More Parity in "college" football than NFL

PSUForever

All-Conference
Feb 17, 2007
2,192
2,231
113
It used to be that a few teams dominated in college and the NFL is where you found parity. I think that has reversed now.

The NFL is dominated by those teams who have the elite QBs.

AFC- Chiefs, Bills, Bengals all others not at that level. Really hard to see any other AFC team winning the AFC championship. Look at that Stillers blowout on Sunday night. Non competitive. Yeah the Stillers beat them earlier but do you really see the Stillers on the same level as the Bengals? Joe Burrow is much, much better than Rodgers.

NFC- Niners, Rams, Bears, Seahawks, Minny maybe Lions The other two divisions in the NFC, the south and east are a joke.

I would be beyond shocked if a team outside of who I have listed wins the SB. In fact you could make a good prediction it will be one of 4 teams...Chiefs, Bills, Bengals or Niners. Don't remember the NFL 15 years ago having this kind of lack of parity that it has now.

Sounds like college football 15 years ago.

So from this perspective, this hurricane of change to paying players, portal transfers, massive roster turnover has been good in my opinion because it has created much more parity. At least we don't have to watch Saban and Bama win it every other year based on hoarding all the best players with their #1 recruiting class every year (who they probably paid illegally). Or throw Georgia into that mix. Yes, they are still good but now we have an Indiana thumping Alabama in the playoff or Georgia losing to Ole Miss. The dominance those teams had in the past has dwindled while the Indianas, Texas Techs and Utahs have surged.
 
  • Like
Reactions: barry j fenchak

Shep

Senior
Nov 8, 2010
216
469
63
It used to be that a few teams dominated in college and the NFL is where you found parity. I think that has reversed now.

The NFL is dominated by those teams who have the elite QBs.

AFC- Chiefs, Bills, Bengals all others not at that level. Really hard to see any other AFC team winning the AFC championship. Look at that Stillers blowout on Sunday night. Non competitive. Yeah the Stillers beat them earlier but do you really see the Stillers on the same level as the Bengals? Joe Burrow is much, much better than Rodgers.

NFC- Niners, Rams, Bears, Seahawks, Minny maybe Lions The other two divisions in the NFC, the south and east are a joke.

I would be beyond shocked if a team outside of who I have listed wins the SB. In fact you could make a good prediction it will be one of 4 teams...Chiefs, Bills, Bengals or Niners. Don't remember the NFL 15 years ago having this kind of lack of parity that it has now.

Sounds like college football 15 years ago.

So from this perspective, this hurricane of change to paying players, portal transfers, massive roster turnover has been good in my opinion because it has created much more parity. At least we don't have to watch Saban and Bama win it every other year based on hoarding all the best players with their #1 recruiting class every year (who they probably paid illegally). Or throw Georgia into that mix. Yes, they are still good but now we have an Indiana thumping Alabama in the playoff or Georgia losing to Ole Miss. The dominance those teams had in the past has dwindled while the Indianas, Texas Techs and Utahs have surged.
Interesting take. NFL: I would include the Jaguars in the AFC title picture. Multi-dimensional offense (with two penn state starters) and they
took steps to improve the defense with several moves at the trading deadline.

College: the picture definitely includes more teams and it is a lot more interesting picture than in the past. The big fish (OSU, Bama, Georgia, Texas) are still in the mix but the number of other teams in the hunt is compelling. Time will tell whether the big players still dominate the NC winner, or whether the meritocracy wins. I'm hoping for the latter like you stated.
 
May 11, 2016
473
280
63
Don't follow NFL as it has zero appeal to me, so I have nothing of value to add to that side of the discussion.

As far as the CFB landscape I think it is way too soon to declare that parity is trending upward. The traditional major players are not going to collapse.

Looking at the current CFP top 10, I only see 2 teams that are relatively new, UCLA and Indiana. Utah and BYU have been on the fringe in the past so no real surprise there. All the rest are not exactly strangers, TX, GA, Bama, Miami and Notre Dame have all been major players. TN is kind of like LSU sometimes good and most years mid-to-bad.

Maybe what we are seeing is a brief 2-3 year adjustment to all these major changes rather than lasting parity. Too early to tell.
 
BWI

Latest

  1. 01 BWI Football Penn State's Audavion Collins on his final season: 'Don't second-guess yourself'
  2. 02 BWI Football Matt Campbell on Penn State's turnaround, Senior Day and two key return announcements
  3. 03 BWI Recruiting Three 2028 Rivals300 prospects confirmed for Penn State's home finale
  4. 04 BWI Football Ben Brahmer and Kooper Ebel returning to Penn State will help 'start to accelerate a little bit of that planning' for the 2027 season
  5. 05 BWI Football Penn State injury updates: Did Carson Hansen practice on Wednesday? Latest on Caleb Bacon, Jahmir Joseph