The actual games don’t matter anymore

Jonesy5960

Heisman
Feb 1, 2023
7,670
15,934
113
There is simply no argument suggesting that the actual games on the field are still important after this week's CFP release.

Boise St beats a bad 5-4 Oregon St team by 4 points at home - Rises 7 spots.

Arizona loses at home - Rises 4 spots.

South Carolina gets shellacked by a terrible Arkansas team 34-6 - Only drops 4 spots

Ohio State struggles mightily to put away the same NW team at home that Iowa dominated just one week before on the road - Rises 6 spots

Alabama struggles to put away a terrible last place Vanderbilt team - Doesn’t move from number 3.

Iowa dominates Purdue, holding them to their lowest point total this year and wins by 21 - Doesn't move while OSU and Oregon leap over them.

It's clear that the committee doesn't care about the games anymore. It's become a popularity contest, and Iowa just isn't very popular.
 

squeezebox_1

All-Conference
Mar 6, 2018
1,372
1,969
113
Meh, there are two factors. ESPN owns the rights to the cfp, so they want the maximum amount of eyes on those games. Ohio State and Oregon both bring more viewers. The biggest issue with the committee as it stands is consistency. I could fathom Ohio State over Iowa given that they **** the bed in the first week to Texas, and spanked us at home. With that said, Oregon's victory over Ohio State is all timing based. That was far form the OSU team we played at Kinnick, and it's not debatable. Oregon has 2 unranked losses, they are put on a pedestal for beating a down OSU team, and a very mid USC squad. Boise bumping up is just another feather in their cap, that is not an impressive victory, they will be out of the playoffs in the first round. We all know that Iowa will not rise in the rankings with a win against Illinois, but they should definitively be ahead of Oregon if that were to happen.
 

Jonesy5960

Heisman
Feb 1, 2023
7,670
15,934
113
Meh, there are two factors. ESPN owns the rights to the cfp, so they want the maximum amount of eyes on those games. Ohio State and Oregon both bring more viewers. The biggest issue with the committee as it stands is consistency. I could fathom Ohio State over Iowa given that they **** the bed in the first week to Texas, and spanked us at home. With that said, Oregon's victory over Ohio State is all timing based. That was far form the OSU team we played at Kinnick, and it's not debatable. Oregon has 2 unranked losses, they are put on a pedestal for beating a down OSU team, and a very mid USC squad. Boise bumping up is just another feather in their cap, that is not an impressive victory, they will be out of the playoffs in the first round. We all know that Iowa will not rise in the rankings with a win against Illinois, but they should definitively be ahead of Oregon if that were to happen.
Oregon showed they are better than OSU by beating them easily at the Shoe 2 weeks ago.
 

Hawkfan_08*

Heisman
Jul 2, 2025
4,003
10,430
113
Committee didn't let Florida St. in when undefeated because their QB had an injury.

Ohio St. losses their QB, looks completely different. Beats a team at home by 11 when the week before we beat them on the road by 14.

Its all about who you are and I guess we should be thankful we get to be in the NCAA where our punishments are doubled for minor infractions where everyone else can openly cheat.
 

squeezebox_1

All-Conference
Mar 6, 2018
1,372
1,969
113
Oregon showed they are better than OSU by beating them easily at the Shoe 2 weeks ago.
Did I say something differently? Since we are on this though, head to heads don't matter to the committee in the top 10, did Tennessee not beat Bama? Speaking of Bama, they get credit for beating a Kamario Taylor led MSU, BYU has a win over ND. If Indiana loses to UCLA, which I don't see happening, they should drop below Oregon, or do they suddenly get credit for playing against a Sayin led OSU. This is the problem, it's all about consistency, and there is none.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DukeSlater

squeezebox_1

All-Conference
Mar 6, 2018
1,372
1,969
113
Committee didn't let Florida St. in when undefeated because their QB had an injury.

Ohio St. losses their QB, looks completely different. Beats a team at home by 11 when the week before we beat them on the road by 14.

Its all about who you are and I guess we should be thankful we get to be in the NCAA where our punishments are doubled for minor infractions where everyone else can openly cheat.
a little apples to oranges when we are talking about a 4 team playoff vs 12.
 
