with data centers. In MS we tend to think this is a new deal, but northern Virginia, ATL and DFW got on board with them, smartly, years ago and are now printing money due to it.

Mississippi requiring investment in non-gaming amenities in order to receive a license and also having open competition helped I think. Not sure that was as important as being somewhere with something else to offer to begin with. Not sure if the non-gaming amenity investment was ever required for Tunica casinos.

Going to be interesting to see how it plays out going forward. The non-gaming amenity requirement and minimum hotel room requirement is a pretty stout barrier to entry now. There hasn't been a new casino in over a decade and I'm not sure when another one will ever be able to get financing. Even the scarlett pearl was I believe self financed by the billionaire family that developed it. So we arguably don't really have new competition, so going to be interesting to see how much the existing casinos continue to invest in their properties.
 

OG Goat Holder

Heisman
Sep 30, 2022
14,693
13,514
113
But yeah, if Memphis or Desoto County had legalized gambling back then, yes those people would be flying into Memphis and bussing to those casinos and the Tunica airport probably wouldn't exist.
And the overall area would be better. Just like the entire Coast is better.

Then maybe that Desoto/Tate airport could have gotten off the ground (just one example).
 
Nov 16, 2005
29,789
25,504
113
1. There's nothing metro about Tunica.
2. Tunica did develop the casinos. Those two fully loaded 737s flying in every day weren't coming from Memphis. That's about 250 people per day who are going to gamble pretty much full time for 2-3 days before leaving.

But yeah, if Memphis or Desoto County had legalized gambling back then, yes those people would be flying into Memphis and bussing to those casinos and the Tunica airport probably wouldn't exist.
For about a year Air Tran flew 4 days a week from Atlanta. When the flood hit they stopped flights. That was also about the time I think they merged with US Air.
 
  • Like
Reactions: patdog
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White Football Mississippi State Week 12 Preview: Who carries the load?
  2. 02 Maroon and White Basketball Bulldogs prepare for mid-major test against Tulsa in Jackson
  3. 03 On3 Football Mississippi State RB Fluff Bothwell re-signs with Bulldogs for 2027
  4. 04 Maroon and White "There will be an opportunity for Brodie": Mississippi State HC Jeff Lebby sets freshman up for Saturday runout
  5. 05 Maroon and White Chris Jans proud of Mississippi State's "must-win" performance on the road at UCF