Butch Jones fired at Ark State - Bowls in 23, 24, 25

ScarletDave

Heisman
Oct 7, 2010
34,786
15,709
85
Arkansas State has had enough of Butch Jones, firing him after a 4-6 start to this season. He has taken them to 3 bowl games in 2023, 24, 25, and still possible in 2026 at 4-6. Yet, the decline in record and in attendance has caused the Pack to move on.

1) Do we take a look? He was only making 900k, 3 years left on his contract
2) Does Arkansas State, one of the worst FBS programs in the modern era, have higher standards for performance in football than Rutgers?
 

M.Sherrane

Sophomore
Sep 10, 2026
107
114
43
Arkansas State has had enough of Butch Jones, firing him after a 4-6 start to this season. He has taken them to 3 bowl games in 2023, 24, 25, and still possible in 2026 at 4-6. Yet, the decline in record and in attendance has caused the Pack to move on.

1) Do we take a look? He was only making 900k, 3 years left on his contract
2) Does Arkansas State, one of the worst FBS programs in the modern era, have higher standards for performance in football than Rutgers?

That is not accurate. They struggled in the 90's when they moved up to FBS, but were fairly good for the past 15 years. They had Freeze, Malzahn, and Harsin for 1 year each from 2011--2013 before hiring Anderson. They went 85--48 in the 10 years before hiring Jones in 2021. Jones' 19-31 record was a big step back from where they were. I don't believe Jones is an upgrade from Schiano.
 

Shelby65

All-Conference
Apr 1, 2008
8,810
4,932
66
That is not accurate. They struggled in the 90's when they moved up to FBS, but were fairly good for the past 15 years. They had Freeze, Malzahn, and Harsin for 1 year each from 2011--2013 before hiring Anderson. They went 85--48 in the 10 years before hiring Jones in 2021. Jones' 19-31 record was a big step back from where they were. I don't believe Jones is an upgrade from Schiano.
Is any downgrade breathing today ? No one could be worse. The 2026 is Hiroshima ground zero and 2027 will be Nagasaki.

One never knows how new hires will fare but it’s certain The Grifter is a proven massive football failure, disgrace and cause for the national embarrassment we face for being unable to fire him.

Throw a dart at a list of hundreds of replacement names and whoever it lands on can’t be worse.
 

M.Sherrane

Sophomore
Sep 10, 2026
107
114
43
Is any downgrade breathing today ? No one could be worse. The 2026 is Hiroshima ground zero and 2027 will be Nagasaki.

One never knows how new hires will fare but it’s certain The Grifter is a proven massive football failure, disgrace and cause for the national embarrassment we face for being unable to fire him.

Throw a dart at a list of hundreds of replacement names and whoever it lands on can’t be worse.

Let's examine the record and you can decide for yourself.

Central Michigan: Jones took over for Brian Kelly (I think I've heard of him :)), who make CMU competitive. 4 years before Kelly, Central Michigan went 12-34. Kelly went 4-7, 6-5, and then 9-4 before leaving for Cincinnati. Jones went 8-6, 8-5, and 12-3 before leaving for Cincinnati. Central Michigan has been a 4 -- 6 win team since.

Cincinnati: Jones once again took over for Kelly who left for Notre Dame. In 3 years Kelly went 10-3 (Cincinnati's first 10 win season), 11-3, and 12-1 (lost to Florida in the Sugar after Kelly left). Jones was at Cincinnati for 3 seasons going 4-8, 10-3, and 9-3 before leaving for Tennessee.

Tennessee: Tennessee was 5-7 in each of the previous 3 seasons before Jones arrived (2010, 2011, 2012). Jones went 5-7 in year 1, then 6-6 (bowl win for 7th win), then 2 consecutive 8-4 (2 bowl wins to make 9 wins), and was fired in Year 4 after a 50-17 loss at Missouri dropped Tennessee to 4-6 and finished 4-8.

He then joined Saban at Alabama as an offensive analyst. He originally agreed to join Locksley at Maryland as TE coach / Assistant Head Coach, but decided to stay at Alabama.