  • Like
Reactions: o_waterboy4582

Jonesy5960

Heisman
Feb 1, 2023
7,670
15,934
113
Did I say something differently? Since we are on this though, head to heads don't matter to the committee in the top 10, did Tennessee not beat Bama? Speaking of Bama, they get credit for beating a Kamario Taylor led MSU, BYU has a win over ND. If Indiana loses to UCLA, which I don't see happening, they should drop below Oregon, or do they suddenly get credit for playing against a Sayin led OSU. This is the problem, it's all about consistency, and there is none.
There can be no consistency when the actual games don't matter. This week's rankings reflect that last week's games were largely irrelevant with respect to movement of teams. It's simply a beauty contest.
 

Palmerhawk

All-American
Jul 3, 2025
2,639
5,173
113
I doubt pettiti is going to argue for Iowa over OSU or oregon.
Keeping OSU relevant is important to preserve the hype around "The Game" on Nov 28.

OSU has no importance to committee this year beyond blocking Iowa ...

Iowa needs a out 6 teams ahead of them to move up 4 spots..maybe.

Oregon ,OSU, TT,byu, at minimum, need to lose.
The sec teams ahead of us like tenn, Tex,bama, would need to lose out for Iowa to maybe jump them.

Screw job.
 

iahawkeyes17

All-Conference
Apr 22, 2014
967
2,426
83
One I’m most perplexed by is bama ucla. Bama has 2 losses to teams in top 10 and best wins over 17 Kentucky and 21 S. Carolina.

Ucla 2 less losses and win over 13 Oregon. Seriously I just don’t get it maybe if there is 1 loss separating but 2 more losses is just ridiculous.

can’t wait to see how it is justified next week when S Carolina gets thrashed by Georgia and somehow kept in at 6-5 to keep bama with 2 top 25 wins.
 

Fight4Iowa

Senior
Nov 25, 2025
461
651
93
The 3 of 12 committee members that are suppose to be Midwestern:

Dantonio- OSU roots...no fan of Iowa
Riley- West coast guy from Oregon country and Nebraska coach .hates Iowa loves oregon
Dannen- neb ad...hates Iowa.

We got no one in room to push back vs the 7 guys from SEC country.

Popularity contest indeed.
Yeah, this spells trouble. The B1G is likely getting at least 3 though. We just need to win out and hope Ohio State and Oregon loses another game.
 

Fight4Iowa

Senior
Nov 25, 2025
461
651
93
Ohio State is not a good football team without Sayin. How they get moved above Iowa after beating a Northwestern team at home that Iowa beat on the road is inexplicable. The only explanation is that the committee wants OSU in the playoff and does not want Iowa in.
Ohio State handled Iowa @ Iowa. Ohio State has a much better win than Iowa with their win @ Indiana. Ohio State has two quality wins (Iowa and Indiana) that Iowa doesn't have. Yes, they're a different team without Sayin, but the committee probably wants to see them a bit longer as their new QB might be growing into the role.

Plus, Ohio State's 3rd loss was @ Texas early in the year, a game they pretty much had control of the whole game until the end.

I don't think Ohio State has a ranking ahead of us locked up just yet. I think how they play against Nebraska vs. how we play against Nebraska is going to be a factor.

We need to just hope Michigan hasn't mailed it in and Ohio State doesn't blow them out by 20+.

What disappoints me the most about Ohio State's ranking currently is we just saw them get owned at home by another playoff caliber team. I think that sort of loss, this late in the year, should have a bit more negative consequences.
 

LakeO83

Redshirt
Jul 10, 2025
16
24
3
There is simply no argument suggesting that the actual games on the field are still important after this week's CFP release.

Boise St beats a bad 5-4 Oregon St team by 4 points at home - Rises 7 spots.

Arizona loses at home - Rises 4 spots.

South Carolina gets shellacked by a terrible Arkansas team 34-6 - Only drops 4 spots

Ohio State struggles mightily to put away the same NW team at home that Iowa dominated just one week before on the road - Rises 6 spots

Alabama struggles to put away a terrible last place Vanderbilt team - Doesn’t move from number 3.

Iowa dominates Purdue, holding them to their lowest point total this year and wins by 21 - Doesn't move while OSU and Oregon leap over them.

It's clear that the committee doesn't care about the games anymore. It's become a popularity contest, and Iowa just isn't very popular.

I think the games actually matter, but it seems obvious that who you play seems to matter more. So when you have a crap schedule, don't lose to crap teams.
 
  • Like
Reactions: OnlyTheObscure

Jonesy5960

Heisman
Feb 1, 2023
7,670
15,934
113
I think the games actually matter, but it seems obvious that who you play seems to matter more. So when you have a crap schedule, don't lose to crap teams.
The games from last weekend didn't matter at all. If they did you wouldn't have seen these movements in the rankings. Struggling to beat the same Northwestern team at home that Iowa dominated on the road the week before doesn't warrant a 6 point rise over Iowa in the rankings. That logic doesn't exist.
 
Last edited:

Herky T Hawk

All-Conference
Feb 5, 2003
568
1,320
93
Our P5 non-conference win isn't helping at all. We at least won the game against ISU, but OSU gets more credit for losing to a currently 8-2 Texas and Oregon gets more credit for losing to a mediocre Okie State team with only one more win that ISU.

This weekend against Michigan was Oregon's first Big Ten victory margin > 14 points, their victory over USC was 14 points exactly. Meanwhile Iowa has beaten Washington, Wisconsin, and Purdue all by 21 or more points.

OSU, in the games since Saiyan's injury, has a 2 game losing streak and a 9 point victory over NW.

Meanwhile, in both of our losses we dealt with injury issues with our starting QB. Since he's been back starting fully after the Minny game we're averaging a 27-6 average score in our three victories.

Yes, the Minnesota loss is bad, but they're an average Big Ten team, not bottom of the barrel. We are being punished because of the schedule that the Big Ten gave us. And then the committee is gaming the system to ensure that crappy 4 loss SEC teams stay ranked to prop up the resume of other SEC teams.
 

Hawkfan_08*

Heisman
Jul 2, 2025
4,003
10,430
113
a little apples to oranges when we are talking about a 4 team playoff vs 12.

How so? FSU would have been in with a 12 team playoff but they were left out as an undefeated team to a 1 loss Alabama team.

Why?

The QB was hurt. That was it. That was the justification.

Ohio St. jumped 6 spots winning their 1st? game after switching QBs at home against a backup QB for NW at home. The same situation we saw saw a week ago and moved up 4 spots with a million teams that lost in front of us.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DukeSlater

squeezebox_1

All-Conference
Mar 6, 2018
1,372
1,969
113
How so? FSU would have been in with a 12 team playoff but they were left out as an undefeated team to a 1 loss Alabama team.

Why?

The QB was hurt. That was it. That was the justification.

Ohio St. jumped 6 spots winning their 1st? game after switching QBs at home against a backup QB for NW at home. The same situation we saw saw a week ago and moved up 4 spots with a million teams that lost in front of us.
Not sure if you are serious, but it was a 4 team playoff, not a 12 team. Bama won the SEC, they were 11-1 with a loss to Texas a team that made the CFP. I think being undefeated granted them that right to get in, but a 12 team playoff is quite a bit different than a 4 team. Adding to the point would be that backup QB did not play in the manner of which Fayhe and Raviola have. I guess the biggest (hindsight being 20/20) comment would be that FSU team played Georgia and it ended up 3-63.
 

DukeSlater

All-American
Jul 2, 2023
2,498
5,499
113
Ohio State handled Iowa @ Iowa. Ohio State has a much better win than Iowa with their win @ Indiana. Ohio State has two quality wins (Iowa and Indiana) that Iowa doesn't have. Yes, they're a different team without Sayin, but the committee probably wants to see them a bit longer as their new QB might be growing into the role.

Plus, Ohio State's 3rd loss was @ Texas early in the year, a game they pretty much had control of the whole game until the end.

I don't think Ohio State has a ranking ahead of us locked up just yet. I think how they play against Nebraska vs. how we play against Nebraska is going to be a factor.

We need to just hope Michigan hasn't mailed it in and Ohio State doesn't blow them out by 20+.

What disappoints me the most about Ohio State's ranking currently is we just saw them get owned at home by another playoff caliber team. I think that sort of loss, this late in the year, should have a bit more negative consequences.
The Ohio State win @ Indiana should have an asterisk since Indiana threw a TD pass to win the game, but the receiver was inches out of bounds on a WIDE OPEN pass. And the Ohio State now is nothing close to the Ohio State that Iowa played.
 

uihawk82

All-American
Nov 17, 2021
3,700
5,377
113
There is simply no argument suggesting that the actual games on the field are still important after this week's CFP release.

Boise St beats a bad 5-4 Oregon St team by 4 points at home - Rises 7 spots.

Arizona loses at home - Rises 4 spots.

South Carolina gets shellacked by a terrible Arkansas team 34-6 - Only drops 4 spots

Ohio State struggles mightily to put away the same NW team at home that Iowa dominated just one week before on the road - Rises 6 spots

Alabama struggles to put away a terrible last place Vanderbilt team - Doesn’t move from number 3.