Arkansas State: As I previously stated, Arkansas State went 85--48 in the 10 years before hiring Jones in 2021. Went 2-10 in year 1 and followed it up with 3-9. Then he led them to 3 straight bowl game going 6-7, 8-5, and 7-6. He was fired this year after 10 games.... another 4-6 record like Tennessee.

None of these programs took a step forward under Jones. Central Michigan and Cincinnati were built by Brian Kelly with Jones taking over and not messing it up. His ceiling at RU would be 7-5, just like Schiano's is. He has either left for a better job after 3 years or got fired in years 5 and 6. He isn't an upgrade from Schiano and will likely get fired before his 5th season ends. As stated, he is not an upgrade. He would be a parallel move.
 

LotusAggressor_rivals

All-American
Oct 11, 2003
16,972
8,946
113
Arkansas State has had enough of Butch Jones, firing him after a 4-6 start to this season. He has taken them to 3 bowl games in 2023, 24, 25, and still possible in 2026 at 4-6. Yet, the decline in record and in attendance has caused the Pack to move on.

1) Do we take a look? He was only making 900k, 3 years left on his contract
2) Does Arkansas State, one of the worst FBS programs in the modern era, have higher standards for performance in football than Rutgers?
No, we shouldn't and yes, they do.
 

AnonAmoose26

Sophomore
Sep 6, 2026
144
177
43
Let's examine the record and you can decide for yourself.

Central Michigan: Jones took over for Brian Kelly (I think I've heard of him :)), who make CMU competitive. 4 years before Kelly, Central Michigan went 12-34. Kelly went 4-7, 6-5, and then 9-4 before leaving for Cincinnati. Jones went 8-6, 8-5, and 12-3 before leaving for Cincinnati. Central Michigan has been a 4 -- 6 win team since.

Cincinnati: Jones once again took over for Kelly who left for Notre Dame. In 3 years Kelly went 10-3 (Cincinnati's first 10 win season), 11-3, and 12-1 (lost to Florida in the Sugar after Kelly left). Jones was at Cincinnati for 3 seasons going 4-8, 10-3, and 9-3 before leaving for Tennessee.

Tennessee: Tennessee was 5-7 in each of the previous 3 seasons before Jones arrived (2010, 2011, 2012). Jones went 5-7 in year 1, then 6-6 (bowl win for 7th win), then 2 consecutive 8-4 (2 bowl wins to make 9 wins), and was fired in Year 4 after a 50-17 loss at Missouri dropped Tennessee to 4-6 and finished 4-8.

He then joined Saban at Alabama as an offensive analyst. He originally agreed to join Locksley at Maryland as TE coach / Assistant Head Coach, but decided to stay at Alabama.

Arkansas State: As I previously stated, Arkansas State went 85--48 in the 10 years before hiring Jones in 2021. Went 2-10 in year 1 and followed it up with 3-9. Then he led them to 3 straight bowl game going 6-7, 8-5, and 7-6. He was fired this year after 10 games.... another 4-6 record like Tennessee.

None of these programs took a step forward under Jones. Central Michigan and Cincinnati were built by Brian Kelly with Jones taking over and not messing it up. His ceiling at RU would be 7-5, just like Schiano's is. He has either left for a better job after 3 years or got fired in years 5 and 6. He isn't an upgrade from Schiano and will likely get fired before his 5th season ends. As stated, he is not an upgrade. He would be a parallel move.
My takeaway is: hire Brian Kelly for 3-4 years, then hire Butch Jones for 3-4 years. Not a bad 6-8 year run.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Knight Shift
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Basketball falls to Notre Dame in wild Players Era 8 OT showdown
  2. 02 The Knight Report The Knight Report - Ask The Experts Chat: November 18th Edition
  3. 03 The Knight Report Wrestling Rutgers Wrestlers in the latest InterMat Rankings - Week Three
  4. 04 The Knight Report Basketball How to watch Rutgers / Notre Dame; Pregame Info, More: Gameday Central
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Basketball HC Brandin Knight's Houston Postgame Press Conference