Iowa dominates Purdue, holding them to their lowest point total this year and wins by 21 - Doesn't move while OSU and Oregon leap over them.

It's clear that the committee doesn't care about the games anymore. It's become a popularity contest, and Iowa just isn't very popular.
The whole effing thing is a joke, south carolina losing by that score should not even be in the top 25, now there is some real SEC blindness, love, sucking something
 

uihawk82

All-American
Nov 17, 2021
3,700
5,377
113
8-9 out of 12 Committee members are SEC, it’s the SEC INVITATIONAL based on Tv markets and branding. Absolute trash and an insult to college football fans.
TV markets, the Big 10 has a ton of people just in their states, MI, OH, PA, NY, MD, NJ, IL, Twin cities, etc etc
 

Kceasthawk@77

All-American
Feb 2, 2005
5,092
8,690
113
There is simply no argument suggesting that the actual games on the field are still important after this week's CFP release.

Boise St beats a bad 5-4 Oregon St team by 4 points at home - Rises 7 spots.

Arizona loses at home - Rises 4 spots.

South Carolina gets shellacked by a terrible Arkansas team 34-6 - Only drops 4 spots

Ohio State struggles mightily to put away the same NW team at home that Iowa dominated just one week before on the road - Rises 6 spots

Alabama struggles to put away a terrible last place Vanderbilt team - Doesn’t move from number 3.

Iowa dominates Purdue, holding them to their lowest point total this year and wins by 21 - Doesn't move while OSU and Oregon leap over them.

It's clear that the committee doesn't care about the games anymore. It's become a popularity contest, and Iowa just isn't very popular.
No doubt. Many of those "adjustments" were just to get certain teams in position for the final poll. For example, Boise is automatically in if they win out so they can't have them in the 20's and then move them to number #12 in one week. that would show how stupid this is, so they were positioned.
 

Kceasthawk@77

All-American
Feb 2, 2005
5,092
8,690
113
The 3 of 12 committee members that are suppose to be Midwestern:

Dantonio- OSU roots...no fan of Iowa
Riley- West coast guy from Oregon country and Nebraska coach .hates Iowa loves oregon
Dannen- neb ad...hates Iowa.

We got no one in room to push back vs the 7 guys from SEC country.

Popularity contest indeed.
The 3 of 12 committee members that are suppose to be Midwestern:

Dantonio- OSU roots...no fan of Iowa
Riley- West coast guy from Oregon country and Nebraska coach .hates Iowa loves oregon
Dannen- neb ad...hates Iowa.

We got no one in room to push back vs the 7 guys from SEC country.

Popularity contest indeed.
Dantonio coached at MSU not OSU and I think he respects Kirk
 

Kceasthawk@77

All-American
Feb 2, 2005
5,092
8,690
113
Ohio State handled Iowa @ Iowa. Ohio State has a much better win than Iowa with their win @ Indiana. Ohio State has two quality wins (Iowa and Indiana) that Iowa doesn't have. Yes, they're a different team without Sayin, but the committee probably wants to see them a bit longer as their new QB might be growing into the role.

Plus, Ohio State's 3rd loss was @ Texas early in the year, a game they pretty much had control of the whole game until the end.

I don't think Ohio State has a ranking ahead of us locked up just yet. I think how they play against Nebraska vs. how we play against Nebraska is going to be a factor.

We need to just hope Michigan hasn't mailed it in and Ohio State doesn't blow them out by 20+.

What disappoints me the most about Ohio State's ranking currently is we just saw them get owned at home by another playoff caliber team. I think that sort of loss, this late in the year, should have a bit more negative consequences.
I do love how beating Iowa is a "quality win", and yet NO one on that committee takes us seriously as a "quality team". Number ONE in the NCAA in points allowed. 82-17 in the last three games
 
Hawkeye Report

Latest

  1. 01 Hawkeye Report Football Hawkeye Report Podcast
  2. 02 Hawkeye Report Football Hawkeye Report Podcast with Trevor Lauck
  3. 03 Rivals Football Recruiting Four-star Iowa QB commit Chase Grove talks latest experience inside Kinnick Stadium
  4. 04 Hawkeye Report Football Kelvin Bell talks Iowa defensive line development
  5. 05 Hawkeye Report Basketball WATCH: Jan Jensen, Hawkeyes recap Vandy, preview Montana State